It's been more than seven years since The Sopranos ended with one of the most polarizing final scenes in television history. Since "Don't Stop Believin'" blasted through the speakers of nearly 12 million television sets on June 10, 2007, everybody has been asking the question: just what exactly happened? Here's what we know about the scene. Tony Soprano walks into Holstein's diner and looks at the jukebox. He selects Journey and looks around the diner at the patrons. Of particular interest is a man sitting by himself at the bar. As the song continues to play, Tony's wife Carmella and his son AJ enter the diner. They converse, and the man at the bar gets up and walks to the bathroom. As this is happening, Tony's daughter Meadow is outside the diner, trying to parallel park but failing twice. She finally succeeds on the third time, and as she enters the diner, Tony looks up, and the screen immediately cuts to black. So...what happened? Did Tony Soprano die or not? For years, show creator David Chase has been mum on details...apparently until now. That famous scene has recently made headlines again when Chase answered a direct question posed to him about Tony Soprano's fate. The article says: "When he (Chase) answered the 'Did Tony die' question, he was laconic. Just the fact and no interpretation. He shook his head and said, 'No, he isn't'. That was all. First off, it was bad journalism to not ask a followup question considering the fact that Chase had finally given a direct answer after years of dodging the question. Secondly, there was no true context to Chase's demeanor. "Laconic" doesn't really tell us much. Did he seem sarcastic? Annoyed? Frustrated? It was very naive of the writer to assume that what Chase told her was the absolute truth. Chase quickly responded to the article in question and offered a non-committal denial. So the debate rages on. But there really should be no debate. Anybody who was paying attention to the final scene really knows the truth: Tony Soprano is dead. The final scene has been broken down in painstaking detail (almost frame by frame) in this fantastic Master of Sopranos essay. It is an extremely long, but worthwhile read that does a great job of making the argument that Tony died in the final scene. Many of the reasons in the essay are theoretical, and many parts are guesses or connecting dots that may not have been meant to be connected. However, when looking at the final scene itself, as well as the hints dropped by Chase throughout the final season, there were five main arguments that should convince you beyond the shadow of a doubt that Tony Soprano was killed in Holstein's in front of his family.
5. The Man In The Members Only Jacket
David Chase gave a lot of attention to the Man in the Members Only Jacket, sitting at the counter during the majority of the scene. He is the only person other than Tony's family who is shown entering the diner. He is shown looking over at Tony at various points during the scene. The camera follows him as he gets up and walks to the bathroom. David Chase wanted us to recognize this man's presence. But why? Because he was the man who murdered Tony Soprano. When the cast of the patrons in the diner was listed in the credits, there were names like Truck Driver in Diner, Old Woman in Diner, Old Man in Diner, etc. However, one credit sticks out as interesting. Its listed as Man in Members Only Jacket. Of all the extras, he got a callout and was the only credit not to have his title end in diner. This was a deliberate decision, and has a tie-in to the very first episode of the season, appropriately titled Members Only. In the first episode, one of Tonys lieutenants, Eugene Pontecorvo (who wears a Members Only jacket) receives as $2 million inheritance and wants to quit the mafia, but Tony wont let him, and Eugene hangs himself by the end of the episode. But before Eugene commits suicide, Tony orders him to kill a man named Teddy Spiradokis (whose initials are T.S.). Eugene shoots Teddy and kills him in a diner, similar to how Tony ends up dying. The Man in the Members Only jacket in the final scene also looks like Eugene. The fact that David Chase cast an extra without a speaking role as Man in Members Only Jacket when no other extra in the diner got any kind of special designation is a clue that this man is important. Namely, he is the man who killed Tony Soprano. So, we have our man. Do we have our method?
4. The Godfather
One of the most memorable scenes in the movie The Godfather involves Michael Corleone (played by a young Al Pacino) avenging two assassination attempts on his father, Don Corleone, by agreeing to murder Virgil Sollazzo (who ordered the first attempt) and Police Captain McCluskey (who pulled his police forces away from the hospital where Don Corleone was recuperating for the second attempt). Michael makes an agreement to meet Sollazzo and McCluskey at a restaurant for dinner under the false pretenses of settling the dispute between Sollazzo and his father. Knowing hed be searched for weapons, Michael has one of his associates hide a handgun behind a bathroom stall. Michael excuses himself during dinner and goes to the bathroom. He retrieves the gun, then returns and shoots both men.There are a number of Godfather references throughout The Sopranos (remember Silvio repeating Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in in the second episodes cold open?), and it was obvious that the film had a big influence on David Chase. Thats why he used the movies most pivotal scene as his muse for his seriess most pivotal scene. If you think of the ending of The Sopranos like a game of Clue, we had the culprit, now we have a weapon and a location. It was Man in Members Only Jacket in the Bathroom with the Handgun!
3. Meadows Parallel Parking
One of the big focuses of the final scene is Meadow Soprano, Tonys daughter, trying and failing to parallel park her car. Considering how strange the cut to black was, viewers may have forgotten how strange it was that in the final 30 seconds of one of the greatest TV shows of all time, the audience is watching Meadow Soprano trying to park her car. The question that can be drawn from Meadows final scenes is: What are we supposed to get out of watching this? If we subscribe to the (correct) theory that the Man in the Members Only Jacket killed Tony coming out of the bathroom, then Meadows parallel parking may have been able to save her fathers life. As the diner table is laid out, Tony is sitting alone with Carmella and AJ across from him. When Meadow gets into the diner, she would obviously sit next to her father. What this creates is a block in the line of sight for the Man in the Members Only Jacket. Without Meadow, he has a clear shot at Tony from the bathroom. Meadows presence is so important because of something Tony told Carmella in the previous episode, The Blue Comet, just after Bobby Bacala was murdered. In an attempt to calm her, he said, Families dont get touched, meaning that there is an inherent code in the mafia to not go after family members. Now, theres no guarantee that had Meadow sat down that the Man in the Members Only Jacket wouldnt have shot her before trying to shoot Tony, but since Meadow didnt make it into Holsteins in time, we will never know.
2. Tonys Point Of View
Many shots in the final scene (as well as throughout the course of the series) were shown from Tony Sopranos point of view. When AJ, Carmella and the Man in the Members Only jacket enter the scene, theyre all filmed from the same location. The camera would be placed exactly where Tony would be looking. And each entrance shot was shown after Tony picked his head up to see who was coming in. Therefore, the audience is seeing everybodys entrance through Tonys eyes. Now, lets go back to Meadow entering Holsteins. The final shot of the series has Tony looking up to see who is coming in, as evidenced by the bell ringing when the door opened. Now, when it aired live, many viewers swore up and down that they saw Meadow enter the diner. But they didnt. They just expected to, because thats what Tony was expecting. The cut to black, which replaced the shot of Meadow entering the diner as Carmella and AJ did, was also shown from Tonys point of view. Its just that he was already dead, so thats why there was blackness. There was also a longer delay than usual between the cut to black and the credits rolling in silence, long enough that many viewers thought that their cable had gone out on them. Those extra seconds of blackness represented the nothingness of death, which we as the audience were experiencing from Tonys point of view. So when people had the theory of, the ending was David Chase whacking the audience, theyre actually right in a sense. Only the audience was experiencing the whack from Tonys point of view. And theres a very good reason why we as the audience, through Tonys point of view, didnt hear any kind of gunshot before the darkness.
1. You Probably Dont Even Hear It When It Happens, Right?
If David Chase can be credited for anything, its how every detail in his programming matters. There was a specific line that was referred to three times in the final season. It was uttered by Bobby Bacala to Tony in the episode Sopranos Home Movies. When Tony talks about how most mob bosses either end up dead or in jail, Bobby says, You probably dont even hear it when it happens, right? referring to being killed. This theme of not hearing it when it happens resurfaces twice throughout the final season. In the episode Stage 5, Silvio Dante is having dinner with Gerry Torciano when Gerry is murdered at the table. The gunshot happens while the camera is focused on Silvio, and Silvio doesnt even notice theres a gunshot until blood is splattered on his face. The sound cuts off, and only a low-volume ringing is heard (like you were wearing headphones and listening to music too loud). Its a good two seconds before Silvio even realizes what is going on. Silvio tells Tony later, scary thing was I didnt know what happened until after the shot was fired. Finally, the dont even hear it when it happens, line comes up one more time in The Blue Comet as Tony reminisces about Bobby after Bobby was murdered. David Chase brought this theme of not hearing death coming up three times during the season to prepare the viewer for not hearing death coming for Tony in the final scene.Those five pieces of evidence should be definitive enough to convince anybody that Tony Soprano was shot and killed by the Man in the Members Only Jacket in Holsteins. If anybody chooses to accept any other scenario, it renders the final scene nonsensical and open for ridicule. David Chases big mistake was overestimating the ability of the viewing audience to think beyond what's in front of their face, as well as underestimating their bloodlust and desire to see Tonys brains splattered all over Holsteins. Chase, as he was wont to do over the course of the series, decided to go cerebral with the ending of his series by wanting the viewers to feel Tonys death rather than see it. And because the ending required people to think rather than to take what was in front of them at face value, hes been forced to have to answer questions about the final scene for seven years now. Unfortunately for us, Chase refuses to compromise his artistic integrity by explaining the scene himself. Thats why it seems that his comment in the Vox article was sarcastic and made out of frustration, but the author of the article chose to take it literally, and now a wonderful website like Master of Sopranos is being bombarded with emails requesting that the site be taken down. No matter what David Chase says in the media, these pieces of evidence put together are convincing enough that Tony Soprano is dead.