10 Doctor Who Characters Who Don't Deserve The Hate

Doctor Who teaches us to be kind, so let's show some appreciation to these unloved characters!

By Ellie Littlechild /

Some Doctor Who characters are immediate fan favourites. Some take a little bit of getting used to. And some should never be spoken of again.

Advertisement

But there are also those characters who receive a ton of hate from fans, but really don't deserve it.

Some are overshadowed by their predecessors, some are burdened by the actor behind them, and some are simply misunderstood. Whatever the reason, we feel compelled to jump to their defence!

Now, are all of these characters some of the greatest in Doctor Who history? Absolutely not, and that's not what we're arguing - it's just that they deserve better reputations than the ones they've got.

10. Craig Owens

Craig Owens is held down by the reputation of the actor behind him.

Advertisement

Played by James Corden, the character is as harmless as it gets. An innocent, ordinary human, living a simple life which gets thrown into chaos with the arrival of the Doctor.

Craig's journey from The Lodger to Closing Time and the confidence he develops as a result of his adventures is wonderful to see, and when these episodes aired over a decade ago, there wasn't the hate for Corden that there is today.

However, since then, he's become a big name in America, and the more popular something gets, the more hated it becomes.

This writer isn't the biggest Corden fan, but Craig is so much more than that. He's relatable and lovable. His interactions with the Eleventh Doctor are very funny. And his episodes provided a much-needed lighter tone in some very dark runs of episodes.

A brilliant, unforgettable character? No. But a good one? Yep! It would even be nice to see Craig return one day - think how funny a third Lodger episode would be with Ncuti Gatwa involved.

9. Strax

Strax is one of the least-hated characters on this list for sure, but over the years, he has received a lot of blame for apparently "ruining" the Sontarans due to his depiction as a total goofball.

Advertisement

In a way, that's fair enough - it really all comes down to personal preference. Do you prefer the warrior Sontarans of the RTD era? The full-on comedy of Strax in the Moffat era? Or the balance of silly and serious that Chibnall delivered? If you like your Sontarans funny, then Strax was a wonderful addition to the show.

There's something about these potato soldiers that's inherently silly anyway, which is probably why he works so well. From offering to feed the newborn Melody Pond ("I can produce magnificent quantities of lactic fluid!") to almost murdering Clara with a newspaper to the face, he's got this aggressive kindness which feels like exactly what would happen if a member of the mightiest warrior race in the universe was forced to become good.

He's not everyone's cup of tea, sure - there's a reason many fans praised Chibnall for taking a less comedic approach to the Sontarans - but there's nothing quite like him in Doctor Who.

8. Elton Pope

It's no secret that Love & Monsters is one of the poorer episodes of Doctor Who. Of course, the Abzorbaloff itself deserves no defending. Nobody needs to be reminded of that tiny loincloth in a hurry!

Advertisement

That said, the questionable elements of this episode do overshadow the elements that were actually successful.

Elton Pope is a good example of this. The idea of a character who grew up searching for a mysterious man they encountered as a child holds a lot of potential - so much so that it essentially became the premise for Amy Pond. We don't often get to see the other side of the Doctor's influence - the people who don't become a friend or a companion, but the people he saves and then leaves behind.

The framing device of Elton using a camcorder to tell his story was a charming way of presenting things, as he walks us through some of the alien invasions from early NuWho. Marc Warren is super likeable in the role, and the character has impeccable taste in music to boot.

"You can't beat a bit of ELO". Damn right Elton.

Yes, he does use and manipulate Jackie Tyler, and he does have a very unorthodox relationship with a paving slab by the story's end, so he's not a saint. But he does get unfairly caught up in the general hate for this episode.

7. Ambrose

Ambrose is one of those characters you're supposed to dislike.

Advertisement

She's someone who challenges and opposes the Doctor's direction, which, most of the time, results in someone getting captured or lost, proving that the Doctor was right all along. These characters can be frustrating to watch, because you just want them to listen to the Doctor.

In Series 5's The Hungry Earth/Cold Blood, Ambrose ignores almost every instruction the Doctor gives, leading to some major repercussions. But she's also easy to empathise with, acting out of that most basic of human instincts to protect one's family.

It was a bone-headed move to kill Alaya and set the drill back up again, but hindsight is 20/20: put yourself in her shoes and we'd all have done the same to protect our partners, kids, and parents. Mistakes were made, but they were well-intended ones.

Supporting casts in Doctor Who are often squeaky-clean and lack development, but these moral shades of grey - and the valuable lesson Ambrose learns at the story's end - brought some welcome depth to an otherwise pedestrian two-part tale.

6. Nardole

Nardole joined the Twelfth Doctor in a full-time capacity following instructions left by River Song after their time on Darillium, and appeared throughout Series 10.

Advertisement

Many viewers found him annoying and couldn't take him seriously, and his first appearance in The Husbands of River Song certainly focused more on the eccentric side of the character.

But what makes Nardole a special companion is his unwavering loyalty and sense of duty and care towards the Doctor. He understands how broken Twelve is following the loss of River, and stands by to make sure he doesn't lose himself entirely.

He doesn't fit the common mould for a modern companion, which is why he's more of an acquired taste. But the combination of Bill's wit and Nardole's wisdom is exactly what the Doctor needed at that point in his life, and Matt Lucas' quirky performance brought something fresh to one of the most underrated TARDIS teams in the whole show.

5. Miranda Cleaves

Like Ambrose, Cleaves is another character we're supposed to dislike.

Advertisement

Her human version is framed as one of the main antagonists of The Rebel Flesh/The Almost People, refusing to trust the Doctor and the Flesh doppelgangers, and even killing one of them at the end of the first episode. She undeniably made things worse, so it's no surprise she was frustrating to watch at points.

But the way the character was written - combined with the performance of Raquel Cassidy, which is showy when it needs to be, but never lacks subtlety - also makes Cleaves a character who's easy to respect.

Why should she trust the Flesh, or the Doctor for that matter? Who the hell would want another version of themselves to potentially steal their life? Cleaves is an interesting pivot in the pro/anti-Flesh struggle at the heart of this story, and a far more engaging presence than the other primary player, Jennifer Lucas.

The less said about that Flesh beast at the end, the better.

One also cannot help but feel quite sorry for Cleaves with the whole blood clot thing, which was resolved way too quickly at the end of the story - but that's a gripe for another list.

4. Dan Lewis

Poor Dan. A character who never got the opportunity to fully shine.

Advertisement

With the introduction of a group of companions at the start of Thirteen's era (rather than just one, as had been the norm in the modern series) there was a big issue with some characters feeling more redundant than others.

Once Ryan and Graham departed, it seemed as though the Doctor and Yaz would continue on their own. In all honesty, this would've been the better option, but instead, audiences were introduced to John Bishop as Dan Lewis.

Dan is a very likeable character. Bishop brings his comedy chops to the role and there are some brilliant moments between him and Karvanista. But with Flux being so busy across various storylines (packed into just six episodes), Dan got lost in the mix, and after just nine episodes in total, he ultimately felt like an afterthought.

Viewers weren't given a chance to properly connect with Dan, and that resulted in some deciding that he wasn't a good character. He lacked depth, granted, but he was very entertaining, and the image of him battering Sontarans with a wok isn't one that's going to fade from the memory any time soon!

3. Malcolm Taylor

Malcolm Taylor made his first and only appearance in the 2009 Easter special Planet of the Dead. Played by comedian Lee Evans, Malcolm is an overly-eccentric UNIT science officer with a strong (and slightly creepy) devotion to the Doctor.

Advertisement

Comedians are always going to be divisive, so it's no surprise that Malcolm has fans on both sides. And while some viewers found his hyper-personality to be rather irritating, he was a refreshing comedic presence in an episode that otherwise lacked any sort of spark.

Further still, this guy's a bloody genius, and it's him who saves the day! Without him, the wormhole would never have been closed, and the Earth would've been destroyed. Don't tell us that that scene where he finally meets his idol, the Doctor, doesn't make you crack a smile.

As UNIT characters go, he's certainly no Brigadier, Kate, Osgood, or even Mike Yates, but it feels like there's nobody out there who even likes poor Malcolm, so we thought we'd fly the flag for him a little.

2. The Wire

The Idiot's Lantern technically has two villains: the bullying father, Eddie Connolly, and the formless creature known as The Wire.

Advertisement

While the Connolly storyline forms the heart of the episode, it's hardly Oscar-worthy material. And yet, it's The Wire that receives the bulk of the hate that's directed at this episode.

The premise of an entity manifesting inside TV screens and feeding on viewers' faces is a terrifying concept, especially in an age where we are surrounded by screens. And though the adopted face of The Wire - and its constant whines of "HUNGRYYYYYY" - are potentially annoying, there's also something deeply unsettling about this creature. Maybe it's the polite manner, or the fact that it's an elderly woman - something scary lurking beneath something innocent.

Of course, there are better villains out there, and The Idiot's Lantern is hardly a classic. But The Wire is one of the most unique Doctor Who antagonists ever, and for that creativity alone, writer Mark Gatiss deserves props.

1. Clara Oswald

Clara Oswald is the most divisive companion of the revival era, and to be perfectly honest, this writer isn't a huge fan.

Advertisement

But does she deserve the insane amount of hate she's got over the years? People saying that she ruined the show, and that she's one of the worst companions ever? Definitely not - there's no way Clara belongs on the same level as an Adric, or a Ryan Sinclair.

Poor Jenna Coleman was fighting an uphill battle from the beginning, entering the show when the majority of the fandom was suffering from post-Pond depression. Like when Matt Smith took over from David Tennant, fans automatically disliked the newbie before they'd even given them a chance.

And to her credit, Clara had one of the most unique companion storylines in the show, and the mystery of her appearing as different characters was really interesting. The resolution wasn't as satisfying as the build-up, granted, but it was a lovely lead-in to the 50th, with Clara being superimposed into those scenes alongside classic Doctors.

Her relationship with the Twelfth Doctor worked even better than her relationship with Eleven. Part of this is because she was no longer the companion to 'Amy's Doctor', but the dynamic of the relationship also changed. She constantly challenged him, and he challenged her in return, and that arc of Clara thinking she was untouchable culminated in a really sad and well-executed death scene in Face the Raven.

And for what it's worth, Clara's arc resulted in one of the greatest Doctor Who episodes ever in Heaven Sent. That alone was worth the character's time!

Advertisement