12 Things Agents Of SHIELD Needs To Fix For Season 2

The first season got better as it went on. Here's how series 2 can build on this momentum.

By Mark Allen /

The first season of Marvel's Agents Of SHIELD ended a few weeks ago, and while the show's had its ups and downs since it premiered last year, it's safe to say that it finished its run on a high note, bringing in major twists and turns for the final stretch of episodes that shook up the dynamics between lead characters and raised the stakes to the rafters. ABC must certainly have thought so too, as they recently renewed the show for another season. While that's good news for those who enjoyed the first season's lighthearted and slightly shambolic attempt to project an action-adventure-cum-spy procedural veneer over the Marvel Cinematic Universe proper, others weren't that happy with the show's inconsistent quality and occasional lulls in story. It's true: the show's first season was far from perfect. It was far from adequate on some occasions, but that doesn't mean it can't get better. Just think about the potential for a series like this, with a huge back catalogue of characters and stories to bring to life on the small screen, and consider that nothing else like this has really been done before on such a huge scale and that perhaps nobody was going to get it exactly right the first time around. With all that in mind, we've compiled a list of things that weren't really working in Agents Of SHIELD's first season that, if rectified, could easily boost the show into stellar territory. Have any ideas of your own? Let us know in the comments!

12. More Involvement From Joss Whedon

It's a no-brainer, isn't it? The Marvel mastermind behind The Avengers' absence from Agents Of SHIELD was never more keenly felt than when the jokes just weren't landing and there wasn't quite enough emotional investment in the characters to care about whatever exposition-heavy craziness was happening in the plot. While Whedon did direct and co-write the pilot episode - and it's telling that it's still one of the show's most playful and simultaneously sincere outings - he contributed no more (credited) scripts to the season and it's unclear how involved he was as an Executive Producer, though from a look at his work schedule prepping and shooting Avengers: Age Of Ultron and his absence from pretty much every interview regarding the show it's pretty safe to say he wasn't on set or in the writers' room all that much. And while you don't necessarily need Joss Whedon running the place to make a show work - Tim Minear on Firefly and Marti Noxon on the latter seasons of Buffy certainly proved that - you kind of do if you're trying to make a show that's straining to imitate his voice. The self-deprecating banter and clever wordplay present in much of the show is entertaining at best and irritatingly affected at worst, tending toward the latter when showrunners Maurissa Tancharoen, Jed Whedon and Jeffrey Bell aren't on scripting duty, but it almost always has a false ring to it, likely due to the effect Joss' writing and his own presence has had on the writers and the shape Agents Of SHIELD has taken. But without him to steer the ship, everyone left in charge seems to have second-guessed at 'what Joss would do' instead of forging their own path, only really redeeming themselves when a company synergy strategy mandated key plot changes. The producers either need to get their captain back to right themselves or get a new one and forget they ever marched to anyone else's fife.

11. Stronger Connection To The Marvel Cinematic Universe

"New York." "Bruce Banner." "Chitauri." "Stark." These are all phrases that have been casually (well, at least as casual as an iron boot on a glass floor) dropped into dialogue in episodes of AoS by pretty much every recurring character to help us remember that all of this is occurring in the same world as Iron Man, The Winter Soldier and The Avengers - and, I suppose, The Incredible Hulk, but Marvel probably isn't that keen on reminding us of Ed Norton when Mark Ruffalo's next door. Despite being consistently clunky with their namedropping, the mentions do certainly serve their purpose, but merely reminding an audience that there's a Hulk somewhere around here just isn't the same as seeing the real thing, and feels very much like a tease with no real prospect of a payoff. To put it simply: Agents of SHIELD needs more payoff, or else everyone will see that it's just blowing smoke while D-list villains populate the show's rogues' gallery. Have an story deal with Tony Stark's company and the weapons he used to produce. Get a consultation from Bruce Banner, or Erik Selvig. The latter was once on SHIELD's payroll, wasn't he? And for the love of God, let Nick Fury and Maria Hill make more than a couple of appearances a season. (Now that How I Met Your Mother is over, that shouldn't be too much of a problem for Cobie Smulders.) They would add to the legitimacy that Clark Gregg brings to proceedings tenfold, and would let an audience feel like maybe what's going on in the show matters in the wider scheme of things.

10. Less Treading Water With Mysteries

Did anybody really need to wait almost ten episodes to find out that Melinda May's origin involved her having to make some tough decisions and going through a rough time in combat? How about the secret identities of Skye's parents, who've been whispered about for almost the entire season, or Coulson's agonisingly stretched-out remembrance of his miraculous resurrection? Now, not all of these are necessarily bad storylines or unimportant to the characters in question (the latter two are crucial to Skye and Coulson's identities, in fact), but when you tease something for months at a time the reveal's bound to be a little disappointing if it's not a jaw-dropping paradigm shift for them. ABC should have learned this lesson long ago on Lost: delayed gratification rarely works unless you've got an ace up your sleeve, and most invested audiences would rather have character development occur gradually so they can grow with the leads rather than waiting for sudden alterations to happen that 'change everything'. We shouldn't be given the promise that the characters will be made more interesting in the future; they should just be as interesting as they can be right now.

9. More Concentration On Characters, Not Plot

The first half of AoS' first season - for the most part - didn't tell us a whole lot about the lead characters, other than that Coulson wouldn't give up on somebody even in the most dire circumstances but was willing to do what needed to be done in order to save the day (but we pretty much got the gist of that in Avengers already, right?). They got put through their paces in the latter half, but a great deal of that, especially during the last six episodes, was motivated by plot and not the characters themselves. It's clear to see what Marvel and ABC are trying to do with the show; they want something that uses the comic company's brand and image in a way that's familiar to people and tells stories that the largest demographic of people want to watch. But that's not the best thing they can make with it, and they've been trying to fit a square peg in a round hole. Superpowers are metaphors, and the best superhero stories are those that understand that. With Agents of SHIELD, Marvel has a chance to tell smaller stories about the people with (and without) powers in a universe populated by incredible beings, and just how terrifying and exciting that might be for them. If the show is to have any lasting impact on the television landscape then it needs to embrace its uniqueness and its weirdness and let its characters be the real focus of the story and the lens through which we view an ever-changing world, not the mission to take down some bland, nameless villain.

8. Have Better Villains

Now, as much as we all love Bill Paxton, it must be admitted that his Agent Garrett was a little uninspired when it comes to comic book villains. Yes, he was crucial to the show's plot following Captain America: The Winter Soldier and the reveal that S.H.I.E.L.D. was being controlled by HYDRA, but - some half-man, half-machine revelations and cosmic goop inspiring some rather insane outbursts aside - Garrett was more or less a guy with a gun and a pretty vanilla villainous agenda. The rest of the season's bad guys were much less memorable, either being flat archetypes like Coulson's Peruvian old flame-turned-traitor in "0-8-4" or the manipulative Asgardian the team goes up against later in the season. That's not even mentioning recurring baddie Ian Quinn, a corporate villain so bland even his hair seems bored of his lame threats and half-assed violence (seriously, the guy practically yawned when he gutshot Skye). What the series really needs is someone an audience can love to hate. The creators did a great job toward the end of the season in turning our ambivalence toward Ward into anger at his sudden (but inevitable) betrayal, and that kind of emotional involvement is dynamite for bad guys who might otherwise come off as one-dimensional. Someone who strikes fear into the characters and the audience would be great - if Melinda May doesn't know if she can take someone, then we know they're trouble. A continuous threat like the Big Bads from Angel and Buffy would work perfectly, as people would have time to get to know the villain almost as intimately as the heroes, and we all know: the worse a person you are, the more interesting you probably are too. Norman Osborn's role as the head of SHIELD replacement HAMMER would be a great arc from the comics to replicate, but if those rights are mixed up in Sony's Spider-Man movies there are still hundreds (if not thousands) of potential scumbags for ABC to pick from. Just make them fun, for Christ's sake, and don't waste any more Gravitons...

7. A Shorter, Tighter, Leaner Season

Hardly anyone who watched the entirety of the first season will tell you that they could really have done with another episode or two to flesh things out a bit more. Agents Of SHIELD isn't the kind of show to leave much to the imagination (except when it comes to ultimately disappointing teasers about Melinda May's past), being big and bright and hammering the audience over the head with exposition at every turn, and it's something of a fossil in today's TV environment in that it had a traditional full run of 22 episodes as opposed to the current standard of 13 (or even Game of Thrones' 10 or True Detective's 8). That's almost twice the number, and it left the season feeling bloated and trivial at times. When a series has a shorter run, the few episodes it does have tend to feel much more important than those shows that run for half the year or more. When that happens, overexposure sets in and many fans might take a series for granted because it's ALWAYS on. Marvel and ABC should probably try the HBO model - or, indeed, even their own Netflix/Defenders one - in keeping a season shorter and more tightly focused instead of trying for twenty-two done-in-one action-packed stories that they can easily repeat in any order they like. That might work for syndication, but a coherent television show it does not make. Some might suggest that having nine fewer episodes won't make the writing any better, but if the showrunners have a clear end in sight, they'll know exactly what story they want to tell and have a much better idea of how to tell it, and they'll make those episodes really count.

6. Develop A More Concrete Identity

As has been mentioned in other points in this article, Agents Of SHIELD has had something of an identity crisis in its (so far) short run, flip-flopping from investigative procedural to action-drama to superhero corporate espionage and back again over the course of several episodes. On their own, those elements aren't inherently negative, but when they're thrown together without any real cohesion in a television show that's still figuring out what it's good at the results can be kind of messy. In the last stretch of episodes, AoS did a standout job of having clear, consistent stories and themes that delivered on the promise of earlier episodes, and that's the show we should be watching every week when it returns. Whether it decides to incorporate more spy or fantastical elements, the writers and producers need to know what show Agents is trying to be before the audience is left to decide for themselves if that's the kind of show they want to watch.

5. Less Sidelining Of Coulson

This one's pretty self-explanatory: give Clark Gregg more to do. Like a lot more. Without a doubt the MVP of Marvel's flagship show (and, arguably, the glue that ties the whole cinematic universe together), Coulson is by no means wasted on the show, but he does sometimes get relegated to the backseat when he's often the emotional core of the team and thus best suited for each episode's biggest moments. The rest of the cast are obviously invaluable too, with each recurring character proving themselves a worthy addition to the team over the course of the season (and Grant Ward completely turning his arc around from least to most interesting character by season's end), but it's when they're fully integrated as a (dysfunctional) family with Coulson at the head that AoS really purrs. Take the last few episodes as a perfect example: when Phil Coulson cares deeply about something, even to the extent where he's making potentially bad decisions and the rest of the team have to fall in line or fight him on them we get some of the best drama the show's produced. There's not really any chance of Clark Gregg going anywhere anytime soon (unless Joss decides to off him again), but the producers really ought to know to use a great thing when they have it on the payroll.

4. More Reimaginings Of Ace Comic Characters

One of the best, most unexpected ideas that the show through out during its first season was the destruction of new superhero/Project Centipede casualty Mike Peterson and his resurrection as the cult comic killing machine Deathlok. His story became twisted in the best way - he doesn't want to do any harm, but he's forced to use the arsenal grafted to his body in order to keep himself and his son from coming to any harm - and brought some much-needed pathos and angst to a character that could easily have been a faceless killing machine. More of that, please. Marvel has many, many C- and D-list characters that have either been sidelined, misused or underused in the past that could easily be made over in their new TV universe. If not the big guns, why not bring in interesting supporting characters from the comics? Doc Samson, the superhero therapist is certainly one who could bring an entertaining dynamic to scenes between (former) SHIELD agents and their superpowered collars, to name but one. A fear might be that messing with original characters too much might ruffle some fan feathers. Marvel succeeded in radically altering the mythology of Thor from the comics for his movies, and if they can get away with that with A-list superheroes then they certainly shouldn't be afraid to mix things up and introduce some completely reimagined characters to the small screen that might not have worked so well if they were completely faithful to their original renderings. We're looking at you, Squirrel Girl.

3. A Bigger Budget So We Can Forget It's A TV Show

As much as Lola, Phil Coulson's flying convertible, is a fantastic idea and a symbol of exactly what the show should be most of the time - a crazy sci-fi procedural about super-spies with mad technology who get into mind-bending scrapes with super-terrorists, aliens and wizards -it's safe to say that most of the time we've seen it in action it's looked a bit naff, a complaint that can also be levelled at most of the bigger action/CG sequences in the show's first season. The fact is that ABC clearly want a Marvel mini-movie in every episode, but haven't given the producers nearly enough money to make that anything close to a real possibility. If the network wants to convince its audience that it's serious about making a series set in a world of capes and flying suits of armor then it either needs to make Agents of SHIELD a decidedly more low-key affair about the intricacies and hidden secrets of that world (which it probably won't) or give the show's makers enough money to convince everyone that these characters exist in the same universe that sees oil rigs, city blocks and even whole towns obliterated on a regular basis.

2. Come Out All Guns Blazing

By JJ Abrams' standards, the series opener was somewhat tame. There were a couple of minor explosions and a climactic stand-off between the newly-formed team and a power-crazy Mike Peterson, but other than that Joss Whedon was mostly just introducing the leads and setting up pieces for later use in the season. After that the show attempted a series of (mostly) standalone episodes that didn't require all that much knowledge of continuity or attention span from the audience, and as a result there was almost no momentum for the show until it picked up in bursts later on in the season. This resulted in great ratings for the pilot but a complete drop-off almost immediately after, because the audience had so little to hang onto. This time around, the producers have a much better chance of not making that same mistake because they don't have to explain so damn much to the audience. They should have also learned that AoS is far, far better when the characters have a constant mission that affects them all on a personal level (and when Clark Gregg gets to yell at people), so if they come out of the gate with three or four episodes dealing with a serious threat and putting the leads through the wringer they should have a much better chance at keeping our attention, only slowing down when the audience is truly invested in the story and characters once more.

1. Don't Rest On The MCU's Laurels

For all this talk of supporting proper integration into the Marvel Cinematic Universe and owning the fact that the show already has an enviable library of characters and stories to utilise as it pleases, there's a significant danger present in Agents leaning too much on that connection. Just as it needs to develop its own identity instead of aping other procedural (and Joss Whedon) series, Marvel risks alienating its more casual audience if every episode is a crossover with Guardians of the Galaxy or an introduction to a character from one of its Netflix shows. Let's be clear: all of that sounds tremendously awesome, but constantly relying on synergy between shared IP to keep a series popular could spell disaster if it means that the leads and season arc are regularly sidelined in favour of promoting the next Marvel movie or just showcasing a kick-ass cameo from Doctor Strange. It's a difficult balance to strike; how can Agents build and retain its own identity while also maintaining its collection to a larger world of movies that all have more or less the same tone? Hopefully the expansion of Marvel's TV empire will take some of the pressure off AoS in spreading the world-building across six shows and we won't get too many moments that namedrop Thor: The Dark World just to remind us that Coulson used to hang out with the Asgardian.