10 Best American Horror Story Characters

The core cast have played dozens of characters over the years, but who’s the very best?

By Stacey Henley /

American Horror Story changed the game for horror, and one of the key developments it made was bringing characterisation back to the genre. While horror tales have been a classic of cinema for decades, characters had been sidelined in the early 00s as shock factor movies like Saw, Hostel, and The Human Centipede rose to prominence.

Advertisement

Ryan Murphy & Brad Falchuk, fresh off the commercial and critical success of Glee, changed that. It might have seemed like a strange place to go to after such a happy, preppy show, but both men have also worked on Nip/Tuck, Scream Queens and 9-1-1. Glee and AHS seem to represent the opposite ends of their writing spectrum.

By pivoting away from the bright neon glow of Glee and building a dark, creepy, atmospheric world in Season One’s Murder House, American Horror Story was a smash hit success, reviving and creating careers along the way. The serial anthology approach is a rarity in television, and it’s only so successful because of all the characterisation they manage to squeeze into each season.

Deciding the best character came down to acting, narrative and popularity in the fanbase. With that in mind, better received seasons are more likely to feature.

10. Kai Anderson

Cult’s sole representative on this list, Evan Peters’ Kai Anderson was a starkly drawn character who represented the scariest monster American Horror Story has ever depicted: society itself.

Advertisement

Or radicalisation within society, to be more exact. Cult held a mirror up and forced us to stare at it, and the thing we saw gazing back was Kai Anderson. Cult eschewed the usual supernatural tropes and left us with only the evil of mankind. Kai personified this with a discomforting charm.

We saw him channeling Tyler Durden as the charismatic leader of his cult, but underneath it all he was far less smooth than Brad Pitt’s character. Kai was prone to bouts of apoplectic rage, and while Durden just wanted mindless destruction, Kai engineered everything to put himself on a path to the top.

Political parodies can often fall short in television, especially when they’re parodying somebody already so over the top as Donald Trump. But in Kai, AHS winks at real life just enough, while still delivering the devastating violence with their usual flair.

Another Peters’ character with charm and power might also have made the cut in James Marsh, but Hotel already has some representation in the top ten.

9. Cordelia Foxx

She’s the f**king supreme. Her rise to power in Coven was methodical and nuanced, playing well against Jessica Lange’s also brilliant Fiona Goode.

Advertisement

Though we see a much steelier version of the character towards Coven’s end (and returning in Apocalypse), she begins her story on our screens as someone kind, caring and gentle. It’s no wonder she sees the similarly sweet Mallory as her supreme successor. Having said that, she’s by no means a smiling dullard. Her relationship with her mother Fiona is acerbic, and while Fiona tends to land heavier blows, Cordelia gives as good as she gets. She might even have murdered her mother early in the season were she not wise enough to know the coven still needed to draw on Fiona’s power.

She’s also one of the most dedicated characters the show has ever seen. Her milky eyes are unnerving at first, though they are apparently key to her supernatural powers of Sight. When Myrtle Snow gives her new eyes, she cannot go on with only natural, human sight, and stabs her eyes with garden shears to get back what she lost.

Cordelia is tender, motherly, and nurturing, but she’s hardcore too.

8. Lana Winters

While Sarah Paulson was dedicated as Cordelia Foxx, there’s no character in American Horror Story who’s ever been as resolute as Lana Winters. In the show’s second season, Asylum, Winters is put through some of the show’s most abject horror, but still manages to come out the other side.

Advertisement

Giving herself a grisly coat hanger abortion is particularly uncomfortable to watch, especially on a rewatch knowing she’s ultimately unsuccessful. Her experience changes her, beginning her arc as ambitious but naive. By the end, her ambition is as fierce as ever, but that wide-eyed naivety has been replaced by a cold core.

She’s emblematic of a lot of Asylum’s core themes, and so ties the season together. As a lesbian career woman trying to expose those in power, she makes herself a target. After she’s (wrongfully) committed to Briarcliff, she becomes a focal point for the torture mental patients used to suffer in asylums.

While the Bloody Face killings, Nazi scientists and demon apparitions give the show that AHS flair, Asylum was always about the horror of humans in asylums. And in Lana Winters, the show has the perfect vehicle to tell that story.

7. Misty Day

Lily Rabe was perfectly cast here. It’s perhaps unsurprising that three seasons in, they were able to wring some of the best performances out of the returning cast members. Rabe’s ethereal look and fine blonde hair was perfect for Misty’s au natural, flower power personality.

Advertisement

Though she is forced by circumstance to live as a loner, she’s actually one of the most loving and friendly characters in American Horror Story, connecting deeply to her sisters in the coven. If ever there was a reminder that flowers have thorns, Misty Day is it. She has respect for all living things, but respect must be earned. When she sees poachers killing an alligator near her swampland home, she resurrects the creative and unleashes it on them.

It’s this core of goodness that makes her story so tragic. Had she been born without magic, she might have had an easy life. Even her own version of Hell is not any form of torture or suffering for her. Instead, she’s back in science class having to dissect a frog. Her worst nightmare is causing harm to an innocent creature.

6. Liz Taylor

Denis O’Hare was always an integral if under appreciated part of the show. Hotel gave him a starring role and he delivered. The show has often explored queer themes (with O’Hare just one of many queer actors in the cast), but with Liz Taylor they went on a deep dive.

Advertisement

Although her story was more of a B-plot, John Lowe was such a bore in the main narrative that many fans preferred the exploration of the Hotel’s lesser lights, and Liz Taylor’s shone the brightest.

Being moved to tears by the Countess’ remarks that her blood ‘smells like a woman’, Liz is quickly transformed from a closeted, occasional crossdresser into a fully fledged transwoman. This occurs when she witnesses the Countess murder two of her co-workers and she gives up her former life to go work as a bartender at the Cortez. While it’s not the most traditional transition storyline, it was strangely uplifting to watch, despite the murder and bloodshed involved.

At the Cortez itself, Liz is no longer the repressed and withdrawn creature she was as Nick Pryor, but instead is vibrant, insightful, eccentrically stylish and wise. In her own way, she is the catalyst that keeps pushing Hotel forward.

5. Dandy Mott

Dandy Mott is such a brilliantly twisted character, and in Finn Wittrock the show proved they could still add valuable new talent to sit comfortably alongside their regular roster.

Advertisement

A little like the Targaryens in Game Of Thrones, Edward Phillippe Mott in Roanoke confirmed that madness had always ran through the Mott bloodline. Similar to his ancestor Edward, Dandy is incredibly awkward around people. This, combined with a warped upbringing, his wealth and his spoiled nature makes Dandy Mott possibly the least well adjusted character in the show’s run. It’s the reason why, despite his good looks, he feels more at home with the freaks of Freak Show than with anyone else.

Though Twisty is the most iconic image from Freak Show, it’s Dandy’s arc that brings Twisty’s story to its full potential. After Dandy tracks Twisty and watches him kidnap two girls, Dandy helps him put in a show for them. This leads to Twisty being killed by Edward Mordrake’s curse, and Dandy taking possession of Twisty’s mask.

While he had previously been a tantrum throwing bore, the mask gives Dandy a sense of power and urgency. From that moment on, neither he or the show looked back.

4. Fiona Goode

While Paulson’s Cordelia Foxx was crucial to Coven’s enduring popularity, it would have been nothing without Jesica Lange’s Fiona Goode to bounce off. Playing Foxx’s predecessor as Supreme (and supremely unmotherly mother), Fiona was a grounded villain, one who came across as ruthless, yet quietly vulnerable. The role was arguably Lange’s finest hour.

Advertisement

Like many great villains before her, Fiona is impossible to truly dislike; she’s too intelligent, charismatic and graceful for that. She’s not a completely evil entity, providing much-needed realism to ground a season full of witchcraft and wonder. There’s a fatal flaw there too, one which worms its way through her like she were a decaying apple: vanity.

It’s this vanity which elevates her. Some villains start off strong and then unravel as they begin to lose, causing them to act more and more desperate. While Fiona’s veneer of cool does slip away as Cordelia ascends (causing Fiona’s own powers to wane), no actions feel out of character.

Ultimately, Fiona is such a great character because she genuinely cares for the witches under her, but is not above using and abusing them for her own gain. Where Kai Anderson is a deliberate caricature, Fiona is the somber reality.

3. Tate Langdon

A sympathetic school shooter is a bold character to lead the opening season, but it set the tone for American Horror Story’s more shocking storylines. Back when the show was brand new, they created one of their most layered and effective characters ever.

Advertisement

Though Murder House aired before Sandy Hook and Parkland reignited the debate over gun control in the USA, having a school shooter as a protagonist was still a huge risk. The shooters of Columbine and Virginia Tech were demons, monsters, villains; their faces splattered on newspapers around the globe, just as their classmates blood had been on the walls of their school. Trying to make us feel sorry for one was an incredibly risky arc.

What makes it most effective is that they don’t try too hard. Tate is not a nice young boy who simply got bullied too much and took misguided revenge. He’s a violent, angry young man, often feeling entitled despite his lack of self esteem, and prone to fits of rage. His bittersweet ending of always been near to Violet yet never able to have her love seemed a fitting purgatory. A shame Apocalypse rewrote this to give him closure.

2. Madison Montgomery

While she has to settle for silver here, bratty witch Madison Montgomery is probably the best vessel Ryan Murphy has ever written for his searing, unique wit.

Advertisement

She’s such a great character, Murphy’s side project Scream Queens was basically a spin-off for her; Chanel is just Madison without the magic. Even without the starring role Scream Queens gave her, Emma Roberts is extraordinary in Coven. While she’s maybe not the greatest actress the show has ever seen, no one has come close to fitting their role quite as well as Roberts did here.

Sassy, egotistical and mean can often lead to writers shoehorning lazy insults in, with the character coming off as flat and false. However, in Madison, Roberts and Murphy combine brilliantly. ‘It’s so hot my freaking vagina is sweating’ is just one of her many quotable lines.

It’s no surprise that she was one of the first Coven witches back in Apocalypse, or that she got so much screen time. Though she has a harrowing and controversial beginning, when she’s back (surprise, b*tch), she grabs Coven’s spotlight with her B-plot.

While the main narrative of Coven casts her in a bit part, it wouldn’t be the same without her acid tongue.

1. The Countess

Lady Gaga’s role as Scathach earned her a spot in the hall of game in the worst characters list, but with The Countess she takes the gold. Gaga is currently winning acclaim for her fantastic performance as Ally in A Star Is Born, but her role in American Horror Story: Hotel was a real breakout moment for her.

Advertisement

The role netted her a Golden Globe in 2016, where she famously nudged Leo DiCaprio out of the way to grab her gong. Horror acting is a relatively rare winner at mainstream award shows, so recognition just goes to show how wonderful this performance was. The Countess’ high fashion, deadly allure certainly suited Gaga’s distinctive voice and she was a commanding, scene-stealing influence in every scene she was in.

The Countess is cultured and complex. When we’re first introduced to her, she seems to have control of every bloodsoaked moment of her life. But as the story unfolds, we see the tragedies that have scarred her, that have afflicted her.

American Horror Story has had scene stealers before, and it’s had rich characterisation before. But this is the best marriage between the two they’ve ever done.

Who do you think is the best AHS character? Let us know down in the comments.

Advertisement