10 Terrible Refereeing Decisions That Changed World Cup Games
Let's hope VAR makes this World Cup a little fairer.
Yelling at the referee is as much a part of the football-watching experience as singing your team’s songs and cheering when a goal is scored. Refereeing isn't easy and it's only natural for mistakes to be made, but those errors are even more glaring when the whole world is watching.
At this summer’s World Cup, for the first time ever, VAR (video assistant referees) are set to be used in a bid to cut down the number of bad decisions. Some fans and analysts are still wary of this technology, but there are plenty of incidents from past World Cups where it would have been welcomed with open arms.
Referees are only human, after all, but the slightest mistake or lapse in concentration on their part can lead to major consequences, not just for the two teams on the pitch that day, but for the rest of the tournament at large.
The World Cup only comes along once every four years, and fans from all around the globe want to see fair games with correct calls, giving both teams a level playing field and ensuring that the best team truly does win. Sadly, it hasn’t always worked out that way.
10. USA Vs. Slovenia (2010)
The United States were one of 2010's surprise packages, managing to narrowly win Group C ahead of England. Both teams earned five points from their fixtures and had the same goal difference, but the US earned top spot due to their superior tally of goals scored.
They could, however, have won the group outright on points if this terrible decision hadn't stood. It occurred in the US' second group game against Slovenia. The match was tied 2-2 and the US had won a free kick in a promising position in the 85th minute. American legend Landon Donovan whipped in a great delivery and substitute Maurice Edu smashed it home, but the referee had blown his whistle just a fraction of a second earlier and the goal didn't stand.
On the replays, however, no fans or commentators could understand what the ref, Koman Coulibaly, had allegedly seen. If anything, replays showed lots of Slovenian players grappling their US counterparts and a penalty should probably have been awarded to the Americans. Koulibaly was not selected to referee another game at the tournament.
9. Spain Vs. South Korea (2002)
As co-hosts of the 2002 World Cup, South Korea's path to the semi-finals was wrought with controversy. Referees seemed to be favouring the host nation at every opportunity and a lot of questionable decisions were going their way. Nowhere was this more evident than in the team's quarter final clash with Spain.
The game finished 0-0 and was eventually decided on penalties, with South Korea winning 5-3, but many spectators argued that the Spanish should have won the match in regular time. In the second half, Rubén Baraja scored what seemed to be a perfectly legitimate goal from a corner, but the ref ruled it out.
Spanish hearts would break once more in the first half of extra-time, when Fernando Morientes again seemed to score a perfectly legal goal, which would have been the 'Golden Goal' to end the game in Spain's favour, but the ref disallowed the strike and the game petered out to a draw. After the match, referee Gamal Al-Ghandour was widely vilified by the media and Spanish players, and never appeared at a major tournament again.
8. Brazil Vs. Croatia (2014)
The opening game of any World Cup is always an exciting and tense occasion. This summer's clash between Russia and Saudi Arabia might not quite live up to the same hype, but the last World Cup began with a bang as host nation Brazil faced Croatia in an entertaining, competitive game. Croatia unexpectedly took the lead after 11 minutes, but from that moment on, the referee, Yuichi Nishimura, seemed to heavily favour the Brazilians.
Neymar equalised after 29 minutes and then scored a penalty in the second half, but many fans argued that the penalty simply shouldn't have been awarded. Dejan Lovren was deemed to have fouled Fred, but the contact was minimal and the Brazilian appeared to just let himself fall to the ground.
Croatia then scored an equaliser but the ref had already blown his whistle for an alleged foul on goalkeeper Júlio César. Again, replays showed that there was no real foul and César had simply mistimed his movement and left his goal open. Brazil eventually won 3-1, but it's easy to see how the game could have ended differently with more competent refereeing.
7. Brazil Vs. Ivory Coast (2010)
There are two terrible decisions to talk about in this game, with one going in Brazil's favour and the other going the way of the Ivory Coast, so maybe it's true what they say: everything evens out in the end. Brazil took the lead after 25 minutes, with striker Luis Fabiano scoring a nice little goal, but Ivory Coast held their own as the game progressed.
Then, in the 50th minute, Fabiano scored a second, blatantly using his hands twice in the buildup to his strike. Everyone in the stadium and millions of spectators watching at home could see the error, but French referee Stéphane Lannoy didn't, and Fabiano's goal stood. At that point, 2-0 down, the Ivory Coast players struggled to stay in the game and Elano scored a third for Brazil about ten minutes later.
The second contentious decision of this game came in the 88th minute when Brazil's midfield maestro Kaká, widely-known as a nice guy and fair player, was sent off for allegedly hitting Ivorian Kader Keita in the face. Replays revealed, however, that Kaká had done nothing wrong and Keita basically ran into him and then fell over, holding his face to feign injury.
6. USSR Vs. Belgium (1986)
One of the most entertaining, memorable, and controversial World Cup games of all time, the round of 16 clash between the Soviet Union and Belgium finished 2-2 after 90 minutes and ended 4-3 to the Belgians after extra time, but a big argument could be made that the game should never have made it past the 90 minute mark.
The Soviet Union side would have given anything for VAR during that game, as both of Belgium's regular time goals were widely-considered to be offside. The Soviets opened the scoring through Igor Belanov in the 27th minute, with Belgium's Enzo Scifo equalising in the 56th. With the TV footage, it's hard to tell whether or not Scifo was offside, but he certainly seemed that way to many fans.
Belanov put the Soviet Union back in the lead in the 70th minute, but Belgium once again got back into the game. This time, the offside was even more obvious as Jan Ceulemans was well behind the last defender as he chested the ball down and tucked it home. The Belgians went on to score twice more in extra time to seal the victory, even though Belanov pulled one back and claimed an impressive hat-trick.
5. Netherlands Vs. Spain (2010)
England didn't make it to the 2010 World Cup final, but one English man was still able to run around on the pitch during the game; referee Howard Webb was given the ultimate honour of officiating the match, but by the time it was all over, he probably wished he'd just watched from the stands instead.
Despite being the showcase game of the tournament, the match was marred by nasty fouls, rather than the beautiful football fans had hoped for. The tie ultimately went to extra time and was won by the Spanish in the 116th minute, but it might not have needed to go on so long had Webb paid attention to what was surely the most shocking foul of the tournament
In the first half, Nigel De Jong was guilty of a gruesome studs-up kick square in the chest of Spanish midfielder Xabi Alonso. De Jong got nowhere near the ball and Alonso was writhing on the floor in agony as Webb approached, but the English ref later revealed he hadn't had a clear view of the incident and was forced to hand out a yellow card, rather than a straight red.
4. Germany Vs. England (2010)
England fans still cringe when they think of this one. Frank Lampard's "ghost goal" at the 2010 World Cup has gone down in history as one of those "What if?" moments, with fans still talking about the incident years later. Everyone has their opinion on what might have happened had the goal stood, but we can all agree that it definitely should have been given.
The Three Lions had limped into the knockout stages and were pitted against Germany. The likes of John Terry and Stephen Gerrard talked a good game in the buildup to the match, but it started terribly, with Klose and Podolski putting the Germans 2-0 up after 32 minutes. But then, England seemed to find a way back into it!
Matthew Upson's face scored a goal in the 37th minute and Frank Lampard equalised just two moments later. Except, he didn't actually equalise. The ball hit the crossbar, bounced into the goal, a good yard over the line, before bouncing back out. Everyone watching at home saw the goal, but the ref and his linesman didn't. The game finished 4-1 to the Germans, but if England had gone in at halftime with the score at 2-2, who knows what could have happened?
3. South Korea Vs. Italy (2002)
South Korea have already appeared in this list but here they are again, with their successful 2002 run to the World Cup semi-finals being one of the most controversial stories in the history of the competition. The team's quarter final against Spain was littered with problems, but the clash against Italy in the round of 16 was even worse.
The first issue came after just five minutes of play, with South Korea being given a penalty for a very light foul on forward Seol Ki-Hyeon. Gianluigi Buffon saved the spot kick, but the ref continued to act in favour of the co-hosts. The South Koreans became increasingly aggressive over the course of the match, getting away with a number of fouls that would normally have warranted yellow or red cards.
In extra time, Italian midfielder Francesco Totti got sent off for diving in bizarre circumstances as the ref was miles away from the incident. Minutes later, Italy thought they'd won with Damiano Tommasi scoring what seemed to be a perfectly legal goal, but it was ruled out for offside. The South Koreans then won the game with a strike in the 118th minute, and even former FIFA president Sepp Blatter said that the referee had a terrible match.
2. Italy Vs. Uruguay (2014)
The group stage game of the 2014 World Cup between Uruguay and Italy will live long in the memory of all who saw it. The game was riddled with bad decisions, starting with a red card for Italian midfielder Claudio Marchisio early in the second half. Marchisio was given a straight red for a foul that was certainly unfair but definitely not the worst challenge of the day. Around 20 minutes later, the game would take a truly shocking turn.
Uruguayan striker Luis Suarez scuffled with Italian defender Giorgio Chiellini. Suarez was then shown biting down on Chiellini's shoulder, before rolling around on the floor and holding his teeth in pain. The ref didn't issue any cards as he didn't have a good look at the incident, but Suarez, who had already bitten two opponents in his career before that game, was later handed a major ban.
Unfortunately, that didn't mean too much to the Italians at the time. Just after the bite, Uruguay won a corner and scored the game's winning goal, sending Italy out of the tournament. Had the referee seen the incident and awarded a free kick and red card, it's easy to see how the game may have ended differently.
1. Argentina Vs. England (1986)
Here's another incident that England fans will never forget. It was the 1986 World Cup and England had made it to the quarter final where they would face off against longtime rivals, Argentina. As they prepared for kickoff, little did the players know that this game would become one of the most memorable matches in World Cup history.
The first half was pretty cagey, but Argentina had the best of it, with England goalie Peter Shilton having to be at his best to keep the score at 0-0. Early in the second half, Diego Maradona, one of the greatest footballers to ever play the game, scored that famous goal that would come to be known as the "Hand of God".
England's Steve Hodge made a mess of his clearance and the ball fell towards Maradona. The little Argentinian leaped into the air and punched the ball over the keeper and into the net. Astonishingly, the ref said he saw no handball and the goal stood, with Maradona adding a sensational second a few minutes later and Argentina winning the game 2-1. On the day, Argentina were probably the deserved winners, but the match might have gone another way without Maradona's famous handball.