10 More Classic Star Trek Episodes Based On Real-Life Events

Yesterday’s News Today!

By Graeme Cree /

Science Fiction began as an attempt to speculate about the form of future technology, and the effects it would have on people's day-to-day existence. Sometimes it's been laughably wrong (personal helicopters by 1980, nobody will ever need more than 640K of RAM), other times it's been extremely prescient (the Get Smart pilot, of all things, eerily predicted a person's personal telephone ringing in a crowded theater). Star Trek has had an advantage in that some of the things it predicted (Floppy Disks and Flip Phones) happened precisely because they were modeled after Trek).

But Trek not only discussed the future, it discussed the present. Stories that couldn’t be told if you called the protagonists North and South Vietnamese could be addressed by calling them Villagers and Hill People and moving them from Southeast Asia to a fictional planet called Neural. This was a mutually beneficial arrangement, since not only did Trek provide commentary on the news, the news helped provide script ideas to Trek.

In his article "10 Star Trek Episodes Based On Real-Life Events", Sean Ferrick examines ten franchise stories that were inspired by the news of the day. Here are ten more, all from the original Star Trek:

10. The Conscience Of The King

Balance of Terror, The Undiscovered Country, A Private Little War, The Enterprise Incident, and Wolf in the Fold were covered in the earlier article, and will not be re-visited here. The earliest episode on today's list is The Conscience of the King. It's often said of this episode that it's not really a science fiction story at all, just a modern-day story that takes place in space. How true that is.

Advertisement

Kirk is diverted to a colony planet by an old friend who insists that touring actor, Anton Karidian, is actually Kodos the Executioner, a former colonial governor responsible for a massacre 20 years earlier.

Kirk is skeptical at first, but takes the matter more seriously after his friend is murdered, and after discovering that other witnesses to the massacre had also met mysterious deaths over the years. Since Kirk himself witnessed the incident as a child, he must determine whether Karidian is really Kodos before he himself becomes the next victim.

The story is loosely based on the hunt for Nazi war criminals, which was still a hot issue only 20 years after the war ended. The most high-profile of these cases was the Adolph Eichmann Trial. Eichmann was a Nazi bureaucrat, responsible for organizing the mass deportation of Jews to death camps.

Eichmann disappeared at the end of the war, until he was apprehended in Argentina in 1960, brought to trial, convicted, and executed. Eichmann was famous for his "I was just following orders" defense, as well as political analyst Hannah Arendt's claim that Eichmann was so terrifyingly normal that he represented the "banality of evil".

9. Tomorrow Is Yesterday

Shortly after World War II, UFO sightings started becoming more commonplace. By the early 1950s, they had become frequent fodder for radio comedy shows. With that in mind, Associate Producer Bob Justman came up with a truly inspired story idea. How about if the Enterprise itself traveled back in time to the present day, and become a UFO sighting?

Advertisement

Earlier in the season, The Naked Time had established mixing matter and antimatter cold as a time travel method that might be employed in a future episode. Rather than re-use that process, this episode comes up with a new time travel mechanism in the slingshot around the sun (later re-used in Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home).

A freak accident, lands the Enterprise in low earth orbit in 1966-ish, where they are tracked on radar and photographed by an Air Force fighter jet. Further accidents result in the destruction of the jet, which necessitates the bringing of its pilot onto the Enterprise (it's really not a very good day).

Kirk must erase all evidence of their journey, return the pilot to earth, and figure out if it's even possible to return the pilot without mucking up the timeline even further. And, oh yes, figure out how to return to the 23rd century themselves. And do it all in an hour.

8. Catspaw

Broadcast on October 27, 1967, this episode gave TOS its first and only Holiday episode. Written by Robert Bloch, of Psycho fame, the story would have been totally justified in playing it for laughs, but instead tries to play it straight, and nearly succeeds.

Advertisement

Exploring an uncharted planet, Kirk makes the mistake of not going down with the first landing party. Naturally, the series regulars disappear, and the walk-on character gets carried off. Kirk, Spock and McCoy go down on the second landing party, as they really should have done in the first place. On the planet, they discover a haunted castle, a giant black cat, a warlock, a witch who threatens to destroy the ship with voodoo, and zombie versions of Scott and Sulu. (Are we sure this wasn't a comedy??)

No, it all comes down to a basically serious back-story about an extra-galactic scouting party casing the Milky Way for future colonization, and aliens who take their imagery from the schlockiest... er, deepest recesses of the human mind. Luckily, the Enterprise crew is dressed for Trick or Treat every day, especially Spock. Kirk resolves the situation by seducing the alien space chick, which wasn’t totally cliched this early in the series.

7. The Doomsday Machine

Kirk comes across a roving planet wrecker, which has wiped out an entire solar system as well as doing a serious number on the Starship Constellation. Through an unfortunate series of reverses, Kirk ends up trapped on the Constellation, while its commander, the Ahab-like Commodore Decker, takes command of the Enterprise, and tries to have another go at making a suicide attack against the Planet/Starship wrecker, this time with the Enterprise.

Advertisement

In case the symbolism in this one is too subtle, Kirk actually spells it out for the viewer. The planet wrecker, or "Doomsday Machine" as it might be called, was probably one of those ultimate weapon thingies, sort of like "the old H-Bomb" was supposed to be. Something strong enough to wipe out both sides in a war, and built primarily as a bluff (we hope). After the war it was built for ended, the planet wrecker kept on wrecking because old habits die hard, or something like that.

Kirk fights nukes with nukes, turns the Constellation itself into a giant atomic bomb, and sends it down the Doomsday Machine's gullet, fortunately remembering to beam himself back to the Enterprise in the nick of time. Commodore Ahab manages to get himself killed off somewhere along the line, fortunately without taking the Enterprise down with him.

6. The Ultimate Computer

The fear of losing one's job to automation goes back to the Industrial Revolution, but became more pronounced as a result of the new technology that came out of World War II. Twilight Zone had done its own take on the theme in an episode called The Brain Center at Whipples, in which Richard Deacon plays a heartless plant manager who gleefully replaces all his workers with machines until his own job goes the same route. Star Trek takes the idea a step further. If Ultimate Alpha Male James Kirk can lose his job to automation, then truly nobody is safe!

Dr. Daystrom, the designer of the Enterprise's current computers, has invented a new sentient computer called M-5, which is designed to replace not only the Captain, but most of the crew. After M-5 is installed on the Enterprise, the ship is stripped down to a skeleton crew, and sent out on patrol, with the now-useless Kirk tagging along to eat his heart out, (or something like that).

Although the M-5 performs well in initial tests, it eventually goes berserk and attacks a flotilla of Starships, as a result of its inheriting Daystrom's own mental instabilities. Kirk must not only talk the computer into destroying itself, but also talk the other Starships out of destroying him. Kirk not only survives, but avoids having to update his resume, and all ends well. Except for the Starship Excalibur.

5. Spectre Of The Gun

With the Third Season, Star Trek began going to the well more often with real-life inspired stories. Unfortunately, many of these efforts suffered from a severe lack of subtlety.

First up is Spectre of the Gun. Kirk tries to make contact with a race of beings that asked him very politely NOT to try to make contact with them. To punish the intrusion, the aliens imprison the landing party in a fantasy pulled from Kirk's subconscious. Fortunately, this involves forcing Kirk and the others to re-enact the 1881 Gunfight at the OK Corral from the loser's side, rather than any of the more embarrassing scenarios undoubtedly rattling around in Kirk's head.

Since there was no money for location shooting, the story is played out on a half completed set that looks either really cheap or really surreal, depending on your point of view. Failing to come up with a sane plan, Kirk hits on the idea that since the whole environment is an illusion, then nothing in it can hurt them if they don't believe in it. (Sort of like how Wile E. Coyote never falls unless he looks down and realizes that he's standing on thin air.) Spock can turn his own beliefs off and on, and after a few Vulcan mind melds, the others can too. The aliens, impressed by Kirk's refusal to kill their Wyatt Earp doppelganger, decide that maybe the Federation isn't so bad after all.

Although this episode is nominally based on the actual Gunfight at the OK Corral, it's equally based on the proliferation of TV Westerns in early television. At one point in 1959 there were as many as 30 Westerns on the air at once. The massive popularity of Westerns caused many non-Western shows, even science fiction shows, such as Lost in Space, Dr. Who, My Favorite Martian, The Prisoner, and of course Star Trek, to do Western-themed episodes. Star Trek itself was originally pitched as “Wagon Train in Space”.

4. Let That Be Your Last Battlefield

In the 1960s, with the Civil Riots movement in full swing, and events like the Watts and Selma riots in the news, Star Trek decided to weigh in on the issue of racism. Fortunately, they came out against it, but that's almost the only thing this episode does right.

The Enterprise picks up two aliens, Bele and Lokai each of whom are made up to look like half mime, half minstrel show singer. Although it's almost immediately obvious that the two are mirror images of each other, this is supposed to be a big reveal later, as the reason why they hate each other and all their kind so much. While the crew twiddles their thumbs, Bele and Lokai return the Enterprise to their home planet, only to find that their civilization has been wiped out by racial infighting. Bele and Lokai beam down to continue the fight, while Kirk moves on to the next adventure.

The worst sin of this episode is its sledgehammer-like subtlety. Just in case the half-black/half-white makeup doesn't make the point crystal clear, Kirk actually states that Bele and Lokai's planet is in the southernmost half of the galaxy. You'd never know from this one that Star Trek started out as a show that took its audience seriously.

In addition, precious little actually happens in this episode. Battlefield is a half hour story padded out to a full hour, which is why it had been languishing in the files for two years, unused until they were desperate for scripts.

Another problem is that the conflict between Bele and Lokai is such a deeply personal one that it obscures the point that they're supposed to hate each other for the impersonal reason of their racial differences.

3. The Mark Of Gideon

Since the days of Thomas Malthus, the dangers of overpopulation had been a public concern. By the 1960s, the issue had become a household word. Star Trek took the idea to the absurd extreme of positing a planet so overpopulated that its entire surface was standing room only. If you think that such a planet could never exist because there'd be no place to grow the food, then you're thinking about it more than the writer did.

But supposing that such a planet could exist, how might it try to solve its problem? Perhaps by moving some of its population to another world? Or heavier use of birth control? Both of these ideas are discussed and rejected.

In their place, the episode comes up with a solution as absurd as its premise. The Gideonites, a civilization that has had no direct contact with the Federation, builds a full-scale mockup of the Enterprise (on a standing room only planet, mind you), which is accurate enough to fool the ship's captain, right down to the personal effects in his own quarters.

Kirk and the Ambassador's daughter are isolated together in the mockup in the hopes that Kirk will impart to her a deadly disease that their people have no immunity to, that will then wipe out half the planet, thus relieving the overpopulation problem. Thanks for the suggestion, Trek. We'll take it under consideration.

In the end, the Gideon's plan is not thwarted, only modified. The Ambassador’s daughter is cured so she can perform the Typhoid Mary role, allowing Kirk to leave. Does this go down as a win, a loss, or a draw in Kirk's book?

2. The Way To Eden

Counterculture movements have been around for ages, but hippies as such date back to the early 1960s, and were on everyone's radar after the so-called Summer of Love in 1967. Star Trek wanted to weigh in on hippie culture, but what could they do with it? They couldn't show drug use, the Federation had no war to protest, and on Star Trek, sex is for the Captain only.

Trek hit on the clever idea of distilling the issue down to the question of alienation, or people who feel like outsiders in their own society, and then of associating that feeling with Spock's everyday existence. That’s what they did right.

What they did wrong was to, once again, assume that the viewers were too stupid to understand what they were getting at, unless they spelled it out in excruciating detail. As a result, the people in The Way to Eden chosen to represent 1960s hippies are, in fact, virtually indistinguishable from actual 1960s hippies. They’ve got everything from the look and the long hair, to the attitudes, the flower power, rock music, and banal slogans. (“Herbert! Herbert! Herbert!”) Producer Fred Freiberger probably worried that it was still too subtle. Odder still, Chekov, the character who was added to appeal to younger viewers, was cast as one of the hippies' greatest nemeses.

The other major flaw with The Way to Eden is that it's not a Star Trek story at all. The plot involves the hippies looking for the mythical Eden, the one unindustrialized planet left in the galaxy, where they can finally get back to nature. Funny, I could have sworn that planets like that were a dime a dozen in Star Trek.

1. Turnabout Intruder

Feminism in one form or another goes back at least as far as the suffragette movement of the 19th century. Since Rosie the Riveter in World War II, the discussion had revolved around the idea of women working in traditionally male jobs, such as riveters, longshoremen, and now Starship captains.

Turnabout Intruder begins with the bizarre proposition that women are prohibited from commanding Federation starships. (the episode strongly implies this, but leaves a little wiggle room, while the Blish novelization states it explicitly). In 1968, women were unable to command combat vessels, mainly because women didn't serve in combat at all. Whatever you think of that arrangement, it didn’t correspond to Star Trek’s premise that women could serve on the Enterprise, but not command it.

Dr. Janice Lester tries to fight this situation, not with pickets and protest marches, but by using alien bodyswap technology to take Kirk’s place, by actually putting her own mind into Kirk’s body and vice versa. Lester’s chances of getting away with this deception long-term are nil. She hasn’t had Kirk’s years of training, and is mentally unstable to boot, as shown by the fact that she has Spock, McCoy and Scotty facing illegal death sentences shortly after taking command.

Of course, Janice Lester is just one nutty, fictional individual. Her actions don’t really reflect on anyone else… Except that since the episode is clearly Trek’s commentary on women’s lib, some reviewers can and have gotten the idea that the show’s message is that women want to do these jobs, but ultimately can’t handle them.

Oh well, this was the last episode. Maybe they were forced to use a script from some hack writer who didn’t understand the series. The story was by someone named Rodden… berry… Hmmmm…

Advertisement