11 Forgotten Christmas Specials You Probably Haven't Seen

The greatest Christmas specials that have sadly faded out of memory...

By Vinnie Bartilucci /

Unless you're very old, there are dozens, possibly hundreds of Christmas specials that you've missed, either because you didn't think you'd care for it, or more likely, they only ran a single time, possibly before you were ever born, and never again (for good reason.) Sometimes they were terrible, or just Seemed Like A Good Idea (and decidedly weren't,) while some may have just been dated before they were even finished: for whatever reason, Christmas specials vanish more often than species of spider in the Amazon. A lot of these one-shot-wonders are getting new life on DVD and content-desperate classic TV cable channels, but not all. So to cherish those that remain lost, or at least under-loved, we're looking back at a few, for better or worse. And no, there's no place for The Star Wars Holiday Special, because if you actually wanted to see it, you probably have.

11. Santa Vs The Snowman

This is the most recent special in the list, premiering in 1998 on ABC. A CGI special by Steve Odekerk, the creator of Jimmy Neutron, it bears many plot similarities to The Nightmare Before Christmas. A mute snowman discovers Santa's workshop, and is rebuffed when he tries to take a pretty flute, so in a fit of pique, he decides he would make a better Santa, and creates an army of ice soldiers and weaponry to lay siege to the North Pole. Jonathan Winters plays Santa, who runs the most benevolent and friendly fascist monarchy you've ever seen. Video transmissions between departments use "Merry Christmas" as a sign off, the way they used "England Prevails" in V for Vendetta. Ben Stein and Victoria Jackson plays elves, and the narration is by legendary "In a world..." movie trailer voice Don LaFontaine. The CGI is quite rudimentary, but it's a perfect argument for how the strength of the story trumps the quality of the animation. It ran on the network once or twice, made its way to ABC Family, but is now a perennial on IMAX screens, where it's run in 3-D

10. Santa Baby!

Historically important, in that this was Rankin/Bass' last Christmas production, released in syndication in 2001. It's also one of the few special to feature an all African-American cast, both before and (predominantly) behind the camera. Eartha Kitt appears, which is delightful as she sang the original version of the song, which has since been covered by dozens of performers, including Madonna, Taylor Swift and Calista Flockhart, AKA Ally McBeal. Gregory Hines plays Noel, a songwriter with two songs in him, desperate to write the third. His daughter is granted a wish after performing a good deed, and wishes for her Dad to write a hit song. The title song gets performed by Kitt, Vanessa Williams and Patti LaBelle. Incidentally, the special was co-written by Suzanne Collins, is better know for being the writer of the Hunger Games trilogy.

9. Nestor, The Long-Eared Christmas Donkey

I could easily do this entire article mentioning only Rankin-Bass specials - they are as linked to Christmas in the American consciousness as fruitcake and credit-card debt. They delivered a steady stream of holiday jollity, in stop-motion and traditional animation format decades, but not every one was a winner. Nestor had all the hallmarks of a winner - another Gene Autry song as the base, a script by Romeo Muller, R-B's personal Shakespeare, a popular performer as the narrator (Roger Miller, who performed a similar role in Disney's Robin Hood), and a mutated main character. Nestor, as you may have been able to tell from the title, had preternaturally long ears, which brought him much derision. But as with the popular reindeer with whom they draw a parallel in the titular ditty, his malady comes in handy - he is selected by Mary and Joseph to carry her to Bethlehem, and when they get caught in a sandstorm, she shields her with his excessive ears. It's a good story, but it was a tad too tied to the religious side of the holiday, and as the desire to stick with the fun, gift-centric side increased, most of the more faith-based stories lost ground.

Advertisement

8. Yes, Virginia, There Is A Santa Claus

There's a new version of this one, sponsored and endlessly hawked by Macy's during the Thanksgiving Day parade, but it's the first version from 1974 I'm discussing here. It's directed by Bill Melendez, who did so many of the Peanuts specials over the years, it's almost as if he forgot how to draw anything else. The character designs of the kids so greatly resemble Schulz' creations, it's a wonder he didn't sue. The story is well known: Little Virginia still believes in Santa, a mindset that was met with some derision by her contemporaries. She contacts the editor of New York paper The Sun with her query about Santa, based on her father's declaration, "If it's in The Sun, it's so". (note: It frequently wasn't) The editor, flush with emotion, answers Virginia's query on the front page with an essay that brought a tear to even the crustiest New Yorker's eye. Jim Backus narrated the tale, his identity revealed at the end of the special. The cast featured a fine multicultural array of representative races, including a nice Jewish candy-maker who offers his opinion on this mysterious character. Jimmy Osmond sang the title song in his near-castrati range - he has sung other songs better.

7. The Stingiest Man In Town

Another adaptation of Dickens' "A Christmas Carol," (and another story one could do an entire list of adaptations) this one from 1978 stars Walter Matthau as Scrooge, and Tom Bosley as the omniscient narrator, Mr B.A.H. Humbug, Esq. Matthau's hangdog delivery made him a great Scrooge Like so many of their work, the character designs were by Mad magazine artist Paul Coker Jr - the traditionally animated specials like this one look so much like his work, it's almost like he drew it all himself. Robert Morse plays the young Scrooge, and Theo Bikel played Marley's ghost. Paul Frees provided the voices of both the ghosts of Christmases past and Future. It's based on an even older live action version, with Basil Rathbone in the title role. All the songs come from the original. As a result, this special has a much different feel than most R/B classics, even with the updating by Romeo Muller.

Advertisement

6 . The Night Before Christmas

Unless you're old enough to have seen this, the only reason you know about this special is because of the South Park cover of its best song, "Even a Miracle Needs A Hand". The original special is slightly less cynical. The original poem is acted out in its entirety as the classic of the special, but only after a wild flight of fancy that has nothing in common with it. The children of a small turn of the century town are dismayed to learn that all the letters to Santa are returned unopened. When the North Pole is contacted to inquire why, they are told that they received a letter from the town, signed "All of us" which stated that Santa was a fraud. clad demigod, in the hopes they can melt his frosty heart. George Gobel plays the patriarch of a mouse family that lives in grey's home, and Tammy Grimes as his oldest son, an intellectual child with more brains than heart.

Advertisement

5. The Night The Animals Talked

Another story with a heavy religious base, this one tells the story of the Christ-child's birth, when apparently the animals in the stable all gained the power of speech and intelligence. Based on a Norwegian folk tale, and originally adapted as a record by Peter Fernandez (the voice of Speed Racer), it was directed by animation legend Shamus Culhane. As the animals first realize they can speak, they fall into in-fighting and tribalism that more than a little resembles Animal Farm. But as Mary gives birth and they're overcome with the event, their interspecies conflict melts away. They head out into the streets to share the good news, but as they pass out of the miracle Another solid entry that lost ground due to the religious aspect of the TV celebration.

4. The Life And Adventures Of Santa Claus

The last Christmas special from Rankin/Bass before Santa Baby! was this one from 1985, and WOW, did they want to go out with a bang. It's based on a novel by L. Frank Baum, which, like most of his non-Oz books, is all but forgotten by the modern era. It was his attempt to give a biography to the beloved Christmas hero, one that would be provided so much more successfully by R/B in their classic, Santa Claus Is Coming To Town. In the forest of Burzee, a council of the forces of nature convene to review the life of a man named Claus, who has dedicated his life to making children happy. He is granted the gift of immortality, so that he may continue his quest forever. The character designs of the council are truly epic, some of the most imaginative they'd ever done. Baum's story is equally fantastic and outlandish - Santa is raised by a tigress, and is protected over by fairies and other mystical woodland beings. JD Roth, best know for hosting kids game show Fun House, plays the young Claus, and WOW can he not act. Long time H/B voice actors Alfred Drake and Bob McFadden also appear in this last great work by the company.

Advertisement

3. Jack Frost

Rankin/Bass started run out of well-known Christmas characters as time wore on, and the were forced to revisit the nose-nipping sprite jack Frost, last seen as the bad guy in Frosty's Winter Wonderland three years before. This story is not set in the same continuity as that special (And yes, there was an actual continuity in the Frosty and Rudolph specials, but that is quite another story), and Jack is played by Broadway star Robert Morse (How To Succeed in Business Without Really Trying!) with Larry Storch, Don Messick and Paul Frees rounding out the cast. A familiar storyline (Little Mermaid leaps to mind), Jack falls in love with a human girl, and asks to be made human to win her heart. Pardon-Me Pete (oiced by Buddy Hackett, a guy who did a LOT of children's entertainment, considering how old-school) bawdy his stage act was, the star of Groundhog Day (the actual day, but the movie) is the narrator of the story, one of the few times where the narrator plays a part in the story. Another classic from Romeo Muller, filled with wild and amazing creative characters like Snip, the sprite in charge of cutting snowflakes and Father Winter, the god of the season.

Advertisement

2. Olive The Other Reindeer

Released in 1999, it's based on the children's picture book and was produced by Matt Groening, creator of The Simpsons. Olive (Drew Barrymore) is a Jack Russell Terrier who mondegreens a radio newscast which, reporting that Blitzen is injured, and Santa hopes "all of the other reindeer" will be able to carry the load, which she hears as "Olive, the other reindeer". Thinking Santa needs her help, she starts a trek to the North Pole, with the help of a penguin named Martini (Joe Pantoliano). Their antagonist is The Postman (Dan Castallaneta) who would rather see Christmas gone, so he doesn't have to carry all that holiday mail. It's a very funny adventure, with a great voice cast, save for Barrymore, who really needs a strong director in order to excel. Seek out her version of Babes In Toyland (with Keanu Reeves) for another example of truly abysmal acting from her.

Advertisement

1. Robbie The Reindeer

This is unique in the list in that it's not an American-produced special - it's from many of the folks from Aardman Animation, the gifted maniacs that brought us Wallace and Gromit. The original UK version is FAR superior to the American version, featuring a pantheon of modern British comedy, including Ardal O'Hanlon, Steve Coogan and Ricky Gervais. The American version re-recorded the entire soundtrack, with Ben Stiller as Robbie, James Belushi as Santa and Britney Spiers as Robbie's girlfriend Donner. Robbie is the son of a certain well-known reindeer with a red nose, that the producers didn't have the rights to, so his name is never mentioned, resulting of a great running gag where people try to start singing the song, and are shushed by bad guy Blitzen. Blitzen wants to be the leader of Santa's team, and with Robbie now here, son of Santa's favorite, he sees his chances drop to zero. The dialogue is classic - one of Blitzen's plans to eliminate Robbie is "Let's trample him into dust, then throw the remains of the dust to the wolves, then blow up the wolves". Available on video, usually with both soundtracks. Enjoy the original UK one, then listen to the American one only to experience what The Residents describe as "The ear numbing power of difference". Which forgotten Christmas specials did we miss? Share your on picks below in the comments.