7 TV Shows That Suddenly Dropped Major Plot Threads

Even our most favourite shows have dropped major plot threads in puzzling, conspicuous ways.

By David Bixenspan /

ABC

The advantage of TV over movies is how much room you have for plots to breathe. The most epic movie is going to top out around three hours long, so even a six-episode season of a British drama is going to have considerably more screen time. When you get into 10 to 22 episode seasons of the U.S., it becomes a very different way of telling a story on screen.

Advertisement

Not everyone handles this framework well, though: Introduce too many story threads, and some will get lost in the shuffle. Neglect the needs of an actor, and soon you might see him or her leaving the show, or give a major storyline to an actor right before their contract expires, and you can be left in the wind. If you shoot too much relative to a network's commercial commitments, you may have to cut something important. Conversely, edit the episode in a way that gives a minor plot thread minor greater weight than you intended, and the audience ends up thinking you didn't care. Or maybe they really just didn't care and got sloppy.

Way too many TV shows have, for one reason or another dropped major plot threads in puzzling, conspicuous ways. Some shows were notorious for it, but who stands out? Warning: All entries contain SPOILERS for the show in question.

Advertisement

7. Lost Producers Don't Understand Puberty

ABC

You knew this one was going to be here, didn't you? In the first season of Lost, one of the big mysteries was centered around Walt, the young boy who was stranded with a father he barely knew when his mother died. Through flashbacks, it started to become clear that Walt had some kind of psychic powers that caused exotic birds to randomly appear and commit suicide (really).

Advertisement

With that in mind, it made sense that when Walt and his father Michael were among the castaways who tried to find civilization on a raft, the evil "Others" kidnapped Walt to do weird island magic experiments on him. It got weird when Walt wasn't rescued until the end of the next season. His scenes were carefully shot to avoid lingering on him too long, and he promptly left the island. The end.

Wait, what?

Advertisement

Malcom David Kelley, who played Walt, was about 12 years-old when the series started. Lost was somewhat unique among TV shows in that as far as its internal timeline went, a few days at most passed between most episodes. It wasn't long before Kelley started going through puberty and had a huge growth spurt that defied the internal logic of how much time was passing.

Producers Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse panicked and wrote him off the show. They've never explained why, on a show about a magical island, they couldn't find a way for him to stay, much less how they were unable to anticipate such an obvious development.

Advertisement

6. Degrassi Tackles HIV/AIDS. Badly.

CTV

Everyone's favorite semi-educational Canadian teen drama, Degrassi (formerly Degrassi: The Next Generation) is well-known for its sensitive handling of topics ranging from rape, incest, and domestic abuse to the plight of homosexual and transgender children to teen pregnancy and everything in between. The acting and writing isn't always the best, but they have a solid handle on writing most of the "issue" stories. Unfortunately, they've also had some major misses.

Advertisement

One of the most notorious took place when the older members of the original cast were only appearing occasionally after graduating high school. Paige Michalchuk had some of the best character development, starting as the show's "queen bee" type, but becoming a much more well-rounded person after surviving a rape and seeing her attacker acquitted, dropping out of college when the pressure got to her, and experimenting with her sexuality. As she was trying to build a life for herself as an adult, she started dating her roommate, Griffin. Because Degrassi claims to "go there," they totally had sex, but because it's Degrassi and she wasn't the designated pregnant teen, they used protection. Which didn't keep her from freaking out when she learned Griffin was HIV positive, having contracted the virus in utero from his mother.

The episode ends with Paige awaiting the results of her HIV test. Sure, they were safe, but she was right to be worried, and she both broke up with Griffin and moved out of their house. That was the last we ever saw of Paige, because actress Lauren Collins was done with the show. It's become a running joke among the show's fandom, with Collins even appearing in a fan parody video that addressed the dropped thread.

Advertisement

5. The Disappearing Daughter - Doctor Who

BBC

Doctor Who made a huge change to the accepted canon back in 2008, with the introduction of Jenny, the Doctor's Daughter, during the show's fourth season, which was titled after the new, potentially game-changing character.

Advertisement

It was revealed that Jenny (played by Georgia Moffet, who is now married to David Tennant, the Doctor at the time), had been artificially created using DNA taken from the Doctor against his will, and she went on to become something of a fan-favourite across a multi-episode arc. Her story seemingly came to a close when she was fatally shot, taking a bullet meant for her father. That, however, wasn't quite the end of her, as she was brought back to life - only to go off and explore the universe, never to be seen again.

Fans of speculated about a return ever since, and a Big Finish audio series will bring the character back later this year, but in terms of TV the story of Jenny has never properly been resolved.

Advertisement

4. The Life And Times Of Behrooz Araz On 24

Fox

In its first three seasons, 24 tended to focus on whitest terrorists possible, almost to a fault. Serbian soldiers, pretty blonde girls, and rich British guys were the key villains in the first three seasons and it felt like the producers were deathly scared of ever doing a season about extremist Muslim terrorists.

Advertisement

In season four, it was made clear well in advance of the premiere that the main villains would be Middle Eastern Muslims, and the media was weirdly excited about this. The key terrorist characters for much of the season were the Araz family, part of a sleeper cell involved in the day's attack. As the day went on, Behrooz, the reluctant teenage son, became the most important member of the family, especially once his parents died. His girlfriend was poisoned by his mother, he beat a terrorist captor about the head with a shovel, and he became a pawn for law enforcement and the terrorists.

For reasons that were never explained, lead terrorist Habib Marwan, who had captured Jack Bauer, was willing to trade Jack for Behrooz. The counter-terrorism agents at CTU agreed, and that was the last we ever saw of Behrooz. Whatever plans Marwan had for him, we never found out what they were. In deleted scenes included on the season four DVD set, we learn different endings for him were shot, and obviously neither was used: In one, CTU saves him from being executed by one of Marwan's men. In the other, he's brought into CTU after being found in a shipping container owned by Marwan. A producer told TV Guide that he was "shipped off for re-education," presumably by Marwan.

Advertisement

3. The Sopranos Misplaces A Russian

HBO

Like with Walt on Lost, this had to be here. Pine Barrens is generally considered one of The Sopranos' finest episodes, a bizarre character piece about Christopher and Paulie. After messing up a collection trip to see Valery, a Russian mobster, they injure him, take him to the woods...and he escapes as they shoot him. In the head.

Advertisement

As Paulie and Chris are stuck in the woods for the rest of the episode, they bond, and...well, that's it. Immediately the fandom wanted to know where the heck Valery went, but he never returned to the show. He could have, though. As Alan Sepinwall explains, Terrence Winter, writer of the episode and creator of Boardwalk Empire, wanted creator David Chase to let him address the issue in the final season. Tony and Chris would visit the local Russian mob boss and see a brain-damaged Valery sweeping the floor. Chris would be worried, but Valery would have no clue who he was because, well...brain damage. The mob boss would explain a Boy Scout troop found him with his skull missing and saved his life at the last minute.

Winter got Chase to agree to include the scene...but he dropped it from the script at the last minute, leaving Winter to plead with him. €œGod, you€™re making a huge mistake leaving that on the table!€ Chase just didn't understand why the fans were so into the idea of finding out what happened to Valery.

Advertisement

2. Buffy The Vampire Slayer Accidentally Flips Off Its Entire Fandom

20th Century Fox Television

In the season six episode Normal Again, after being stabbed by a demon, Buffy keeps hallucinating that she's in a mental hospital, because hallucination Buffy was hallucinating that she was a vampire slayer. In simpler terms, it was a world where she was real but the show wasn't. Or something.

Advertisement

As the demon poisoning takes hold, Buffy thinks killing everyone in her Sunnydale life will make her, well, "normal again" in the hospital, where she'll get back her absentee father and now-deceased mother. She's stopped, and eventually drinks and antidote, and that's that. Except the episode was edited to end on a scene where mental hospital Buffy goes completely catatonic.

Regardless of whatever the intention of the producers was, a whole hell of a lot of the audience came away thinking that, by ending on that hospital scene and not Buffy in Sunnydale, the episode strongly implied that yes, Buffy's life as we knew it was something she was hallucinating at a mental hospital in Los Angeles. No matter how the writers addressed this in interviews, if you just watched the show, you were left with the impression that in the show's universe, what we had invested in for years "wasn't real."

Advertisement

1. Alias Thrives On This Crap. Over and Over.

ABC

The second season of Alias ended with one of the craziest cliffhangers in recent memory, with lead character Sydney Bristow (Jennifer Garner) being knocked unconscious, waking up in Hong Kong, and discovering she was missing for two years. Oh, and her boyfriend, Michael Vaughn (Michael Vartan) was now married.

Advertisement

The show was unable to live up to the potential of the twist and the mystery was unraveled mid-season as Sydney having her memories removed so she could properly hide magical ancient sperm that she didn't want the bad guys to impregnate her stolen eggs with - and I swear I didn't make that up. So the next stage was getting her back together with Vaughn.

First step? Make his wife, Lauren (Melissa George) a villain since the audience already hated her. Vaughn is badly injured at the end of the season, and while he's in the hospital, it's somehow revealed that he was brainwashed by Lauren into marrying her. Well, almost. That scene was cut from the final episode. It was left in such a late cut of the episode that not only did the ABC website's episode summary include a mention of the brainwashing until someone noticed the problem, but Vaughn addresses the brainwashing in the next episode.

Advertisement

The show was a complete mess at this point, and it got worse. In the season finale, Vaughn kills Lauren to save Sydney's life, but not before she tells Sydney about a safe deposit box she needs to investigate. Sydney finds a bunch of documents she needs a black light to read, and all we see is: The CIA project written about on the pages in the box is named SAB-47 - Sydney's initials and the show's magic mythological number. SAB-47 started on Sydney's date of birth and was signed off on by her dad. Sydney crying as she reads everything. Then her dad shows up and says she was never supposed to find those pages. Smash to credits. Yes, it looked like Sydney's whole life was a secret CIA project run by her dad. The internet was abuzz, and that was amplified, when, AGAIN, ABC posted a summary that included references to deleted footage:

In Wittenberg, Syd opens the safe deposit box and finds a top secret document. She cries as she learns that Jack wasn't in prison after Irina betrayed him, that Vaughn's father William worked for him, and that he has documented her entire life, as well as Nadia's. Jack appears and says she was never supposed to have found these documents

That was edited to read like this:

Advertisement
In Wittenberg, Syd opens the safe deposit box and finds top secret documents. She cries as she peruses files documenting her life, each one bearing Jack Bristow's signature. Jack enters and says she was never supposed to have found these documents.

Not too bad, right? Hey, they only cut out what they decided to save for the next season...right? Wrong. Worried they made her dad too much of a bad guy, the cliffhanger was retconned so that it turned out the documents revealed Sydney's dad killed her mom because her mom had hired someone to kill her. And that was the end of SAB-47.

Which unresolved TV plot threads annoyed you the most? Let us know down in the comments.

Advertisement