10 Recent TV Shows That Failed Hard (But Should Have Been Great)
We were all so excited, then all so disappointed.
With the glut of quality television coming out in current times, audiences have certainly developed a higher standard of expectations than a few years back.
It was different in say, the 90s, when a show could launch to a handful of luke-warm early seasons (e.g. The X-Files, Buffy) but slowly build an audience, as well as eventually find its footing as a strong show.
Yet, in the present day, no one tolerates it: sub-par shows really don’t have much chance of surviving very long, usually disappearing swiftly if they’re downright mediocre or the promotional materials just didn't manage to grab people.
But what about when a much-hyped show - with every reason (on paper) for it to succeed, or with an insanely talented group of people behind it - results in lacklustre quality?
The accumulated list is focusing on the rare cases of such - shows that should have been incredible but turned out dull, or even in some cases, were epic dumpster fires. The results for most of these are more confusing than infuriating, as all the elements seemed to be in place, yet the results were left wanting.
10. Marvel's Iron Fist
An argument can be made that the character of Iron Fist as a comic already felt a little goofy and dated in a modern age. Yet, as proven by Matt Fraction and Ed Brubaker's 2006 comic reboot, in the right hands his legacy can be enthralling storytelling. So the prospect of having the character join the high-calibre slew of Marvel/Netflix shows that came before, had several expecting a strong outcome.
Instead, we were given a show that felt like a true chore to sit through, with a cliched superhero origin tale with story beats that had been done better in movies (Batman Begins, Dr Strange) and TV (the early seasons of Arrow). It didn't help that it was all delivered with the amount of enthusiasm of the show-runner reading out a checklist.
The lead actor Finn Jones lacked the charm and range needed to give the whiny lead any depth or sympathy, and he was amateurish in the martial arts department too. Add to that a rushed production filled with cheap CGI and underwhelming sets, plus two lacklustre villains.
It was an ordeal that basically made Luke Cage's uneven elements feel like The Wire in comparison. At least that show had passion - something this quick attempt at filling up the Defenders roster was sorely missing.
9. The Last Tycoon
The 1930’s Hollywood setting, F. Scott Fitzgerald's source material, and solid casting of Matt Bomer and Kelsey Grammer all signified great things were coming. Yet, this just became another expensive Amazon drama that aimed at high prestige plaudits and awards recognition - but ultimately came up short.
The series was gorgeous, with period detail and costuming that bore the same level of passionate perfectionism that a show like Mad Men holds. As handsome as it was, though, it lacked anything going on behind it, making it all the more infuriating to watch.
The dapper lead of Bomer plays a familiar spin on the successful yet broken male from a lost era - sadly, we’re never given a good reason to connect with him or his backstory. This applies to the supporting cast as well - all interactions are played with stiff theatrical dialogue or anecdotal monologues, and everyone ends up feeling like roving plot-points and not much else.
Ironically, for all its thematic musings on the facade the characters use to hide their true selves, the series was guilty of the same thing: a handsome exterior that’s basically hiding a shallow and dull interior.
8. Emerald City
The distinct director Tarsem bets big when attached to a project. Although his broad strokes approach can miss the mark, when it's coupled with a strong script, his exclusive stylings can make for stellar work.
So, the prospect of him directing every episode of a reimagined Wizard Of Oz by way of Game Of Thrones was an exciting prospect. Here, matched with Josh Friedman - the former show-runner of the criminally underrated Sarah Connor Chronicles - we had the potential for a scorching network TV event.
Weirdly enough though, despite Tarsem’s ‘go hard or go home’ approach to filmmaking, the show managed to be dreadfully uninteresting.
Sure, there were plenty of thoughtful compositions and off-the-wall costuming to fit his aesthetic, but the main mandate felt like 'Edgy Fantasy 101' and lacked a pulse. Even the ever charismatic Vincent D’onofrio - deliciously cast as a grounded version of The Wizard - lumbers through proceedings with zero excitement.
It didn’t help that the trend of gritty fairytale reimaginings had run their course, and this show brought nothing new to the table to reverse those connotations. Its attempt at being dark were predictable, its fantasy adventure tropes were obvious, but most importantly, its connections to the source material felt completely superfluous and downright silly.
7. Hand Of God
This early Amazon show had a cracking premise: Ron Perlman’s corrupt judge undergoes a traumatic meltdown after his son and his wife are lethally attacked. He soon begins to receive vivid yet accurate visions - ones he believes come from God - that directly help him to conduct his revenge.
Its pilot certainly opened things up with an enticing cliffhanger premise, and with the introduction of Garret Dillahunt’s reformed neo-nazi coming into play, it appeared to be shaping up into a smartly written and shockingly dark twist on the crime drama, with two stellar central performances.
Despite Perlman and Dillahunt being reliably fantastic, the rest of the elements misfired. The writers basically played up the nastier aspects with absolutely zero substance underneath it, hoping it would distract from the shallow central body of work.
Add to that the enticing ‘visions’ and their possible origins never really came into play in a worthwhile manner. Most important though, it trudged forward at a snail's pace, yet - for those patient enough - it didn't have anywhere interesting it wanted to go.
It’s a shame since, with the premise, Perlman and Dillahunt, and Amazon willing to pump a solid budget into proceedings, it could have added up to something really special.
As is, it was quickly forgotten after two lame duck seasons.
6. Marco Polo
Made four years ago, when Netflix was attempting to get their original programming on a roll, this historical epic attempted to rival the major productions coming out of HBO.
A fascinating storyline - Marco Polo’s complex period spent in Kubla Khan's court - with lavish locations, mature content, and an extravagant budget. Netflix was betting big that this would be there answer to Game Of Thrones.
Well, one’s thing for sure: the budget shows, with a lush visual palette, and the Kazakhstania dessert making for some enthralling window dressing. That’s all well and good, but asides from an on-fire Benedict Wong as Khan, the rest of the cast just lumber through proceedings.
No one is more guilty of this then Lorenzo Richelmy in the titular role, who basically stares and squints his way through two seasons, without us ever caring a smidgen about his character's journey.
The story is a familiar tale of political infighting, civil wars, and naive Western eyes in an Eastern world. We’ve all seen it done before, and done much better. It doesn’t help that its attempt at period elegance erratically switches to hardcore sex and violence without a moments notice - perhaps in an attempt to distract its vast shortcomings.
5. Roadies
A while ago, it felt like Cameron Crowe could do little wrong as a writer/director. He arguably hit his peak with the fantastic Almost Famous (2000), a heartfelt piece charting the behind-the-scenes of the 70s music scene, and his own rollercoaster journey as an underaged journalist for Rolling Stones magazine.
After that, his films were accused of being saccharine, indulgently self-aware, or just plain missing the mark. Showtime's Roadies was a chance to get things back on track, with him returning to the same wheelhouse of that less shiny (yet more fascinating) side of that industry, as it followed a gang of roadies on tour in present-day USA.
Unfortunately, the long-format only helped draw out the director's flaws as a storyteller; the excessive sincerity fell apart due to feeling like a shallow Crowe roadmap, the barrage of conflicted love scenarios were exhausting, and most importantly, its musing on the integrity of 'the music' felt painfully outdated.
And therein lay the sad truth: Crowe just didn’t have that much more left to say about the subject.
It was a shame since it held a strong and likeable cast with plenty of potentials, yet the shows biggest selling point - Crowe’s involvement - managed to topple it into cancellation.
4. 24: Legacy
There’s no denying the mark the original run of Fox network’s series 24 left - frankly, it was a game-changer.
Sporting rip-roaring action and thrills straight out of a high-end blockbuster, its small screen presence allowed it room for unpredictable twists and sucker-punches, resulting in it setting a new bar for TV thrillers in the modern age.
Like most successful U.S. network shows though, it outstayed its welcome. The unpredictable became predictable, and the formula got worn down and surpassed by fellow rival upstarts (e.g. Homeland).
However, with several key writers and producers returning for a revival show, the opportunity to bring the brand back to relevance was nigh. Its purpose was to rejuvenate it equally for long-time fans as well as a new generation. The creative team strived hard to replicate the old feel while replacing the aged Kiefer Sutherland with young gun Corey Hawkins.
Unfortunately, it only served as a reminder of how dated the principles and style of the show had become. Sure, it was true to the original formula, but TV had moved on - the whole ordeal basically felt archaic.
Sometimes things are just better left alone.
3. Crisis In Six Scenes
Many things have been said about Woody Allen over the years, both personal and professional, but one thing you can't fault him for is being consistently productive; every year, like clockwork, he delivers a movie. Even if the results are hit-or-miss.
Here - collaborating with Amazon Originals - he shook up the formula with an enticing prospect of him tackling long-format storytelling, by creating his first mini-series. Sadly, that’s where the excitement ends.
Setting up a classic 'comedy of manners' type scenario as middle-class Jewish couple (Allen and Elaine May) end up housing 60's political radical (Miley Cyrus!) from the police. Hilarious consequence ensues, in as stale fashion as possible.
Allen later admitted that he was worn down by the TV experience and found the whole ordeal 'hard work' which might explain why everything feels so lazy.
The premise of a middle-class family shaken up by a wild card is tired, most of the jokes obvious and Allen's neurotic protagonist - the first time he's used the persona since 2002 - feels more like a safety crutch than a welcome return.
It boils down to a mini-series that - instead of shaking up the director's strict formula - feels like a three hour Allen movie that far exceeds its welcome.
2. Marvel's The Inhumans
Paul Jenkins and Jae Lee’s 1998 comic reboot of Marvel's silver age property The Inhumans, was a dark and deliciously cinematic tale, feeling almost as if Clive Barker created his own twisted version of the X-Men. It had enough political intrigue and superhuman smash-ups to make it immediately viable for live-action.
When plans for a movie were scuppered, the appealing prospect of creating an ABC TV show linked to the rest of the Marvel Cinematic Universe was announced. Considering cult hits Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D and Agent Carter had been doing strong work for the network, it became eagerly awaited.
Add to that its pilot being filmed in IMAX and released in cinemas, and you had every reason to believe Marvel was gearing up for big things.
Then it dropped and the results were - interesting? No, actually it was an outright disaster.
Even from just a conceptual stage, taking the elaborate tone and careful atmosphere of the Jenkins run and shoehorning it into a cookie cutter fish-out-of-water scenario - with these aliens emplaced on present-day Hawaii - was as awful as it sounds.
Plus, costume and production values that were C-movie bad, performances that were flat (asides from a decent Ken Leung), and large helpings of cringe-worthy action scenes. It was a baffling result considering the money pumped into the production.
1. Vinyl
After Terence Winter and Martin Scorsese collaborated on the hugely successful show Boardwalk Empire and the movie The Wolf Of Wall Street, HBO managed to land the duo’s alluring next project.
It was a TV show that charted the ‘sex, drugs and rock and roll’ era of the 70s New York music scene, with Boardwalk stand-out Bobby Cannavale taking the juicy lead role of a record executive struggling with cocaine addiction while he attempts to save his record label.
Well, despite Scorsese’s reliably bombastic directorial style displayed in the pilot, the show stumbled almost from the get-go - still, it had the potential for improvement. As the season crept on it was clear things weren’t going to improve, in fact, they only got incrementally worse.
Cannavale's character was erratic and wholly unsympathetic, with his plot arc more annoying than compelling. Olivia Wilde’s sulky trophy wife didn’t fare any better. These were the weak anchor points in a myriad of overindulgent flourishes, plot threads that went nowhere, and genuinely pat writing from the usually brilliant Winter.
It was a train-wreck, but not a glorious one even - it managed to be boring more than anything else, resulting in a disappointing and expensive failure that basically forced HBO into a regime change.
What did you think of these TV shows? Any others you'd add? Let us know down in the comments.