10 Times Star Trek Broke The Fourth Wall

Star Trek loves giving audiences a Nog and a wink...

By Nick Edgeworth /

Originating as a stylistic choice in modern theatre, the fourth wall is a relatively recent concept in the realm of performance. Whereas ancient Greek or Shakespearean plays would be filled with soliloquies and audience asides, the idea posits that actors perform in a four-walled room, with the audience peering through the imagined ‘fourth’ one. It is a trope that conventionally separates reality from fiction, but also creates something which can be played about with, stretched or, in some cases, broken.

Advertisement

Not known for its stylistic inversions or deconstructions of form, Star Trek is a franchise that relies on the fourth wall a great deal in order to create the escapism that the Utopian Federation embodies. That’s not to say that it can’t cheekily wink, or even wave, at the camera from time to time though, and with 50 years of history, and plenty of self to reference, there’s more than a few times that the crews have gone boldly through that wall and right into your living rooms.

10. Dealing With Ferengi - The Price (The Next Generation: Season 3, Episode 8)

Before they came to be the greedy little intergalactic clowns we all love, there was a time where Gene Roddenberry genuinely thought the Ferengi would be a legitimate threat to follow the Klingons. Although their ultra-capitalist worldview does indeed put them at odds with the post-money ethos of the Federation, their diminutive stature and slightly goofy appearance made taking them seriously as a villain particularly difficult.

Advertisement

Sure enough, following a disastrous introduction in season 1, subsequent Ferengi appearances in TNG had them demoted to bumbling secondary villains and comic relief. When a wormhole to the Gamma Quadrant (no not that one) opens up near the planet Barzan II, and delegations are sent to procure rights to its use, the Ferengi are naturally at the table. Characteristically bullish in their negotiations, the Ferengi employ bribes, aggression and even poison in their bid for the wormhole.

Captain Picard eventually finds himself at the receiving end of DaiMon Goss’s ire, and reacts the only way a sane man can: with an exasperated look, directly down the camera lens. While some may argue that this is just a mistake as opposed to a fourth wall break, it’s worth noting that Patrick Stewart is a very highly regarded Shakespearean actor, and logic would state he’s professional enough not to look at the camera during takes.

Furthermore, this isn’t a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment, but a full stare, ‘Parks and Rec’, style at the kind of idiocy with which he is forced to suffer. Call it a slip up or a fourth wall break, whatever the case, we’ve all been there.

9. Sisko’s Personal Log - In The Pale Moonlight (Deep Space Nine: Season 6, Episode 19)

If we’re being completely honest it may be a bit of a stretch to call this episode a fourth wall break, but it means I get to talk about ‘In The Pale Moonlight’ so I’m going to accept it. Set in the midst of the brutal Dominion War, the episode is told in flashback as a tired and dejected Captain Sisko relays his personal log of the depths to which he will sink in order to win the war.

Advertisement

The Federation is on the back foot, and the only way out would seem to be forming an alliance with the Romulans, who maintain a non aggression treaty with The Dominion. Throughout the episode, the narrative occasionally pans back to the present, as Sisko recounts his tale to his personal log. Knowing full well that Starfleet is supposed to be a paragon of morality, Sisko winces at every red line he has to cross, including bribery, forgery, trafficking restricted goods and even accessory to two separate murders.

As the tale unfolds, actor Avery Brooks increasingly delivers his monologue straight to the camera, as if he is looking for validation or forgiveness from fans who had just spent seven years enjoying the ethical purity of Jean-Luc Picard. After questioning if he can live with himself, and deciding he can, Sisko deletes the log, but we’re all left knowing, as much an accessory as he is.

8. Eisenberg Class - Die Trying (Discovery: Season 3, Episode 5)

A series with as much history as Star Trek is bound to get pretty self-referential from time to time, with the occasional meta-nods to fans, and tributes to the things that made Star Trek possible. In Season 3 of Star Trek: Discovery, the crew are hurled into the far future in an attempt to evade the psychotic AI Control, and find themselves looking upon a galaxy barely held together following the cataclysmic ‘Burn’.

Advertisement

After several episodes of searching, the crew eventually manages to track down the beleaguered remnants of Starfleet, hidden away behind a distortion field as a shadow of their former selves. Having not seen any Starfleet ships besides their own in this time period, the crew are overjoyed to see many, and even manage to spot the USS Voyager-J, the 11th ship to bear the name following the original famously captained by Katherine Janeway.

Alongside these ships, although not mentioned in the episode, is the USS Nog. Much like Voyager, the reference of Nog is obvious: Starfleet’s first Ferengi who proved to be a pivotal officer during The Dominion War. However, less obvious is the specification of the Nog; Eisenberg class, named for Aron Eisenberg, the actor who played Nog on Deep Space Nine, and who tragically passed away in 2019, during the production of Discovery season 3.

Although not a huge self-referential banner held up to the audience, the inclusion is a small tribute for devoted fans to find, and a testament to the legacy of one of Star Trek’s most underrated characters.

7. I’m A Doctor… - (Voyager: Various Episodes)

Whilst ‘Beam me up Scotty’ is the most well known yet apocryphal quote from The Original Series, another recurring catchphrase with some legs is the consistently exhausted protestation of Dr McCoy: “I’m a doctor, not a…(a reference to the thing he isn’t yet being asked to do)”.

Advertisement

The phrase is first heard in its traditional form in the first season episode ‘The Devil In The Dark’, where McCoy protests he is not a bricklayer when asked to treat a rock-like silicone-based lifeform. He would go on to utter the phrase many more times over the course of the original show, with the phrase even cropping up in the Kelvin timeline iteration in the 21st-century movies. So iconic is the phrase that Trek couldn’t resist a chance to reference it, with a few oblique references from Dr. Bashir in DS9, but most notably as a running joke from Voyager’s own Emergency Medical Hologram; The Doctor.

Sci-fi staple Robert Picardo first used the phrase before he’d even been cast, with the doctor’s inability to deactivate his own program reference within his audition scene. Once the crew had left, Picardo’s line was “I believe someone has failed to terminate my program” before he decided to ad-lib “I’m a doctor, not a nightlight”.

The producers were clearly impressed, as not only did they cast Picardo, but decided to add this little bit of sass to his character. The phrase would crop up again and again over the series run, including Picardo’s cameo in the First Contact movie, and whether you find it joyful or nauseating, it’s a phrase that will likely follow the show for many more years to come.

6. The Last Word - Journey To Babel (The Original Series: Season 2, Episode 15)

A far cry from the more self serious and contemplative shows that would follow it, The Original Series was a great example of inherent 60s corniness. With shoddy special effects and unnecessarily sexy costumes it was one of many authentic, if occasionally problematic, relics of the time.

Advertisement

Part of this kitschy charm came from the sort of quips often employed by Kirk and his crew, both to each other, supporting characters and, on at least one occasion, the audience itself. Journey To Babel marks the first appearance of Spock’s father Sarek, a character who would go on to appear in The Next Generation and form a pivotal part of the recent Discovery.

During a diplomatic conference on the planet Babel, Sarek is accused of murder, but the investigation is derailed as he succumbs to a heart defect requiring emergency surgery. Whilst McCoy has him on the table, Kirk is stabbed by the real culprit but, following a tense battle with a rogue starship, justice is served. With all the loose ends tied up, Sarek’s surgery is a success, and Kirk can finally relax/collapse from his stab wound.

Following an episode rife with emergency surgery, political intrigue, murder, assault and suicide, McCoy takes this opportunity to order his Captain to lie still and be quiet, gleefully looking at the camera and enjoying getting the last word. Real smooth Bones, real smooth.

5. We Do Not Discuss It With Outsiders - Trials & Tribble-ations (Deep Space Nine: Season 5, Episode 6)

Few species in the Star Trek canon are as iconic as the Klingons. With their language, traditions and iconic Bat’leths, you’d be hard pressed not to spot one in a line-up, with or without facial ridges. Wait…without facial ridges?

Advertisement

Although Klingons have been portrayed with their customary cranial features since the beginning of The Next Generation, in The Original Series they appeared almost completely human, creating a sort of continuity error that a show with this much time travel simply had to address. Deep Space Nine’s ‘Trials & Tribble-ations’ takes place concurrently with TOS’s ‘The Trouble With Tribbles’, and sees the crew of The Defiant travelling back in time to stop a genetically disguised Klingon from assassinating Captain Kirk.

During their time undercover, several smooth faced Klingons walk in to the bar whilst Worf, O’Brien and Bashir sit and observe. When Worf’s human friends note the difference in appearance, Worf bluntly responds ‘We do not discuss it with outsiders’.

Whilst Enterprise would later go on to canonise the difference as a result of genetic engineering gone wrong, in the meantime we all got to enjoy this little meta-joke from the writers, as they shrugged and declared: ‘your guess is as good as ours’.

4. Denise’s Goodbye Wave - Symbiosis (The Next Generation: Season 1, Episode 22)

Despite all its strengths, one of the enduring failures of The Next Generation was the squandered potential of Lieutenant Tasha Yar. Despite a promising start as a strong feminist role model, as well as a troubled back story unusual for Star Trek at the time, no episodes truly gave the character room to grow.

Advertisement

Feeling like she was in a rut, actress Denise Crosby made the decision to leave in the first season, being unceremoniously bumped off in the wildly divisive Skin of Evil. Although the anti-climatic tussle with the angry space goop would be Yar’s final appearance, the shooting schedule actually meant that Crosby’s final filmed scenes in season one would instead be from the earlier episode ‘Symbiosis’.

The episode, like many in Star Trek’s canon, deals with the ethical quandaries of The Prime Directive, as Picard struggles to decide his course of action over one civilisation addicting another to a drug by passing it off as a treatment for a fictional plague. In a final scene, Picard subverts the Directive by allowing the drug to be shipped but not repairing the freighter carrying it, thus breaking the cycle of addiction.

Although about 40 yards in the background, this would prove to be Crosby’s last scene during her time on Star Trek, and she takes the opportunity to give the camera, and her fans, a quick wave over Captain Picard’s shoulder. Although alternate realities and cloning would allow Yar to return in one form or another, for now this fourth wall break was a cheeky little send off to a truly under-appreciated character

3. Put On A Red Shirt - Star Trek Into Darkness

Star Trek has been around long enough to be meme-able to a fault, and one of the most enduring memes is that of ‘The Red Shirt’. Jokingly applied to the legions of unnamed crewmen from security and engineering sent on away missions with their plot armoured officers, the red-shirted human shields serve as a way to communicate the peril of the situation without damaging anyone whose name is in the opening credits.

Advertisement

Understandable then is the reaction of Ensign Chekhov in Star Trek Into Darkness when asked to don one. Following an assault on Starfleet Headquarters by the enigmatic John Harrison, Captain Kirk and his crew are tasked with covertly following Harrison to the Klingon homeworld and executing him without trial.

The ethics of such a mission understandably ruffle the feathers of several of Kirk’s officers and this, alongside the loading of unscannable and experimental torpedoes, is enough to warrant Chief Engineer Scott’s resignation. Needing a new officer in engineering, Kirk decides to promote Chekhov to the role, and his first duty is to put on a red shirt.

In a subtle nod to fans in the know, actor Anton Yelchin pulls a face somewhere between distinct shock and mild terror, as apparently everyone in-Universe knows what the red shirt entails as well. Although all characters manage to make it through the events of the film, despite Kirk’s own brief fatality, this is one fourth-wall smashing moment of levity amongst a film with some pretty hefty moral baggage.

2. This Wink - The Infinite Vulcan (The Animated Series: Season 1, Episode 7)

There’s the metaphor of winking and the camera, then there’s literally winking at the camera. Often the overlooked series in the franchise, The Animated Series served to finish the five-year voyage of the Enterprise crew following the cancellation of its live-action predecessor. Whilst retaining the DNA of its original, the animated nature allowed Roddenberry and co to play around with the less physically plausible aspects of sci-fi, however wacky they may be.

Advertisement

The Infinite Vulcan is one such example of this, with Spock kidnapped by a giant augmented human on a planet of plant people so that he can clone the Vulcan and create a master race to keep peace. That is the most bizarrely sci-fi sentence I have ever written.

Once Spock is saved and the crew can return to their journey, Kirk asks Sulu to teach him a body throw that he had used on a plant person earlier in the episode. When Sulu remarks that you need to be inscrutable, Kirk jokingly responds that Sulu is the most scrutable person that he knows.

At which point Sulu turns to the camera… and winks. Notwithstanding trying to work out if Sulu’s being insulted or not (and that the Asian-American character is the one who knows martial arts moves - go figure), the wink is such a bizarre addition to an already bizarre episode. Sure it breaks the fourth wall… but at what cost?

1. "Some Kind Of Star Trek" - Star Trek: First Contact

Just like the ones found in Christmas crackers, the groan-inducing joke is a concept we can all share, having been the victim of one on many occasions in each of our lives. Within the realm of film and television, there’s nothing more groan-inducing than crowbarring a reference to the title within a script, and in First Contact, the Star Trek franchise has you covered.

Advertisement

One of the better entries in Star Trek’s decidedly mixed bag of movies, First Contact finds The Borg travelling back in time to prevent Zephram Cochrane’s first warp flight, curtailing First Contact with the Vulcans and ultimately ending The Federation before it even begins. Witnessing Earth turning into a Borg sphere before their very eyes, The Enterprise follows the Borg through the time portal with the intention to fix the timeline.

Whilst half of the crew stay on board the ship to defend it against a Borg incursion, Riker and Troi beam down to the surface to ensure that Cochrane’s flight goes off without a hitch. Having grown up on stories of the hero who began The Federation, the pair are shocked to find a grumpy alcoholic more interested in rock and roll than engineering.

Seeing no way to help him without breaking the Temporal Prime Directive, the officers reveal their origin, and the importance of his mission. Trying to wrap his head around it all, with possibly the cheesiest line in all of sci-fi, Cochrane asks: “You people, you're all astronauts on... some kind of star trek?” Groan.

Advertisement