After flirting with the idea of releasing more Harry Potter stories almost imperceptibly, JK Rowling has finally given fans exactly what they've hoped for since the final full-stop of the final chapter of the final book. Her characters will return - in some capacity - though not on the page for a new stage-play in 2016 written by Let The Right One In adapter Jack Thorne. The big question at this stage is who the titular Cursed Child actually is. Given the initial announcement (and "official" synopsis) of the play way back in December 2013, the suggestion was that it was always intended to merely be a retelling of Harry's early years from a different perspective:
What was it like to be the boy in the cupboard under the stairs? This brand new play, which will be developed for the UK theatre, will explore the previously untold story of Harry's early years as an orphan and outcast. Featuring some of our favourite characters from the Harry Potter books, this new work will offer a unique insight into the heart and mind of the now legendary young wizard. A seemingly ordinary boy, but one for whom Destiny has plans...
But since then Rowling has been quick to pour water on the rumours that it will be a prequel (which some fans have read that synopsis to imply), and there is some suggestion that the premise has now changed. And of course there's the small issue with the title. How could Harry be the Cursed Child, when he's already in the title? Wouldn't that make it Harry Potter & Himself? No matter how you choose to read it, there are questions - and thus some potential theories to address them - that need to be answered before the curtains open next year...
7. It's A Prequel About Harry's Parents
While details are sparse, the detail that keeps coming back is that the play will focus on a new perspective or an untold element of Harry's life, and despite the fact that the title makes no sense, it's hard to resist the idea that he is the cursed child in question. If you consider the Prophecy, there's an intriguing time period between Dumbledore hearing it and Harry's birth, and the specifics of Trelawney's vision do fit with the idea of Harry being a cursed child. How his parents - and Dumbledore as their friend - dealt with that would be an interesting story. Theory Rating: 4/10 If we're to believe Rowling, the play is definitely not a prequel, so delving backwards to the time shortly before their death would seem contrary to that, BUT there's every chance the author is merely being deliberately evasive in semantics. Just because the whole play might not take place before the events of The Philosopher's Stone doesn't mean it can't jump backwards in time, so there's still a good chance that that untold part of Harry's story will be explored.
6. It's About Voldemort Again
As with every new expansion of a beloved franchise, fans will inevitably hold some hope that the most iconic elements of Harry Potter return. Just as Star Wars fans will grasp at the idea of Darth Vader returning right up until the moment he doesn't, Potterites will hope that the Dark Lord rears his creepy serpentine head in some way. Since the play is a spin-off rather than a new chapter entirely, it would be logical to assume that the Curse in question has something to do with the evil at the heart of the first seven books. Just how much of a presence he will have is what remains to be seen. Theory Rating: 7/10 It seems likely that Voldemort will play a significant part in the play, even if he doesn't actually appear, unless there's a significant curve-ball coming (more of which later). Even in just symbolic terms, as long as there's a Harry Potter in the title, Voldemort's impact on him will shape how his life unfolds, and having the Curse as being fundamentally linked to the Dark Lord is a compelling thought.
5. One Of The Potter Brood Is The Cursed Child
Introducing younger family members doesn't always work - Scrappy Doo, for instance, was an abomination - but the idea that Harry Potter and his family went on to live a quiet life after the tumultuous Voldemort years is just too convenient. Even with the pleasant full-stop of the epilogue, fans inevitably asked what happened next, and the concept of Harry and Ginny having to turn from children in danger to the parents of a child in danger offers an intriguing new perspective. Particularly since there has to be at least SOME question of how screwed up Harry's genetics are after having part of Voldemort's soul clattering around inside him. Particularly interesting theory linked to the epilogue concerns the timing of the release. The play will be released 19 years after The Philosopher's Stone was released, and it's probably no accident that the epilogue was titled "19 Years Later", and that does feel like a hint. Theory Rating: 4/10 As interesting as a Potter brood spin-off might be to some fans, it would pose some logistical problems, including the need to cast (or recast) the original core cast of the films and books. And it would be a pretty massive kick in the teeth for the Boy Who Lived to have raised a Child Who Ended Up Also Being Cursed. But then Rowling did kill Dobby, so all bets should probably be off for now.
4. Draco Malfoy Is The Cursed Child
The evolution of Draco Malfoy from secondary antagonist to whingey victim by the end of the seventh book was entertaining to watch - particularly as he saw himself as some sort of chosen one - but it would be foolish to imagine that that was the end of his arc. Malfoy arguably has as many wounds as Harry by the time Voldemort is vanquished: he's a blood traitor, he was defeated by his mortal (and inferior) enemy and he was abused by Voldemort badly in the final book. Seeing him deal with that, wrestling with his ghosts and the weight of expectation in his genes to grow up a "true" Slytherin (and go bad), could be a less obvious take on the meaning of the play's title. And it would be compelling viewing on a stage. Theory Rating: 2/10 This is far more a fan-wish than an actual theory, as Draco's story beyond the end of the books has bountiful potential. By rights, he should grow up broken or seeking vengeance (rather than becoming a blunted blade), and picking away at the surface of that alternate future would have been wonderful to watch.
3. It Will Focus On An Entirely New Character (Perhaps In Harry's Auror Days)
Despite the fact that he doesn't actually graduate from Hogwarts and gain the required entry level grades, Harry becomes head Auror under the clearly sycophantic rule of new Minister Of Magic, Kingsley Shacklebolt. That career path in itself should have lead to a series of Potter Grown Up books reimagining him as a sort of magical Indiana Jones/Ghostbuster hybrid. It might still. Given Daniel Radcliffe's performance in The Woman In Black, the idea of him returning as Harry Potter - however unlikely - and investigating a creepy case of a cursed child would have made for some great theatre. Theory Rating: 5/10 It's very possible that the titular child will be an entirely new character, but the Auror Potter element - sure to delight fan fiction writers online - is far less probable, unfortunately. Someone should definitely convince Rowling to pass the rights on to someone to expand the universe though.
2. Teddy Lupin Is The Cursed Child
When you consider the title of the play, it should inspire thoughts of one surviving wizarding world character more than any other: the child of tragic lovers Tonks and Lupin. Their deaths were the hardest part of the books to take, and it's not hard to consider their surviving son as being Cursed in that context. After all, he was marked by death and his origin is similar to Harry's. And while Rowling was keen to push the idea of difference - in that he grows up in a safe world - it would be intriguing to see him wrestling with the ghosts of his past in an intimate stage environment. Theory Rating: 3/10 While there is an established fandom for Teddy, it would probably be too much for even Rowling to add to the misery of his first year by making him cursed. It would also be a betrayal of the expanded lore of the books to explore the effect his father's blood might have on him, since it's established he isn't a werewolf, but there could be room to explore that impact without making him fully infected. The Curse could merely be the hangover from his father's condition.
1. It's Just Going To Retell The Events Of Privet Drive
While Rowling has said it's not a prequel, that doesn't mean the play can't or wont leap back in time. It seems likely that the narrative will start at the point of his parents' death and then explore Harry's early years before Hogwarts. And the promise of a new perspective could easily be fulfilled by having it deal more with the Dursleys than with Harry himself. They're painted easily as monsters up until the final book, and understanding that through Harry's formative years (when he was experiencing things he couldn't explain) would be interesting to watch. Given the choice of writer - and his own experiences at school - the puzzle comes together quite nicely:
I tended to be the nerdy kid stood at the back, watching other people having fun I wasnt always necessarily a big part of the fun myself. But theres a lot that I hope comes from the feelings I had then, or things that I recognised in other people. You just plug into what that felt like.
Theory Rating: 8/10 Probably the most likely eventuality, since the initial announcement promised as much. And Rowling wouldn't actually be lying in saying it's not a prequel, because the first book begins with Harry arriving at Privet Drive, and the play wouldn't need to go back beyond that point to offer a new perspective. That still doesn't mean the title would actually make any sense, though. Are you excited to see Harry Potter & The Cursed Child? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.