12 Brilliant Ways TV Characters Were Brought Back From The Dead

How do you cheat death, but not annoy the fans? Like this...

By Baz Greenland /

A couple of weeks ago we looked at 12 ridiculous ways TV characters were brought back from the dead; stories where shocking plot developments were ignored just so the show could go in a different direction. Suicides being faked to characters returning without explanation and being explained away as angels, there have been countless instances where TV resurrections from the dead have been, frankly, ludicrous. But it's not all a laughing matter. Sometimes characters can return from the grave in seemingly imaginative and ingenious ways. With a healthy dose of mystery, the supernatural and most importantly of all, plausibility, character resurrections can be a thrilling shake up in the drama of any show. It doesn't matter if it€™s a gritty crime drama or a show set on a space ship in another galaxy; like any story, a character€™s resurrection can be believable if it€™s done respectfully and with style and flair. It€™s a reason Sara Tancredi€™s return in Prison Break was silly. You can€™t show someone€™s decapitated head and then next season explain it all away as a hoax. The less said about rebooting story lines after an entire year by making it all a dream, the better. Dallas, you never recovered from that one. For every ridiculous resurrection, TV has an ingenious one, so in this article, we'll now look at 12 brilliant ways TV characters were brought back from the dead. As before, please feel free to share your thoughts at the end.

12. Winnifred 'Fred' Burkle / Ilyria €“ Angel

Joss Whedon is known for subjecting us poor fans to one horrible death after another. It started with Jenny Calendar in Buffy The Vampire Slayer and continued with Joyce, Tara and Anya. The cast of Angel fared even worse; Doyle, Cordelia, Wesley and Fred all met their maker and Gunn looked to be on his way out by the time the final credits rolled. Worse of all was Serenity, the big screen outing for the Firefly crew. Double bluffing the audience by killing Shepherd Book, fans were traumatised when Wash found himself skewered on a giant Reaver spear. The phrase €˜I€™m a leaf on the wind€™ brings a tear to even the most hardened Whedonite. Fred's death cut almost as deeply in the fifth season of Angel. The sweetest, brightest, most innocent of all Angel's crew, she found herself dying in Wesley's arms, her soul burned out of existence as the goddess Illyria possessed her body. It was excruciating for everyone that knew her; despite looking like a blue-haired warrior she was still essentially Fred physically, even if their friend no longer existed. And yet, the show was cleverly able to resurrect poor Fred. Realising the importance of the person whose body she now inhabited, Ilyria was able to transform her guise into that of Winifred "Fred" Burkle, first to deal with the unfortunate appearance of Fred's parents, both unaware of their daughter's death and later to help poor Wesley ease his suffering as he dies of his wounds in the series finale. Joss Whedon's plans for an unaired season six would have been for Ilyria and Fred to be separated but as we didn't get that, fans can take comfort that they got to see Fred a couple more times after her horrific death.

11. Batman €“ Batman: The Animated Series

In the classic episode 'The Man Who Killed Batman', the caped crusader had presumably, as the episode title suggests, been killed. Told through the past escapades of two-bit crook Sidney, we discover that he got into a struggle with Batman during a drug run. Gotham's hero is killed in an explosion and a triumphant Sidney emerges, holding Batman's cape and cowl and goes on to become the infamous killer and hero of Gotham's criminal underworld. Considering the class of criminals in Gotham; The Joker, Two Face, The Riddler, Poison Ivy et all, Sidney receives high praise indeed, until he's lured into a trap by the Joker and Harley Quinn in the most bizarre funeral tribute to Batman of them all (Harley even plays Amazing Grace on a kazoo!). Of course, Sidney's luck doesn't end there and he manages to escape the acid bath the Joker has planned for him. It's only at the end that Batman reappears, seemingly unscathed from his encounter with Sidney and an observer to Sidney's exploits since his death. In a rather sentimental turn of events, Batman has allowed poor Sidney to take the credit for his death and for managing to outwit the Joker (Batman saves him from the acid bath), making him the toast of the prison scene. It shows a different side to Batman; he still puts Sidney in prison for his criminal activities, but in a world of larger-than-life super villains, he has allowed the little man to become the hero, even if he is on the wrong side!

10. John Locke €“ Lost

One of the most shocking moments in season five was the death of fan favourite John Locke at the hands of Ben Linus. Since the early days of season one, John had been a big advocate of the island and the benefits it could bring to the survivors of Oceanic Flight 815, not least because it restored feeling to his legs, allowing him to walk again. It's why he takes on the thankless task of trying to convince Jack, Kate and the other members of the Oceanic Six to return to the island even after they make their escape at the end of season four. Of course, being Lost, his story doesn't end at his death and as his body is delivered back to the island we discover, going into the final season, that the island has chosen to help John a second time by bringing him back to life... ...Or has it? In a tragic turn of events we learn that one of the show's greatest heroes has been dead since Ben killed him and the man walking around the island is in fact the enemy; the smoke monster wearing the guise of John Locke. His resurrection is a cruel trick on the audience, and it takes one final climatic battle with Jack and the loss of both their lives to rid the world of the evil within the island. Sometimes people don't return from the dead, even in a show like Lost and unfortunately John Locke never got to live out his life on the island he made his home...

9. Laura Bristow / Irina Derevko €“ Alias

Alias's debut season is a master-stroke in story telling; where most shows take their time to get going (Agents Of Shield, we're looking at you), Alias knocked it out of the park from the first episode. The reveal that Sidney worked for an criminal organisation (SD6) posing as the CIA who murdered her fiancé and her dad is a double agent working for the real CIA? That's just episode one and as the season progressed, Sidney's double life allowed for some amazing drama, action sequences and even comedy. (Will discovering who Sidney is covers all three!) Yet, the show accelerated further with season two in no small part to the reveal of Sidney's supposedly dead mother. Established as a teacher killed in a car accident in the first season, deceased Laura Bristow was revealed to be the very much alive Irinia Derevko, a former KGB spy, confidant of series villain Arvin Sloan and the leader of the criminal organisation Sidney had been fighting against in both her SD6 and CIA guises. How does that first meeting go? Irina shoots her, of course! Though as we learn that is a ruse to save Sidney before turning herself in and establishing a relationship with her daughter by feeding her secrets about the enemy. It's a brilliant example of introducing a dead character that has a massive connection to the protagonist's life and flipping it on its head a hundred times over. Few characters have been brought back from the dead with as much style as Sidney Bristow's treacherous mother.

8. Optimus Prime €“ The Transformers

Forget Michael Bay's CGI fest; the original animated movie from the 1980s was the best cinematic outing. Awe-inspiring with cheese-fest rock ballads, a planet-eating transformer called Unicron, the slaughter of several recurring characters and most significantly of all, the death of Autobot leader Optimus Prime. Causing such a climatic shift in storytelling, the subsequent season three of the animated series was a very different beast. Hot Rod was now leading the good guys at Rodimus Prime and Megatron had been reborn as Galvatron. But by the season end there was something of a renaissance in the epically titled 'The Return Of Optimus Prime'. Our favourite hero was back but with a much darker twist; he was now a trap created by scientists seeking to destroy the autobots and they almost succeed. Dark-Optimus was a shocking event for kid audiences at the time; he infects the good guys and battles new leader Rodimus Prime, defeating him, and almost succeeding in destroying the Autobots entirely. Thankfully Optimus regains his senses at the last moment and retakes his place as leader once more, ensuring that fans got to open up their beloved Optimus Prime toys one more time.

7. Sherlock Holmes €“ Sherlock

A controversial choice perhaps, with the lack of definitive clarification over how Sherlock survived the fall at the end of €˜The Reichenbach Fall€™. Given the sheer ingenuity of this series, was anything ever going to meet the expectations we all had in that long wait between the second and third series? Series three opener €˜The Empty Hearse€™ does present three options as to how Sherlock ultimately survived and the third is the most plausible; he used Molly to provide a fake body, his homeless network to engineer fake crowds and distractions and a bungee cord to survive the plummet. It's all rather...simple in a Sherlock-kind of way. But of course, it's not how he faked his death but the why (to allow him to dismantle Moriaty's criminal network) and how people react to his return. In this, his resurrection is utterly brilliant. Impersonating a waiter to surprise Watson is one of the funniest moments in recent years and lead to a further series of events resulting in a frustrated Watson hitting him. It's over the top yet completely believable at the same time and made for some amazing television, showing exactly how to bring a character back from the dead with style and flair.

6. Dean Winchester €“ Supernatural

The Winchester brothers have died several times over the last nine years, so much in fact that when a season finale rolls in, there's a good chance that either Dean or Sam are going to meet their maker. Fans shouldn't worry; like a fellow slayer of demons, Buffy Summers, they'll always be back for more. Dean's resurrection at the start of season four is the most ingenious of them all as it paves the way for Lucifer and the apocalypse end game of season five. Killed by hell hounds the previous year, Dean awakens in his own grave and literally has to claw his way out. His new lease of life, it turns out, is all down to an angel called Castiel, working on the orders of God and who, as it turns out again, becomes the most beloved character on the show to date. What's so clever is the chain of events that surround his resurrection. Dean is charged with stopping Lilith from breaking the 66 seals and releasing Lucifer, the first seal being Dean himself, who was forced to torture an innocent soul in Hell. By being brought back into the fold, he gains a greater sense of purpose and goes from simple hunter to saviour of the world, even when all his friends fall in the battle to save humanity from the apocalypse itself. It was the turning point when Dean took center stage from his brother Sam, who until this point had been mostly connected to the ongoing story.

5. Clara Oswald €“ Doctor Who

Rory Williams might be the Kenny of Doctor Who, surviving drowning, old age and being erased from time itself but it is Clara Oswin Oswald still beats him for sheer the scope of her many resurrections. We might have seen two deaths so far, but that doesn€™t mean we might encounter another version of herself in the future, alongside the current modern-day companion. Fans wanted something simpler in tone after the arc-heavy stories of series six and the following run of episodes did that with the €˜mystery girl€™ story line that began, rather surprisingly, before the entrance of the Doctor's post-Ponds companion. Her appearance at the start of series seven was a master stroke in storytelling and the follow up reveal of her death at the hand of the Daleks had us scratching our heads for months. Finally she was back in The Snowmen, only to die a second time. The mystery of her many deaths and resurrections came together extremely satisfactorily in the series seven finale 'The Name Of The Doctor'. She jumps into the Doctor's time stream to save him and the universe from the Great Intelligence, scattering herself across every pivotal moment in the Doctor's life. From the First Doctor picking his Tardis on Gallifrey to a trip Svartos to save the Seventh Doctor from a polystyrene cliff (though Dragonfire, really?), Clara was literally everywhere at once, living and dying for the Doctor. In one decisive action, she became one of the most pivotal companions in Doctor history; a companion who can live and die a thousand times over. Even Rory can€™t beat that one.

4. Agent Phil Coulson €“ Agents Of Shield

Someone had to die in The Avengers. With Joss Whedon at the helm, we were expecting it and it was probably a bit early (and self-defeatist of the studios with mega-bucks-sequels awaiting) to kill off one the headline superheroes. Second time round, we're not so confident for Iron Man, Captain America et al but at least they'll make it to their encounter with Ultron. While a death was expected, Agent Phil Coulson's demise was also shocking and tragic. A firm favourite since he appeared in Iron Man, we should have known something was up as soon he began discussing his cello-playing love interest with Pepper Potts. (It's a SPOILER by the way!) His death was also spectacular; taking on the god Loki with a big-ass gun, it's something we've come to expect with Agents Of Shield on a weekly basis. But here, it was the sign of greater things to come. Talking of Agents Of Shield - a post-Avengers TV series with Coulson as the lead? How could this be possible? Well it's all down to a mysterious and horrific resurrection that audiences finally learned about in pivotal episodes 'The Magical Place' and 'T.A.H.I.T.I'. Using the DNA of a mysterious blue-skinned alien and some rather nightmarish brain scrambling machinery, Coulson was resurrected a number of days after his death. What was so ingenious about this reveal was that the essential question wasn€™t how he returned from his death, but why. This was one of the major steps towards the darker side of SHEILD, something Captain America: The Winter Soldier has expanded on. Why did Nick Fury resurrect a colleague who had been dead for days? That€™s the question series villain the Clairvoyant and audiences are eager to learn in equal measure.

3. John Sheridan €“ Babylon 5

€œIf you go to Z'Hadum, you will die€. Ever since Kosh spoke those fateful words in season two of Babylon 5, we knew that Captain John Sheridan would make his way to the home world of the Shadows one way or another. The return of his long-dead wife Anna in the season three finale was certainly a knife in John's developing relationship with Delenn and gave him the motive to venture to the home world of his greatest enemy. John's death at the end of season three (crashing the White Star into the shadow city, nuking his enemy and jumping into the abyss) was a pivotal moment in the show. The Shadow war took a breather, allowing the Vorlons to unleash their armada and a resurrected Sheridan and Ivanova the chance to bring the last of the old ones and the alien races into one final battle that would determine the fate of the galaxy forever. Of course no resurrection is without its consequences. Lorien was able to revive Sheridan in order to allow him to end the war, but the price wass just twenty more years of life; Sheridan was able to fulfil his destiny in becoming president of the Interstellar Alliance but his time with Delenn was cut short, leading to his final journey in the epic and emotionally wrought series finale 'Sleeping In Light'.

2. Buffy Summers €“ Buffy The Vampire Slayer

In a previous article, we voted Buffy's death and subsequent resurrection in the season one finale the 5th most ridiculous way a character was brought back from the dead. Her recovery from a bout of drowning was a tad silly, but fortunately her second revival, following her fatal confrontation with Glory at the end of season five, was handled far better. Like Dean Winchester, Buffy is forced to climb out of her own grave when Willow's spell brought her back from the dead at the start of season six. Only it's not all hugs and smiles for the slayer; during the course of the season we discovered that Buffy had been ripped out of Heaven. How could an Earth, where she is forced to fight vampires and demons week on week, be anything but Hell to Buffy after that? The consequences of Buffy's resurrection are immense. Not only is the slayer traumatised by her return (it takes an entire season for her to find her purpose again), but poor Willow goes off the deep end after realising what her magic has done and the nature of Buffy's return gives the First Evil the footing it needs to destroy the world. Returning from the dead isn't a quick fix for Buffy The Vampire Slayer: the ramifications run through the rest of the show. All 44 episodes of it.

1. The Doctor (Every Regeneration) €“ Doctor Who

The most ingenious resurrection of them all was the creative decision by script editor Gerry Davis and producer Innes Lloyd in 1966 that allowed the Doctor to keep on living even after the lead actor moved on. It's a theme that allowed the show to celebrate fifty years last year, and, gods willing, will allow it to continue on to a hundred. In any other show, replacing the lead character would most likely be a death sentence, but in Doctor Who it allows the show to remain fresh and reinvent itself every few years. It's heart-breaking watching your favourite Doctor go, but without John Pertwee leaving, we wouldn't have had the best Doctor of them all in Tom Baker and without David Tennant, there would have been no Matt Smith. It€™s reason enough to be excited for what Peter Capaldi will bring to the role. As to which Doctor had the greatest regeneration, fear not, because we handily compiled this list last year, prior to Matt Smith's departure. (For the record, the Eleventh Doctor's regeneration is one if the best). So do you agree with these choices? Do you find them clever or contrived? Do you think television should use the whole €˜character resurrected from the dead€™ method of storytelling or steer clear of it altogether? Please let us know your thoughts and choices in the comments below!