8 Notable Comparisons Between Breaking Bad And Scarface

By Joe Young /

Vince Gilligan, the creator of AMC's Breaking Bad once said in a now infamous interview that his ultimate goal was to turn "Mr Chips" into "Scarface". At the beginning of the series Walter White is an unassuming, seemingly unthreatening teacher with absolutely no criminal tendencies. By the end of Season 6, Walt is a criminal mastermind, and a morally ambiguous character who is willing to kill to achieve his goals.

Advertisement

Similarly Tony Montana starts at the bottom, and becomes a drug inhaling, Druglord over the course of the 1983 released Brian De Palma movie.

Click next to explore more comparisons between these two productions (Obvious spoilers ahead)-

Advertisement

8. Drugs

A good starting point is that both Scarface and Breaking Bad feature drugs as a key component to the anti-heroes rise to the top and then subsequent downfall. Scarface's drug is cocaine, which is featured heavily throughout, especially with regard to its usage by the titular character (at one stage on his desk there is even an impressive mountain of white powder). It could be said that the cocaine on his desk is symbolic of how he rose to power. In fact it is doubtful that there is ten minutes of screen time without Tony Montana getting his fix; it is clear that cocaine is a primary component of both his business and personal life.

Advertisement

Both of the characters use their respective drugs to build their way up the foodchain and to garner millions of dollars. As Walt arrogantly puts it at one stage, he is neither in the money or meth game but rather in, "the empire business". However Walt's drug is Methamphetamine, a more modern drug.

Advertisement

Walt and Tony are ultimately destroyed by their drugs, Tony's overuse of the drug renders him a paranoid mess and leads to his demise whilst Walt, evidently doomed from the beginning of him "breaking bad" would not have had to face the ultimate price of losing his family if he had not embarked on a drug fuelled empire construction.

7. Family

Both Scarface and Breaking Bad employ family as a key theme in both of their stories. Walt's main goal at the beginning of the series is to raise enough money for his family so that they are not left penniless if the cancer were to take him. While his purpose becomes more and more blurred throughout the series, it definitely can be said that Walter is a man that holds family in high regard (although clearly not enough to stop his dealings once he has gained enough money). He clearly loves his son Walt Jr., even attempting to contact him once he has been incarcerated in the snow at the end of the series, leading to a bitter, angry son shouting curses down the phone and Walt exclaiming "it can't all be for nothing". Walt's submission in the critically acclaimed episode "Ozymandias" to Hank and his calling off of Jack and the Nazis is also a clear show of how Walt was even willing to be arrested to save a member of his family, and his horror when Hank is killed provides even more evidence for this. Tony Montana is much less of a dedicated promotor of family care. However, similarly to Walt, he does attempt to give his foul gotten gains to them but is denounced by his mother who is appalled by his means of obtaining the money. More important to the story is Tony's relationship with Gina, his sister. Tony is overly protective of his sister and almost seems to have an incestual obsession with her, when Tony sees her with a drug dealer in a club he immediately (in his mind) comes to her rescue and violently kicks the man out. He also tells Manny, his seemingly best and only friend, to stay away from her. Eventually he discovers that the two have married in secret; Tony goes off in a rampage and shoots Manny dead. Finally, before the end Gina stumbles into Tony's office in a bathrobe, exclaiming seductively "you can't stand for another man to be touching me. So you want me, Tony, huh?" before revealing a gun and shooting him in the leg. Unfortunately for Gina, a hitman is standing behind the window and shoots her. This scene is important as it shows how Tony's bad decisions have resulted in the death of a cherished family member.

Advertisement

6. Violence

Scarface is probably one of the most violent films of all time, some of it to the point of it being sickening, for example the infamous scene in the bathroom at one point where Tony is made to watch his partner being dismembered by a chainsaw. Blood dramatically spewing off into people's faces serves as a reminder of the danger of the trade Tony has entered himself into. Similarly Breaking Bad features a huge volume of violent scenes, Walt strangling a drug dealer in his basement, Jesse shooting Gale in the head, Gus Fring poisoning an entire cartel, are too name just a few of the violent scenes in Breaking Bad. However the one that is the most striking is the scene in the first episode of season 4 "Box Cutter", where Gus Fring ruthlessly slits the throat of his accomplice Victor. The reason that the violence is so striking is that Victor has seemingly done nothing wrong to Gus and this is just done as a message to Walt and Jesse; in that they could be next.

Advertisement

5. Memorable Dialogue

Apart from the obvious visceral attraction of Scarface and Breaking Bad, both also include fantastic, memorable parts of dialogue that live long in the memory after and serve to encapsulate the character's mindsets and opinions. Walt's "I am the one who knocks" monologue is one of the most unforgettable lines of dialogue throughout the series, illustrating Walt's reversal from school teacher into being the one who knocks on people's doors to deliver their end. As Skylar reaches out to Walt, still seeing the vulnerable school teacher she was once married to, she assumes that Walt is in danger but rather as Walt puts it, he is the "danger" and is the head of a business that is big enough to be "listed on the NASDAQ" that would crumble without his input. This memorable scene encapsulates the whole objective of the show, as seemingly within minutes Walt has gone from being "in danger" to being "the one who knocks." Other lines of dialogue such as when Walt commands a drug dealer to "say my name" and when Gus Fring threatens Walt: "If you try to interfere, this becomes a much simpler matter. I will kill your wife. I will kill your son. I will kill your infant daughter" are other great examples of the striking dialogue used in the show. Perhaps not as silver tongued and eloquent as Walt, Tony Montana still has many memorable lines of exchange throughout the movie. For example, when he is sitting in the car with Manny, and he declares that he "wants the world and everything in it"Of course, Tony's most enduring line of dialogue in the film is in the final scene when he screams in a seething rage, "Say hello to my little friend!" and also when he announces that "I always tells the truth, even when I lie". All of these lines display how Tony is an ambitious, loud mouthed character, hell bent on achieving his goals.

4. Greek Tragedy

Both Scarface and Breaking Bad follow literary dramatic conventions of old, as they feature aspects that are similar to a Greek tragedy. Both Tony and Walt start at the bottom before falling into adversity, following Aristotle's term of Peripeteia (where the tragic hero has a reversal of fortune). In Scarface, Tony becomes an all encompassing Druglord, only to eventually fall from his throne and into his demise. Similarly, Walter rises from a non assuming teacher into the dominant Heisenburg character and is feared and respected by everyone. However, like all tragic heroes, he eventually is defeated by his hubris (pride) when he is tricked into thinking that his money, his life's work, is being burned to a crisp. From then on the story spirals into a chaos until Walt's eventual confrontation with the Nazis at the end of the series. Ultimately, both characters have the potential to do good but fall because of their decisions. Both pieces also feature a cathartic element to their conclusions, "catharsis" is when there is a release of tension or emotion, typically found at the end of a play and that has an emotional impact on the viewer. In Scarface, Tony Montana falls to his death, mirroring his fall from grace, and into his lavish pool which is overlooked by a statue with the words "The World Is Yours" branded across it. The statue reinforces that Tony had the potential to be something else but instead went down a dark path due to his corrupt decisions. The score also creates an emotional impact on the viewer, leading them to reflect on what could have been. On the other hand, Walter dies more peacefully and in a meth lab. Again the score of "Baby Blue" by Badfinger creates an emotional release and the shot of the camera rising from Walt's face is an impactful image that lives long in the memory. There is also a moment of catharsis for Jesse, perhaps the most sympathetic of all the characters on Breaking Bad, as he drives off into the distance crying and laughing to himself, whether Jesse is beyond repair due to Walt and the Nazi's actions is another question, but the ending is fitting for Jesse and we can finally feel some sort of hope for the troubled character.

Advertisement

3. Both Characters Are Eventually Honest With Who They Are

Both of the leads are, at least by the end of their lives, accepting of who they are and of their motivations. The scene that marks this from Scarface is in a restaurant where Tony Montana unleashes an all out verbal attack on the upper class: "You need people like me so you can point your f**kin' fingers and say, "That's the bad guy." So... what that make you? Good? You're not good. You just know how to hide, how to lie." leading him eventually to proclaim, "I always tell the truth, even when I lie." For all Tony Montana's faults, being honest for who he is is not one of them, rather than hide behind a mask he accepts that he is a "bad guy". Walter White hides behind the facade that it is "all for his family" for the majority of the show's run. However, in a surprising turn of truth, Walt confesses to Skylar, probably the person who he lied to the most throughout, that he "did it for me" and that "I liked it, I was good at it...I was alive". This marks an extreme change of character, the usual unscrupulous, scheming Walt that was present for most of the show has been laid bare, and can finally admit the truth to his wife after years of treachery and dishonesty before leading to his grisly demise. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FaqxAEx46Zk

2. Neither A Good Advert For Drug Use

Breaking Bad has received a fair amount of negative publicity for supposedly glorifying the meth business and acting as an advert for the extremely dangerous drug. However, watching the show, it seems that these opinions have came from somebody who has not actually watched the show, and have just observed that it is about drugs and so have made a fictional cause and effect relationship. The meth addicts on the show are clearly not in good shape (see above) and are shivering, incoherent wretches. Clearly the show is not glamorising the uses of methamphetamine. This is particularly evident in the shocking episode in season 2, "Peekaboo". Jesse is held hostage by a drug-addicted couple, and the snivelling wife drops a stolen ATM onto her husband's head in retaliation for his repeatedly calling her a "skank" and in order to take the meth in his pocket. What is even more shocking is the presence of a child, in the doomed, dismal environment of the house. If anything, in this scene Breaking Bad does the exact opposite of glorifying drug use, but rather denounces it as a terrifying, dark path to follow. Scarface similarly provides a negative perspective on drug use. As glamorous as Tony's life is, with the mansion and the flashy car, his life is really quite empty. He barely has any friends or family and his life is marked by violence and death. What's even worse is that his consistent drug use leaves him paranoid and always on the edge. Does this really look glamorous to you? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJUt_x0gwug

1. Explosive Endings

Scarface, in one of the most memorable finales in cinema history, bows out all guns blazing. A seemingly endless stream of foes, almost respawning like in a Call of Duty game, arrives at his mansion, hell bent on ending his grim existence. As stream upon stream of enemies approaches, Tony's inevitable fate is delayed by his kamikaze attitude, bringing out a grenade launcher and screaming in a furious coke fuelled rampage the now infamous lines "Say hello to my little friend!". Tony in turn eventually dies how he lived; high on cocaine and surrounded by death and violence. Likewise, Breaking Bad also features a predictably explosive finale. Perhaps undeservedly, Walter dies on his own terms and with the cold feeling of revenge as his primary motivator. He returns to Albuquerque to have a showdown with the sickeningly ruthless Jack and his Nazi associates, however instead of wielding the gun himself in a courageous yet foolish manner, Walt uses the main weapon in his arsenal; his intelligence and attaches a machine gun onto a rotator device to decimate the entire Nazi crew at the touch of a button. While Tony dies fittingly in a pool with a statue with the words "the world is yours" on as mentioned earlier, Walt dies in a meth lab surrounded by equipment, again a fitting ending for the character, who's death is the cause of an excess of pride and ambition at the hands of the deadly drug.