10 Most Controversial Premier League Moments

An unforgettable selection of outrageous Premier League incidents.

By David Lee Wheatley /

Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport

The English Premier League began in 1992 to much fanfare and has since provided a multitude of magical moments for worldwide fans to savour.

Advertisement

However, it hasn’t all been sweetness and light.

A rap sheet chock-full of unsavoury happenings have occurred to unsettle even those supporters hardened by the brutality of the seventies.

Advertisement

Players and managers have squared up to one another when the going got too tough to handle. Wild punches have been thrown, flailing kicks have been aimed, and spiteful shoves have been dealt out in the heat of the moment.

Even the officials got in on the act, with unbelievably poor decisions causing unbridled uproar both on the pitch and in the stands.

Advertisement

Bad boy footballers have cultivated infamous reputations upon such episodes, whilst even respected figures have lost their cool during the tensest of situations.

This list represents the ten most controversial Premier League moments, but there’s little doubt that many more scandalous events will follow if the last 25 years are anything to go by.

Advertisement

10. Pedro Mendes’ Effort Ruled Out To Spare Carroll’s Blushes

Matthew Ashton/EMPICS Sport

Tottenham Hotspur midfielder Pedro Mendes’ looping shot from just inside Manchester United’s half with two minutes on the clock caught Red Devils’ goalkeeper Roy Carroll napping.

Advertisement

As the shaken Northern Irish shot-stopper scampered back towards goal, he set himself ready to make the save. However, Carroll failed miserably in his attempt to catch the ball, subsequently letting it squirm out of his grasp and way, way, beyond his line.

Astonishingly, the officials disallowed Mendes’ perfectly good strike, leading to howls of derision from the disbelieving Old Trafford crowd, as the score somehow remained at 0-0.

Advertisement

Spurs boss Martin Jol and his players were livid. Even the usually biased Sir Alex Ferguson offered sympathy in the wake of the contest, having realised that the goal was legitimate.

Advertisement

This incident proved to be one of the catalysts in the push for the eventual advent of goal-line technology.

9. Darren Bent Joins The Beach Boys

Joe Giddens/EMPICS Sport

Sunderland striker Darren Bent was handily placed 15 yards out as a cross from the right got flicked into his path and everything appeared normal at the Stadium of Light.

Advertisement

The deadly forward then aimed a first-time right-footed attempt directly towards Pepe Reina’s goal. A large object in Reina’s eyeline took the brunt of the shot sending whatever it was to the ‘keeper’s right, while the football itself was diverted to his left.

Unfortunately, the Spaniard became mightily confused by this unusual set of circumstances, and followed the path of the unknown object, as the net rippled behind him making it 1-0 to the home side.

Advertisement

According to the rules, the referee should stop the game due to any outside interference, including ‘foreign objects’ such as the beach ball – as it turned out – in question. Due to his oversight in approving such a controversial goal, red-faced official Mike Jones was demoted to a Championship fixture next time out between Peterborough United and Scunthorpe United.

Laughably, it was a Liverpool supporter who inadvertently cost his team by chucking the inflatable on in the first place.

Advertisement

8. Ruud van Nistelrooy Finds His Personal Space Invaded

Martin Rickett/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Dutch master Ruud van Nistelrooy faced a torrid time when he missed a stoppage-time penalty against old foes Arsenal.

Advertisement

The incident occurred in the days when the Gunners set sights on more than just the FA Cup to fill up their trophy cabinet, therefore a positive result for either side would have been viewed as a major statement of intent.

Van Nistelrooy had, in some people’s eyes, overreacted during an earlier altercation with Patrick Vieira, which saw the Arsenal captain receive his marching orders. His conduct had riled Vieira’s team-mates to such an extent that their collective blood pressures reached boiling point by the time Martin Keown felled David Beckham in the box to concede a last-gasp penalty.

Advertisement

It was villain of the piece ‘Van the Man’ who stepped up to take the spot-kick, but he unluckily whacked it off the crossbar and it flew away to safety. Renowned hard-man Keown was the first to get into his face, ferociously goading the Dutchman.

Seconds later, the final whistle blew. Keown leapt up with arms outstretched, ensuring that he caught Van Nistelrooy on the way down. A 22-man brawl ensued, creating one of the ugliest on-pitch scenes within the Premier League era.

Advertisement

That precious point was integral to Arsenal’s incredible unbeaten run to the 2003-04 title, which led to them being bestowed with the ‘Invincibles’ moniker.

7. Roy Keane’s Very Own Tunnel Of Love

Sean Dempsey/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Another Arsenal versus Manchester United humdinger hadn’t even begun in earnest when sparks flew in the Highbury tunnel.

Advertisement

Midfield lynchpin Roy Keane walked towards the front of the line-up as he prepared for the match when he noticed a gaggle of Gunners giving Gary Neville a hard time.

Fiery Irishman Keane immediately went on the offensive, pointing and shouting in the direction of opposing colossus Patrick Vieira, whom he claimed had been the ringleader in a bullying campaign of sorts against team-mate Neville.

Advertisement

Although a truly unsavoury incident, it displayed the United skipper’s care and consideration for his comrades, as well as handing the visitors a psychological edge which helped to deliver a handsome 4-2 victory.

6. Kevin Keegan Would Love It, He Really Would

Sky Sports

Probably the most memorable post-match interview in Premier League history occurred when Kevin Keegan lost his rag on live television, as the 1995-96 title race between his beloved Newcastle United and perennial challengers Manchester United came to a head.

Advertisement

The Magpies swept all before them throughout the opening half of the campaign to cement a 12-point lead at the top of the league by January. However, the wheels began to come off afterwards and that seemingly unassailable lead was eroded.

Red Devils supremo Alex Ferguson then suggested that teams tried harder to beat his United side than they did against ‘The Entertainers’ of Newcastle, which lit the touch-paper for one of the greatest outbursts ever to hit our screens.

Advertisement

“I've kept really quiet but I'll tell you something, he went down in my estimations when he said that,” bellowed Keegan following a narrow 1-0 win at Leeds with two games still to play.

“We’ve not resorted to that. You can tell him now, we're still fighting for this title and he's got to go to Middlesbrough and get something. And I'll tell you, honestly, I will love it if we beat them, love it.”

Advertisement

Despite his passionate show of emotion, Keegan’s north-eastern upstarts drew the final two fixtures and their illustrious rivals won both of theirs, thus claiming the trophy by a four-point margin.

5. Paolo Di Canio Unleashes Superhero Powers

Barry Coombs/EMPICS Sport

Italian magician Paolo Di Canio was always a hot-head, whether plying his trade in his homeland or on British shores.

Advertisement

But, he took things to a whole new level when pushing referee Paul Alcock to the ground during a game between Sheffield Wednesday and Arsenal.

A fracas took place near the touchline and, true to form, Di Canio decided to involve himself where he wasn’t needed. He completely lost control, proceeding to push Patrick Vieira and then lashing out Martin Keown, before clasping his hands around the Arsenal defender’s throat.

Advertisement

Despite the melee having comprised of around 17 players, it was the maverick forward who saw red – in more ways than one. Di Canio shoved the ref in the chest, seemingly creating a cataclysmic event that saw Alcock stumble backwards in comical fashion for about 10 yards before falling flat on his back.

The Wednesday star stormed off the field and was not seen again for quite some time thanks to an 11-match ban meted out for his indiscretion.

Advertisement

4. When Lee Bowyer And Kieron Dyer Collide

Owen Humphreys/PA Archive

It’s relatively common to see a case of handbags at dawn between two or more opposing players, but much less so in the case of footballers who are meant to be fighting for the same cause.

Advertisement

Nothing went right for Newcastle United on a day when they had a player sent off and were three goals down at home to Aston Villa in April 2005. In fact, little had gone right all season, with Sir Bobby Robson jettisoned unceremoniously earlier in the term and replaced by Graeme Souness.

A young, vibrant side built by Robson was coming apart at the seams and it finally fell to pieces when a poor pass prompted a full-scale war between team-mates Lee Bowyer and Kieron Dyer.

Advertisement

Bowyer accused Dyer of ignoring him on the pitch in favour of passing to others, to which Dyer suggested he did so because it was his firm belief that Bowyer was basically s***.

Suddenly, all hell broke loose, with punches exchanged and black-and-white jerseys ripped to shreds. Villa star Gareth Barry and Magpies full-back Stephen Carr had to pull the pair apart before someone lost an ego.

Advertisement

In the dressing room, fuming boss Souness offered to fight both at the same time, to which they wisely declined. A public apology followed, but the damage had been done.

3. Alan Pardew Loses His Head, Into David Meyler’s Face

Lynne Cameron/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Well-travelled Alan Pardew has suffered more than his fair share of scrapes during a turbulent managerial career to date.

Advertisement

He famously clashed with opposing bosses Arsene Wenger, Martin O’Neill and Manuel Pellegrini in the past, but none came close to the head-to-head combat he laid on Hull City’s David Meyler after what appeared to be an innocuous coming together.

Former Sunderland man Meyler brushed Pardew out of his way to retrieve the ball after it had gone out of play, only for the then-Newcastle United manager to throw a headbutt in the bemused midfielder’s direction.

Advertisement

It was perhaps the craziest moment in Pardew’s footballing life, made even more nonsensical by the fact that his Magpies were sitting on a 3-1 advantage. He got charged with a £160,000 fine and a three-game stadium ban, topped up by a further four-match enforced hiatus from the touchline.

2. You Wouldn’t Like Luis Suarez When He’s ‘Hangry’

Peter Byrne/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Uruguayan superstar Luis Suarez arrived in England from Ajax with a glowing reputation, and little mention of a wild side that had reared its ugly head in Holland.

Advertisement

Liverpool, however, endured his Jekyll and Hyde character in all its forms during a three-and-a-half-year stay at Anfield.

For all his wonderful performances and important goals, Suarez simply couldn’t stop anger issues from getting the better of him.

Advertisement

Having conceded a penalty at one end against Chelsea, Suarez raced forwards desperate to rectify the situation. However, his eagerness to secure the ball caused a tangle with Blues defender Branislav Ivanovic in the opposing area.

Shockingly, replays clearly showed that the feared Liverpool striker had used his teeth as a weapon by planting them into Ivanovic’s arm. What’s more, Suarez unashamedly –and unsuccessfully – claimed for a foul, yet eventually salvaged a point from the jaws of defeat with an injury-time equaliser.

Advertisement

Though the true extent of the confrontation was missed by officials, he was slapped with a 10-game ban in the aftermath. It was the beginning of the end for his time on Merseyside, as another similar occurrence only a year later at the 2014 World Cup saw him shunned by the Premier League and his club.

1. Eric Cantona Was Kung-Fu Fighting

ACTION PLUS sports images/ActionPlus/Corbis

Long before the larger-than-life personality of Zlatan Ibrahimovic arrived in Manchester, it was King Eric Cantona who ruled the Old Trafford roost.

Advertisement

Cantona was a law unto himself and he refused to take crap from anyone, which was best illustrated by his actions at Crystal Palace’s Selhurst Park on a cold January evening.

The Manchester United maestro had been sent off for reacting to marker Richard Shaw’s persistent provocation. As the mercurial forward made his way off the pitch, Palace fan Matthew Simmons bounded down the stand simply to hurl insults.

Advertisement

Cantona claimed there were racist connotations and abuse of his mother included in Simmons’ words, but the supporter in question denied using such language. No matter, the Frenchman launched a stinging attack, as he leapt over the advertising hoardings with a flying kick reminiscent of a Bruce Lee movie.

Simmons left with stud marks on his chest and bruised machismo, but King Eric came off worst with a nine-month FA ban, the loss of his national team place and a two-week jail sentence that was reduced to 120 hours of community service on appeal.

Advertisement

At least the world got to witness one of the weirdest press conferences ever as a result, when Cantona produced his priceless quote concerning seagulls following a trawler for sardines.

Lacking his considerable influence, United lost out on the 1994-95 championship to cash-rich Blackburn Rovers.

Advertisement