8 Current TV Shows That Don't Treat Audiences Like Idiots

Some shows treat audiences like intelligent beings and don't spell everything out for us!

By Baz Greenland /

There's nothing more frustrating than watching a TV show where characters spout reels and reels of exposition just to move the plot forward. Or having a flashback to a moment ten minutes earlier because - shock horror - it relates to a big twist coming up. Having everything spelled out treats audiences like they have little or no intelligence. TV shows have to maintain a balance in their storytelling. Make the plot too dumbed down and anyone with an ounce of intelligence will switch off. Go the other way and make a show too complex and you'll loose your audience - and the ratings war. Having sign posts along the way is a simple way to make sure everyone is on the same page. Unfortunately even shows with intelligent characters and plots fall into the trap of spelling everything out just to stop audiences from getting 'confused'. Take Criminal Minds; the BAU unit boasts some of the most intelligent, gifted agents the FBI has to offer. Yet they constantly sit and discuss the motivations behind a killer's actions among themselves. In reality, their skill, training and experience mean they wouldn't need to spell everything out, telling each other their thoughts on the case. Because audiences need this information, they launch into exposition mode just to keep us from getting lost and switching off. Luckily, for those of us who enjoy being treated like intelligent viewers, there are some shows that don't treat us like idiots. We've picked eight of the most intelligent, thought-provoking shows currently on TV. Shows that require you to pay attention, don't spell everything out but reward you with a fantastic pay off. Shows that also treat challenging subject matter with reverence, challenging us to view something in a new light. So click 'Next' to discover the first. Warning, there may be some spoilers if you're not up to date.

8. Homeland

In its first season Homeland captivated audiences (President Obama included) with its intelligent, bold look at terrorism. It presented the subject in a way that didn't conform to the media's portrayal of the war on terror. The character of Brody was key to this. Suddenly we were presented with a 'good' solider converted to Islam after years of imprisonment, trying to find his place in his old world. That meant carrying out what he believed to be a righteous attack on the US Government for killing children in cold blood. His character challenged the audience's way of thinking, forcing us not to think in black and white terms. In doing so we understood his motivations even if the end goal wasn't right. While his story may have gone awry in the second season, his redemption and tragic fate in season three brought us right back to that question of morality that the show began so brilliantly with. But for all the twists and turns of the show, one of the most courageous elements of Homeland is its sensitive portrayal of bi-polar through its central character Carrie. Claire Danes gives her greatest performance as the CIA analyst struggling to manage her condition around the sheer stress of her work. Her breakdown and gradual return to the fold have been played beautifully, never treated as sensational. She has brought bi-polar disorder into the light, making it accessible to a mainstream audience. Like Brody, her situation has allowed us to question how someone like Carrie can survive in a world that will so easily use her and spit her out again. The only reason Homeland isn't higher on the list is because it sometimes stumbles into 24-style territory, adding sensational action over intelligent drama. The new direction Homeland is likely to take in season four could make or break the show. But if it handles those moral issues and treats Carrie's condition with the sensitivity it deserves, then there is no reason Homeland can't continue for many more years to come.

7. Sherlock

Fresh from it's multiple Emmy wins, we have Sherlock, possibly the cleverest show on television. While you might argue that the cases solved by Sherlock Holmes are beyond the reach of the average human mind, there are definite levels of mystery within the show. From the big (what was the Hound of Baskerville) to the small (cracking the safe code based on Irene Adler's measurements), there are some moments you might solve yourself if you're up to it. One of he key strengths of Sherlock is its ability to absorb you completely in the interplay of its characters, be it Sherlock and John, Sherlock and Mycroft or John and Mary. But most significantly, its central character, like many in this list, isn't someone you can easily sympathise with. The show doesn't insult the audience by softening his personality to enable you to identify with him. Sherlock is far more complex than that and requires the audience to follow his every action even if they don't agree, or understand, with motivations. There are few shows that can thoroughly entertain and push you at the same time; Sherlock is one of those classics that does both. Which is why those rare occasions when a new episode is on our screens is a precious moment indeed.

6. Luther

We all thought the third series of Luther was the end. However between the rumours of a prequel movie and Idris Elba now suggesting that series 4 might be coming, we may be seeing more of Detective John Luther before long. Which is a great thing as Luther remains one of the most intelligent, gripping procedural dramas of recent years. What makes this series so special is that Luther can be as dangerous as the criminals he hunts; the idea that he will throw a child killer over a balcony creates that moral debate with the audience; should he act within the law even if the killer doesn't deserve it? Add to that the moral ambiguity of his connection to Alice; his friend, ally and antagonist. He deduces how and why she murdered her parents from their very first meeting and yet their relationship grows because she is someone who can challenge his way of thinking. He gets who Alice is and what she wants. In a black and white world he would arrest her and throw away the key. But Luther doesn't deal in black and white. It's not always easy viewing. Many of the crimes are deeply psychological in nature, such as the nature of fear in the Penny Dreadful killer of series two. With a grey anti-hero that challenges the conventions of what TV detectives should be, it is a show that pushes its audience every time.

5. House Of Cards

House Of Cards is worth your Netflix subscription alone. The antithesis of The West Wing, the show charts the rise and rise of the very worst of humanity; Frank Underwood and his 'Lady Macbeth' Claire. What makes this show so engaging is that you have to immerse yourself his world, piecing together his actions until his plan becomes clear. A moment from one episode will pay off several episodes later and the show trusts you to pay attention to all those cunning little snippets of information. It is not a show that you can dip into - it's why it is best suited to binge viewing that Netflix provides - but if you keep up the payoff is immense. This show does make you question yourself as a viewer. We've enjoyed every moment of House Of Cards, watching narcissistic bad guy Frank Underwood using every dirty, Machiavellian trick in the book to trample over the good guys and get to the top. Heroes lose in this show, but that's part of the fun. But you have to ask yourself... didn't you want Frank Underwood to succeed every time? (It helps that Kevin Spacey gives the performance of his career). You become absorbed in his thirst for power, everyone be damned, even if that questions your motivation as a viewer. There's always a chance to redeem yourself. Considering how high he has come, the fall is going to be spectacular and just as fun to watch.

4. The Americans

The Americans has been keeping audiences on the edge of their seats as Elizabeth and Philip Jennings, two deep cover Cold War spies, try to juggle their duties to their country and their family. But what takes this show to the next level is that they aren't brave US soldiers fighting for God and country. They're Russian KGB operatives fighting for the downfall of capitalism. Making the protagonists of the show the enemies of the US is brave for any show, let alone one created in America. It forces the viewers to see the world from a different point of view. To admit that Russian's aren't all evil and have their own moral view they are fighting for. It €“ possibly €“ even goes as far as to suggest that communism isn't that bad; or at least as bad as some politicians would have you believe. Not playing from the set rulebook of 'US good, everyone else bad' means this show treats the audience as intelligent agents that are able to make up their own minds when it comes to good versus evil.

3. Orphan Black

We've all been gobsmacked at Tatiana Maslany's acting as Sarah Manning, the con artist who's just trying to get by and look after her daughter. Oh, and her performance as Beth Childs, Alison Hendrix, Cosima, Helena, Katja, Rachel, Tony.... Each of these characters having their own lives, values and motivations. Motivations that mean they all €“ in general €“ operate with their own interests in mind. But Orphan Black doesn't handhold the audience with this. It allows the watcher to keep track and work out, at any one point, if that particular character is working for themselves, the Dyad Institute or even someone else. There is a great level of trust in it's audience. Not just in understanding those motivations but in keeping up at every stage of ever-unfolding mystery. We have to remember the clues to earlier episodes, be clever enough to deduce where one clone is impersonating another and piece together the puzzle even as Sarah and her clones do. But that investment is well worth the pay off. This flip-flopping of allegiances makes Orphan Black such a great show on top of the already top-notch award-winning acting. Keeping track of the various characters, their lives, their motivations and allegiances makes this show both a pleasure and a puzzle.

2. The Newsroom

Aaron Sorkin delivered one of the greatest TV shows of all time in The West Wing and so it's a joy to have him writing for TV again, even it is coming to an end all too soon. The Newsroom is a show willing to push boundaries, asking challenging questions about the society we live in. Whether you believe it to be agenda-heavy or not, there is no denying that it makes you think. The use of real life events as source material is a clever motif within the show. It creates drama and discussion in a narrative the audience can relate to. It's also likely the reason that The Newsroom garners controversy; using real stories as a springboard to attack the negative elements of society is much more likely to turn people against the show. Ultimately, the stories that take place within the world of Atlantis Cable News idealise what we believe TV news broadcasting should be, just as The West Wing presented an idealised view of politics. As much as it is entertainment, filled with drama and comedy in equal measure, it is also a platform for us to question how we can better ourselves. For that reason, The Newsroom is a rare thing indeed. You might feel vastly intelligent keeping up with the moral debates and political undercurrent through the show, but you'll also feel bettered by your ability to think and question how we live our lives. With just six episodes in its final season, enjoy the show while you can.

1. Hannibal

Hannibal is one of those rare shows where not a single moment is wasted. Phenomenal acting, gripping twists and turns and an intelligent approach to this well-known story; it is easily the most absorbing - and disturbing - drama on television. A big theme running through this article is the intelligent approach to the debate of good versus evil and Hannibal does it better than anyone else. You might support Will and Jack in their search for the truth but Hannibal really is a show where you want the villain to succeed. Not to mention the amazing looking food he prepares - can you honestly say you've not wanted to eat everything on the menu, even knowing the content? It asks some strong questions of ourselves as viewers. It is also a show that credits you with intelligence at every step. The dialogue demands you understand the world these characters live in. The deductions made by Will and the FBI feel natural and their conversations don't state the obvious at every turn. You are expected to keep up. In Will's court case in season two, the discussion of his possible Aspergers came up. Unlike most shows, it was referred to simply as 'the scale', just as it would in the professional world. Another example of Hannibal expecting you to have a understanding of the psychological discussions in play. In fact, one of the reasons that the show doesn't do as well in the ratings is down to the fact that there is so much depth within the scripts that larger audiences may struggle with the content. Throw in the stunning cinematography, gripping performances and jaw dropping performances and Hannibal remains the most riveting show currently on television. And here we conclude our study of some of the most intelligent, captivating shows currently available. Show that don't treat us like idiots. They may not get the viewing figures we would all like, they be too niche for mainstream audiences, but their loss is our gain.Do you agree? Are there other shows worthy of consideration? Please feel free to add your comments below...