Every Nirvana Project Ranked From Worst To Best

The Good, The Bad, and The Beautiful from The Godfathers of Alternative Rock.

By Tim Coffman /

Record executives have been looking to court the next Nirvana for years now. Ever since Kurt Cobain's band of merry men infiltrated the rock mainstream off of the strength of Smells Like Teen Spirit, the entire musical landscape was virtually changed overnight. Though there is some magic sprinkled throughout each respective Nirvana song, there are some that shine a bit brighter than others.

Advertisement

For the limited amount of time we got with this band, there is actually a shockingly diverse array of sounds at play here. Whether it be the more caustic sound of the early days or what Kurt Cobain himself described as the "candy-ass" version of themselves in later years, there are bits and pieces across every Nirvana project that is worth your time. While only having a couple of albums to their name, the real meat is found in the deep cuts, B-sides, and even some choice live tracks, each of which has reached legendary status alongside their more celebrated releases.

Even though the next Nirvana is not going to be coming any time soon, there's no shame in looking back at the greatness that they gave us when they were still around. Excluding greatest hits albums, let's take a look back into the warped mind of Seattle's prodigal sons.

5. Incesticide

There's a reason that B-sides never tend to get brought up when talking about an artists' complete discography. Given the more slapdash delivery of some of these albums, they kind of don't count when put up against the actual artistic statements these musicians wanted to make. However, Incesticide proved that even some of Nirvana's cutting room floor material is still better than most bands at their best.

Advertisement

Coming out right after the release of Nevermind, this collection of singles and covers feels like the natural extension of where Kurt was going after the release of Bleach. Instead of the radio-ready singles that turned up on Nevermind, there's a lot more eccentricities on this record, one of which includes a new wave version of the disquieting acoustic song Polly. In fact, most of this album is indebted to new wave, as these guys work through covers by Devo and the Vaselines and Nirvana-fying them into their own unique entity.

That's not to say it's all new wave rock either, with noise freakouts like Big Long Now, pop singles like Sliver, and even a combination of the two on tracks like Aneurysm. Even though this album ranks pretty low on the totem pole, this is an absolute must if you're still craving more Nirvana outside of their studio output.

Best Songs: Stain, Aneurysm, Son of a Gun

4. Bleach

No artist really exists in a vacuum. Despite many bands knocking it out of the park on their first outing, it doesn't always work out like that. For as much of a cultural shift was felt with the release of Nevermind, even Nirvana had to start somewhere on Bleach.

Advertisement

Then again, that's not to say that Bleach is even a bad record. Being their first outing on the famed indie label Sub Pop, this record shows the bare skeleton of what made this band so special. While the tunefulness of Cobain's voice is still there on cuts like About a Girl, this is a much more caustic affair than you would have gotten on later albums. In fact, this is probably the one Nirvana record that comes recommended for any metal fan, with riffs that are as much indebted to Metallica as they are to Flipper on songs like Negative Creep and School.

However, that kind of slapdash delivery does leave some songs not reaching their full potential until they hit the live stage. Also, it's a bit hard to consider this a full-on Nirvana album considering that Chad Channing is still behind the drumstool before Dave Grohl took over just a few years later. As it stands though, this is a solid-as-hell first outing from a group destined to become giants.

Best Tracks: Negative Creep, About A Girl, Paper Cuts

3. MTV Unplugged in New York

As the tour for 1993's In Utero wore on, you could tell that Kurt Cobain had fallen out of love with being a rockstar. After making one of the greatest albums in recent memory just a few years earlier, Cobain had spoken at length about being used by the mainstream, with his privacy becoming virtually non-existent. While no one could have predicted that the end was near, MTV Unplugged in New York was the final gasp we had for Cobain's artistic self.

Advertisement

Filmed close to the holidays in 1993, this stands as one of the greatest unplugged sessions ever put to tape, as Cobain reveals a completely different side of himself. Instead of the typical performance where a band blazes through their greatest hits, this hour of music is a unique artistic statement in and of itself. With the exception of Come As You Are, most of the songs are deep cuts and obscure covers, many of which became classics in their own right like their rendition of David Bowie's The Man Who Sold the World.

However, the constant themes of death and heartache in these songs ended up feeling all too real once Cobain was found dead in his home a mere months after this show was filmed. From the dirge like tempos to the raw emotion to the big white lilies on display, it was as if the audience got to see a warm up for Kurt's own funeral.

Best Tracks: Oh Me, Something in the Way, Where Did You Sleep Last Night

2. Nevermind

It's still inconceivable to imagine how much the music world changed with the release of Nevermind. As the '90s first started to get underway, rock was still firmly in the glam rock mold, with one band after another getting sillier and sillier with every song. After one listen of Smells Like Teen Spirit though, it was all over.

Advertisement

On the other hand, one song does not a great album make, and Nevermind certainly lives up to that opening track across its runtime. Growing up extremely quickly, the band ducked into Sound City Studios in Van Nuys, California with some of the most infectious alternative rock songs ever created. Even though the tunes were still powerful enough to hit you in the face, you couldn't help but groove along to the fantastic melodies behind songs like In Bloom and Drain You.

Despite having some of the more indecipherable lyric sheets in modern rock, Cobain's lyrics on this album are also pretty poignant when you take the time to look through them, like on the sarcastic pastiche of bandwagoners on In Bloom or a woman's real journey out of sexual torture on Polly. While these three guys may not have intended to become bonafied stars right out of the gate, this is the perfect example of when an album is so good the mainstream comes to you.

Best Tracks: Come As You Are, Smells Like Teen Spirit, Breed

1. In Utero

So...how do you list something higher than Nevermind? I mean, the album is one of the most awe-inspiring feats in grunge and single-handedly reshaped the way that most rock fans approached the genre going forward. While Nevermind may have been the call to arms for the new regime of rock and roll, In Utero is where you got to really see inside the mind of Kurt Cobain.

Advertisement

Though he chased the spotlight whenever he could, Nirvana's 3rd outing shows Kurt Cobain at war with his own celebrity across every track. Hooking up with famed indie producer Steve Albini, the resulting songs are a lot more abrasive than the stuff on Nevermind, leading to straight up noise tracks like Tourette's and Milk It. On the other hand, this is one of those rare instances where the sonic ugliness actually plays to the album's favor.

From one track to the next, you can hear Cobain lashing out at everything around him, be it the paparazzi, the music business, his friends, or even himself. For every experiment like Very Ape, you also get some of the most beautiful tracks that this band has ever made like on Dumb and All Apologies. However, this cry for help didn't register with the public in time when Cobain was found dead in his home in between two legs of the tour. Nevermind may have been the defining musical statement, but when it comes to the purest artistic expression, In Utero is Kurt Cobain, warts-and-all.

Best Tracks: Dumb, Scentless Apprentice, Heart Shaped Box

Advertisement