Of all the major franchises driven into the ground by increasingly awful instalments, Psycho must be among the worst offenders. Between abysmal sequels, unwatchable remakes and just plain weird attempts at TV spin offs, its a testament to the strength of the original film that it still commands the respect it does. Now halfway through its first season (and renewed for a second), A&Es sort of Psycho prequel Bates Motel is an interesting piece of television. I will be the first to admit that its flawed; the dialogue is occasionally pretty awful, it has multiple plot holes and sometimes the motivations of the characters just fail to make any sense. Yet somehow, its still compelling viewing. Ive been trying to figure out what it is about Bates Motel that makes it so exciting, and, after many sleepless nights and tortured days, Ive boiled it down to five core aspects that sum up why anybody who is a fan of Psycho or just horror/suspense in general should be watching this show.
5. Fear
You might be thinking that this one should be a given. After all, anything even vaguely linked with the original Psycho has an obligation toward being scary. But stop for a moment and think about just how many TV series are genuinely terrifying on the same level as a horror film. Dexter is more concerned with pretending to be existentialist and dragging out its plot than making the most of its dark subject matter. American Horror Story seems to verge on camp weirdness more than genuine fear. Maybe TV as a medium just doesnt lend itself all that well to horror, but Bates Motel is doing exceptionally well on this front. The brilliance of it is that all the creepiness comes from the characters and how unpredictable they are. By episode four we already know that Norman Bates is deeply disturbed; he imagines his mother Norma telling him to do things and, in a moment of pure rage, attempts to murder his brother with a meat tenderizer. As an audience we know that this story will inevitably end with Norma, mummified in the basement while her son dresses in her clothes and murders young women. The suspense, however, comes from the fact that there are many other sympathetic characters introduced on the sidelines, and not a single one of them is present in the original Psycho. This, obviously, does not bode well for their fate. Then we have the many scenes that will leave you on the edge of your seat. In the pilot episode alone Norman and his mother meticulously clean up a crime scene, only to have the police arrive halfway through. The body is hidden in the bathroom by a shower curtain; the same bathroom where one of the police goes to take a leak. The whole scene is shot so slowly and carefully, with perfect balance between the cop casually going into the bathroom and the reactions shots of Norman and Norma. I hate to say it, but its very, very Hitchcockian. And so it should be.
4. The Town
In producing a prequel (or whatever they want to call it) to Psycho, it would be very easy to just make a by the numbers origin story for Norman Bates. But in a very smart move, show runners Carlton Cuse and Kerry Ehrin have added a new element that was never present in any of the original films; that of a small town and its ugly secrets. Between the gigantic marijuana plantation owned by rich businessmen and the Asian sex trafficking ring, along with all the unnervingly creepy townsfolk, White Pine Bay begins to feel almost as dangerous and surreal as Twin Peaks. In fact, the influence of that earlier show is evident all over Bates Motel, and it works brilliantly. Part of the strength of the setting is how perfectly the town mirrors Norman himself. Its an unassuming, quiet seeming place with a very dark, very ugly underbelly. The town manages to be both a powerful metaphor AND a compelling part of the overall story arc, ensuring that the subplots based around it never feel out of place or like a waste of time. Which leads me to
3. The Plot
By now it should be obvious that there is a lot more to the plot of Bates Motel than the story of how Norman Bates went crazy. In fact, take the relationship to Psycho out of the picture and you have a pretty strong premise for a show already. An emotionally fragile boy and his unstable mother buy a motel in a small town populated by criminals and psychopaths. Within days of their arrival they are forced to cover up a murder and in their attempts to escape police attention they unwittingly become more and more drawn in to the dark secrets of their new home. Doesnt sound too terrible, does it? And that isnt even touching on the real overarching story, that of how the boy is driven to murder and insanity. What is clever about the writing is how nothing feels disconnected or unnecessary. Every subplot is effectively woven in with the others, creating a complex and intoxicating tapestry of intriguing story strands. The show goes to great pains to illustrate the toll that all of this is taking on Norman, and particularly on his relationship with his mother, which was not exactly healthy to begin with. Add to this his delinquent half-brother Dylan, a very interesting addition to the mythology clearly conceived as a counterpoint to Normas domineering nature. Dylan offers a different path for Norman and, despite how unpleasant and messed up he obviously is, he seems to be the only character who cares for Norman unconditionally. If I was to hazard a guess as to where this series will end up, it will be with Norman having to choose between his mother and brother. Dylans days are almost certainly numbered, but I for one cannot wait to see how that comes about. This is the kind of show where you become desperate to see what happens, which is bizarre for a story where the endgame has been public knowledge since 1960. But again, it just goes to show how well constructed this series is.
2. The Performances
There is a scene in the original Psycho which is probably one of the most well written scenes in movie history. Marion Crane, tired from her long journey and still conflicted about the money she stole from her boss, unwittingly pulls into the Bates Motel. She is greeted by the friendly but slightly awkward Norman Bates, who invites her into his parlour for some dinner. They bond and there is the suggestion of a potentially deep connection. Then talk turns to Normans mother and it becomes clear how unhappy he is. Marion gently suggests that he puts her someplace, meaning an asylum, and his offended reaction is the first hint that there is something very wrong with him. Every line Anthony Perkins delivers in this scene is infused with menace, but it is so brilliantly underplayed; his body is rigid, his face almost impassive with slight twitches being the only hint at how furious he is. Everything about this moment screams repression. Norman cannot outwardly express emotions well at all, and Perkins absolutely perfect performance makes this very clear. It is a classic scene in a classic film and the reason Im bringing it up is that in Bates Motel there was one moment when I sat up and said out loud; holy crap, this IS Norman Bates. It is during a scene where Norman becomes angry with his new friend/love interest Emma and his reaction evokes Perkins brilliantly without mimicking him. Its all there; the rigid body, the rage in his voice, the slight tremor as he tries to keep under control. It is something small that is just so utterly Norman and I was thrilled when I realized how well Highmore understood it. His Norman is likable and sympathetic but simultaneously creepy and sometimes terrifying. Then there are the other major players; Vera Farmiga plays Norma with so much understated manipulation and malice. Her reaction in the opening episode when Norman asks her to sign a permission form for him to join the track team immediately says so much about both her and her son. She reacts with exasperation and disappointment, and it becomes immediately evident how controlling she really is, making Norman feel guilty for wanting to have a life outside her. Likewise when she first meets Emma, who suffers from cystic fibrosis. Within moments she sweetly asks what the poor girls life expectancy is, right in front of a disbelieving Norman. She is a dangerous, vicious woman and her evolution into the shrieking voice heard in Psycho is not much of a stretch to imagine. An actor who wont be under nearly as much scrutiny but is also doing sterling work is Max Thieriot as Normans half-brother Dylan. Introduced in the second episode as Normas son from an earlier relationship, Dylan is an angry, snide character unafraid to turn to crime to support himself. Thieriot plays him as a hurt, damaged man who clearly has a lot of resentment toward his mother. His scenes with Norman are uniformly excellent, as we see their relationship turn from mutual dislike to something closer to brotherly love. Dylan may have been initially telegraphed as an antagonist, but in the space of a few episodes he has become one of the most sympathetic characters in the series, along with Norman himself. That is in no small part due to the strength of Thieriots performance.
1. It Feels Like Psycho
It might have become a little bit obvious over the course of this piece just how in love with Psycho I am. I wont lie; its one of my all-time favourite movies, so yeah, Im bound to be a little bit biased. But its also a universally recognized classic and for good reason. Its tightly written, brilliantly acted and highly atmospheric suspense thriller full of shocking twists. There is a particular tone to Psycho that is a huge part of its genius. From the opening frames the feeling of dread hangs over the whole film, the knowledge that we are going to head into some bleak territory. Its there in the shriek of the violins, the invasive camera, the determined yet terrified look on Marion Cranes face. It is a tone that does not let up for the rest of the film; in fact, if anything it becomes worse as we enter the gothic nightmare of the Bates Motel and its deadly owner. Even with its questionable relationship to Psycho, Bates Motel has managed to capture the feeling of the original film. While it does not use any of the music from that film, the scoring is similar. As Norman approaches the house of a dangerous police deputy to uncover his secrets, the violins start in the background. The camera is tight on his face, and we, as an audience, are on the edge of our seat. Then theres the cinematography; just slightly bathed in shadows with muted colours suggesting age. Even with the modern setting, the costumes and cars seem like theyre from the 50s. Bates Motel may not be canonically linked with Psycho, but it is packed full of references and tributes. These work because the series is committed to doing its own thing. It does not slavishly adhere to the template set down by the original, and, ironically, this has freed it up enough to capture the elusive spirit of Hitchcocks classic in a way few of the sequels ever came close to. Nothing about Bates Motel should have worked. And yet, against the odds, it has been a success, both as part of the Psycho series and as its own piece of television drama. I for one cannot wait to see where this series goes. And if youre still not interested in jumping on board, well, youre the one missing out.