It might have been a sure-thing, as yesterday's pro-selection article about that Olympic snub stated: David Beckham might have been wanted by people from the Olympic committee down to the fans and he might have been a big player in the recent history of English football, but he shouldn't ever have been included as a playing member of the Olympic GB Team. Ignoring for now the inane accusations that Stuart Pearce cut David Beckham after initially including him on the short-list as some kind of publicity stunt to "make a name for himself," or that Beckham should be included as a member of the playing squad to represent Britain simply because of his effect on the gates is absurd, there are a number of reasons that make his snub a wholly justified one. And when that second argument is backed up by assertions that his snub somehow suggests that his inclusion on the Olympic committee was false advertising, it all gets a little bit tiresome. David Beckham was included on that committee not because he was definitely going to play - Lord Coe isn't participating for instance - he was there because of what he has represented to the sport, and because of his celebrity draw. To include him in the actual playing squad for the same reasons would be outrageous. Here are six reasons why Stuart Pearce was right to leave Beckham out...
6. It Isn't An Exhibition Tournament
Nostalgia counts for nothing. The idea that Beckham would be included as some sort of trophy, and in the process welcoming a circus spirit to the matches as fans apparently flock from far and wide to catch a glimpse of the star is redundant and laughably outdated. No squad player should be included because of their effect on ticket sales, and to do so would be to criminally undermine a major sporting event that is already considered to be an inferior concern to any of the other prestige international tournaments. I keep hearing assertions that we aren't in the Olympics to win, or that Stuart Pearce is taking it all too seriously, and both are ridiculous. When you appoint a man of Pearce's passion to any high-profile coaching job, you get everything that comes with that appointment, including the famous burning will to win that characterised him as a player. If the heads of Team GB wanted the team to have a Harlem Globetrotters style jaunt, they should and would have appointed someone like Terry Venables. But they didn't, they went for a man who they knew would want to win Gold, and then equipped him with the power to pick his own squad for that very reason. Had they wanted a patsy who would have collected together ceremonial players that ticket-buyers would put their hands in their pockets to see, they should have appointed the team that put together the Soccer Aid programme and made Simon Cowell the manager. This tournament is about winning, as every professional tournament should be. And no well-paid underpants model who used to be the best in the world in his position is going to help that.
5. Giving Youth a Chance
The England team will go through a period of transition in the next year or so as older stars opt to retire, and new blood is brought in to explore new alternatives (as long as Roy Hodgson does his job properly). The Olympics offers the perfect opportunity to give those players who might make the step up to the full team a chance to play on a big stage, and one which will be more televised and celebrated than any U21 tournament. The Olympics is an opportunity for those players to mature in a competitive environment, to possibly make a bridging step towards the full team. Like U21 tournaments, this U23 event should be seen as a developmental opportunity predominantly - and though some might say the presence of David Beckham might equally influence those type of players, it is just as possible that such influence would be just as profound if Beckham was given a coaching role in the set-up. By the way, that assertion regarding young England players might seem to undervalue the influence that other British team members might have on the team, but let's face it, the core of the squad is likely to be English considering the comparatively low world rankings of the other teams.
4. The Other Over-Age Options Are Better
Ryan Giggs, Micah Richards and Craig Bellamy. All three offer something more than a good right foot and commitment, even if Ryan Giggs' inclusion does smack slightly of the same ceremonial selection that I am so dead against in David Beckham's case. But even in that case, Giggs comes to the Olympics after another season in the Premier League, in the team that came second, and having played a part in that final position, albeit a lesser one than he has in former seasons. Craig Bellamy meanwhile offers something more than most U23 England strikers at the minute, and would probably have got into the England squad were he born in this country based on how poorly the current strikeforce have been doing. The majority of the backlash aimed at the three rumoured over 23 inclusions has been and will be aimed at Micah Richards, thanks to his conduct surrounding the EURO 2012 squad, and specifically refusing to be on the waiting list. Yes, it was something of a poor PR decision to turn the opportunity down, but Richards should have been included in the main squad from the off. He is powerful, fast and passionate on the pitch, and the snub for the EUROs squad hurt him - making a mockery of accusations that he won't care enough to warrant inclusion in the Olympics. He walked away because it meant something to him. Personally I would prefer to have not only these three players, but a long list of other over 23 players ahead of Beckham, based on current form and value to the team's performance, as opposed to the hope of an intangible effect he will have on the spirit of the camp.
3. There's No Target Man
Aside from the apparently spiritual effect that Beckham might have on the team, which the outraged fans seem to be suggesting would be his major selling point, Beckham would undoubtedly provide excellent service and deliveries from set-pieces. He would effectively be a special team player on the pitch for 90 minutes (or however long he lasted), and that would certainly be valuable in the right circumstances. But consider this for a minute - who exactly would Beckham be aiming those crosses and long cross-field balls at? Without a target man, or at least someone who will win the ball in the air for someone else of Craig Bellamy's ilk to run on to, those crosses - away from set-pieces at least - would be no more valuable than long balls out from the back. Including Beckham would require playing a system that gave him the ball as much as possible in order to build attacking play around his array of passing, but that would entirely change the dynamic of what will otherwise be a forward-thinking, pacey team, based on (presumably) Gareth Bale's wing-play and willingness to advance play with the ball at his feet. Yes, no doubt Beckham would ping cross-field balls towards Bale in the advanced wing position, but the Welshman is arguably more dangerous running from slightly deeper, which takes away the need for Beckham's chief asset. Of course Beckham faced a similar situation when playing on the opposite wing to Ryan Giggs in his Manchester United days, but that team wasn't as lop-sided as the GB team would be with the 37 year old Beckham on the right, because back then, he ran forward down the flanks as much as he crossed from deep. The idea that he could play that way now, after so many years in the MLS, and with the weight of age in his legs is rather optimistic. Had Andy Carroll been in the squad, it might have been different, but he isn't likely to be, and Britain have few younger options who could offer the same sort of outlet.
2. Team GB Need An On-Pitch Leader Not a Figure-Head
Beckham would be a ceremonial figure-head, included because of what he represents, rather than what he tangibly offers to the team on the pitch, and while that will be good for the dressing room, what is really needed is an on-field general who will lead by example. Beckham used to be that sort of player - in fact he was the archetypal on-pitch leader, willing to run further and harder for the cause than any of his fellow players. He used to lead by example, increasing the performance of other players through proximity, precisely because his effort and workrate made those who weren't as keen look bad. That won't be the case now - Beckham won't be able to keep up with teams of under 23 players, no matter how much his spirit would be willing, so his opportunity to lead by example would be significantly diminished. But that doesn't mean he should have been over-looked entirely, because of the impact he could have on the team in the dressing room: the former Manchester United man still talks with passion and could represent enough of a ceremonial figure-head to command a place on Stuart Pearce's coaching squad. And if he isn't able to take that role, it will be to the cost of the team spirit. That still doesn't mean he should be on the pitch, though.
1. He's Just Not Good Enough Anymore
Charm and integrity don't win football matches. And neither does a player who is too old for the international set-up, and who is currently playing his club football in a comparatively inferior league offering 150% every game. Because that 150% isn't necessarily going to be as good as a younger player's 100%. Beckham should have been included if he was the best available player, and unfortunately for him, the opportunity to play in the Olympics came two years or so too late. It might have been a lot different if the rumoured move to Tottenham on loan had come about, but no matter what his form has been in the MLS this year, it is all relative, and that league is no more than Championship quality. The squad is built on merit, as opposed to sentimentality, and to suggest otherwise sets a dangerous precedent that continues the unnecessary devaluation of the entire association of football and the Olympics. What better way to make the British treat the event, and the football aspect of it seriously than to go out and take it seriously, and make a real effort to win Gold? What do you think? Do you think David Beckham's snub was a disgrace? Or do you agree with my own assessment? Let us know below.