8 Shockingly Unethical Experiments That Actually Happened
Poison, shocks, and state-sanctioned euthanasia - the dark side of science in the 20th century.
Science has done some truly incredible things, saving billions of lives, and improving the quality of billions more. But it has also done some terrible things.
Nowadays, there are strict rules dictating how we conduct experiments, and these are in place to protect participants and prevent wildly unethical research from taking place. These rules, however, were mostly introduced in response to some seriously morally questionable experiments that occurred, mostly in the 19th and 20th centuries, when we were really starting to get to grips with the scientific method.
Experiments on children, animals, racial minorities, and the mentally ill all simultaneously pushed the boundaries of scientific understanding and human ethics - people were poisoned, shocked, mutilated, mentally scarred, and even killed by these practices.
Some of these experiments did actually teach us something, albeit at a terrible cost, but many others were simply tragic and barbaric wastes of time and life.
The scientific leaps and discoveries we have made since the strict ethical code has been imposed on science demonstrate that the means do not necessarily justify the ends. This said, there are still many ethical debates raging in science to this day, so perhaps we'll look back on the 21st century with equal shock and horror some day.
8. Robbers Cave Experiments
If you've ever read Lord of the Flies, you'll be aware of the kind of chaos a group of boys can descend into if left unattended ... or indeed, if provoked.
The Robbers Cave Experiments gathered 22 6th grade boys from 22 different schools, split them into two groups (the Eagles and the Rattlers) and sent them off to a remote summer camp. Initially, the two groups were unaware of each other's presence, but the "camp counsellors" - who were in fact mad scientists in disguise - intended to slowly introduce them to one another over the course of three weeks.
Oh, and no one but the scientists knew this was a social experiment.
The rivalry between the groups escalated quickly, resulting in repeated raids on one another's camps, stealing, the burning of each others' flags, and one of the groups even fashioning makeshift weapons by putting rocks in socks. Hostilities grew between the groups and verbal abuse was guaranteed when they came near one another.
Towards the end of the week, the experimenters cut off the boys' water supply by blocking it up, just to see what would happen. Amazingly, the two groups came together to try to fix the problem, and the Rattlers even let the Eagles take first go at the newly fixed pump, as they had water canteens and the Eagles didn't.
The experiment was supposed to recreate the dynamics between hunter gatherer groups, supporting the realistic conflict theory, and the natural instinct for tribalism in the face of scarce resources.
7. The Aversion Project
The 70s and 80s were a dark time for the LGBT community and, in apartheid South Africa, a shocking number of gay and lesbian soldiers were forced to undergo aversion therapy and gender reassignment surgery as part of a secret operation to root out homosexuality in the armed forces.
Suspected homosexuals were exposed by army psychiatrists, and sent to military psychiatric units, chiefly ward 22 of 1 Military Hospital at Voortrekkerhoogte where they were to undergo "aversion". This included shock therapy, in which they were forced to view gay pornography and shocked with increasing intensity in order to create a negative association and chemical castration.
If none of this "worked", then they were forced to undergo a sex change operation. As many as 900 homosexual males, mostly 16–24 years old, were surgically turned into women and given birth certificates to fit their modified anatomy.
6. Facial Expressions Experiments
Whilst it might seem blindingly obvious to us that different emotions elicit different facial expressions, in 1924, a psychology graduate named Carney Landis at the University of Minnesota decided that what we needed was an experiment to test this. The aim was to see whether the facial expressions produced were consistent between different people, or whether we all had our own unique responses to emotions such as fear, disgust, shock, and joy.
Unfortunately, to produce these kinds of facial expressions, you have to actually shock, disgust, and terrify you test subjects.
Most the the stimuli were reasonable, if horrible, with subjects made to smell ammonia, look at pornography, and put their hands into a bucket of frogs, but the final disgusting stimulus was definitely a bridge too far, as the participants were told to behead a live rat. Only one third of the participants actually followed through with the instruction, but as so few of them knew how to behead a rat in a humane manner (it's not exactly the kind of thing taught in finishing schools), the whole experience was 10 times more disturbing than it was supposed to be.
An unexpected result of the experiment was to demonstrate that a lot of people will do almost anything if instructed by a scientist. It did not, however, prove that we have unique emotional facial expressions.
5. Learned Helplessness
If you've ever felt powerless in a situation, you might have been experiencing something called 'learned helplessness', the psychological effects that makes a situation seem hopeless even if it isn't and is thought to be one of the underlying causes of depression.
In order to study the effect, psychologists Mark Seligman and Steve Maier conducted experiments with dogs and electric shocks back in 1965. They split dogs up into three groups and put them in harnesses: Group one were simply kept and then released after a certain amount of time, group two were given electric shocks that could be stopped by pressing a lever, and group three were given electric shocks, but the shocks didn't end when the lever was pressed.
Later, the dogs were placed, unharnessed, in a box and given shocks. They could easily have escaped the shocks by simply moving away, but the dogs from group three stayed there, assuming that there was nothing they could do.
Aside from the act of repeatedly electrocuting poor pups, the dogs from group three then went on to exhibit classic signs of clinical depression.
Be right back, going to hug my dog.
4. The Milgram Experiments Were Unethical, But Not How You'd Think
The Milgram Experiment is so often included in lists such as this, and everyone knows that it just proves that us humans are inherently evil dicks.
For a bit of background: The Milgram Experiment was a study into obedience carried out by Stanley Milgram back in the 1960s. The participants were led to believe that they were delivering potentially deadly shocks to another person under the guise of a "learning exercise", and were encouraged to carry on by the "scientists" in charge, even to the point where they were screaming in pain or even becoming unresponsive. The truth is that everyone but the participants were actors and no one was really getting shocked, but the point was that ordinary people are willing to do terrible things if instructed to by an authority figure.
It seems pretty conclusive. The results show that 65% of the participants were willing to give someone an electric shock strong enough to kill them. The experiments struck a nerve with a public that remembered the horrors of the Second World War, and were trying to come to terms with how exactly so many ordinary people could commit such atrocities.
The results, however, were a sham. In reality, about 60% of participants displayed strong empathy, disobeyed the authority figure and refused to continue, despite many of the authority figures resorting to coercion and bullying to get them to continue, which was against the rules.
So people might not be inherently evil, but Milgram was willing to twist the figures to say they were.
3. The Holmesburg Program
The history of unethical experimentation is shot through with experiments being carried out on the 'underclasses' of society: black people, women, prisoners, orphans, and the mentally ill. The Holmesburg Program was one such experiment, carried out on the inmates of Holmesburg prison.
For a period of 20 years, the prisoners were used to test all sorts of products such as toothpaste, deodorant, shampoo, skin creams, detergents, liquid diets, eye drops, foot powders, and hair dye. These seem harmless, but the test were often accompanied by biopsies and painful procedures. In 1967, the U.S. Army paid Kligman to apply skin-blistering chemicals to the faces and backs of inmates at Holmesburg, in Kligman's words, "to learn how the skin protects itself against chronic assault from toxic chemicals, the so-called hardening process."
Things got darker still when the inmates were used as guinea pigs to test the latest mind-altering drugs the Vietnam war, when they were dosed with dioxin, a highly toxic and carcinogenic compound found in Agent Orange,
The prisoners developed severe skin lesions which were left untreated for seven months, and many went on to develop long term health problems such as lupus and psychological damage.
2. The Tuskegee Syphilis Study
The Tuskegee Syphilis Study, a 40-year project by the US Public Health Service in Alabama to study the long term effects of syphilis, is one of the more infamous and deplorable experiments ever conducted by the US government.
The way they went about it was to purposely infect 399 impoverished African American men and leave them untreated to allow the disease to naturally progress. They administered it under the pretence of giving the men a free treatment for "bad blood" and they were not informed of the true nature of the experiment.
By 1972, when the study ended, of the original 399 men, 28 had died of syphilis, 100 were dead of related complications, 40 of their wives had been infected, and 19 of their children were born with congenital syphilis.
1. Eugenics In The US
Eugenics is the practice of essentially genetically modifying the population through selective breeding. Promoting higher reproduction rates between people with "desirable" traits and discouraging it in those with "undesirable" traits theoretically gives you a strong, healthy, disease resistant population which, from a utilitarian point of view is a good thing. In practice, however, you have serious issues with free will and discrimination and, well, you get the Nazis.
Before Hitler came along and made eugenics the dirtiest of dirty words, however, it saw massive popularity in the United States. In 1907, the world's first eugenics-based compulsory sterilization law was passed in Indiana, closely followed by 30 other U.S. states. The sterilisation of "imbeciles" was commonplace in many states for a lot of the 20th century.
Stepping up a gear from sterilisation was the introduction of euthanasia for "genetically unfit" individuals. Whilst gas chambers were suggested but never actually implemented, patients at mental institutions were fed milk infected with tuberculosis, reasoning that "fit" individuals would be able to fight off the disease, resulting in 30-40% annual death rates.
This dark time in the US is said to have actually inspired the Aryan master race projects in Nazi Germany, with reports from the American program being widely cited by the Nazi government in support of its regime.
You could write for WhatCulture Science! Click here to find out how you could get paid to write about what you love.
If science gives you the warm fuzzies, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter to stay up to date.