5 TV Couples That Elevated Shows (And 5 That Ruined It)
Love always wins, but at what cost?
We all love a good old-fashioned love story, especially when it plays out on a TV series. The idea of watching two people connect on an emotional level while the world around them fades into the background is one that has enticed viewers for years. Thus, in a television landscape overflowing with an array of genres, it's no surprise that love is the one thing that they all have in common.
Over the years, we have seen countless iconic couples dominate their respective TV show, reeling viewers in with their passion while enhancing the narrative that said show is telling. And in today's era of 'shipping', some fans even watch a show just to see their beloved couple while remaining indifferent to everything else.
However, not all couples are beneficial for a TV series, as the love trope can be used as a last-ditch attempt to interest viewers in characters who just aren't all that interesting on their own or to force conflict where there is no chemistry. And sometimes, bad couples can end up becoming bigger than their own show which, of course, should never be the intention.
With that in mind, let's take a look back at some of television's most revolutionary couples and reflect on how they ended up making their own show a better place, while also setting aside some time to look at those that destroyed their show altogether.
Couples That Elevated Their Show...
5. Mike & Eleven - Stranger Things
Netflix's Stranger Things is a triumph in just about every way possible, so it's understandable if you read this and laugh because it never needed to rely on a couple. And you'd be right: it doesn't need a couple to elevate it - it just needs Mike and Eleven, because whether they are together or apart, they are the heart of the show.
El may be the hero of Stranger Things but, as each season reminds us, she is still learning about human interaction, and the fact of the matter is that she wouldn't have gotten as far as she has without Mike in her life. However, on the other hand, Mike wouldn't be the heroic and selfless hero he is today without knowing her.
Two sides of the same coin, these kids learned a lot about themselves as they grew up in each other's company. Mike taught El the importance of communicating with people and, in the process, taught himself that very same lesson as, for the first time in his life, he fell in love.
Unlike a lot of the couples on this, the endearing relationship between Mike and El never overshadowed the show itself. It's always been there, playing a supporting role to the supernatural narrative because it is one of the foundations on which said supernatural narrative (and the show in general) is built. It's far more integral to the story than you would think and, without it, Stranger Things just wouldn't work.
4. Betty & Jughead - Riverdale
The relationship between Betty Cooper and Jughead Jones on The CW's Riverdale quite literally came out of nowhere. One moment, the pair were investigating the murder of Jason Blossom, and the next, the normally reserved Jughead (who didn't get attached to much), placed a passionate kiss on his fellow detective's lips. And that right there might be what makes this relationship so enticing.
In the beginning, it seemed like the writers were going to venture down the typical love triangle route, with Betty facing-off against newcomer Veronica for the affections of Archie Andrews, but upon reflection, it's clear that would have been a bland and predictable storyline that would have offered nothing of value to the show.
Betty and Jughead are easily the show's two most interesting characters so the idea of pairing them together was genius. In a town full of generic caricatures, they are the outsiders, so to speak - the ones that aren't afraid to venture into darker territory to get the answers everyone so desperately craves. Two sides of the same scarred coin, they always have each other's backs and know that their love for each other will guide them through the darkest of discoveries.
Look, we get it, Riverdale isn't the most coherent show in TV history. Heck, it's not even the most coherent show on The CW. But the fact of the matter is that when Jughead and Betty are on-screen together, it's hard to look away.
A luscious silver lining, Bughead remains Riverdale's ace in the hole.
3. Ari & Temo - Mi Marido Tiene Familia
Mexican TV series Mi Marido Tiene Familia decided to switch things up in its second season by delving deeper into one of its supporting characters - and it was that decision that turned the show into the global phenomenon - as the introduction of newcomer Cuauhtémoc López resulted in regular Aristóteles Córcega learning new things about himself.
Ari and Temo grew incredibly close as friends before the latter confessed his love during a night out. While this prompted Ari, a social influencer, to publicly announce his support for Temo's brave decision to come out (despite much of his own family's opposition), he told him that he didn't feel the same way. However, he soon began to realise that this wasn't necessarily the case.
Throughout the season, the pair found their way to each other's hearts, as they embarked on personal journeys of self-discovery and, in the process, kick-started similar journeys for some of their own family members. The narrative stood out among the show's other storylines, as it was both compelling and educational - and yet it managed to be so in a completely natural way.
While Mi Marido Tiene Familia was always about family, the creative decision to primarily focus on a same-sex couple in Season 2 started conversations in a way that the show had never done before. As a result, 'Aristemo' took the world by storm as the show attracted a global following and even won a GLAAD award. The pair would then go on to headline their own spin-off series.
2. Oliver & Laurel - Arrow
Fans of Arrow will know that there were two sides to Oliver Queen's personality. One was the self-obsessed playboy who knew how to love but was too afraid of it to commit to any one person, while the other was an emotionless and troubled (but good-hearted) vigilante that would stop at nothing to survive and/or save his city. Two completely different versions of the same person, but they shared one similarity - they both refused to let anyone in. The one person, however, that got through to both of these Olivers was Laurel Lance.
Oliver's first love, Laurel was always meant to be the love of his life and, thanks to the fantastic on-screen chemistry between Stephen Amell and Katie Cassidy, it was clear to see how much they meant to each other - even when they didn't want to admit it.
The show's first season expertly told the story of how one deeply troubled man longed to get back to the woman he loved, as it was the thought of reuniting with Laurel that kept him alive during his hellish experience on Lian Yu. And when he returned, these two scarred souls had to find a way to overcome their emotional obstacles so that they could fall in love all over again.
With strong use of foreshadowing, impressive writing and convincing performances, Oliver and Laurel's history in the show (and the comics) set the stage for a compelling on-screen relationship - one that enhanced the show's debut offering.
Unfortunately it was all downhill from there for Oliver's love life (which we'll get to shortly)...
1. Stiles & Lydia - Teen Wolf
When it comes to relationships, few shows have ever played the long-game quite like Teen Wolf did with the nerdy adorable Stiles Stilinski and cool girl Lydia Martin.
Though the show established that Stiles had feelings for Lydia as early as the first episode, nothing ever came of it as the writers prioritised the pair's involvement in the show's supernatural stories in a bid to allow the latter to grow as a character and, more importantly as a person, while seeing Stiles for the hero that he had always been.
The brilliance of it was that, in spite of the fact that both of them enjoyed other relationships throughout the show's six season-run, the writers continually teased us with the long-running possibility of 'Stydia', having the pair share a few special moments over the years - including their now-iconic panic attack-ending kiss.
Despite the incredible chemistry between Dylan O' Brien and Holland Roden, there was a time when it felt Stiles and Lydia were never going to get together, but the fact of the matter is that, in the final season, something changed for the pair, as it was only when Lydia was separated from him for a long period of time that she realised how much she actually loved him.
Stydia was always the plan, and the writers executed it to perfection - naturally progressing it over a six-year period and, in the end, it was indeed worth the wait.
Now, for the couples who didn't have quite as positive an effect on their TV shows...
Couples That Ruined Their Show...
5. Hannah & Zach - 13 Reasons Why
Most of this argument could be attributed to the fact that almost nothing about the second season of 13 Reasons Why made sense, but that didn't stop the creative team from running amok with new material designed to take place during the show's strong debut offering.
How do you keep Hannah Baker involved in a dual-timeline show about her death that already told both sides of her story? Why, you keep her around as a ghost and fill blanks that didn't exist in the flashback narrative, of course!
One of those apparent blanks was Hannah's relationship with Zach Dempsey who, upon realising that he was nothing like his mindless jock buddies, decided that he wanted something real out of a relationship. As a result, he ended up falling for Hannah and the pair embarked on a loving and sexual relationship with each other the summer before her death - only for the pair to end it when the school year commenced and never speak of it again. Why did they never speak of it again? Well, because the writers were constricted by the fact that they were writing around the first season's narrative.
Unlike the next couplings, the frustrating thing here is that Zach and Hannah were actually adorable together (and could very well rival the latter's endearing relationship with Clay Jensen) and that ended up tainting the near-perfect first season.
If they really felt that strongly about each other, why would Hannah have included Zach on her tapes? More than that, why would she have included a reference to the note he crumpled up when he already apologised for that during their summer relationship? There were far too many inconsistencies here, and as a result, it makes it impossible to take the first season at face value.
If anything, this manipulation of the narrative is proof that the show never should have attempted to continue the story when Hannah's arc had been wrapped up.
4. Blaine & Karofsky - Glee
Glee made a lot of mistakes during its six-year run - mistakes that ultimately made viewers tune out - but the show managed to overcome some of them in its final season - resetting things in a way that didn't necessarily make sense but, at the very least, allowed the writers to take things back to basics.
Of course, given that they planned on revisiting a lot of things that worked in the beginning, they decided to reinvigorate the groundbreaking relationship between Kurt and Blaine (a.k.a. 'Klaine') which had grown stale due to lacklustre writing. And the best way to do that was to split them up.
In theory, this was a perfect idea, as it gave Klaine something to fight for - and putting Blaine in a new relationship gave Kurt an obstacle to overcome. But who did Blaine end up with instead? Was it the formerly-villainous-but-completely-redeemed stud Sebastian Smythe who desperately wanted him in the past? Um, well, no because actor Grant Gustin had moved onto The Flash. Instead, the writers decided to use the other formerly-villainous-but-completely-redeemed guy in Kurt and Blaine's lives - and that was Dave Karofsky.
Not only did this make zero sense, it painted Blaine in a horrific light - as he was introduced back in Season 2 as a means of helping Kurt deal with the bullying he was facing at McKinley High at the hands of (wait for it) Karofsky.
To top it all of, after Dave made amends for all he had done in his younger years, he admitted that he was in love with Kurt... not Blaine. Thus, the decision to inexplicably pair Blaine with the bully of his ex-boyfriend was a really insensitive one that just didn't make sense with who the character was.
If Sebastian had been the original plan, it's a shame they couldn't make it happen. But using Karofsky was a major mistake because even though it was nothing more than a plot device that mostly took place off-screen, it threatened to undermine the very basis of Klaine's iconic relationship.
3. Lana & Lex - Smallville
During the first half of Smallville's run, Lana Lang had always been portrayed as the sweet genuine and kind-hearted first love of the Man of Steel himself, Clark Kent, so you can imagine how the relationship between her and Lex Luthor turned out in Season 6. Well, if you can't, it went down like a led balloon and, in a way, it took the show with it.
Lex was the charismatic best friend of Clark, who desperately wanted to be seen as more than just a Luthor. Though he tried hard, there were some that he just couldn't convince - and it certainly didn't help that he was jealous of everything that Clark had. Thus, the creative decision to have him fall for, and ultimately marry, the one person that he knew his best friend loved more than anything in the world was pretty twisted - and not the cool evil Lex Luthor kind of twisted.
Though the pair had gotten on really well in the earlier seasons, there was something more naive about their dynamic. Unfortunately, that all went out the window here as they were forced together in what apparently turned out to be a highly-sexual relationship between two people that never had that kind of chemistry in the first place.
It was wrong on all counts and just felt like another contrived way of prolonging the Clark and Lana drama because he couldn't just tell her his secret after six long years! This, however, this was not the answer as it damaged Lana's character beyond repair (and her relationship with Clark) - and it ultimately made Season 6 the least enjoyable season of Smallville's entire run.
2. Lorelai & Christopher - Gilmore Girls
Throughout Gilmore Girls' initial run, the writers told the story of how Lorelai, a young woman with rich parents who ended up running away from home after she got pregnant at 16, raised her daughter Rory alone and ended up giving her everything she could have wanted during her young life in Stars Hollow. However, it also alluded towards that woman finding love so that she could finally do the one thing she hadn't yet done - get married.
Fans of the show watched for years, as Lorelai fell for Luke - the oddly grumpy owner of the local diner who was clearly head over heels in love with her - as the pair eventually found their way into each other's arms. And when it seemed like they were finally ready to tie the knot, the relationship fell apart and Lorelai ended up eloping with Rory's father Christopher in the final season.
While Lorelai always had great chemistry with Christopher, the show made it very clear from the beginning that they wouldn't end up together, simply because she was no longer that girl and he couldn't tie himself down. Thus, while a few brief nights of passion kept things exciting for the pair, they were never endgame - not in that way anyway.
Yet, for some inexplicable reason, the creative team decided to waste Lorelai's long-teased wedding by having the pair (that nobody wanted to see get married) elope off-screen. Not only did this undermine seven years of storytelling, it backed the writers into a corner as, given that the end was nigh, they had to split the pair up quickly and reunite Lorelai with Luke in the final episode.
Thus, the original show came to an end, and fans were robbed of the chance to see the character have the wedding she always dreamed of (with the man she always wanted to marry). Doesn't really make sense now, does it?
1. Oliver & Felicity - Arrow
It's hard to believe that there was ever a time when the vast majority of Arrow's fans were rooting for Oliver Queen and Felicity Smoak to get together, but alas, the unique chemistry between the pair meant that, at the very least, the creative team had to try it. And, well, if only they hadn't.
The moment that these two got together, the show immediately lost sight of what it was as the writers inexplicably began prioritising melodramatic couple drama over the actual plot and, as a result, Oliver became a pathetic shell of the strong character that he once was. Meanwhile, Felicity lost that spark that made us all fall in love with her and became an infuriating (and downright annoying) monster who somehow managed to make everything about her.
To top it all off, in the midst of this half-baked experiment, the writers thought it would be a good idea to kill off the love of Oliver Queen's life, Laurel Lance - because, yes, fans were expected to buy that this sinking original character was more important to the show than the Black Canary. Needless to say, they didn't. Ratings fell dramatically as the show's fourth season spiralled so hard that the creative team were forced to hit the reset button for Season 5.
Though Oliver and Felicity have since had some genuinely sweet moments, it's hard to look at Arrow without imagining everything that it could have been if this ill-fated ship never sailed in the first place.
-
Which TV couples were your favourites? Tell us in the comment section below.