10 Incredible TV Shows That Everyone Thought Would Be Terrible
Did anyone have high hopes for a Karate Kid sequel series that debuted on YouTube?
For a studio to greenlight any new television series is a major decision.
Millions of dollars can be on the line (sometimes billions) on whether a show succeeds so a studio will not give it the thumbs up unless they're firm it'll be a hit. Of course, some shows sound great on paper but don't come together in practice. I mean, look at Space Force. (Actually, don't - you're not missing much.)
However, there are some soaps or dramas that sound terrible to the point where you can't understand why a studio greenlit them in the first place. There's all sorts of reasons why a series sounds like it's doomed to fail.
Maybe it has a boring premise. Maybe it's an adaptation of an outdated franchise. Maybe it's a remake that nobody wanted. The reception can be very frosty when a new serial is announced, causing people to write it off before a single episode has aired.
But every once in a while, a disregarded program proves the naysayers wrong. Even if it originally came across as a cash-grab or a pointless reboot, there are some series that are better than they have any right to be.
10. Castlevania
Until recently, adapting a video game into... well… anything, tended to end abysmally. Adapting the best games like Super Mario Bros, Street Fighter, and Assassin’s Creed into films and TV shows was met with disaster and ridicule.
So when a Castlevania cartoon was announced for Netflix, gamers couldn't for the life of them figure out why. The gothic-horror was a big hit in the 1990s but has devolved into a lacklustre series in recent years. Its last platform game, Lord of Shadows 2, was among the worst entries in the vampire-themed franchise. Because Castlevania had become somewhat of a relic, it seemed non-sensical to adapt into an animated show.
And yet, Castlevania is possibly the greatest video game TV adaptation ever. The series sinks its fangs into the game's complex lore to forge a compelling story, driven by one of the most compelling depictions of Dracula ever seen. The Transylvanian count is humanised so well, you can't help empathise with him despite his murderous intent.
Some performances are flat but the fluid action and well-written characters more than make up for it. Even though it doesn't focus on Dracula as much recently, Season 4 still can't come soon enough.
9. Hannibal
Not only is The Silence of the Lambs pretty much perfect, Anthony Hopkins’s portrayal as Hannibal Lecter is one of the most captivating villains in cinema.
So when a show revolving around Thomas Harris' most iconic character was given the go-ahead, it sounded like it would be dead on arrival, ready to be served to the cannibalistic doctor himself (with a nice chianti). Not only would there be no Anthony Hopkins, the series wasn't allowed to incorporate ANY material from The Silence of the Lambs. So why bother make it?
But thanks to Harris' other novels, Red Dragon and Hannibal, the showrunners had plenty of material to work with to literally flesh out the show's title character.
But can Mads Mikkelsen’s portrayal of the serial-killing psychiatrist compete with Hopkins? Well, it’s like comparing Heath Ledger’s Joker with Joaquin Phoenix. They’ve approached the same character very differently so it’s not fair to compare them. Even though Hopkin’s incarnation of Hannibal is a standout, Mikkelsen's makes the character his own with his effortless hypnotic charm.
The show's only flaw is that it came to an end far too soon.
8. Tron: Uprising
Unlike the Tron films, Tron Uprising takes place entirely in the virtual reality world, The Grid. Apart from Jeff Bridges’ character, Kevin Flynn, appearing for a few seconds, all the characters are programs. Also, the main villain, Clu, barely appears and he isn’t voiced by Jeff Bridges. So… why would anyone be interested in this show?
Simple. Because it’s BETTER than the films. The cel-shaded look is gorgeous and there is enough Lightcycle races, Recognizers, and disc wars to satiate fans. However, the creator, Charlie Bean, never forgets to put the characters first. The show elevates itself with a phenomenal cast that includes Lance Henriksen, Paul Reubens, Olivia Wilde, Ben Schwartz, David Arquette, Kate Mara, Aaron Paul, and many more.
However, the standout is the title character, Tron, with Bruce Boxleitner reprising the role. Although he doesn't appear much in the original films, he takes a central role in this story, serving as a mentor to the new Tron, voiced by Elijah Wood. Boxleitner's voice is utterly captivating, which makes one wonder why Tron didn't play a bigger role in the rest of the franchise.
Considering the show is available on Disney+, there’s nothing stopping viewers from discovering this lost gem.
7. Battlestar Galactica
The most defining aspect of the original Battlestar Galactica was the the the cybernetic antagonists, the Cylons. With their imposing metallic body and red-beam visor, these sinister androids are among the most iconic characters in sci-fi.
So, when a reboot was announced in 2004, fans were exhilarated… until it was announced the Cylons' original design was scrapped. Instead, they would look like regular humans. On paper, this sounded like a terrible idea. Imagine rebooting Doctor Who without a TARDIS. Imagine rebooting Star Wars without lightsabers. Why would the showrunners remove the most recognisable aspect of the franchise?
But as soon as the pilot episode aired, there was no question the screenwriters' bold decision was a stroke of genius. Not only did this plotpoint literally humanize the story’s main villains, it created a mystery that spanned multiple seasons since viewers had to figure out which of the main characters were Cylons in disguise.
Considering the United Nations held a meeting purely to talk about Battlestar Galactica (yes, that actually happened), it's safe to say this reboot exceeded the most die-hard fans expectations.
6. The Big Bang Theory
Excluding It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia, The Big Bang Theory is the longest live-animation sitcom of all time. This is a staggering achievement considering the cold reception to the first season.
Although a lot of great shows received mixed reviews at first, the reviews for Chuck Lorre's work was almost unanimously negative. The three-camera structure was considered outdated and the pining nerd trope was deemed cliched.
But the viewers liked it, didn't they? Actually, the ratings for the first season never reached the top 50. By season 2, it only ranked at 40. Because a lot of the comedy centred around science and obscure superheroes, the audience seemed very niche.
But by Season 3, everything came together. The teased romance between Leonard and Penny finally blossomed into a relationship and Sheldon was revised to be more likeable and less... Sheldon. The season also introduced Amy, Bernadette, and Will Wheaton - three characters who are responsible for many of the most hysterical moments in the entire run.
Not only did the critics' opinion on the show completely flip, The Big Bang Theory went on to become the highest rated show on television.
5. Seinfeld
Two decades after it came to an end, Seinfeld is still regarded as one of the funniest series ever. Even though many shows have tried to imitated its formula, NBC's comedy is still considered the top-tier of sitcoms. When the series hit its stride, Seinfeld became successful in a way never seen before. It was so lucrative, it was making over $4 billion in syndication alone.
That's pretty crazy considering NOBODY thought the show would do well. When the test audience watched the pilot, they perceived George as a "loser" and the titular comedian as "boring". Overall, the opening episode was deemed "underwhelming and weak".
So, if nobody liked it, why did the studio agree to air it? The reason is simple; they didn't have a choice. Although NBC originally pulled the plug on Seinfeld, they changed their mind after another potential series got dropped.
The studio had no faith in the show (nor did anyone else) and only greenlit Seinfeld to fill a slot in their schedule. It was fortunate that NBC made this decision, since Seinfeld went on to become the master of its domain.
4. The Office
It’s a mystery why so many British shows are remade in the US, considering how many fail. Because a lot of the humour in these British shows revolves around… being British, it doesn’t work when you put in an American setting.
But that didn’t stop American studios remaking classics like The IT Crowd, Spaced, The Inbetweeners, and Fawlty Towers. Not only were all these needless reboots utter dribble, some of them got canned after a single episode.
So when plans were announced to remake The Office, it sounded idiotic. The Golden Globe-winning series is pretty much perfect. And when reception of the first season was lukewarm, we all saw it coming.
But by the second season, the new Office stopped trying to duplicate the British version’s humour and just did its own thing. Instead of making the characters generically awkward, most of them were tweaked into likeable bumbling oafs. This made the comedy cringier, but this time, it was for the right reasons.
Within a few years, The Office was regarded superior to the original, which in itself was considered a flawless comedy.
3. Friends
After 236 episodes, ten seasons, and 62 Emmy nominations, there is no question Friends had one of the greatest runs in sitcom history. It wasn't just a funny show in its own right - some of the most gut-busting episodes and most iconic moments in television history took place in the confines of Central Perk.
That's why it's bizarre in hindsight that Friends was seen as a smutty, ghastly and anaemic. Sitcoms were a dime a dozen at the time and every one of them seemed to be trying to be the next Seinfeld.
In fact, that was Friends' most common criticism when it aired. Newsday, Detroit Free Press, and The Houston Chronicle described the comedy with the same phrase; "a Seinfeld wannabe".
Other critics like The Plain Dealer stated Friends worked "less successfully on the hanging-out style of Seinfeld". The reception wasn't universally unfavourable but viewers couldn't help placing Friends in Seinfeld's shadow. That's right. Critics complained Seinfeld sucked and then those same critics ridiculed Friends for not being as funny as Seinfeld. You couldn't make it up.
But as Friends became a titan in the world of sitcoms, the critics eventually realised the series was here to stay.
2. Parks + Recreation
After The Office became a hit, it wasn't long before it spawned a plethora of copycats. And there was no sitcom that duplicated the awkward mockumentary style as painfully obvious as Parks + Recreation.
It imitates The Office's reaction shots so often, it's impossible not to notice. Also, it primarily takes place in an office!! With jokes not landing and unlikeable characters to boot, viewers just accepted this "comedy" was on the way out.
Knowing cancellation was a real possibility, the showrunners over Park + Rec overhauled everything for Season 2. Characters that didn't work were cut, new characters were inserted, and most of the main cast were revised.
Andy was changed from a selfish man-baby into a loveable idiot. Leslie went from a carbon copy of Michael Scott to one of most likeable characters in television. By the time the second season had concluded, Parks + Rec had become its own animal and the comparisons to The Office were no longer an issue.
If the show had been canned after the first season, we would've been deprived of many classic moments in comedy including Ron's jazz persona, The Johnny Karate Show, or Ben's Cones of Dunshire.
1. Cobra Kai
With rebooted sequels like Fuller House, Saved By the Bell, and The Mighty Ducks becoming the norm, it appears the television industry is banking on rehashing the same old stuff rather than writing something original. And when The Karate Kid follow-up, Cobra Kai, was announced in 2018, no one was expecting much.
Apart from the original film, everything connected to The Karate Kid tanked, whether it's the sub-par sequels, the abominable spin-off, the forgettable remake, or the cartoon you didn't know existed. Also, Pat Morita had passed away, meaning the franchise's best character, Mr Miyagi, would be absent from the revival.
And yet, Cobra Kai was a massive triumph. The Easter eggs for its predecessor are there but the series isn't a slave to nostalgia. It focuses on the characters, fleshing them out so well, you end up caring about everyone. (Except Tom Cole, because screw that guy.)
Watching The Karate Kid, you never thought twice about Johnny's mates. But Cobra Kai makes you teary-eyed when one of them dies.
The series should be used as the blueprint for reviving old properties since the showrunners clearly know how to commemorate the original story while not latching onto it like a crutch.