8 Reasons Gotham's Second Season Could Fail Miserably
What real life obstacles might this Batman prequel face going forward?
Superheroes rule at the cinema, especially with the Marvel Universe juggernaut started with 2008's Iron Man, and now, they are taking over television. Joined for a single season by the ill-fated Birds Of Prey - about vigilante heroines taking on Gotham's rogues in Batman's absence - the Superman prequel Smallville stood alone for much of its run despite attempts to spin it off into a show about Aquaman.
In 2013, Marvel got into the act with Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. and then Agent Carter this year. Now, DC is blitzing the airwaves with hits Arrow and The Flash on the CW, the upcoming mid-season spin-off Legends of Tomorrow, and CBS' Supergirl this Fall - all sharing producers Greg Berlanti and Andrew Kreisberg. In another corner, though, is Fox's Gotham.
Named for Batman's city, Gotham is sold as a prequel about the rise of future police commissioner James Gordon beginning just after the murders of Bruce's Wayne's parents. With partner Harvey Bullock, he witnesses the evolution of Gotham's underworld into one eventually ruled by familiar super villains, a number of whom have early introductions. Despite getting off to a good start in September of last year and being renewed for a second season, things began changing both in the show and in the way it was received.
Some changes were subtle, a few were good but others generated skepticism. And though interest remains strong after a thrilling first season finale, here are eight reasons Gotham could be facing a tough uphill battle.
8. Major Shifts Away From Premise
James Gordon has been a stalwart ally of Batman and Gotham, upholding the law while recognizing Gotham's need for Batman's work. Though never a very colorful character by the comics' standards, much of Gordon's appeal lies in his grounded nature, his stability, and most of all, his incorruptibility both personally and as a cop. All of this distinguishes James Gordon as a hero unto himself in a city which tempts everyone to go a little mad sometimes.
When it was announced that Gotham would focus on Gordon's career, fans were as excited as curious. Stories like Frank Miller's Batman: Year One and others represent a rich history the show could draw on. As its first season progressed, however, it appeared that villains like Oswald Cobblepot might again draw too much of the focus away from Gotham's central hero.
Smallville ostensibly outgrew its premise after the 4th or 5th season, yet its well-established characters sustained its core audience. While the Batman connection will always be important, there was a chance from the start for the show to grow legs of its own as a bizarre police procedural.
Heller and crew could still exploit that chance and take Gordon in any number of interesting directions, yet some signs predict an even more splintered story-line in which Penguin, Riddler, Catwoman and others threaten to render Gordon's arc incidental.
7. Gordon's Lackluster Motivations
Rarely is personal or altruistic heroism enough by itself anymore. On Gotham, Gordon is a war hero whose father was a district attorney and who always seems to have a love interest to protect, yet the kind of heroism which puts Gordon in danger is usually tied to his quest to clean up the Gotham Police Department. While this will always seem admirable, it's likely a character like Gordon could need stronger, more personal motivations.
Batman's motivation is rooted his parents' death by violent crime. Aside from parental loss being universally poignant, by the time Batman was created and his back story revealed, comic book readers of the time included young adults about to go to war in a society for which urban crime and moral ambiguity were all too familiar themes.
People in the 1920's frequented nightclubs and "speak-easy's" run by mobsters they otherwise feared because many defied Prohibition by finding creative ways to serve alcohol. Robbers like John Dillinger became quasi-celebrities in the 1930's for robbing banks that had to deny so many their money during the Great Depression.
Gotham is an exciting show, but without stronger motivations, Gordon's dangerous and excessive efforts to enforce the law and reform his department - often by himself, more or less - could lose audiences along with its credibility.
6. The Inevitability Of Crime In Gotham Compromises The Heroic Arc
Stories such as Gotham's are about heroes or protagonists winning or changing.
Gotham's hero is a cop who proactively sets out to solve crimes and expose corruption regardless of the potential cost. Season one ends with a great illustration of this with its story about the "Ogre," who remains free by threatening cops' families.
This sort of thing would work for the average police procedural whose focus was on one remarkable central character. With Gotham, however, it is an empty promise. The path the show must take is clearly set just to satisfy most fans and arguably justify its very existence.
The premise of Gordon's rise in the Gotham PD is the type that usually implies some eventual success, yet viewers with only the most basic knowledge of Batman still know that not only won't Gotham fundamentally change, it cannot if Batman is ever to exist.
Television shows and movies sometimes put established characters on different and unpredictable paths, but Gotham's path was pretty much set when the Waynes were murdered in the first few minutes of the pilot. Gordon's path is also set by the show's promise that we'll see him "rise" in rank, like in the comics; however, if the city fails to become safer and Gordon's superiors are still corrupt, then his rise could seem unlikely and unbelievable.
5. Some Villains Work Best With A Batman To Fight
As with the upcoming movies, there was always going to be a Joker in Gotham's deck. For better or worse, there is also a Penguin, an eventual Riddler and Scarecrow, Black Mask, and even a Red Hood - all just in the first season. Many are part and parcel of the Batman world, which is not only what the show is about with or without Batman in it, but the source of its title. As they say, however, a good villain always gets the hero he or she deserves, so is Gordon the best hero for these villains?
It isn't that recognizable villains should never be included. The show would have probably had trouble surviving its first season without them, and of those featured, liberties have also been taken. The Penguin is far from his shorter and fatter counterpart in the comics and prior onscreen depictions.
What makes some skeptical and has already been written about is that given the obvious time frame, most of the villains featured will be way past their prime by the time Batman shows up on the scene. Part of the show's obvious attraction is seeing how Gordon eventually deals with these freaks, yet the playing ground is unbalanced.
The very reason Batman exists and is eventually needed by Gordon, himself, is that the Batman's extreme presence helps to counter theirs.
4. Villains Could Run Out Of Steam!
Though variations on a theme by now, this obstacle is one of the more obvious. Gotham's Bruce is to future Batman what Smallville's Clark was to future Superman, yet at least Clark was close enough in age to the time he put on the cape and tights that early encounters with Metallo, for example, never ruled out future meetings. With Gotham, we have familiar villains like Penguin and the Riddler in their late twenties or early thirties while Bruce Wayne is still a decade or more from becoming Batman.
There is no denying the necessity for Gotham to include at least some familiar faces from Batman's rogues gallery, but they should have been sparsely used and depicted as a little younger. Given a tantalizing taste with the scenes featuring Bruce and Selina together, it would have been interesting to see young Bruce Wayne meeting and even socializing with more kids his age, particularly those we know he will one day have to hunt down - making that inevitability all-the-more poignant.
A great would-be example is the future Riddler. Harking back to his late-1940's origin, Bruce could have met and befriended with the bright, yet tormented young Eddie Nygma. Their friendship (ala Clark and Lex) could have foreshadowed Batman's unique empathy and understanding stemming from his own psychological and behavioral connections to the villains he fights.
3. Predetermined Futures Lessen The Threat To Main Characters
Almost as detrimental to Gotham as realizing how old some of the villains will be by the time Bruce becomes Batman is the knowledge of characters' future, potentially lessening almost every threat.
Again, shows have taken familiar characters on different paths. Gotham actually killed off Sal Maroni long before he is supposed to help turn Harvey Dent into Two-Face, but think too hard and too many villains seem like they're holding back and biding time.
Star Wars tread these waters with Lucas' divisive prequel trilogy, paralleling the story of Anakin Skywalker's journey from good to evil with the Old Republic's similar journey under a string of corrupt and ineffectual leaders culminating in the rise of Emperor Palpatine and the Galactic Empire. The difference is that no matter what is added to it or when, Star Wars is one long story. Even if you distinguish between the plots and subplots of the various movies, their inter-connectivity makes it dangerous to the telling of that overall tale to leave any one of those story lines out.
Gotham is one city with any number of different characters, stories, and threats which, were it real, could have different outcomes. With Gordon presented as the reliable cop we've always known, the problem worsens by limiting how much he can be grow and be changed by the series' events and its other characters.
2. Wasting Leslie Thompkins
Gotham's diverse and nuanced women include precociously defiant Selina Kyle, the privileged alcoholic Barbara Kean, Captain Sarah Essen, and mousy sexpot Kristen Kringle, who literally drives "riddle man" Edward Nygma mad.
Perhaps it was inevitable that Gotham introduce what is arguably its most two-dimensional female character to date: Leslie Thompkins, who means far more in the comics. Created by writer/editor Dennis O'Neil, Leslie is a friend and colleague of Thomas and Martha Wayne who not only runs a shelter and free clinic, but is so close to Bruce that she eventually knows he's Batman.
On Gotham, she meets Gordon while working as a physician in Arkham and takes the GCPD coroner's job to be near him. This would be fine save for the missed opportunity to better connect the Wayne family and Bruce's story to the rest of the show. For the first time on any screen, we could have already seen something new in young Bruce dealing with a surrogate mother figure!
Instead, we likely have a temporary companion for Gordon until future wife Barbara dodges a life sentence and returns to sanity. As faithfully depicted in shows like Batman: The Animated Series, Gotham's Leslie Thompkins could have enriched young Bruce's story, giving him as well as the show another, perhaps clearer perspective on Bruce's function going forward and his evolution into the dark knight.
1. Should This Have Really Been About Bruce?
Since Batman is Bruce Wayne and there would be no Gotham without him, whether the show should have been about Bruce is an obvious question. However, it's a double-edged sword.
Many wondered if Gordon would keep his promise to solve the Waynes' murder in Gotham's first season. One criticism has been that this promise went from promimence to being dropped before November Sweeps. That matters because it potentially affects our perception of Gordon as the righteous cop he's supposed to be.
Can Gordon really carry his own show? Even Batman: Year One has Batman in it. Though intended to be Gotham's main character, the villains already overshadow him.
We could have had a show about Bruce as a troubled Encyclopedia Brown, personally motivated to solve crimes with Selina as a rebellious "my girl Friday" and Gordon a secret police contact. Even if things are better as-is, Bruce and his parents' unsolved case could become a dangerous distraction indicative of a priorities problem.
Gotham is still entertaining, yet maybe it should have been a more traditional police procedural, with Bruce relegated to the pilot and the thought of super-villains rare. At least then, Gordon and associates could have had more time to develop without the near-constant teases and disingenuous fan-service which, like cheese in a mouse trap, can never be fully consumed or enjoyed.