10 Weirdest TV Show Crossovers

Like fanfic... but it's canon.

By Anne West /

There is a rich history of crossovers in film. As early as 1943 their was a crossover of horror greats in Frankenstein Meets Wolf Man, but it took a while for the tradition to make it to the small screen.

Advertisement

Famously, in 1990 an East German and West German mystery series had a crossover in which their respective detectives investigate a crime taking place just after the fall of the Berlin Wall, and since then we have seen more and more TV crossovers.

There are many reasons a show can decide to do a crossover: fan service, ratings, wanting to tell a story that combines two different worlds and characters, or merely a network wanting to introduce one show to a different show's audience.

It's always fascinating to see how a crossover navigates bringing two shows together, sometimes with a delicate balance that keeps the integrity of both worlds, sometimes with the wild abandon of a drunk clown throwing hammers at a nail.

Here are ten of the wildest, weirdest and sometimes wonderful crossovers from TV shows we love.

10. Sleepy Hollow/Bones

Bones: The Resurrection of the Remains

Advertisement

Sleepy Hollow: Dead Men Tell No Tales

This two-part crossover special joins the worlds of Bones and Sleepy Hollow. Sleepy Hollow takes place in a supernatural world where Ichabod Crane awakes in 2013 and befriends a cop. Like Sleepy Hollow, Bones is a mystery, but unlike its fellow Fox show, it uses a real-world setting without any magic.

Consequently, having these two shows exist in a shared universe is a bit of a problem for a series like Bones that relies on "hard facts" and "science" to solve their cases.

That said, this spooky episode starts with Booth and Brennan finding a decapitated body, which brings Crane and Abbie to D.C. to help. Set in the Bones universe, despite dealing with a magical skull that is said to bring people back from the dead, the ep concludes that no magic was involved. Just normal, rational murder.

The second episode takes place in the Sleepy Hollow universe and stomps all over the rules of the Bones episode by being about a zombie army. Brennan and Booth never find out about the supernatural elements though, and it all ends well for everyone.

9. Captain N: The Game Master/The Legend Of Zelda Animated Series

Captain N: Quest for the Potion of Power

Advertisement

The main thing these two cartoons have in common is that they're both poorly remembered. They're both also inspired by Nintendo games.

Captain N: The Game Master is a cartoon that started airing in the late eighties about a boy and his dog who are transported to Videoland. The main character, Kevin, fights against villains from Nintendo games in order to save, and like most eighties cartoons it was a great vehicle for advertising all those nifty games kids should probably ask their parents to buy after they were done watching the episode.

The Legend of Zelda cartoon is based - as you probably guessed - on the game of the same name. In The Quest for the Potion of Power, Zelda and Link join forces with Kevin. This admittedly does make some sense though, since Captain N exists in a video game world and helps video game characters.

It's gets pretty meta for the Legend of Zelda characters however. They don't know they are from a video game, but despite this weirdness, both shows are eighties/early ninties cheese and the crossover isn't half bad.

8. Brooklyn 99/New Girl

Brooklyn 99: The Night Shift

Advertisement

New Girl: Homecoming

Brooklyn 99 is a sitcom about outlandish police officers solving crimes. New Girl is a sitcom about a quirky girl who moves in with new roommates. Both are Fox shows, and comedies, but the crossover was still an odd choice.

The New Girl characters live in Los Angeles, Brooklyn 99 takes place in New York. Both are big cities, but no where near each other. Likewise, all of the New Girl main characters fly to New York for this crossover - even Nick, who has issues with debt, is somehow able to swing the expensive trip.

Normally, for two-part specials like this, an overarching story will connect the two shows. In this case, The Night Shift is primarily a standard Brooklyn 99 episode with a short guest appearance of Jess from New Girl.

Homecoming, on the other hand, puts most of the cast of Brooklyn 99 into the New Girls episode.The excuse used to get the New Girl cast to New York is that Schmidt is having a kind of high school reunion which he believes will be honoring him. Spoiler: it's not.

It's a decent episode, but it doesn't make good use of the extended cast of characters.

7. The Simpsons/Futurama

The Simpsons: Simpsorama

Advertisement

Both of these animated shows were created by Matt Groening and air on Fox, so a crossover was perhaps always inevitable. However, that it took until Futurama was off the air is a bit of a surprise.

Similar in style, the main oddness in combining the two worlds is that despite Simpsons playing fast and loose with reality, it does exist in some semblance of a 'real' world. Most of the more fantastical reality bending happens during Halloween episodes. Luckily, the episode leans towards Futurama's sensibilities and ends up balancing the words and characters well.

The intro features the text gag: "A show out of ideas teams up with a show out of episodes" - which really does sum up this crossover. Bender must travel to the past to try and kill Homer who he believes is the cause of a mutant rabbit army attacking the future.

The result is an excuse for all our beloved Futurama characters to kick it with the Simpsons cast, and it's enjoyable on that front.

6. Lilo And Stitch/The Proud Family

Lilo and Stitch the Series: Spats

Advertisement

Lilo and Stitch the Series is a spin off of the much loved film. In it Lilo and Stitch search for lost "cousins" of Stitch, other alien experiments like himself who are lost on Hawaii, each with their own unique skill.

On the inverse, The Proud Family is a comedy cartoon with a sitcom dynamic that follows Penny Proud and, well, her family. There really isn't much more to it.

Disney does its best to mesh together the two different comedy styles of the shows. The excuse for the crossover is that Penny and her family decide to go on vacation to Hawaii and stay at the "Bed and Not Breakfast" Jumba and Pleakley are running.

Lilo and Penny end up working together after a new cousin "Spats" is activated by Penny's grandmother. Penny rolls with the discovery that alien experiments exist, and helps save the day. Weirdly, it all comes together surprisingly well.

5. Magnum P.I./Murder She Wrote

Magnum P.I.: Novel Connections

Advertisement

Murder She Wrote: Magnum on Ice

This two part crossover special combines two very different types of detectives. Thomas Magnum is a private investigator who likes to take cases he finds interesting and lives on a wealthy estate owned by a mysterious benefactor. Jessica Fletcher is a popular author who accidentally finds a mystery each episode that she must help solve.

While both are mystery shows, the way in which the main characters function within their universes is pretty different. Magnum is a professional detective that approaches each case as simply a job, while Fletcher is untrained, and at random becomes involved in solving a mystery. This puts them on uneven footing when working together, and the story has to work hard to justify Fletcher taking a more hands-on role in the detective work.

Starting with a Magnum P.I. episode, Jessica visits Hawaii and gets tangled in a case ,ending with a cliffhanger where Thomas is arrested. The next episode is in the Murder She Wrote series, where Jessica steps up to investigate, while the framed Thomas is out-on-bail trying to evade the law.

4. X-Files/Cops

X-Files: X-Cops

Advertisement

X-Files is about two FBI agents, Mulder and Scully, who investigate paranormal mysteries. Cops is a reality show that follows actual officers on the job. Trying to do a crossover between a fictional TV show and reality TV show seems like it would cause some trouble, but X-Files - somehow - makes it work.

X-Cops begins with the Cops theme song, it's filmed in the style of Cops, and tells the story in real-time so that the audience experiences the plot as the characters do. It also has Cops crew members featured in the episode, helping with production: giving the fictional episode the same tone as the reality show

It was a mad idea that could have gone terribly wrong, but the ep was positively reviewed, despite its odd premise, and X-Cops was considered a crossover success and is even often featured in lists of the best X-Files episodes.

3. Bones/Family Guy

Bones: The Critic in the Cabernet

Advertisement

The main thing Bones and Family Guy have in common is that they are both owned by Fox. That's pretty much where the similarities end. One is a live-action hour-long mystery drama. The other is an over the top half-hour animated sitcom show. Not the most intuitive crossover choice.

However, In The Critic in the Cabernet blends the two worlds in an interesting way. Booth is dealing with the stress of trying to decide whether or not to be a sperm donor for his friend and coworker Brennan. He also has an undiagnosed brain tumor, and this is all the excuse needed to have Booth hallucinate the British baby from Family Guy who berates the man in classic Stewie Griffin style.

Considering the seriousness of the situation, this was a wild way to reveal such a dramatic point.

2. Supernatural/Scooby Doo

Supernatural: Scoobynatural

Advertisement

Supernatural is a long running CW series about two brothers who fight against, you guessed it, supernatural threats. Scooby Doo is an even longer running animated series about four meddling kids and their dog who also band together to solve mysteries.

While these two shows seem worlds apart, Supernatural uses a magical solution to get this crossover rolling. Dean and Sam are sucked into a cursed TV and end up in an episode of Scooby Doo. The Scooby Doo cast don't know they exist in an animated world and their normal gentle mystery turns sinister as violent murders begin to take place. Dean and Sam know the murders are supernatural in their nature, but the Scooby gang doesn't believe in ghosts. obviously.

Scoobynatural plays with the cartoon logic of the Scooby Doo world as Dean and Sam try to help solve the mystery before real world supernatural violence might do real world damage to their cartoon favorites.

1. Mr. Robot/ALF

Mr. Robot: Master Slave

Advertisement

Mr. Robot is a thriller about a young man, Elliot, who is recruited by a secretive hacker organization. ALF was an eighties comedy about a sarcastic alien who lives with a human family. These shows have next to nothing in common, so you can imagine that the crossover was a surprise for viewers.

Mr. Robot was a very experimental show, and it used Elliot's loose grasp on reality to make this episode work. Master Slave starts out like a sitcom: in its filming style and in the uncomfortable laugh track. Technically taking place inside Elliot's head while he's in the hospital, the episode follows a disturbing family road trip with Tyrell in the trunk of the car and a guest appearance from ALF.

It's totally surreal in a style that actually works for the show, making for a surprisingly solid crossover, and one which makes more sense than it seems on paper.

Advertisement