9 Compelling Pieces Of Evidence That The Universe Is A Simulation
The Matrix is looking more like a documentary by the day.
How's your day going? Good? Yeah? Ok, well, there's a chance that nothing is real, reality is a phantom and to attempt to extract any meaning from the universe is ultimately futile. So that's fun.
Far more than an angsty experiment in grunge philosophy, it could well turn out that The Matrix is more of a documentary than a gritty mainstream foray into neo-noir. Perhaps not in the "intelligent machines farming human bodies for bioelectric energy and only you can prevent them" kind of way, but the idea that the universe we perceive is not all that it seems, is one that continues to grow in popularity in both scientific and academic circles.
We've been considering this as a possibility for thousands of years, with solipsism reaching all the way back through history to Plato's Cave, but now it is moving beyond the realms of a thought experiment.
There are those out there who believe that, if the universe really is just the result of a clever bit of code, we should be able to tell - all we have to do is look close enough. Scientists are beginning to gather real, empirical evidence for the glitches, processes and even the base code of the universe.
Whoa, indeed.
9. Physics Is Computable
One thing that raises many scientists' suspicions about the nature of the universe, is just how well it all seems to work and, what's more, how easily we can put it all down in the form of equations.
We tend to take it for granted that the universe is governed by a set of immutable laws. We give these names like thermodynamics, gravity, magnetism and relativity, but these are just our ways of quantify the strict set of rules that reality appears to follow.
Another thing that is based on a strict set of rules that will always yield the same results if given the right input, is code. Computer code.
Could it be that the reason that physical laws are so computable (E = mc2, for example), is because that's the way it was programmed?
One rock-solid way of refuting the claim that the universe is a simulation, would be the discovery of uncomputable physics, something that we can't quantify with maths. Can you think of any?*
*Hint: No, you can't.
8. The Universe Is Fine Tuned
Speaking of a perfectly programmed universe, another thing that bothers people is the fact that the universe seems to be perfectly programmed to allow us to live in it.
Any minor adjustment to any of the physical laws, and the universe could never have formed in the first place. If the nuclear strong force was just that bit weaker, matter would fall apart. If gravity was much stronger, stars would collapse in on themselves in seconds.
This, however, hasn't happened. The universe is not too hot, nor too cold, it is juuust right.
The Anthropic Principle is the philisophical stance that the conditions of the universe are constrained to that which life can emerge. The explanations for this range from the multiverse to intelligent design, but one of the possibilities is that the universe is fake - a simulation created by another being.
If you were a computer programmer (maybe you are), and you were designing a virtual universe to run, you would probably code for the conditions in which life would emerge too. Otherwise it would be like playing The Sims with an empty house.
This is all very well as part of a philosophical debate, but what about the evidence?
7. It's Built On A Grid
After thousands of years of wondering whether we're all just part of the matrix, one group of scientists think they might be able to come up with some more solid evidence.
Silas Beane and a team from the University of Bonn, have calculated that, if the universe is indeed a simulation, we should be able to spot certain artifacts from the underlying lattice that it is built on. When we simulate universes ourselves (at an impossibly tiny scale of course), we also use a grid structure to keep everything in place.
The key is in cosmic particles. As these rocket around the universe, they spread themselves across a spectrum of energies. There is, however, a limit to the amount of energy these cosmic particles can have, and there is a steep drop off after this amount. This cliff, according to Beane and his colleagues, is remarkably similar to the kind of cut-off you get when running a limited simulation with an underlying grid.
If the grid is there, Beane et al reckon that they should be able to pick up evidence of it by observing the way these cosmic particles scatter when they come up against it.
6. You Can Get Complexity From Simplicity
So if the universe is a simulation, it must be an immensely powerful and complex one, right? You might even think that the universe is far too intricate to be the result of a simple string of ones and zeros.
In fact, it's really not that difficult to give rise to an immense, even infinite, amount of complexity from a relatively simple set of rules. John Conway's Game of Life is an elegant demonstration of this.
This game, which was programmed in the seventies, has only four simple rules, but is capable of producing complexity, stability, annihilation and even infinity. Altering those rules also produces some incredible results, there's even a tumblr dedicated to it.
Now, nobody is implying that every time you play this game, you create a simulated universe, but it goes to show that complexity can indeed arise from relative simplicity.
Some digital physicists are even inclined to see the parallels to this in particle interaction in our universe. At our most fundamental level, the universe arises from some very simple "building blocks" that are governed by relatively few laws.
5. It's The Natural Progression Of Technology
It might seem like a pretty out-there hypothesis, but what if creating virtual universes is a natural progression of a technologically advanced society?
We are currently in the process of creating ever more complex simulations ourselves and, considering the progress we've made in just the last half a century or so, it's not beyond the realms of possibility that we'd be able to simulate complex, thinking universes soon enough.
For this not to happen, we'd have to either end as a species (or at least end our technological age) or somehow lose interest in the idea altogether.
Now, with this in mind, consider the probability of our species being the first in the history of the universe to achieve this. If it is an inevitability of a technological society, then it is wildly unlikely that it hasn't happened before, perhaps even many times - perhaps we're a simulation within a simulation within a simulation.
To break this down to numbers, even if we make the fairly modest assumption that this has only happened a million times in the entire history of time and space, then there is a one in a million chance that we are the first. However, this means that there is a 999,999 in a million chance that we're one of the simulated universes.
This is the argument that Elon Musk made not so long ago, when he stated that, in his opinion, the chances that we're not living in a simulated reality are a billion to one.
4. It's An Effect Of Quantum Realism
Okay, for this one, forget everything you know about simulations, computers and virtual reality. Just because the universe is a simulation, doesn't necessarily mean that it was programmed by an intelligent being. It's possible that our physical universe is actually a virtual reality, created by a quantum reality.
Still following?
Since the advent of quantum mechanics in the 20th century, the properties of the physical reality that we not only take for granted, but take as self-evident, have started to make less and less sense. They do not work with quantum mechanics, and every one of our attempts to unify them have failed.
Quantum reality, on the other hand, proposes that the quantum world not only exists, but also calls our physical world into virtual existence. You're not so much a brain in a jar, but an illusion created by quantum laws.
3. There Is Lag
Sticking with quantum realism for a moment, there are a couple of aspects of physics that make a lot more sense if you think about them as products of quantum virtual reality.
Einstein's famous twin paradox, for example, in which time dilation can cause one twin to age much faster than another. This isn't just a weird product of some complicated maths either, time dilation has been objectively observed in the real world, but how could it be physically possible for time to run at different speeds in the same universe?
The answer is every gamer's worst nightmare: Lag.
In gaming, time slows down when the servers are busy, moving at a different rate to others' time. In the "real" world, time slows down near a large gravitating mass, or at high velocities, suggesting that it is virtual. If reality is busy processing huge amounts of gravity or velocity, it might only have a small amount of power to spare for the passage of time.
As well as time dilation, dark matter and even the curvature of spacetime are also thought to be potential indicators of our quantum overlord.
2. The Universe Is Digital
We tend to think of the universe as a smooth, continuous structure, but its is actually split into discrete chunks.
Much like the cubes in the grid that we talked about before, there appears to be a "minimum" measurement in the universe, known as Planck Length. Just like in a game of chess, in which you cannot move less than one square, in the universe, you can't have less that on planck length. It is digital, quantified, it is in bits.
To be clear, you won't be able to see the pixels of the universe, even if you put your eye really close to your hand. To visualise Planck length, picture a dot at 0.1mm in size, then blow that dot up to the size of the observable universe (about 92 billion light-years), and a Planck length would be the size of a 0.1mm dot in the middle of that. Pretty small.
However small they are though, these "bits" of information are temptingly similar to the way information is stored on a computer. Maybe whoever programmed it just didn't expect us to look that closely.
1. So Whos Running It?
So, if the universe is indeed a simulation, who exactly is simulating it?
Well, so long as we're not a random bit of noise as a result of quantum reality, we can assume that there's some kind of conscious intelligence writing the code.
It's tempting to picture some kind of science fiction inspired race of super-intelligent, pan-dimensional beings in futuristic hats, but the likelihood is that our virtual reality was probably programmed by, well, humans. Or at least the "real" version of humans.
Much like we have a propensity to create the people we know on The Sims, it stands to reason that a civilisation with the ability to run complex simulations would create something like themselves. Perhaps these simulations are even being used to predict events in the "real" world, perhaps the future human race is simulating its past, as a form of digital archaeology.
If you want to get really meta, perhaps the simulators are simulations themselves. It's just simulations all the way down.
Love science? Of course you do. Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter for plenty more where that came from.