5 Fox TV Shows That Were Cancelled Far Too Soon

By Ian Coomber /

As much as people love them, TV shows eventually get cancelled. Whether they have told the story they want to tell, are cut down before their prime, or even on occasion mercifully put out of their misery, all shows must come to an end. There will even come a time when The Simpsons will call it a day. At a record 24 seasons (although I reckon 25 is a nice round number) animation's longest running series is unprecedented not just in its general success, but that it has survived so long on a network that has gained a reputation for its cancellation policy. Seeming to take the idea of audience quantity over quality all too literally, much loved shows that were adored by smaller audiences were often cut down on the basis of mere numbers. This has led to FOX being something that many are wary of. After their all to brief time producing Firefly (too obvious for the main list, but I had to mention it somewhere), Joss Whedon and co.'s next offering, Dollhouse, suffered from rushed storytelling in a desperate bid to race against the axe they knew was coming. More than just those aired on the FOX network, the sister company 20th Century Fox television also produced a number of series for other networks which, you guessed it, were cancelled long before they should have been. Although there are those which came back to TV screen thanks to DVD sales showing FOX that the quantity of audience was there all along, Family Guy and Futurama being great examples, most are simply cut down with no remorse, never to see the light of day again. Here is a list of five shows that belong to the Fox family whose potential went (largely) untapped.

5. Lie To Me

Starring Tim Roth as deception expert Dr. Cal Lightman, Lie To Me was a detective series with more than one difference. Firstly, the main characters weren't police officers or lawyers but psychologists. Although Mekhi Phifer appeared in season 2 FBI agent Reynolds, he was remarkably absent without much to explain why, other than the fact the show worked better without him. Focusing on the Lightman Group's ability to detect people's lies and what they were feeling, the show utilised science to a degree that is not seen in very many shows. Unlike the "science" depicted in C.S.I. and its clones, Lie To Me used actual proven research and techniques which come courtesy of Dr. Paul Ekman. A psychologist who has studied the universality of microexpressions in some of the worlds most remote tribes, and has co-written the book Emotional Awareness with the Dalai Lama, he also acted as an adviser working closely with the show's producers. Although arguments that the episodes were too formulaic do have some merit - different leads would often take Lightman and his team in different directions until the truth is finally revealed - something hardly unique to Lie To Me. In fact the same could be said of medical investigation series House, and it hardly caused that show to be cancelled too soon. Formula or not however, the biggest draw to the series was its characters. Although each was unique, it was Roth himself as Lightman that was the most intriguing. As a man whose talent has become his curse, he is unable to not read the faces of those around him, something which doesn't always have the best consequences for how he deals with those he cares about, teenage daughter notwithstanding. He has a business partner he desperately wants to help but can't, a protegee with a natural talent he envies, and then of course there's Loker. Not content with just refusing to lie, his concept of 'radical honesty' has him blurting out whatever truth is on his mind, whether people want to hear them or not.

4. Angel

Although Firefly would be the obvious show from Joss Whedon to be on this list, there does come a time when you have let things go. It was ten years ago, most of us have moved on. One year later however, FOX cancelled the Buffy The Vampire Slayer spin-off Angel, which in many ways is much more of a crime. Although Angel ran for five seasons, four and half more than its sci-fi western cousin, allow me to explain. Unlike Firefly, the network (and audiences) not only knew what they had on their hands, but season five was arguably the strongest of the whole show. As Whedon himself rightly articulated, it was akin to a "healthy guy falling dead from a heart attack." Not only did the take over of the antagonistic Wolfram & Hart law firm gave the show a fresh spin, the Angel/Spike double act was a great regular addition, episodes such as Smile Time showed how ridiculous concepts could be brilliantly realised, and the Wesley/Fred romance took a heart-wrenching turn. While there are those that argue it ended on a high (which it undoubtedly did), considering this all came after the rather dreary season 4, just imagine what season 6 could have been. Even though the various fabled ratings systems showed how well Angel was doing, someone made the decision that it would come to an end. Luckily Whedon and co. were given enough warning to tie up loose ends though, and Not Fade Away made sure that the series didn't. One reason given for its unfathomable fate is the WB's move towards more reality TV, but all those angered at such an idea can take heed in the fact that the WB no longer exists as television network. Although it has been reported that the executive who made the final decision didn't stay with the network much longer than Angel did, his dismissal wasn't able to bring TV's most loved Vampire back from the beyond.

3. Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Despite having big budget effects and being shown on massive cinema screens, films are often only second place to TV when it comes to story telling. This is nothing to be ashamed of however, just a byproduct of the smaller amount of screen time they are given. On the plus side though, when some of Hollywood's best loved films are given a spin-off TV series, they have the potential to be truly epic. Potential that The Sarah Connor Chronicles only began to utilise. Originally produced between the cinematic release of Rise of the Machines and Salvation, The Sarah Connor Chronicles actually followed on from Judgement Day instead (as the series would explain, there are a whole number of different futures), and managed something that neither of the James Cameron-less sequels could, which is tell a captivating story about family. I guess this should be pretty obvious from the title, The Sarah Connor Chronicles, and Lena Headey does a stellar job taking over from Linda Hamilton as the mother of humanity's survival, Thomas Dekker who plays a more subdued but equally headstrong John, than T2's Edward Furlong. They are joined by the newly introduced Derek Reese (Kyle's brother and John's uncle), but it is Summer Glau who truly steals the show. Utilising James Cameron's original idea that Terminators should be infiltrators capable of blending in, over the show's two seasons we saw Glau's Cameron develop through her interactions with the Connors (or Baums as they are known to those they are hiding from, taking the name of Wizard of Oz author L. Frank). Whether it be socially when protecting John at school or learning the nuance of dance, Glau's unique model of Terminator often blurred the boundaries between cyborg and human, and the gradual exploration of robotics and emotions was just one particular aspect of the show that deserved far more attention than it would be given.

2. The Lone Gunmen

Fan favourites ever since their first appearance in season one's E.B.E., The Lone Gunmen appeared sporadically throughout The X-Files. They were even given their own episodes in Unusual Suspects and Three Of A Kind, but it wasn't until the show's Eighth season that they would have their own spin-off, coming just a tad too late. Interest in The X-Files had started to wane by this point, and David Duchovny leaving the series didn't help much either. If The Lone Gunmen had been produced just one season earlier, there would have been a bigger audience willing to watch it. This would arguably have allowed its parent show to bow out gracefully while it took over. Instead The Lone Gunmen had only one season, while The X-Files went on too long. The Lone Gunmen was a perfect successor in so many ways; it continued the conspiracy theory elements The X-Files was so famous for, but gave them enough of a fresh twist by focusing on the technological rather than supernatural. Not that these mysteries were all so entrenched in hacking so as to alienate the average viewer, cases involved proving the innocence of a death row inmate, discovering how a Children's TV show was being used to transmit secrets to China, and even helping an intelligent Chimp from escaping a research facility. Ok, so maybe a bit more different than The X-Files than I may have originally implied, but it was nonetheless still entertaining in its own right, and Three Men And A Smoking Diaper managed to mix baby humour and genuine political commentary in a way that is much needed on our TV screens.

1. Over There

Broadcast in 2005, Over There followed a US army unit during a tour of Iraq. Despite the obvious similarities to the likes of Band of Brothers and The Pacific, it was largely a fictional series but focused on a lot of real life issues that soldiers have to deal with. Mixing this level of seriousness with good humour though, one of the most thought provoking series of the past ten years also had an episode called I Want My Toilets. As the only US TV series to be set during a war still ongoing during its broadcast (although M*A*S*H is obviously written about Vietnam, it had to be set in Korea to get past the censors) it is unsurprising the series was cancelled, but you have to give it credit for not only trying, but also the 13 episodes that were produced. Perhaps the biggest difference to similar military series is the inclusion of the families back home, and the rehabilitating Private Bo Rider after he loses his leg in an IED explosion. Although the alcoholic adulterer going to rehab storyline of Private "Dim" Dumphy's wife has the tendency to become soap opera at times, the emasculation of Sergio being the only husband in a support group full of wives and mothers is a great exploration that it is more than just those who sign up whose lives are affected by the military. Despite the obvious potential, the series never seems to take sides in the hugely political argument of whether we should have been in Iraq in the first place, but instead focuses on the predicaments faced by the soldiers caught in the middle, something particularly emphasised in Situation Normal. When ordered to protect an American construction crew working near a small Iraqi town, Dim is unable to just stand by and watch as a small child struggles to carry a simple pale of water back to his home. His efforts to help the boy and his mother, alongside the construction contractor's (Breaking Bad's Dean Norris) assertion of democracy on the townspeople, eventually results in a the mother being ostracised and the unit having to leave knowing that when they are gone she will most likely be stoned to death. Doing all it can not to fan the flames of Islamaphobia, Over There does remind people that Iraq and the middle east is a different culture to the western world, and ideals such as democracy can only work if they have been developed over time rather than thrust upon people not ready for it. It is aspects like this that give you the sense that the producers knew they were on a knife edge from the start, and so just included everything they could, idealistic journalists, going AWOL, and even friendly fire, before receiving their discharge papers.