Over the coming weeks the annual glut of end-of-year 'Best Of' lists will undoubtedly begin to saturate the pages of websites, magazines and newspapers far and wide. Within the context of popular music these lists serve not only to canonise the tastes of particular institutions and individuals, be they journalists, retailers, artists or fans, but also function as useful subjects of debate within the confines of many a blog, music forum or pub corner. At a time when keeping abreast of every new release, even within a particular genre, is virtually impossible due to the sheer volume of music digitally available at little or no cost (and with swathes of recorded material either forgotten after a solitary listen or else failing to find an audience altogether) the end-of-year list offers a timely and highly rewarding opportunity to take momentary shelter from the cultural deluge, switch on our record players, iPods and laptops, and attempt to evaluate the year in sound. Predicting which albums will appear in end-of-year lists can be a tricky yet enjoyable task, though it stands to reason that the coterie of musicians whose work has garnered widespread praise over a period of months should be there or thereabouts. At the time of writing, among the most likely records to dominate 2013's lists is Daft Punk's 'Random Access Memories' (henceforth 'RAM'). Perhaps surprisingly, given the high-profile nature of the record, coupled with the whirlwind of hype which preceded its entry into the world back in May, RAM seems to have disappointed very few critics. Early reviews across a diverse range of leading publications were highly positive - The NME (10/10), Pitchfork (8.8/10), Q (5/5), FACT (4/5), Resident Advisor (4/5) - and dissenting voices in the established music press have remained few and far between ever since. However, the response across social media, on music forums, and from Daft Punk's contemporaries within the field of electronic music has been rather more ambivalent to say the least. With the objective of questioning dominant critical readings of the record and in order to expand upon some of the issues raised online by Daft Punk's peers and a proportion of their fan base, this article provides five reasons why, for this writer at least, RAM should feature on only one end-of-year list: 'The Most Disappointing Albums of 2013'.
5. It's A Masterpiece! (Of Marketing and PR)
When the dust settles on 2013 and 'Get Lucky' is fondly remembered as the year's equivalent of 'The Macarena' - destined to be a staple in the sets of Yates' Wine Lodge resident DJs for years to come - what many will remember most vividly about RAM is not the souped-up, nostalgic take on disco, west-coast soft rock, smooth jazz, prog and show tunes which constitutes its music, but rather the behemoth of a marketing campaign which powered it. From the record's inception in 2008 through to its release five years later, Daft Punk - French duo Thomas Bangalter and Guy-Manuel de Homem-Cristo - not forgetting their manager Paul Hahn, record label Columbia and the PR firm Biz 3, developed a promotional campaign owing more to the gradual rollout strategies employed by Hollywood majors in handling a summer blockbuster than a conventional album release. Unsurprisingly, for two men who have not been publicly photographed 'sans casques' since the mid-90s, the project was initially shrouded in mystery, with information strategically withheld and then gradually drip-fed to the world via a plethora of sources. Strong visual branding was central to the campaign, with the duo's iconic robot helmets appearing first on their Facebook page and website in March, before permeating the skylines of various US and western European cities in the form of enormous billboards. Teasing video adverts were subsequently screened during the TV show 'Saturday Night Live' before a full trailer for the record appeared at the Coachella festival, greeted with the kind of ecstatic response normally reserved for an evangelical baptism. Next up was 'The Collaborators' - an eight part video series produced by the Vice/Intel initiative The Creators Project and featuring interviews with 'RAM' guest stars Nile Rodgers, Pharrell Williams, Giorgio Moroder and the guy who co-wrote the theme song from 'The Love Boat'. On April 16th the album's name and track-list was revealed on Vine, before finally, a few days later, the world got to hear some actual music in the shape of 'Get Lucky'. The potential of Vevo and Spotify was maximised as the album's release date grew closer, with many fans and music journalists salivating at the prospect of a full album in the vein of the infectious robot-disco of the Rodgers/Pharrell-fronted lead single. On May 17th RAM had its exclusive, high-tech global premiere in the rural Australian town Wee Waa, prior to being unveiled to the wider world via iTunes a few hours later. (Though naturally, a clutch of privileged UK journalists and celebrities got to hear it at the top of The Shard). Via their utilisation of drip-feed promotion techniques, multimedia platforms, ancillary markets, guest-stars and a high profile launch, Daft Punk and their collaborators ensured that RAM was not merely a collection of recorded music, but a major, not to be missed cultural event. Of course, none of the above detracts from the merits of RAM's music. It does, however, illustrate the context into which the album was born and explain, at least in part, how the record was the focus of so much critical attention in the first place. Accordingly, it will be interesting to see how the record is viewed when the propaganda machine finally goes into hibernation. Did RAM's astute marketing influence its overwhelmingly positive reception? I would argue that the answer is yes, and that within a year or two, people aren't going to be kicking back to listen to the 74 minute, 24 second vanity project which it ultimately turned out to be. Instead they'll be scouring YouTube for footage of two French dudes in helmets cycling round Amsterdam with Ron Burgundy. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5Yn_8tX1Jk
4. It Sounds Like Andrew Lloyd Webber Produced The House Band From 'Strictly Come Dancing' Playing On A Saga Cruise
As Daft Punk began to conduct exclusive face-to-face interviews to discuss their new record, the initial mystique which had surrounded RAM gave way to a veritable information overload, with particular attention afforded to the million dollar extravagance of the recording process, which took place in five different studios and featured vast orchestras, a choir, Warner Bros.-aided Foley, and a microphone once used by Frank Sinatra. Much of Daft Punk's previous work had been created using electronic hardware - synthesisers, samplers and drum machines - and recorded onto computers, though the duo had become dissatisfied with their established approach during early RAM sessions and instead elected to use live instruments, played by high-profile session players. Whilst partly an aesthetic decision, Daft Punk's move away from machines was also an attempt to 'bring back the magic' (as alluded to with sledgehammer subtly via the title of album opener 'Give Life Back to Music'). As Thomas Bangalter explained in an interview with Pitchfork: 'Technology has made music accessible in a philosophically interesting way, which is great. But on the other hand, when everybody has the ability to make magic, it's like there there's no magic. If the audience can just do it themselves then why bother?' Furthermore, in a subsequent interview Bangalter criticised the state of contemporary electronic music more directly, arguing that 'it's going through an identity crisis' and 'not moving one inch'. Bangalter's proclamations raise a number of important issues regarding creative democracy, music technology and, more specifically, the state of dance music in 2013. However, for reasons of brevity I'll only touch upon the latter two, as they are most significant in relation to the sound of RAM. Firstly, if Daft Punk wanted their record to serve as some kind of corrective to ailing dance music, then was downing electric tools and picking up wooden ones really the solution? In truth, would a greater challenge for two artists who 'like the idea of trying to be pioneers' not be to reinvent electronic music from the inside out? It's churlish to criticise an artist for wanting to expand their creative horizons by utilising different types of instruments or employing alternative production methods to the ones they've used in the past, but Bangalter's implication that Daft Punk's switch to live instrumentation and hi-end gear could help music rediscover some kind of lost alchemy just reeks of more PR guff.Secondly, whilst RAM is unarguably a remarkable feat of sound engineering - its music recorded with crystalline clarity - the record's production is curiously sterile, devoid of the kinds of stylistic flourishes which characterised Daft Punk's previous work. The Julian Casablancas vehicle 'Instant Crush', for example, is totally bereft of bite or dynamic range, and trundles along like a Phoenix demo recorded on a bagload of diazepam. Bombastic theatrical rock intro aside, 'Bring Life Back to Music' is similarly lacking in personality and sounds like the kind of sanitised fare you'd expect to hear served up after dinner on a Saga cruise around the Med, perhaps by the super slick house band from 'Strictly Come Dancing'. Though far more engrossing, the eight minute album centrepiece 'Touch' is difficult to listen to without thinking that the curtain's been raised on a ridiculously expensive, post-modern, p*sstake-sounding as it does, like a gaudily pristine facsimile of a song from an Andrew Lloyd Webber musical. (The influence of co-writer Paul Williams' work, particularly his soundtrack for Brian De Palma's 1974 musical 'Phantom of the Paradise', is also worth nothing here). RAM is professional, flawless in its audio fidelity and featuring musicianship which is accomplished to the point of virtuosity, but for the most part it is simply not a particularly captivating record. Ultimately, RAM is little more than a superbly executed homage to some of the music Daft Punk love, and the record's production, for all the cash thrown at it, does little to take that music anywhere new. Finally, whilst Bangalter's criticism of modern electronic music arguably rings true in relation to the Skrillex/Deadmau5/EDM monster that Daft Punk themselves indirectly helped create, his claim that there are 'no signatures' in electronic music (i.e. "it all sounds a bit the same to me dear") is either disingenuous or indicative of a man woefully out of touch.
3. It Rips Off The Theme Tune From 'Cagney and Lacey' (Twice) and Only Features Three Good Songs
Whilst deeply flawed, RAM, it should be remembered, includes some fine music. 'Get Lucky' was a fitting soundtrack to the summer (thankfully reducing the airtime given to a certain Pharrell-featuring ode to sexual assault) and even after being played to death its winning blend of human/robot vocals, jutting Chic guitar and languid, loose-limbed funk rarely fail to radiate a warm boogie glow. 'Lose Yourself to Dance', whilst perhaps a little over-long, is a well-judged follow-up single, trading the warm hues of its predecessor for slap bass-driven, stone-cold shimmer. Penultimate track 'Doin' It Right', a collaboration with Panda Bear - aka Animal Collective's Noah Lennox - is arguably the one song on that isn't completely in thrall to the past: Lennox's multi-layered, Beach Boys-esque vocal serving as an affecting human counterpoint to the primitive trap beat which kicks below it. The remainder of the record is less rewarding. As noted by the Glaswegian comedian Brian Limond (more commonly known as Limmy) in his hilarious live video review of the record, at least two songs - 'Bring Life Back to Music' and 'Fragments of Time' - include melodic hooks which sound uncannily like they've been lifted from the theme of 80's cop show 'Cagney and Lacey'. (Seemingly a series of great influence amongst French producers, given that Breakbot's 'One Out of Two' owes a debt to the same source). Elsewhere, 'The Game of Love' is flacid soft porn muzak, closer 'Contact' a mash-up of a NASA sample and an outtake from Jeff Wayne's 'The War of the Worlds' score, and 'Giorgio by Moroder' a glib exercise in self-reflexivity, unworthy of the Italian synth maestro's name.
2. It's Not The Best Robot-Featuring Dance Album of 2013
Crucial to much of Daft Punk's most vital work (all of which, I would argue, was recorded between 1994 and 2001) was the producers' ability to cherry-pick the best of music's past and playfully twist and contort their sources in ways which pointed towards an imagined future. On their debut, 'Homework', Bangalter and Homem-Cristo re-defined the parameters of electronic music by fusing Chicago house and Detroit techno with elements inherited from classic 70's funk and boogie, paving the way for a renaissance in French dance music at a popular, international level (as exemplified by the subsequent rise of Cassius, Stardust, and The Micronauts). On their next record, 'Discovery', meanwhile, the duo merged the New York garage made famous by their heroes Todd Edwards and Romanthony - both of whom would become Daft Punk collaborators - with disco samples, 80's electro, prog-synths and ludicrous Yngwie Malmsteen guitar in an equally imaginative and influential manner. The record's legacy can be identified in various stylistic trends at play in electronic music today; from the sublime (Hudson Mohawke, Rustie) to the ridiculous (Avicii, Steve Aoki). As intimated earlier, one of the most disappointing elements of RAM is Daft Punk's decision to forgo paying tribute to their musical ancestors by inventively modifying, de-constructing or re-contextualising their work in favour of outright pastiche. Whilst the band's first two records showcased a vibrant musical exchange between voices past and present, Random Access Memories is the sound of two musicians often overwhelmed by their influences to the point of creative paralysis. https://soundcloud.com/spacedimensioncontroller/space-dimension-controller-you Fortunately then, another artist - Space Dimension Controller (aka Jack Hamill) - produced the album that many hoped Daft Punk would make in 2013. Hamill's debut full-length, 'Welcome to Mikrosector-50', is an epic, cinematic chronicle of Mr. 8040. 8040, impressively voiced by the 23 year-old Hamill in a manner which makes the producer sound more like a resident of Planet Rock rather than his native Belfast, is a music-maker from the year 2352, and whose journey - through space, time, love, drugs and bad nightclubs - is accompanied by a deftly woven sonic collage of cosmic funk, intergalactic techno and glittering nu-disco. In short, Hamill takes a number of Daft Punk's own influences - Prince, Drexciya, Tangerine Dream, Juan Atkins and John Carpenter to name a few - and forges an album which is in equal parts thoughtful and playful, human and machine, past and future.
1. It's Not Even The Most Interesting Version Of 'Random Access Memories'
Whilst it's not unheard of for a cover version, remix or edit to improve upon or transmogrify its source material - see Jimi Hendrix's 'All Along the Watchtower', R. Kelly's 'Ignition (Remix)' and pretty much everything that Kieran Hebden has ever got his hands on - a single artist making-over a recently released number one album to stunning effect is surely an unprecedented feat. Or at least it was before 'Random Access Memories'..... Just four short weeks after RAM exposed itself as the new clothes to Daft Punk's robot emperors, two young musicians released the snappily titled 'Random Access Memories Memories'; an artistically and conceptually coherent fourteen track re-working of the Daft Punk album, made entirely outside the mainstream industry. That duo was Darkside (though the album was released under their Daftside moniker) and is made up of the American-Chilean producer/DJ/label boss/all-round polymath Nicolas Jaar, and the Brooklyn-based multi-instrumentalist Dave Harrington. https://soundcloud.com/daftside-2/07-daftside-fragments-of-time?in=daftside-2/sets/random-access-memories-1 Darkside's take on 'RAM' strips away the schmaltzy, million dollar sonic bullsh*t which coats the bloated original and replaces it with a heady mix of pulsating drums, lithe guitars, glitching electronics, white noise and roughly-hewn samples (the vocals from Daft Punk's record being chopped and screwed into oblivion). In the hands of Jaar and Harrington 'Beyond' becomes a gorgeous hybrid of melancholy funk and deep house; 'Get Lucky' is mutated into otherworldly space blues; 'Fragments of Time' sounds like a Steely Dan cut being sired by minimal-techno demigod Ricardo Villalobos rather than Sarah Brightman's ex-husband; whilst the jagged tech of 'Instant Crush' wouldn't sound out of place on 'Homework'. The uncompromising outsider ethos which Daft Punk's debut celebrated is alive and well in 2013, it's just not evident in the French duo's own blockbuster paean to the music industry of yore. Instead it's here: On an unofficial, self-produced 'remix' album, made without financial backing and released for free on Soundcloud. Darkside's take on 'RAM' is a dense, sometimes challenging record (it seems unlikely that the cast of Eastenders will be pirouetting around The Vic to the frenetic jungle of 'Motherboard' any time soon), though it successfully highlights many of the flaws which have been often overlooked in reviews of the original. It's the sound, as Daft Punk acolyte James Murphy sang on LCD Soundsystem's 'Losing My Edge', of "the kids coming up from behind".