The various snippets and teasers in the trailer for Series Nine have generated plenty of speculation and interest in the forthcoming new adventures of the Doctor and Clara: Was that a 1960s dalek in the background? Surely that's Karn - so does that mean 1976 villain Morbius is back? Was that a war torn Skaro - with biplanes? All interesting observations, but it is the identity of Maisie Williams' character that has generated the most chatter in fan circles. The line "What took you so long, old man?" has created a frenzy of theories as to her identity (Susan, the Doctor's daughter Jenny, Lorna Bucket etc.), even if in all likelihood she is an unknown character yet to be introduced. Whether it's a deliberately provocative throwaway line, a blooper, double entrendre, a teaser or a myth buster, fandom often gets embroiled in lengthy debates about a single line of dialogue. No doubt, the producers rub their hands in glee at the publicity - either that or face-palm because something which really shouldn't matter much in the general scheme of things has caused such consternation. Here's a rundown of some of the most talked about one liners - some are more controversial than others, but each of them seems to have taken on a life of their own, at times even at the expense of the story in which they feature.
10. "Still Not Ginger!"
Sometimes it's the general audience and not the dedicated fans who get hot under the collar about a line in the show. Take Matt Smith's first scene as the Eleventh Doctor in The End Of Time Part 2 which managed to upset several parents of ginger haired children. Even without a knowledge of the Tenth Doctor's wish to be ginger in The Christmas Invasion, Matt Smith's delivery makes it pretty obvious that the line "still not ginger" is uttered in regret rather than relief. Nonetheless the BBC received 143 complaints that it was offensive towards redheads. The BBC overplayed its response by rather amusingly pointing out that on the contrary the Doctor has a bit of a thing for the lady with ginger hair (Donna Noble, Amy Pond - though they could have also mentioned Mel as played by Bonnie Langford). Fans speculated that it was a hint that the twelfth Doctor will be ginger. Among those heavily rumoured to be in the running for the iconic role included Ben Daniels, Rupert Grint and Daniel Rigby.
9. "A Merry Christmas To All Of You At Home"
Over the years there have been all kinds of meta references to the fact that what we are watching on our screen is a made up drama - from the show within the show in Remembrance Of The Daleks to the parody of fans in characters such as Clive, Malcolm Taylor, Elton Pope and Osgood. There have also been many times when a character has addressed the camera directly. Take for instance, Tom Baker's "not even the sonic screwdriver will get me out of this one" (The Invasion Of Time) or Oswin's "Run you clever boy. And remember." (Asylum Of The Daleks), But the only time in the 50 years history of the show that it has dared combine the two within a regular episode came in the very first Christmas special - The Feast Of Steven - Part Seven of the epic Daleks' Masterplan, sadly no longer available in the archives. And back then it didn't go down at all well with the emerging fan base. But it was Christmas after all, and back then we didn't have Doctor Who At The Proms, Comic Relief or Children In Need to bring audience participation into our favourite science fiction series. Ironically, the one episode where the good Doctor talks to you and me is the one we're least likely to ever see again.
8. "There's Only One Reason I Would Tell Anyone My Name"
Two weeks after it had been announced that Steven Moffat would be taking over the showrunner's reigns from Russell T Davies, Forest Of The Dead both concealed and revealed a special future relationship between River Song and the Doctor; one even more intimate than his friendship with Rose Tyler. Viewers were left to speculate about what kind of bond the 51st century archaeologist would develop with the Doctor. We had no idea whether it would be left to conjecture or be followed up in future stories. The smart money was on River Song being the Doctor's wife, and predictably this caused more than a few rumblings of discontent among traditionalists who prefer their Doctor to remain unattached and asexual. It was impossible to lip read the Doctor's reveal of his name to River Song. The same cannot be said of Steven Moffat's giveaway spoiler at the San Diego Comic Con 2008. When asked by fellow panellist Julie Gardener, "Is she the Doctor's wife?" he leaned forward and in full view of those sitting on the left, clearly whispered "yes." Tut, tut Steven, River would not have approved... spoilers.
7. "Clara Be My Pal Tell Me... Am I A Good Man?"
Last year's trailer was just as exciting as 2015's offering but instead of running with rumours of a possible davros return etc, attention was focused on what kind of character Capaldi's Twelfth Doctor would turn out to be. There were mutterings before Matt Smith's first series of a darker doctor to come, somewhat in the vein of the then in vogue Twilight franchise. Yet despite the one moody publicity image, this couldn't have been further off the mark. So when the series eight trailer hinted at a Doctor with questionable morals, fans were quick to speculate that the zany and gregarious Eleventh Doctor would be succeeded by a very different personality. As it turned out, this question was a constant undercurrent in a series where the viewers side with Clara in trying to determine whether or not the new Doctor could be trusted. In the end he was still just a madman in a box.
6. "I Remember The Original Between You And Me What Really Happened..."
In the Easter special Planet Of The Dead, the Tenth Doctor complains that the movable Christian feast isn't his favourite festive time of the year before implying that the first Easter (in the Christian sense) didn't happen the way tradition records it. Queue furious complaints from some quarters that this was an unnecessary attack on the Christian belief in the death and resurrection of Jesus. Some cited Russell T Davies' open atheism and even claimed there was a hidden agenda in play. The old wounds reopened when in last year's Christmas special, Father Christmas was allowed to be real for fear of dashing childhood dreams. Does the show treat religious beliefs disrespectfully by comparison? Of course there isn't a singular historical record of the first Easter, only multiple religious interpretations and the Doctor doesn't actually say what "really" happened, leaving it completely open-ended. At least Christians can take heart that in the Doctor Who universe there is a historical Jesus, since the Doctor was apparently there at his birth too (Voyage Of The Damned).
5. "I'm Quite The Screamer... Now There's A Spoiler For You"
The answer to the oldest question in the universe was certainly hidden in plain sight when in the 1965 adventure The War Machines, the computer Wotan and others too called the Doctor, Doctor Who. But if that's the case, why the big secrecy? On the many occasions on which the words Doctor Who have been uttered in irony, not once has the Doctor followed the lead of the knock, knock joke and replied "yes, that's right." There have been various attempts to explain this away, e.g. as the computer's default name for the unknown Doctor, as an assumption based on a lie propagated by the Doctor. Thank goodness authorial intention can be easily dismissed in the post-modern world, because Ian Stuart Black certainly never intended it to mean anything other than the Doctor's true name. As for his actual name. Well, that careless tongued Steven Moffat has given that one away too. In reply to a reader's question in the official Doctor Who Magazine last year he said: "No-one can know the Doctor's name, except each successive showrunner. We're taken into a special room far beneath the BBC and given the ancient and special runes that spell his true and awful name. We're commanded never to reveal what we have learned, because then the show would have to be renamed Mildred. Oh bugger."
3. I've Been Married Four Times... All Deceased
Clara's speech in Death In Heaven whilst masquerading as the Doctor, has prompted a fair bit of discussion about the many wives of Doctor Who. As the impossible girl she ought to have known that this was a little disingenuous. Taking into account spin off material, the Doctor has in fact been married more than four times - perhaps unsurprisingly given his age, and if Amy Pond is anything to go by, his irresistible appeal. Marilyn Monroe, River Song and Elisabeth II are the only confirmed spouses in the televised stories (although the First Doctor had a near miss in The Aztecs), leading to speculation as to the identity of the fourth. Should we assume that he was wedded to Susan's Grandmother? Besides the weddings of convenience, there have been plenty of hints that the Time War claimed the lives of his natural family. Who knows how many more wives, or husbands for that matter, might come out of the woodwork? Now that's a point, Maisie Williams isn't playing...? Surely not?
2. I'm Half Human On My Mother's Side
Sometimes one line can shake the foundations of Doctor Who mythology to the core. Russell T Davies challenged assumptions about regeneration limits in a Sarah Jane adventure (The Death Of The Doctor) and River Song (yes her again) claimed that the wheezing groaning sound of the TARDIS was down to the Doctor's mishandling of a TARDIS designed to land silently. But the award for the most controversial line of all time goes to Matthew Jacobs, from his script for the 1996 ill fated pilot, The TV Movie. Written out of canon by those who like to give credence to such a term, or reinterpreted as a joke, it's clear that the vast majority of fans are unhappy with the suggestion. Not surprisingly the idea has not been revisited since. And yet in the early days of the show, despite the brief that he was from another planet, it is never clearly spelt out that the Doctor is an alien. In The War Machines, Wotan not only calls him Doctor Who, he also wants his "human" brain. Steven Moffat posed the following question in a recent Doctor Who Magazine: "In which story is it confirmed, definitively, that the doctor is not human?" The answer is episode eight of The War Games, and since then there have been a few times when the Doctor has made it clear he is a bona fide alien. In The Pyramids Of Mars, the fourth Doctor tells Sarah "I'm not a human being. I walk in eternity." But in fairness in what sense is a half-human a human being? And what's to say we humans aren't half-aliens in the Doctor Who universe, if not our own?
1. I Said He Was Me... I Never Said He Was The Doctor
As soon as the end titles to The Name Of The Doctor rolled, social media and Doctor Who forums were awash with speculation as to the nature of Sir John Hurt's character in the 50th anniversary special. The jaw dropping revelation of a hitherto unknown past incarnation of the Doctor would lead to six months of ingenious and not so clever attempts to reconcile, "Introducing John Hurt as the Doctor" with the established lore of the Time Lord and the Time War. Some fans cited The Next Doctor for precedents of misdirection, others quoted Steven Moffat's open admission that "the Doctor lies." A few even turned to those shadow sides of the Doctor - the Valeyard and the Dream Lord, for answers. Pretty much everyone expected that BBC caption to be hyperbolic or simply false: Surely even Steven Moffat wouldn't mess around with the numbering of the Doctor's selves? If this was a new Doctor, then some ingenious plot twist would ensure that at the end of the special the accepted order would be restored. As it turned out, it both was and it wasn't. The War Doctor earned his right to stand among the pantheon of Doctors and yet he will always be regarded as the one that didn't quite fit in, who despite his redemption was born to renounce much of what the Doctor stood for. So let's return to the Series 10 trailer and Maisie Williams. Chances are she's a new character that wont radically change what we know of the Doctor. But on the other hand, if the War Doctor's anything to go by, Steven Moffat has proved he is nothing if not audacious in his treatment of Doctor Who's ongoing narrative.