10 Totally Unnecessary Deaths In Horror TV Shows

It's a horror story - so somebody has to die. But why them?

By Jack Morrell /

No medium presents death the way that television does. TV tends to be a long-form narrative: actors play the same characters over a multitude of different stories, often over years, with a shifting team of writers piling big events up to satisfy the demand for engaging drama - and there's no bigger event than death.

Advertisement

Done well, a death on a TV show will be a standout moment in a season, and a defining moment for the show as a whole.

Meanwhile, horror and death go together like hotdogs and mustard. If horror is a way of confronting that weird gestalt of fear and desire that drives us all, then there's nothing that repels and attracts us more than death. It's the undiscovered country, and no one crossing that border has returned to tell the tale.

All of which is to say: when it comes to death, horror-centred television shows are in a class of their own. People don't just die - they are killed, often violently, on camera and as part of a culmination of a storyline. The portrayal of the act is as important as the ramifications of the loss.

It's a shame that not every show connects those dots. Sometimes it's simply due to poor overarching storytelling. Sometimes (especially with horror shows) a death can be purely for some fleeting shock value, wasting an opportunity to provide some emotional resonance.

Let's look at some of the most unnecessary deaths in horror shows on TV - but remember, spoilers follow...

10. Anya - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Beginning life on Buffy The Vampire Slayer as one of the monsters of the week, Anya grew to become one of the most beloved members of the cast... which is why her death was so insulting to the fans, not to mention to actor Emma Caulfield Ford.

Advertisement

Vengeance demon Anyanka had taken the form of a Sunnydale High student, Anya Jenkins, in order to enact her particular brand of 'woman scorned' hoodoo upon Xander Harris after he'd cheated on Cordelia Chase. Her plans thwarted, Anyanka found herself trapped in 'Anya''s body, doomed to live out the rest of her life as a mortal woman.

Eventually falling in love with Xander, Anya became a valued member of Buffy's gang. Part of the charm of the character was her barely controllable accessing of human emotions after centuries as an immortal and her hilarious bluntness.

Although Anya and Xander's relationship would go south in the end, she was with them all in the series finale, fighting the First Evil's forces under Sunnydale. That is, until she was unceremoniously sliced in the back by a sword in a blink-and-you'll-miss-it death scene that (in the days before pausable streaming television) a whole lot of people actually did miss, being confronted with her staring corpse in the final minutes of the episode.

To add insult to injury, when Xander finally found out that the woman he loved had died saving some schmuck's life, his only response was "that's my girl. Always doing the stupid thing." Wow.

9. Abbie Mills - Sleepy Hollow

Hailed for showcasing a Black female lead on a network TV show, Fox's runaway horror hit Sleepy Hollow starred Nicole Beharie as Abbie Mills, a cop who becomes the partner of Ichabod Crane's resurrected supernatural hunter.

Advertisement

Abbie was initially an integral part of Sleepy Hollow's cast. However, the quality of the show's writing dropped and the diverse cast began to be misused, frustrating fans, who left in droves.

By the end of season three, Sleepy Hollow was a shadow of its former self - and then the writers chose to have Abbie sacrifice herself in the season finale to stop the villain.

In the absence of that central partnership between Ichabod and Abbie, the show went through a soft reboot with a new supporting cast and a new setting. It wasn't enough to save it, and Sleepy Hollow was cancelled after a shortened fourth season.

Beharie later explained that she had to leave the show due to her unequal and at times unjust treatment by the show's producers. She explained that she had fallen seriously ill during production but, despite her doctor's recommendations, was forced to continue working. Beharie believed that the way she was treated stemmed from her race, as other member's of the show's initially diverse cast had also been treated poorly.

Had Sleepy Hollow not done its leading lady so dirty, it might well have retained its stellar audience and remained on the air - attracting further critical acclaim - for some time.

8. Beverley Katz - Hannibal

Bryan Fuller's ground-breaking adaptation of characters from Thomas Harris' novels - FBI profiler Will Graham and cannibal serial killer Hannibal Lecter - is justifiably critically acclaimed. Despite that, the murder of FBI Agent Beverly Katz in season 2 caused a huge outcry.

Advertisement

Katz' death was off-screen, the dogged agent being caught in the act while searching Lecter's home. However, her corpse was displayed in perfect vertical slices for the FBI to find. Incarcerated and powerless, Will Graham takes drastic action and persuades a second psychopath to go after Lecter - who nearly kills the good doctor.

This left an overwhelmingly bad taste in the mouths of the show's fans. Katz was an anomaly on American TV in 2013/2014 - a strong, well-rounded and interesting young female Asian character. Her presence on such a high profile network television show was significant, as was the representation that her characterisation afforded younger Asian women, who simply didn't get to see themselves on television in roles such as this.

Fans accused Fuller of 'fridging' (abusing or killing a female character, whereby their suffering is incidental except to provide a male character with motivation). Fuller confirmed this was his motivation when he admitted that Katz would have been killed in season one, except for the fact that her death wouldn't have had as much impact on Graham (or the audience, for that matter).

In a way, it's the ultimate in 'unnecessary deaths': Fuller treated Beverly Katz like an object, ending her story just to add spice to someone else's.

7. Eddie Munson - Stranger Things

Every season of Stranger Things has made a storytelling virtue out of introducing a character, establishing them as adorable only to kill them before the year was out. Nancy's loyal best friend Barb, Joyce's sweetheart Bob, cheeky but loveable Soviet scientist Alexei... and the pinnacle of the lot, charismatic metalhead Eddie Munson.

Advertisement

Sometimes you can argue that, like Alexei, a character has reached the end of their usefulness to the narrative - or that, like Barb, their death will catalyse other characters to become a greater part of the story. But Eddie?

Eddie Munson was established very quickly as a larger-than-life mentor figure. His self-imposed status as school outsider, his infectious grin, sweet nature and shaggy rock-god hair made him a gloriously eighties throwback figure, equal parts Bender from The Breakfast Club and Duckie from Pretty In Pink.

Having done all this stellar work to establish this brand new character as equal to Stranger Things' central cast in the audience's affections, it came as a shock when Eddie was killed in the Upside Down, sacrificing himself to lure Vecna's Demobats away from his friends so that they could attack the monster on his home turf.

And perhaps that was the intention - tease fan favourite Steve Harrington's death throughout the season only to misdirect the audience at the last moment by once more killing the new guy.

It's just that this time, the character wasn't at the end of his usefulness. Having found his courage and literally faced his demons, Eddie Munson deserved better.

6. Elijah Mikaelson - The Originals

Originally the antagonists of The CW's long-running hit The Vampire Diaries, Klaus Mikaelson and his family of ancient vampires became part of the supporting cast before spinning off to star in their own show, The Originals.

Advertisement

While the half-werewolf, half-vampire Klaus was the de facto leader due to being the most powerful, it was his older half-brother Elijah who fans were more devoted to.

With his hot temper and self-loathing arrogance, Klaus could play the anti-hero or the villain. Elijah, the family guardian, was his best friend - and occasionally his worst enemy, because as an honourable man with iron principles, Elijah was fearlessly, relentlessly devoted to redeeming his wayward younger brother of his sinful ways.

That's why the series finale of The Originals resonated so much to begin with. Determined to save his daughter from the Hollow, the evil spirit of the most powerful witch in history, Klaus planned to take that spirit into himself. Elijah would then stake him, assisting his brother in finally achieving the redemption he'd always wanted for him.

However, in a bizarre twist Elijah decided to die alongside Klaus, taking part of the Hollow into himself so that each brother would have to kill the other.

It never made a scrap of sense. If Elijah was determined to die he could have spared Klaus the sacrifice and allowed him to return to his daughter; if he was so devoted to the family, he should have stayed alive to look after her himself.

5. Allison Argent - Teen Wolf

MTV's Teen Wolf (a reimagining of the 1985 Michael J. Fox movie) didn't take long to become an out-and-out horror show with teen elements, rather than the other way around.

Advertisement

Starring alongside Tyler Posey's titular teenage werewolf Scott McCall was Crystal Reed as Allison Argent - the latest in a long line of fanatical werewolf hunters. Even after their relationship ended, they remained allies... until Allison's sudden death at the end of season three.

Now, this wasn't due to the demands of the storyline. Reed was a few years older than the rest of the cast, and asked to leave the show to pursue other roles. Reed's amicable exit meant that, had Allison not died, she could have returned at any point to resume her role, whether full time or as a guest star.

However, the McCall/Argent relationship had been pivotal, defining the show's conflict dynamic between humans and supernatural beings. Allison's arc was to be the leader destined to rewrite the Argent family motto from the militant "We hunt those who hunt us" to "We protect those who cannot protect themselves", a credo which included protecting innocent supernaturals.

In her absence, the show continued with a vital piece missing from the puzzle. It's telling that even the show's creator Jeff Davis recognised their mistake, mandating Allison Argent's resurrection in this year's Teen Wolf: The Movie, even if that arc was fairly nonsensical.

It would have been so much easier if he hadn't needed to resurrect her in the first place.

4. Dodge - Locke & Key

Locke & Key's high concept is fascinating. The Locke kids, living with the loss of their father, move into his old family home and discover the supernatural secrets of his past.

Advertisement

But it was the villain that made Locke & Key so compelling. In season one, Laysla de Oliveira played Dodge, the ruthless demon that murdered the Lockes' father. Stunningly gorgeous, utterly malevolent, bestriding the narrative like a Disney villain on PCP, de Oliveira steals every scene she's in.

Now, season one contained multiple twists in the tale, but the most staggering was the revelation that the Lockes' friend Gabe (Griffin Gluck) had also been Dodge, changing shape (and gender) to infiltrate their group. Season two brought us a cold war, as Dodge messed with the family from within.

Gluck's version of Dodge was colder and more sinister than de Oliveira's magnificently extra Dodge, but no less effective as a villain. That was Locke & Key's appeal: brave kids wielding magical keys to fight the demon that killed their father. So it made no sense at all that, in the season two finale, the Lockes sent that demon back to the hell that spawned them, stripping the family of their nemesis and the narrative of one of its unique selling points.

Season three would see a new demon menace rise to challenge the Lockes, a monstrous force of nature played by Kevin Durand... but despite the dependable Durand giving it all he had, it wasn't the same.

3. Dean Winchester - Supernatural

For those of you reading this who aren't familiar with The CW's long-running monster-hunting franchise: Supernatural's Winchester brothers die and are resurrected a lot.

Advertisement

Well, in the series finale, Dean dies yet again. Coming an episode after all the dangling plotlines had been resolved and so serving as a kind of epilogue to the whole show, 'Carry On' saw Dean impaled on some rebar jutting from a beam.

Cue a bizarre, yet bizarrely affecting 7 minute death scene, Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki acting their absolute hearts out (with Dean standing bolt upright the whole time), followed by Sam living out a happy life (in montage, naturally) with a wife and son before dying of old age and joining Dean in a miraculously perfect Heaven together.

It's a deeply flawed ending. That cringeworthy final eighteen minutes essentially implies that the only thing stopping Sam from having a proper life was his doofus big brother, which is a weird capstone to put on their relationship.

Honestly though, Dean's death isn't that much better. By this point the character had been killed and brought back 111 times (!!), stripping the tactic of any impact, while the supposed finality of the act was immediately undercut by seeing Dean in Heaven almost straight away.

Thanks to the weird passage of time Up There, Dean only had to wait for that montage to end before seeing Sam again - for him, only a few minutes after he'd passed on.

It's a cheap and manipulative ending - and completely inconsequential.

2. Brian Moser - Dexter

Dexter's high concept is that Dexter Morgan, a Miami police forensic technician, is actually a violent psychopath trained by his policeman foster father to channel his murderous urges solely towards criminals who the system has failed to punish.

Advertisement

It was always a strange choice to make for Dexter's debut season, introducing the protagonist alongside Brian Moser, the Ice Truck Killer, as his primary antagonist.

Ideally a first season would establish the character, his MO and the life he leads before bringing in a potential game changer to upend everything. Introducing Dexter's older brother, also a serial killer, to set up conflict within the premise of the show is season two, season three material.

The reason for this was that the show was adapting the first novel in Jeff Lindsay's Dexter series, Darkly Dreaming Dexter. Now, there's nothing really wrong with a storyline showcasing two siblings facing off: it's been done a lot, but it's still a powerful trope. However, in the novel Brian lives - yet in the season one finale, Brian dies.

Not only does the early introduction of Dexter's murderous brother rob the storyline of some of the disruptive, dramatic impact it would have had if it had occurred after the show had time to find a rhythm, but Brian's early demise then robs the show of anything interesting that might have come up with the sibling rivalry dynamic - a dynamic which was the only reason for the character's existence in the first place.

1. Carl Grimes - The Walking Dead

Season 8 of The Walking Dead saw hero-protagonist Rick Grimes' teenage son Carl (Chandler Riggs) bitten by a walker to bite the dust.

Advertisement

Even for a show that made a name for itself by butchering its cast, Carl’s death was always a head-scratcher. It was a significant departure from the original comics, which is not always a terrible thing: however, it also seemed to neuter a lot of upcoming storylines, including a budding relationship with Negan, and the fact that Carl was essentially the star of the upcoming Whisperers plotline.

By this point the show's ratings had truly begun to fall off a cliff, and it seems clear that the decision was made to provide a media talking point that might bring some of the show's lapsed fans back.

Riggs certainly didn't see it coming: the kid had just bought his first house in Atlanta, where the show was filmed, on the understanding that he'd be around for a while yet. The fans were even more appalled.

While it's telling that his send off episode saw ratings recover a little, the tactic didn't work in the long term, because the overall story being told simply wasn't as compelling as it used to be. Years of falling in love with characters only to see them brutally killed to further the bleak USP of the show had turned the audience off.

There was only so much they could take, and it can be argued that Carl's senseless, irritating death was the final straw.

Advertisement