10 TV Characters With The Most Wasted Potential
Justice for Charlie Bradbury.
The making of any great TV show depends on a wide variety of things, but mostly it comes down to a well-deployed concept and some compelling characters to drive it forward. Unfortunately, regardless of a show's overall quality, some characters are destined to be squandered from time-to-time, victims of behind-the-scenes mix-ups, contract disputes, or just plain bad writing that misses the greatness staring audiences right in the face.
Such is the case with the following ten characters, who for one reason or another never lived up to their glowing potential, either abandoned, forgotten or outright killed before they could become what they were - in another life, at least - always meant to be.
Making a show is hard work for writers and actors alike - no one knows what is going to happen, or what needs to - but even so these characters surely deserved a touch more than they got.
With that in mind, from richly developed supporting players cruelly forgotten and betrayed, to fan favourites who simply vanished, never to be heard from again, here are ten of the most wasted TV characters you're ever likely to find.
There will be major spoilers for each of the shows discussed in this article.
10. Captain Georgiou - Star Trek: Discovery
When you get an esteemed actress like beloved Oscar-winner Michelle Yeoh on a show, you're well within your rights to assume she's going to play a big role and stick around for the foreseeable. Because who wouldn't want that!
That wasn't the case this time around, as Yeoh's turn in Star Trek: Discovery as Philippa Georgiou, captain of doomed USS starship Shenzhou, was a middling two-episode affair that ended with a noble death and nothing more. Yeoh returns as an alternate version of the character later on, which is fun but not the same.
Despite giving a great performance (no surprises there) and serving as one of the finest additions to Discovery's opening two episodes, Yeoh was cut down before the series could really get moving, and Georgiou - mourning but hopeful, brave and pragmatic - was never allowed to become more than a glorified one-off.
You can argue that Georgiou's death was a necessary evil to sell the stakes of the coming drama, and to make way for show lead Michael Burnham, but Discovery simply made the captain too compelling to disappear so quickly.
9. James Doakes - Dexter
In one of the most heated subplots of Dexter's first two seasons, embattled Detective James Doakes finds himself drawn closer and closer to his colleague's murderous secret, which inevitably culminates in Doakes' death when he learns the truth. But did we really have to lose him so soon?
As thrilling as this drama is - especially when you have actors Michael C. Hall and Erik King bringing so much dark humour to the situation - the main issue with the Doakes/Dexter showdown is that it starts as a slow-burn but ends with a rushed explosion of action to tidy everything up ready for season three.
Given the depth of animosity and tension between the two men, it would have been brilliant to see Doakes stick around, his quest for answers perhaps slowed down so it could be stretched further over more seasons of the show. The character's ill-timed death is even more egregious when you note he survives in the books (albeit with a much nastier eventual fate). There was still some story to play with here, but the whole thing was tossed aside a bit too quickly.
8. Catelyn Stark - Game of Thrones
Of all the members of the doomed Stark family, Catelyn always felt the most out of place, sidelined as a passive passenger to her husband and sons' journeys.
Game of Thrones had plenty of wasted characters, but Catelyn was one of the first to properly suffer from the show's epic scope. She's fierce and strong, and Michelle Fairley was tremendous in the role with what little she had (that final scene!), but watching the show again serves as a stark reminder (cough) that she always struggled to break through.
Worse still, of course, was the show's decision not to follow the books and resurrect Catelyn as Lady Stoneheart, an undead, hooded assassin seeking vengeance for her death and the other victims of the Red Wedding. When Catelyn dies, she stays dead, which seems odd given the less desirable creative leaps the show took after the fact.
Catelyn was merciful and embattled and compelling enough, but never more than surface right until the end, and the fact she never returned in her most exciting guise remains a baffling disappointment in a show with many.
7. Jerome Valeska - Gotham
Despite being the most exciting and promising addition to the wild crime drama Gotham, Jerome Valeska was used too sparingly to leave a dent as large as he should have.
Played with twisted glee by Cameron Monaghan - who also plays his evil but slightly less intriguing twin Jeremiah - Jerome's murderous appetite, nihilism and captivating charisma injected Gotham with an energy it sorely lacked in his absence. You didn't know where he was going next, sometimes on a line-to-line basis.
Still, despite his obvious virtues and audience popularity, Jerome's sporadic appearances and twisty plots always left him feeling underused and half-forgotten, disappearing and awkwardly reappearing at a moment's notice.
Never a main character, Monaghan's performance alone was case enough to make Jerome a bigger aspect of the series, but it never came to pass. Instead, we got several seasons of The Riddler and The Penguin, who were never able to match the verve Jerome brought to the screen (though those two were fine in their own way).
6. Lexa - The 100
The 100 ran for far too long and suffered some major setbacks despite some creative highs early-on, but none so tumultuous as when the writers decided to kill off fan favourite warrior Lexa with a stray bullet and little reason.
A profoundly fascinating character, Lexa's bravery and selflessness as a leader, as well as her loving relationship with series lead Clarke, made her a woman of limitless potential and depth. Depth, it should be said, the show wasn't close to fully uncovering when it so offhandedly shot her down.
The kind of beloved character whose fate massively impacts their show, Lexa's untimely end was met with widespread derision and upset from audiences and critics alike, especially considering her status as one of TV's most compelling LGBTQ+ icons.
Of course, the writers obviously realised the errors of their ways, bringing her back for a guest spot in The 100's otherwise forgettable finale, but Alycia Debnam-Carey's return did little to fix the damage done. Lexa had so much to give, and it was taken from her due to a blatant, lazy attempt to shock for the sake of it.
5. Darla - Buffy the Vampire Slayer/Angel
Darla is the very first character we ever see or hear in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, playing the stereotypical blonde damsel who, in a then-shocking twist, is revealed to be a demon.
Her importance to the Buffy canon doesn't end there, though. The sire of infamous vampire Angel, it could be argued Dara almost singlehandedly sets some of the biggest stories of the franchise in motion. Only, she's never treated as more than this - a plot device for the bigger (male) characters to suffer and grow.
In Buffy, Darla lasts a few episodes before Angel kills her, and when she returns for the Buffy spinoff, her new life as a human never feels like anything more than an attempt to torture her former lover, and move the plot rather than her character.
For someone with so much backstory and critical importance to the events around her, Darla was entertaining and tragically empathetic for a soulless killer, but every time she looked poised to become something outside of Angel's influence, the shows pulled back and used her only to move his story along. Booooo!
4. Cottonmouth - Luke Cage
Two-time Oscar winner Mahershala Ali is only in the first seven episodes of Luke Cage before his character, the Godfather-like supervillain Cornell "Cottonmouth" Stokes, is killed. Funnily enough, these seven episodes are also the show's best.
A looming threat to rival that of fellow Marvel foils Kingpin and Kilgrave, Cottonmouth was calculating and cold, sure money and fear would buy him the power he craved, and the results of his greed made him a formidably entertaining foe - and, by extension, the best aspect of a show with many highs.
It was a shock, then, when the ruthless arms dealer was killed in Luke Cage's seventh episode by his cousin, Mariah. The show never recovered from the vacuum his death left, and though Mariah herself was a magnificent villain, she never quite matched the steely, unpredictable nature of Cottonmouth's evil.
Ali may have known the death was coming, but audiences sure didn't, and it's safe to say everyone would have loved to see him stick around a little longer. Ah, what could have been...
3. Barriss Offee - Star Wars: The Clone Wars
Star Wars: The Clone Wars does an incredible job of filling in the gaps not just between Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith, but across the entire movie canon, often diving deep on its subjects with meticulous detail.
Throughout the show, we learn about Maul's miraculous return, the origins of Order 66, the depth of Anakin and Padme's relationship. and the inner-workings of the Jedi Council, with the results being utterly captivating.
That's why the final fate of Jedi padawan Barriss Offee feels so frustrating, because whilst she starts the series as a competent, compassionate Jedi, she ends up betraying the Order further down the line. The vague, hand-waving execution of her turn to the Dark Side gives no real insight into her sudden personality change, and that really is a shame, given the potential of seeing such a stalwart and true champion of peace lose her way so dramatically and so tragically.
Some added insight into Offee's fate and the flaws of the Jedi way that led her there would have been greatly appreciated - and probably very powerful, indeed.
2. Isaac Lahey - Teen Wolf
Throughout its six-season run, Teen Wolf altered its cast line-up half a dozen times, with an even mix of welcome surprises and shock omissions - and Isaac Lahey's disappearance after the show's third season fits very firmly in the latter category.
Initially an abused young man who tastes power for the first time in his life after being turned into a werewolf, Isaac started life as a circumstantial villain; a foe simply because he liked who had become. But given enough time - that is, given a handful of near-death experiences and a variety of well-meaning new relationships, particularly with brief girlfriend Allison - Isaac's colours soon started to change shade, and it wasn't long before we were watching a conflicted antagonist become a bona fide good guy.
A great source of comic relief given plenty of time to shine, Isaac seemed in position to become a main character after his exemplary season three arc. But he didn't. Instead, he left never to return or be mentioned again, and though Teen Wolf did just fine without him, his presence (and his potential with it) was sorely missed.
1. Charlie Bradbury - Supernatural
Outside of Sam and Dean Winchester, there were very few characters on Supernatural who stuck around for the long haul - the obvious exceptions being Castiel, Crowley, and Bobby Singer - but one every fan wishes had been given more time was Charlie Bradbury.
First appearing in season seven as a hacker who helps the Winchesters face big bad Dick Roman, Charlie recurred sporadically for the next three seasons, often for one-episode stints that were the highlight of their respective seasons thanks to her easy, sister-like rapport with the hunters, her happy geekiness and infectious energy.
An absolute ray of sunshine who lit up the Winchesters' dreary lives, Charlie fit in so easily with the wider mythology of the show - becoming a hunter in her own right and using her skills to combat a wealth of childhood trauma - she could have easily joined them as a main fixture on the series, and would have enriched it massively.
Unfortunately, it wasn't meant to be. Charlie dies in the tenth season, and though an alternate Charlie turns up sparingly afterward, the original Charlie's absence was a major loss. Quirks and all, she should have been with the brothers through it all, but if Supernatural taught us anything, it's that God sure can be cruel.