10 Players Who Probably Regret Leaving West Ham

Leaving isn't always the wisest decision!

By Steven Bardgett /

West Ham have long had the reputation of a 'feeder' club, highlighted most prominently by the 2003 season which saw countless players including many academy players leave following the club's relegation. A team which included stars such as Jermain Defoe, Paulo Di Canio, Joe Cole, Frederic Kanoute and Glen Johnson, saw these players all leave in following season's transfer windows to varying endeavours. Other notable players such as Frank Lampard and Michael Carrick were sold on at the beginnings of what could have been illustrious careers at West Ham. Frank Lampard is a prime example of a player that went on to great post-West Ham success with Chelsea, but the decision to leave West Ham has not been a wise one for everyone. Whether higher expectations for money or an ambition for a bigger club, players have left in search of something more; something that they failed to find. To play for West Ham, a player must recognise exactly what it means. The fans, the history, the academy; all things that make West Ham United a very special club. These are players that made the decision to leave West Ham, and probably regretted it later.

10. Carlton Cole

An interesting choice, as seemingly Carlton Cole immediately regretted leaving West Ham. After believing he was worth more money than West Ham were willing to pay, he went off in search of a new club and we went off in search of another striker for our money. In a matter of months, it became apparent that Cole had failed to find a new club and evidently we had failed in finding a new striker. A deadline day deal saw Carlton Cole given his second chance with the Hammers.

9. John Hartson

Despite a successful career at Celtic, years after his West Ham departure, John Hartson has since detailed his regret at leaving the Hammers in 1999. Following a crazy incident in which he kicked teammate Eyal Berkovic on the training ground, Hartson claimed many fans turned against him and his time at Upton Park was never the same again.

9. Yossi Benayoun

The Israeli playmaker had the potential to be something special at West Ham, but after two relatively successful seasons with the Hammers, he left, somewhat controversially to join Liverpool. This was after verbally agreeing to sign a new contract with us, for much higher wages than he was offered at Liverpool too. He showed flashes of his quality at Liverpool, but after a disappointing move to Chelsea and two unsuccessful loan spells - one of which was back at West Ham again, where he played only a handful of matches and scored no goals - he is currently playing in the Israeli league for Maccabi Haifa.

8. Nigel Reo-Coker

Captain Nigel Reo-Coker was at the heart of our midfield in the years leading up to and immediately following our dramatic promotion back to the Premier League in 2005. After Alan Pardew was sacked in 2006 when we found ourselves in danger of relegation, Reo-Coker was singled out as one of the main factors towards our downfall. Despite helping keep us up that year - with much help from a certain Carlos Tevez - Reo-Coker searched for and found another club in Aston Villa. After a half decent spell with Aston Villa, and a couple of forgettable stints at Bolton and Ipswich, Reo-Coker is currently playing in the MLS.

7. Robert Green

When Robert Green turned down a new contract offer in 2011, we all presumed it was because of his aspirations to play for a bigger club. He had been in great form for us, and despite his tarnished reputation following a nightmare error against the USA in the 2010 World Cup, Hammers fans still saw him as a great quality goalkeeper. Strange then it was, that after his release from West Ham he joined QPR who were amidst a serious relegation battle. They failed to win this battle and this saw Green demoted to playing Championship football.

5. Alessandro Diamanti

When Alessandro Diamanti left for Breschia following a single season with the Hammers, things seemed to be going well for him. As West Ham were relegated the following season, Diamanti found form with first team spells for Breschia and Bologna, even managing to break his way into the Italian national team. It would seem strange then that his name is on this list, but Diamanti has stated himself that his only regret was leaving West Ham. He became an instant fan favourite in the short time he was with the club, with fans hoping he would become the new Paulo Di Canio. That seemed like one of his own aspirations too, which was unfortunately cut short.

4. Anton Ferdinand

Anton Ferdinand became the second of the Ferdinand brothers to leave West Ham in a lucrative deal; this time to Sunderland for £8 million. When Rio Ferdinand signed for Leeds in a record breaking £18 million deal, we found him difficult to replace, but when his brother Anton came along fans saw many of the same traits and the potential for a star defender arose once again. However this just wasn't to be. Whereas Rio Ferdinand's career flourished at his following club, and led to an even bigger move to Manchester United, Anton's did not. Struggling to find form for his clubs, he now plays his football in the Championship for Reading.

3. Jermain Defoe

Jermain Defoe was one of the best up and coming English strikers when an unfortunately poor season saw West Ham relegated in 2003, and him hand in a transfer request. He moved to Tottenham in the 2004 January transfer window and despite being on the fringes of the first team on more than the odd occasion, he has still proven his worth as a top quality finisher. He has since expressed his love for West Ham United and his regret of not staying with us. It's all good saying that now, but I have a feeling he's still going to get more than his fair share of boos the next time he returns to Upton Park.

2. Scott Parker

In Scott Parker's four seasons with the Hammers, he received Hammer Of The Year 3 times, and Player Of The Year in a season that saw West Ham relegated. That alone proved Parker's quality and passion for the club, almost single handedly keeping us up in the 2010 season. When we were relegated at the end of the following season, Parker left for bitter rivals Tottenham in a move that saw many fans turn their backs on him. He soon went from Hammers star man to a very ordinary Tottenham player struggling to hold down his first team place. Parker is currently playing his football at Championship club Fulham.

1. Joe Cole

Joe Cole left West Ham at the end of our 2003 season of relegation. He joined Frank Lampard at Chelsea and enjoyed a good run of first team action. Slowly but surely, he was edged out and became nothing more than a fringe player, and through his transfer to Liverpool, this became almost a permanent role for him for the rest of his career. He made a return to West Ham in 2013 and showed glimpses of his former self much to fans delight, however this just highlighted the fact that Joe Cole could've made himself a real West Ham legend had he stayed.