Harry Potter fans: never fear, this isn't an interrogation over your favourite creator of magical worlds. Beloved by all, and regardless of whatever inconsistencies there are in the books and films, J K Rowling for forever be held dear in fans of all ages, big and small. Rowling herself commented on any flaws that have appeared in the book, saying: "As obsessive fans will tell you, I do slip up! Several classrooms move floors mysteriously between books and these are the least serious continuity errors! Most of the fansites will point you in the direction of my mistakes. But the essentials remain consistent from book to book because the story has been plotted for a long time and it is clear in my mind". But depsite the fact that fans are content with her defence and no one since has created a story so vivid and endearing since the first harry Potter book arrived on in book shops, there are still some questions that need answering.
10. How Does The Economy Work?
While the high security bank stops witches and wizards from stealing other people's life savings (well, most of the time), there's still an overarching question that we'd love to have a solid answer too. HOW THE HELL ISN'T EVERY CHARACTER IN THE HARRY POTTER SERIES STINKING RICH? You can use magic, for crying out loud. Mr and Mrs Weasley must surely have worked out some sort of loophole (if it's needed) to conjure up a sweet pile of money to save Ron from his aunt's dress robes. When, by the final books, it's apparently ok to go ahead and use the killing curse whenever you like, on the other hand it's just not alright to magic yourself a little wad of cash to cover things like groceries.
9. Why Can't Harry See The Thestrals?
In The Order Of The Phoenix, Harry sees that the magical carriages taking students from the Hogwarts Express up to Hogwarts upon arrival are actually lead by horsey-type animals called Thestrals. As Luna explains to Harry after he's left feeling confuddled because Ron and Herminone can't see them, one can only actually see the Thestrals if that person has seen someone die. While this scene is put in place mainly to prove how devastated and affected Harry is by Cedric Digory's death, there is no reason at all why Harry wouldn't have been able to see them before - because he saw his mother die when he was tiny, and everyone knows that.
8. Why Did Hedwig Have To Die?
While good people do have to die in the battles between good and evil (because that's fair, right?) why, why, WHY did JK Rowling have to kill off Hedwig? There was no character or animal in any of the Harry Potter books as good and true and loyal as that owl. Dobby's death was upsetting, but created to stage a tragedy in order to fuel Harry's rage against Voldemort. But Hedwig? That death was just excessive. No owl needed to die, especially that so white and fluffy.
7. Were Fred And George Blind To The Man In Ron's Bed?
Fred and George not noticing Peter Pettigrew sleeping in Rons bed every night on the Marauders map is quite a serious plot hole. In their first year, Fred and George Wesley stole the Marauders map, which showed everyones location in Hogwarts. Ron inherited Scabbers, Percys old rat, when he first went to school. Scabbers was really Peter Pettigrew in hiding. So, logically, why wouldnt Fred or George (or Harry, for that matter) have been able to see Pettigrew hanging out in Rons room for years? Even if Fred and George didnt recognize the name Pettigrew as the man Sirius Black supposedly murdered, wouldnt it still have been odd to have seen a stranger they didnt know following their brother around all the time on the map?
6. When Did Hogwarts Students Learn Sex Education?
While the witches and wizards of the magic community have made every reader think at least once during their lives, 'I wish I could be a wizard!', if you think about it, they can't be all that functional due to the education system. What skills did those pupils really learn at Hogwarts? How to put earmuffs on correctly? How to deceive your teachers? How to eat as much as you want during a never ending supply of food in the Great Hall at dinner? They appear to learn very few actual life lesson: Maths, English, Sex Ed, Foreign Languages. Where are all the skills needed for later life? School ends at 17 too: so good luck on finding out what the big wide world really holds in store for you once you'v left the confines of Hogwarts (heaven forbid you don't know your male and female anatomies...)
5. Where Was The Time Turner When We Needed It?
Ah the time turner; one of Rowling's greatest creations and biggest mistakes. Over the years, fans have repeatedly poked holes in the whole time turner plot line. The most obvious question is: if wizards can travel through time, why couldnt someone Harry, Dumbledore, literally anyone go back in time and stop Voldemort back when he was young Tom Riddle? They saved Buckbeak using the time turner, so why not stop Voldemort using it too? Or is there a time limit on the time turner? What is it? What are the other rules? Would stopping Tom Riddle or even stopping Bellatrix from hurting someone a few minutes ago break the rules? Would this be an abuse of the time turner power? Which begs another question: what the heck was McGonagall doing giving such a powerful tool to a second year anyway?
4. Why Are the Laws About Magic So Selective?
While it's made quite clear to readers from The Philosophers Stone that magic is only to be used within the school while underage, this doesn't always seem to be the case. Magic use around muggles appears to be monitored unless you are still a kid who hasn't started Hogwarts, or Dumbledore. Young Tom Riddle uses some form of his magic to ensure he and the other two muggle children reach that cave in the Half-blood Prince. Something happens and they are frightened to death - but there is no law action. Likewise, Dumbledore goes ahead and apparently uses an Imperius Curse on a muggle and nothing happens. Plus he gets a muggle drunk. And that's fine again. While we understand that loopholes are often necessary in order to move a plot along, the uses of magic seem to happen as and when needed with little thought for the law. If Harry was to be charged for all of his improper uses of magic, he'd be jailed for life.
3. Are The Dementors Really So Good At Their Job?
The answer to this appears to be no: the mass breakout from Azkaban suggests that actually, the soul-sucking prison guards were probably on their lunch break or something when all the terrible killing evil criminals escaped from Azkaban in The Order Of the Phoenix. The Dementors, which feature in the last five of the Harry Potter books, have a terrible affect on anyone who happens to bump into them (think Harry meets the Dementors while playing quidditch) - and yet can't bring themselves to group together to stop all the inmates from escaping. These are the monsters who can suck out a wizard's soul from a few hundred yards away, and fly and swoop through the air in a hurry when they want to. It's hardly believable, is it Rowling?
2. Can Mimicking Parseltongue Really Work?
Ron being able to mimic Parseltongue *sigh*. It's just not working, is it? While audiences accept this as a stroke of good luck ("hooray, Ron can speak snake language too - kind of!"), it just seems like a bit of a clumsy attempt on Rowling's part to get us to the next scene in The Deathly Hallows. We know earlier on that Dumbledore understood Parseltongue, but couldn't speak it, and it's stated that only direct Slytherin descendants could speak it. But not to worry, in this time of need, Ron can just try out some language skills - and thank goodness he's good at them, because otherwise all the characters would probably be dead.
1. Did The Rest Of The World Just Not Care?
While it's understandable that creating the entire wizarding world from scratch plus writing seven books worth of stories to go with it is a big job (and no-one here is saying they could do it any better), were the rest of the world content knowing that a reign of terror was upon them and just let it go? For example: what were all the Down Under wizards doing while Voldey was searching the world for the Elder Wand? What was the rest of Europe doing while evil seized the UK? Where was Russia?! We needed you Russia! What were the witches in Thailand doing, except sunbathing and probably riding on magical tame dolphins or something? In another world, the final book would have seen magical armies from across the globe coming in Harry's defence. Not just the last few students from Hogwarts and their guardians. Just saying...