For over 20 years now, Warner Bros. Animation has been producing some of the finest programmes and films in the business, with their most successful outings of course revolving around the titular heroes of the DC Universe.
Advertisement
Recently however? Their releases have been less than exemplary. The decline can be traced back to the demise of DC's old universe, with the New 52 sadly alienating a great deal of fans with its rupturing of continuity and unchecked editorial interference. Sadly, its roots have also worked their way into DC's once immaculate animated efforts, with films like Justice League: War and Son of Batman embedding themselves very comfortably in the annals of animated mediocrity.
Uniform art styles and rigid story telling never used to be the norms of Warner Bros.' animated adaptations, but they certainly are now. It's not just the films that have suffered either though - high quality TV programming has all been gradually eroded as executive focus turns its gaze towards toy sales - Young Justice and Green Lantern: The Animated Series being the most high profile of victims to this profit-making approach. In their wake came Beware The Batman and Teen Titans: Go!, and though the latter has won over fans in recent years, everyone still misses the old stuff.
Advertisement
For over a decade fans were treated to an animated universe unafraid to ask big questions, approach big themes, and tap into source material in a way like no other. For many, it proved to be their introduction to the world of capes and cowls - and what a fine one it was. Some may say that this is just unfettered nostalgia run awry, but it's hard to deny that DC Animation was at its best when the likes of Paul Dini, Bruce Timm and the late Dwayne McDuffie were at the helm.
10. The DC Animated Universe
Kicking off the whole shebang with the long-adored Batman: The Animated Series, the DC Animated Universe blossomed into something quite spectacular. First adding Superman into the mix, shows like Batman Beyond, Static Shock and Justice League all expanded the world to eventually encompass the entire DC Universe in animated form - even going as so far as to add parallel worlds to the equation. This animated universe endured for a little over a decade, but DC's recent attempts to resurrect a shared universe have been left pretty high and dry - mainly due to its pseudo emulation of the DCNU. Rather than carve out something unique and different writers have instead chosen to imitate DC's most successful line of comics to date, perhaps in some strange attempt at corporate 'synergy'. Either way it sucks a great deal, failing to recapture the magic the old universe managed to convey. The animated universe of old not only had a fluid yet consistent art style, but also a huge swathe of talented actors portraying DC's best and brightest. The saddest part is that it had so much more left to give, but at least fans can rest easy knowing that the old universe never made a misstep during its tenure.
9. The Art Styles Were More Varied And Fluid
Part of what made fans love DC's old animated efforts was the fact that they always strived to emulate the source material both visually and narratively - at least in the case of adaptations based on certain comic book storylines. Darwyn Cooke's New Frontier comes to mind as a brilliant page to screen transition, as his distinct and iconic pencils are brought to life in the silver age's onscreen rebirth. Other animated features such as The Dark Knight Returns, All Star Superman, and Batman: Year One all emulated their respective artists very truthfully, in turn benefiting the films stylistically and visually. These unique and varied styles were abandoned with 2012's Flashpoint Paradox, with every subsequent adaptation following suite with the rather garish look chosen to portray DC's crop of characters. Their misshapen proportions rekindle nightmares of the infamous redesigns of the 90s, and nothing feels quite as clean as older animated features did, nor quite as charming.
8. It Gave C-Listers Their Chance To Shine
I wouldn't be the fan of DC I am today had it not been for Justice League Unlimited. The cartoon endeavoured to stretch the boundaries of not only the DC Universe, but also children's television - needless to say it succeeded immaculately. Part of what made JLU so special was that its focus wasn't solely drawn to the 'Trinity' (Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman), but more to the lesser known characters that have featured in DC's countless years of publications. Characters like Green Arrow, Huntress, Dr Fate, Mr Terrific, and of course The Question all came to dominate many episodes together, and the show was much stronger because of it. For many young newcomers to the world of DC the show really elevated and enriched the escapism to be had in following its universe, and for older fans it even introduced readers to some fantastic yet forgotten reading material. Reimagining characters from the Charlton and Silver Age era and the way it benefited the series cannot be understated, so why does DC currently neglect these once unkown heroes once more? Today tales revolving around the league are engulfed by the original seven members and non-league stories are pretty much Batman and nothing but Batman. It's a sad retreat to the safety of DC's biggest hitters, giving the impression that this is a company not willing to take risks like it used to.
7. It Wasn't Non-Stop Batman
'Bat-Mania' is bad for comic fans, and bad for creativity. Whilst it's undeniable that The Dark Knight has had an awful lot of critical successes that success has at times proven to be overbearing, with the character enjoying a renewed choke-hold over all avenues of DC entertainment from games, to film, and even comic books themselves. This is because Batman sells, and though the old DCAU certainly had its fair share of the pointy eared vigilante it gave plenty of space for other characters to thrive - as evidenced by the wide range of material provided in DC's Animated Original Movies. Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, Superman and more all had titles to their names whilst DC's animated department was at its peak, but since then attempts to expand adaptations have all but faded into obscurity. Though Bruce Timm had indicated a wish to pursue features centred around Green Arrow, The Flash and The Teen Titans (the latter of which would've adapted Marv Wolfman's famed 'Judas Contract' to the small screen), DC's slate has been predisposed with Batman, Batman, and oh, more Batman. Perhaps the most frustrating thing about it is Warner's determination to use the name to sell stories not wholly dependant on the character - as is the case with the upcoming 'Batman: Bad Blood'. It's a shame that even when writers wish to make a film about Batwoman they feel the need to prefix Wayne's guise to the title, especially as animation presents the perfect opportunity for DC to expand their characters to different audiences.
6. DC Nation
DC Nation was somewhat of an animated resurgence for the company - providing Cartoon Network with two incredible shows to continue their comic book bonanza. In its two seasons Young Justice managed to create one of the largest fanbases of a DC property of all time. Its approach to story telling was incredibly emotional, and the maturity in which it tackled it with was simply unbeatable. Portraying adolescence and the trials that come with it earned the show a place in many fans' hearts - which would only lead to heartbreak when it was abruptly cancelled without reason. Young Justice's cancellation also brought to light a worrying trend with network executives. Speaking with Kevin Smith on the splendid 'Fatman on Batman', veteran scribe Paul Dini made the point that during the show's production, Cartoon Network were adamant on shifting its focus to "boys' action" and "goofy boy humour" - under the misconception that girls don't buy merchandise. Obviously the writers didn't heed their calls, but it was ultimately DC Nation's inability to sell toys that resulted in its demise. Everything from the animation to the writing and voice acting was pretty much perfect, with only the occasional hiccup in the casting department proving to be a distraction. Green Lantern: The Animated Series also turned out to be a fan favourite programme, though it followed the same fate of cancellation as other shows before it. Teen Titans: Go! and Beware The Batman simply didn't pack the same punch that its predecessors did, leaving a big DC-shaped hole that needs filling.
5. Faithful Storyline Adaptations
In the aftermath of Justice League: Unlimited's cancellation WB sought to continue their accomplished animated streak by adapting DC's most famous comic storylines, with most succeeding in almost every regard. Titles based on comics like DC: The New Frontier, Under The Hood, The Dark Knight Returns, The Tower of Babel and All Star Superman all did their respective source material justice - sometimes exceeding it in the process as well. Art was masterfully adapted - particularly in The Dark Knight Returns - showcasing Frank Miller's unmistakeable pencils very faithfully on screen. These films also gifted fans with new portrayals of iconic characters, with performances by John DiMaggio, Peter Weller and Neil Patrick Harris coming to mind as the most notable of newcomers to tackle DC's characters. Despite occasional wobbles such as Superman vs The Elite and Superman/Batman: Apocalypse somewhat ruining Warner's perfect slate, DC's original movies still managed to bounce back with successive hits - until they began to go down a somewhat different direction. Though not a bad film by any means, Flashpoint Paradox put Warner on a path to mirror the road to the New 52 - beginning with the dull art style and a recurring yet just acceptable voice cast. There's little variety in the DC animation of today, especially when compared to the sure-fire successes of the past. The fantastic 'Gods and Monsters' may be a step in the right direction, but only time will tell if the company moves back to the model that saw so much adulation when The Killing Joke makes its appearance in but a few years time.
4. DC Showcase
If there's anything missing from DC's newest Animated Original Movies, it's DC Showcase. In its few brief appearances, Showcase highlighted a number of DC's characters in their own 15-20 minute short film - ranging from the likes of Jonah Hex and Green Arrow, to Catwoman and even The Spectre. Each short simply oozes with creativity, and actually had the effect of sometimes overshadowing the animated movies they accompanied too.These shorts also packed a star-studded cast as well, with the aforementioned Jonah Hex tale featuring the voices of Thomas Jane and Linda Hamilton. Irrespective of the star power included each short was beautifully acted, demonstrating that a lengthy running time isn't necessary to create a high quality story based around the escapades and misadventures of DC's finest. Showcase was a great bonus for those who purchased the physical copies of DC's films - it's just a shame there aren't more of them to fawn over.
3. Voice Acting Was Spot On
If there's anyone we can thank for Warner's immaculate voice casts, it's Andrea Romano. Hired as a casting director for the company at the beginning of the 90s, Romano has gone onto cast some of DC's most iconic characters with now definitive performances, most notably with Kevin Conroy as Batman and Mark Hamill as The Joker. From then on Romano has since become a staple of WB's animated features, even starring in some of the titles she helped to cast. Though a fan of recurring castings the voice director has never been one to shy away from mixing up the formula, as demonstrated by her variation of style when casting actors in roles already traversed rather famously by others. It's hard to argue against the fact that her influence has been positive, as these casts have proven their worth time and time again. Indeed, it shouldn't really come as a surprise to hear that apart from Assault on Arkham, Gods and Monsters and Batman vs Robin, Romano has been largely absent from DC's latest comic book adaptations. Without being too harsh on the pseudo-52 casting line up, I really don't think people will be rushing to cite the performances given so far as being definitive in any sense of the word.
2. It Expanded The Lore Perfectly
This speaks more for Batman than anyone else, but Warner Animation has probably been the single biggest influence on the character in the past two decades outside of live action. Batman: The Animated Series gave birth to Harley Quinn (a fan favourite character who's now heading to the big screen), redefined certain characters outside of the page and even predicted the Caped Crusader's future - pretty impressive for a children's cartoon if I do say so. Batman simply wouldn't be the character he is today had it not been for his animated counterparts, nor would his universe be quite as rich. Though rebooted along with the rest of DC's universe, Terry McGinnis's role as the Batman of the future was canonically cemented in the comics timeline, something that pleased countless fans of the show. Aside from offering now definitive portrayals of Batman's many characters, animation's contribution to building the Bat's universe really is immeasurable. It may not be a necessity to impact the source material in such a way, but animation really hasn't had the same effect on it since.
1. The Stories Were Unbeatable
Mask of The Phantasm, Return of The Joker, Secret Origins - these are just some of the amazing storylines that formed a part of DC's extensive animated filmography. The first two especially are ranked as being not just good animated films, but as two of the greatest tales to have featured the Bat in recent memory. It's not just the films that are worthy of critical acclaim, but the shows as well. Each one managed to combine the sense of escapism and charm that DC is known for, whilst also providing very mature themes and social commentary that until that point hadn't really been tackled by children's cartoons, let alone one revolving around people dressing up and fighting crime. Pretty much everything from adult relationships, racism, to government policy, WMD's and more worked their way into Warner's programming block - something that should be commended above all else for pushing the boundaries that once limited the stories that writers could tell. Captivating the hearts and imaginations of countless fans is no easy achievement, but appealing to so many both young and old was what made these films and shows so special. They can be better, they can do more, and to let them stifle any longer would be a huge shame indeed. What are your favourite memories from DC Animation? Have you enjoyed their more recent films or shows? Sound off below!