10 TV Shows Which Completely Changed Their Premise
For better or for worse.
Is there any question more difficult to answer than the request to boil your favourite show down to a single sentence?
Selling Mad Men to someone on the basis that it's about advertising executives is a tall order, as is convincing conservative relatives that a show about drug dealing is one of the great cultural milestones of the century.
Everyone's had that conversation which ends with a mumbled assurance that they'll check it out sometime while you wail, "But it's really good!" It's even more difficult to encapsulate all the depth of a TV series in a quick sales pitch when it doesn't only alter its tone, characters and style during its time on air, but also its most basic premise.
Long-running shows have a tendency to change over the years, but this article includes only those for which the original summary actually became inaccurate, for better or for worse. Spoilers abound, so be warned.
10. Friends
"So no one told you life was gonna be this way/Your job's a joke, you're broke/Your love life's D.O.A.!" It is perhaps the catchiest theme tune in TV history, but by the final season of Friends there was a huge thematic dissonance between its lyrics and the show's newfound status quo.
Friends was envisioned as a snapshot of that time between university and adult life, when expectations are disappointed and your future is in limbo, and that uncertainty is reflected in the theme song. By season ten, almost everyone (except perhaps Joey) was in their preferred field of work, Rachel and Ross were raising their little girl, Monica and Chandler were married and looking to have kids and even the bohemian Phoebe was settling down.
The characters weren't the immature 20-somethings of the early seasons any longer; yes, they were still the titular friends, but that friendship wasn't the most important thing in their lives anymore. It became a show about the grown-up life which once seemed impossibly distant.
9. Doctor Who
Doctor Who's premise is reinvention, but the classic series underwent a major retool which is still felt in the modern incarnation. It was originally intended as an educational series which would use time travel to teach children about history and science, so the First Doctor was accompanied by his young granddaughter Susan and her two schoolteachers.
The concept of regeneration wasn't even floated until it became apparent that William Hartnell's health was failing three years after his first appearance. The popularity of the Daleks and other science-fiction elements of the show led to a gradual shift away from these storylines and towards the sci-fi epic we recognise today.
Occasionally the Doctor still visits historical figures in the revival, but it's hard to argue that Ten's romance with Elizabeth I was intended to teach children about the Tudors.
8. Sabrina The Teenage Witch
The self-explanatory title became redundant in the last couple of seasons of 1990s hit show Sabrina The Teenage Witch, since she was no longer a teenager. Buffy the Vampire Slayer made a similar transition from high school to college and beyond, but its contemporary is noticeable for almost completely revamping the supporting cast in the process.
Even Sabrina's aunts, who teach her about magic for six seasons, were written out of the final season, just like Sabrina's crush Harvey (for a while), her high school friends and other later love interests.
While Buffy was never dependent on the teen drama of its early years, Sabrina suffered outside the comfort zone of its first three seasons. The move from ABC to the WB did nothing to ease the change, and the tone of the show never matured with Sabrina's character.
7. Borgen
The Danish political drama Borgen begins as a chronicle of the newly elected female Prime Minister's attempts to balance her family life with her demanding new role, and throughout the first and second seasons that's a fair description of the show's premise. By season three, Birgitte Nyborg is retired from politics and the series details her return, while the second protagonist, Katrine, ceases to be her distant mirror and joins Birgitte in her creation of a new party.
Kaspar, once Birgitte's spin doctor, fades into the background (in part due to the actor's other commitments). Borgen's last series looks at the political system and asks whether you can achieve your goals without sacrificing your values, which is essentially what the show had always been about, but its protagonist is now an outsider. It's a great example of a show which changed its premise without compromising its thematic consistency.
6. Angel
Angel, sister show to Buffy the Vampire Slayer, began life as a supernatural detective show with a monster of the week format and healthy doses of noir. It was sort of a more grown-up version of Buffy, while Buffy herself was still attending college in the small town of Sunnydale.
The show is now remembered as a heavily serialised dark fantasy. The season one finale introduces the season-long arcs which would be the future of the series, and by season five, Angel and his team took over former enemy Wolfram & Hart and the original procedural elements of the show were forgotten as it built to an emotionally wrenching conclusion.
5. Happy Days
Nice guy Richie Cunningham was the ostensible protagonist of Happy Days, but it soon became obvious that bad boy Fonzie was the breakout character of the series. Henry Winkler received top billing alongside Ron Howard, whose eventual departure for the directorial career for which he's now best known changed the premise of the show to revolve around the Fonz's exploits.
Happy Days also inspired the phrase 'jumping the shark', named for the episode in which Fonzie literally does just that. It's a quick reference point for the show's exaggeration of his character's abilities, and the point at which it's thought to have begun its transformation into a very different series.
4. Dollhouse
Like Angel, another show from Joss Whedon's stable, Dollhouse initially relied on self-contained episodes, which explored the missions undertaken by mind-wiped human operatives called 'dolls' who were implanted with new false memories each week. It was Alias starring Eliza Dushku, in other words, with sci-fi elements thrown in. The first handful of episodes were consequently quite dull until the overarching plot began to take effect, and the show began to explore the roots of the doll technology and its potential misuse.
By season two, Dollhouse had a firmly established mythology and the dolls were beginning to recover their individuality to face the sinister corporation Rossum. The weekly assignments disappeared after the first few episodes and the series built to its game-changing series finale, then dropped another bombshell when it revealed a post-apocalyptic future set barely ten years afterwards. It had utterly outgrown its original premise, but ratings had already diminished beyond repair.
3. Being Human (U.K.)
The original U.K. version of Being Human was famously marketed with the tagline "a vampire, a ghost and a werewolf share a house in Bristol". It was a sitcom/supernatural horror mash-up which worked brilliantly when its elements cohered and still rather well when they didn't. Series 3 tipped the balance in favour of the supernatural, as werewolf George dealt with threats to his unborn child with girlfriend Nina and the vampire Mitchell became a much darker character. Oh, and it also moved to Wales.
Being Human is perhaps a unique case of a show which lost sight of its premise in one season and managed to reinstate it in the next with a new cast. By the finale of the third series, the show had become a more conventional grim and dark horror for which the original tagline would have felt thematically as well as literally out of place, and the first episode of series four had to work to regain its quirky perspective. It ran for two more successful series, one without any original cast members.
2. Smallville
The teen melodrama of Smallville's early years alienated comic book fans expecting a more traditional Man of Steel to reappear on their TV screens after the romanticism of the 1990s series Lois & Clark. Instead, we got a high school soap with superpowers in the mix, and the biggest enemy of season one was a tornado in Kansas. Still, it delivered on its promise of a young Clark Kent finding his feet in Smallville.
In later seasons, Clark had moved to Metropolis, established a familiar rapport with Lois Lane, become a part of a primitive Justice League and was essentially Superman in all but name. Smallville stuck firmly to its original promise of 'no tights, no flights', but instead drew more and more on the DC mythos. By its final season, in which Clark faced Darkseid, it was no secret that this was a comic book series and proud of it to boot, and it hadn't been set in Smallville for years.
1. Fringe
The pilot of Fringe will be familiar territory for fans of The X-Files as it establishes a small FBI team tasked with investigating strange phenomena. The episode "Peter", an hour-long flashback which explains that one of the protagonists was kidnapped as a child from an alternate universe by his father's doppelganger, is anything but familiar.
Fringe improved immeasurably once it began to explore the parallel universes, and by season three was alternating between the two, complete with separate title sequences. Fringe later went on to introduce alternate timelines and the evolved humans called Observers. If you had caught part of a season one episode, it would have been relatively easy to pick up on the episode's storyline and maybe even some of the overarching mysteries like Olivia's Cortexiphan abilities.
Dropping in on the complex and mythology-heavy seasons which followed is a more daunting task, but for longtime fans, Fringe's evolution is a reward in itself.