5 Darkest BoJack Horseman Theories

BoJack fans making theories! What do they know? Do they know things? Let’s find out!

By Stacey Henley /

BoJack Horseman is one of the darkest shows going, with central themes of depression, loneliness, and failure at its heart, and previous plot threads dealing with addiction, death, childhood abuse, statutory rape, and sexuality. However, seeing as it’s also one of the most layered and nuanced shows on television, it’s attracted a lot of speculation and fan theories.

Advertisement

This list isn’t dealing with Season 6, necessarily, although there is still room for some to come true and be explored in upcoming seasons. Mainly though, it’s taking a look at background details, foreshadowed hints and the general world building to offer an even deeper insight into what the lore might be.

Most shows have various theories, often involving the central character being dead or in a coma and imagining the whole thing. That particular one doesn’t feature here (though the tinfoil hatters could probably make a case for it), but it’s certainly true that BoJack pays more attention to the little details than most, so theories are to be expected.

With that in mind, while these theories are definitely dark, none of them are so outrageous that they fundamentally change the character arcs or storylines in order to make.

5. The Main Cast Represent The Stages Of Grief

This is more of a meta theory. Courtesy of Redditor u/hoodiesleeves, there’s some suggestion that that creator Raphael Bob-Waksberg had grief’s five stages in mind when designing his central cast.

Advertisement

The first stage of grief is denial, which fits Mr. Peanutbutter. He fails to ever address the seriousness of his brother’s illness, even when Diane talks to him about it directly. Season 5 also saw him finally realise that his parents hadn’t moved to a farm; they’d actually been dead for years. He’s in complete denial about the negatives in his life.

Second comes anger, which matches with Diane; although it’s possibly the most tenuous one. He doesn’t hulk out, but she certainly has a simmering, rage-against-the-machine sort of anger at the world.

Third is bargaining, which is literally what Princess Carolyn does for a living. She also keeps making and breaking promises to herself, and tries to grift Sadie somewhat while trying to adopt her baby.

Stage four is depression; obviously BoJack, no explanation needed.

The final stage is acceptance, which most fits Todd. He hardly even blinks when he accidentally gives away his fortune, and generally seems the happiest of the lot.

4. Mr Peanutbutter Is Manipulating Everyone

Occam’s Razor is the theory that simplest explanation is most likely to be correct; and in Mr. Peanutbutter’s case, that explanation is that he’s simply an idiot.

Advertisement

This theory by u/MorelMountainLady though posits that he’s not an idiot, but rather does almost everything deliberately and methodically to aid his career, destroy BoJack, or control the women he’s with. His first big break came when he strolled onto the set of Vincent D’Onofrio’s show, seemingly unaware of the audience, crew and set, and just began vamping. His peppy attitude was the perfect antidote to D’Onofrio’s sour approach, and he’s hired on the spot.

With BoJack, there’s too many annoyances to count. The biggest ones are his decision to question BoJack as to why he kissed Diane on live TV, then getting himself cast in Philbert and stealing BoJack’s limelight. It’s not beyond possibilities that he’s deliberately trying to sabotage BoJack at every turn.

As for his girlfriends, he constantly dates younger women, either naive or idealistic; easy fodder for manipulation. Diane’s Belle room/ball room are great examples, as are the fact he tells Pickles he still has feelings for Diane, then proposes to her despite not being in love with her.

3. Hollyhock Is Mentally Ill

In a way, fans already know this is true; she talks to BoJack about hearing voices telling her she’s worthless, where BoJack offers her the comforting lie that things will get better.

Advertisement

If we take BoJack as the example though, things only get worse. Season 4’s Stupid Piece Of Sh*t showed just how insidious and invasive this voice is in his daily life, and this could be bad news for Hollyhock. Their father, Butterscotch, was hardly the picture of mental health either.

Her overdose in the fourth season was a result of Bea slipping her too much weight loss medication, but her reaction upon returning back to BoJack’s house is worrying. Her trauma is understandable, but that doesn’t change the fact it’s evidence of a mental break.

Hollyhock flips out and throws BoJack’s own pills down the garbage disposal, with the animation distorting in ways similar to BoJack’s own mental episodes.

We don’t see all that much of her in Season 5, what with her having moved away, but things might not be as rosy as they seem. Characters never stay happy for long in BoJack, and it may well be that Hollyhock’s mental health has gotten significantly worse while she’s been away.

2. Sarah Lynn Was Molested By Her Step-Father

Often when childhood stars go off the rails, there’s some sort of dark underbelly to it. Bella Thorne and Amanda Bynes, both stars with varying degrees of parallels to Sarah Lynn, have each come forward to talk about the abuse they were put through in adolescence.

Advertisement

It’s likely to never be explored in the show now, but still worth looking over. The basis for this theory, hypothesised by various fans, other than the general stereotype, are two throwaway lines said by Sarah Lynn in Herb’s garage.

She says that her mom’s boyfriend homeschools her, and that he’s a photographer; neither of these things are particularly creepy on their own, but they do build up the picture.

Soon afterwards, she’s able to identify bear fur just by taste; considering her stepdad is a bear, this suggests she’s used to kissing (or worse) her stepfather. The offhand nature of these remarks, the lack of a punchline for a show so laden with jokes and her mother’s clear lack of care for her... it certainly makes for grim thinking.

Given BoJack’s frequent use of pop culture jokes, her dad might even be a reference to the mid-00s meme, Pedobear.

1. Diane Will Die In A Car Crash

This is the only prediction of sorts on the list (though arguably both Mr. Peanutbutter’s manipulation and Hollyhock’s illness could still come to light), but considering how often the show has used foreshadowing previously, it’s definitely worth exploring.

Advertisement

The only crucial piece of evidence here is that Diane is nicknamed ‘Princess Diana’ when her therapist gives her and BoJack fake names to protect their identity when telling their stories to her wives. This may well prove to be the ‘don’t choke any women’ moment fans look back on if things pan out as predicted.

Diana famously died in a car crash in a tunnel, and the season ends with Diane driving into a tunnel before the cut to black. Even with all this though, a spin-off of the theory by u/Magik_boi gets darker; it won’t be an accident, but a suicide attempt.

Strangely for a show so concerned with background continuity, Diane never unpacks her boxes in her new apartment; maybe she’s been planning this for a while. She rejects getting back together with Mr. Peanutbutter, she leaves Philbert and still feels unfulfilled, and after dropping BoJack off at rehab, the anxiety hinted at in her character might become too much for her.

What are your favourite BoJack theories? Let us know down in the comments.

Advertisement