10 Amazing TV Shows (With Terrible Lead Characters)
Should've just gotten in the god damn robot, Shinji.
TV shows are built on characters. While a movie can certainly get away with the characters not being that interesting, since you're only stuck with them for two and a half hours at most, a TV show asks quite a bit more of a time commitment from its audience. As such, we had better like the people we're stuck with.
What makes a likeable lead character is one of the most subjective things on the planet, since it often reflects back on the personal biases and experiences of the person giving the opinion. But every now and then you'll find an anomaly, a show that most people love...with a protagonist that NO ONE loves.
Lead characters have to carry and push the plot of the story forward, while staying likeable at the same time. That's a hell of a tightrope act, and not every character walks it without falling and breaking their necks.
Whether because they're required to be jerks in order to justify the story not ending yet, or because they just weren't that well written to begin with compared to their co-stars, these great TV shows managed to still be great, even when hamstrung by genuinely AWFUL main characters.
10. Arrow
Arrow as a whole did not get off to an appealing start. While it would find its footing as it went on, pretty much all of its problems can be summed up in how it portrayed Oliver Queen.
The problem with this version of Oliver Queen is that he ISN'T Oliver Queen. From front to back, you can tell the writers of this show really just wanted to make a Batman show. So when they couldn't do that, they decided to forcibly cram Oliver into a Batman mould.
Gone were Oliver's liberal politics and aesthetic of "guy who is a billionaire, but would take a guillotine to every single billionaire on the planet if he could get away with it" in favour of Green Arrow just being yet another dark brooding avenger of the night using the cover of a playboy rich kid.
As the show progressed and the writers got over themselves, Oliver would more closely resemble the version from the comics, which ultimately redeemed it enough to place it at the bottom of this list. But the fact that Oliver didn't even call himself Green Arrow for over three seasons still deserves mockery.
9. Daria
Like with Arrow, Daria's eponymous lead grew more likeable in the later seasons, but watching those first few seasons in 2020 is nigh unbearable.
A lot of this has to do with how starkly different youth culture in both this author's generation and the one after it has developed in the fallout of the 90's. Nowadays, Daria's monotone, too-cool-for-school, "liking things and being excited for things is for sheep" attitude is just no longer relatable.
We've thankfully seem to have outgrown the 90's mindset that the best way to be interesting is to be a cynical, know-it-all jerk. So showing someone who was in Daria's demographic the show these days is likely to result in them rolling their eyes at the lead, and who can blame them?
What makes this complicated, again, are those later seasons, where Daria's attitude actually bites her in the ass more than once, and even nearly costs her the few relationships she actually lets herself care about, forcing her to adapt and evolve. The latter half of the show is what makes it such a fondly remembered classic, but if you didn't grow up in the generation Daria did, then she'll make getting there an utter slog.
8. Girls
Main characters in comedy are a tricky sort. Make them too defined by one joke like the rest of the cast, and audiences will despise them. But if you make them too much of what comedy terms the 'straight man', they become boring, because no one wants to follow a comedy where the main character does nothing but roll their eyes or tut-tut the other characters' antics.
Comedy writers have to make their main characters funny and likeable enough for audiences to want to follow them, while making sure they aren't the weirdest part of their world, so audiences aren't turned off.
A fine line that Girls' Hannah Horvath fails miserably at walking.
This brilliantly grounded mumblecore comedy unfortunately has a lead who is uninteresting at the best of times acting as an albatross around its neck. While the other characters have their defining gimmicks, quirks, and running gags, there's always something a bit more hiding underneath the surface to help you believe that these are real people. Hannah, on the other hand, is often portrayed as a one-note stereotype of millennial youth culture, and not even in a funny way.
Mumblecore is already an acquired taste as a subgenre, and characters like Hannah do not help Girls make a case for itself as the unique comedy that it is.
7. Malcolm In The Middle
Being the straight man in a comedy is a thankless job, but someone's gotta do it. But when you have a straight man as your protagonist, you need to make sure they feel like they still inhabit the same universe as the zanier members of your cast. The titular Malcolm from Malcolm in the Middle does not accomplish this.
Ask any fan of this show what their favourite scene from this classic sitcom was, and if any of them mention a scene where Malcolm was the one who delivered the funniest bit, that person is lying to you.
Some people will point to Michael Bluth from Arrested Development as the biggest example of a straight man protagonist dragging down the insanity of the rest of the show. But to be fair, Michael had his own quirks and eccentricities - it's just the rest of the cast was SO insane and out there that even a centimetre less than that felt like coming down from a high.
For the more grounded insanity of Malcolm in the Middle's cast, Malcolm's boring nature comes through all the more and with less of an excuse.
6. My So-Called Life
My So-Called Life is right up there with Firefly and Tron: Uprising as one of the best TV shows that was cancelled way too soon. But where it differs from those two shows is that Angela Davis is nowhere near as likeable as Tron or Firefly's protagonists.
None of which is the fault of Clair Danes, of course, as she put in an amazing performance as always. But Angela is the epitome of everything you wanted to strangle your 15 year old self over. Annoyingly self important, whiny, and stealing scenes away from far more worthwhile members of the cast.
My So-Called Life was a smart show, so it's entirely possible that they were planning on pulling a Daria and giving Angela a much needed dose of maturity as the series went on.
But alas, that's not what ended up happening, as the show instead getting cancelled right as it was starting to go from good to genuinely great. Which means we are stuck with the Angela that the show had from up until that point, who was frankly a waste of space.
5. Future Diary
If there's anything negative that NGE contributed to anime, it was starting a trend that lasted all throughout the late 90's and 2000's where shows seemed convinced that the best way to be dark and mature was to make your main character not do anything or make even the most basic of decisions in favor of laying around moping all day long.
Yukiteru Amano from Future Diary is by far the worst example of this trend, dragging down an otherwise entertainingly sick and wonderfully depraved death game anime pretty much every moment he was on screen by being just the biggest wet napkin wuss on the planet.
There's a reason that every ad you see of this show revolves around his psycho stalker girlfriend, because trying to sell this show via its actual protagonist is an exercise in futility. Yukiteru is one of the biggest pansies in anime history, and that threshold is vast.
In fact there's only one anime character that could top Yukiteru for being a terrible protagonist in an otherwise great anime, and it's the one that's to blame for him existing in the first place...
4. Neon Genesis Evangelion
Ask any anime fan what amazing show has the worst protagonist, most of them will point straight to that most problematic of faves: Neon Genesis Evangelion and its frustrating hero, Shinji Ikari.
Originally pitched as a harsh, biting deconstruction of the giant robot genre of anime - particularly its laissez faire attitude towards child endangerment - it makes sense that the audience is not really meant to like Shinji.
He is, after all, a teenager in a show that remembers that teenagers, by and large, suck in real life. Especially when you pile on the kind of emotional baggage that this teenager in particular has going on.
However, Shinji does have an arc that stretches throughout the show, and we are meant to be satisfied with where he finds himself by the end of the story. Which makes his lack of any kind of agency and general refusal to actually contribute (hence the famous meme "get in the god damn robot, Shinji") all the more frustrating.
Add onto this a near constant attitude of "woe is me" when his issues aren't even in the same ballpark as what the other characters have going on, and you get a protagonist that frankly annoys more than anything else.
3. Orange Is The New Black
Orange is the New Black was one of the first heavy hitter shows that Netflix rolled out for their original content, and all these years later, it still holds up today. Only problem is that Piper is still the worst possible protagonist for a show like this.
The main problem with Piper is that her near constant grumbling and complaining would be tolerable (she is, after all, stuck in the American prison system, so her frustrations aren't unwarranted) if everyone else around her didn't have it a million times worse.
Point to any character in the above image alone, let alone any given episode of the show, and chances are good that they have it way worse than Piper, yet she and the show act like she has it the worst of all. And yes, the show does get around to smacking her with some reality, but her attitude doesn't change to any significant degree to make a difference.
2. How I Met Your Mother
One of the funniest sitcoms ever made is How I Met Your Mother, without a doubt. But many fans agree that Ted Mosby is not the reason why.
Even going beyond the main sin he commits of being by far the least interesting part of his own story - which frankly is the case for all sitcom protagonists - Ted's story just isn't interesting enough to be stretched as long as the story goes on. Add onto that a general whiny demeanor, and you wonder why any woman would look twice at this doofus. Even Barney at his worst is at least more interesting.
When you spend more time talking about your kids' aunt instead of their mother, you know, the person the whole show is predicated on talking about, then you know you just don't have that much to say.
1. Rick And Morty
Of course it's Rick and Morty, don't act shocked.
Rick and Morty is, for the most part, one of the smartest TV shows ever made. But its main problem up until recently was that its lead character, Rick Sanchez, was fundamentally unlikable, and the show was nowhere near as good at calling that fact out as it believed itself to be.
Rick is an insufferably nihilistic, self-destructive, irreparably toxic man. He is smart enough to end world hunger and all known diseases, but not only actively chooses to do otherwise, but would probably launch into a drunken rant about the idiocy of trying to use his intellect for anything other than personal entertainment or gain.
And until season four rolled around, the show was always incredibly non-committal about his attitude biting him in the ass to any genuine degree. No matter what it said about him, it would always spend the next episode showing Rick being cool or badass or really really smart, so its callouts of his behaviour always felt more like dodges than actual plot points because it wanted to have its cake and eat it too.
Season four is where we finally see his family grow genuinely sick of his whole first year philosophy class "nothing matters so be a jerk" routine and him actually failing to fix the problem, making it feel all the more solid of a callout.
But considering the length of time between each season, how many fans of the show have actively refused to get that they're not supposed to like Rick, and how long it took them to punish Rick for his behaviour in a way that felt in any way permanent, it wasn't enough to keep the show from the top spot on this list.
Rick and Morty is a great, clever, and hilarious TV show. Rick Sanchez is a terrible main character. Both these things can be true, and it isn't a contradiction.