8 Things Yellowjackets Does Better Than Lost
What's the best show about plane crash survivors? There's only one way to find out...
One of 2021's best new dramas, Yellowjackets, focuses on the survivors of a plane crash as they fight to survive in an isolated wilderness. Flashbacks and flashforwards tell the stories of the survivors both before and after the crash, providing tantalising hints of what's to come as the fallout from the accident plays out.
There's an over-arching mystery, strange symbols etched in the trees and disturbing hallucinations. If all of this sounds familiar, then you'd be absolutely right, it sounds like 2005's best new drama Lost, that captured the imagination of viewers worldwide before eventually running out of steam.
However, almost everything about the first series of Yellowjackets suggests that this is a series that will avoid the pitfalls of the Lindelof/Abrams/Cuse show. You feel as if creators Ashley Lyle and Bart Nickerson have the series mapped out in a way that Lost never quite did. Of course, Yellowjackets is only in season 1, and everyone loved Lost season 1, so it remains to be seen whether or not the show can stick the landing.
For now though, here are 8 things that Yellowjackets is already doing better than Lost. There will be spoilers throughout.
8. The Mysticism
One of the most obvious links between Lost and Yellowjackets, plane crash aside, is both series' strange, mystical overtones. While Lost almost immediately doubled down on the "magic island" conceit (curing cancer, restoring Locke's mobility), Yellowjackets plays its cards closer to its chest. Almost every strange happening can be explained by the survivors' trauma, isolation and paranoia.
Where Lost was very much about faith and philosophy, Yellowjackets is a Lord of the Flies style metaphor for teenage hierarchy. A group of teenage girls, stranded in the middle of nowhere, forming a cannibalistic cult isn't necessarily the result of some unseen forces in the forest wilderness. It's just as easily explained as an extreme response to teenage hormones, clique mentality, starvation and isolation.
Where the island in Lost continued to have some mystical hold on each of the Oceanic Six, the Canadian wilderness is a gaping wound for the surviving Yellowjackets. It's a reminder of how close they came to savage barbarism, something they're trying and failing to suppress in their adult lives. Was it the result of teenage clique mentality or something more supernatural? It's a more compelling story than a magic island in need of a guardian.
7. The Comedy
Lost was very much a show that had a comic relief character in the form of Hurley, and the sarcastic, charismatic conman Sawyer. The rest of the series, and the characters, were either paper-thin hero and villain archetypes or compelling enigmas. Yellowjackets, on the other hand can be incredibly funny.
The series has a rich undercurrent of black comedy. Christina Ricci, for example, is phenomenal as the sweet, smiling sociopathic adult Misty who gets the lion's share of the comedy. Meanwhile, Melanie Lynskey excels at the suburban ennui that gives way to the sort of absurdist comedy that can be found in a Coens movie. Juliette Lewis is the Sawyer of the group, archly funny but with an obvious vulnerable side.
Meanwhile, in the survival timeline of the crash's immediate aftermath, the juxtaposition of teen movie tropes and archetypes with a creepy forest and a desperate fight to survive provides much potential for black comedy. For example, the younger Shauna's dream of giving birth to a rotisserie chicken is equal parts horrifying and hilarious. It's this comic sensibility that prevents Yellowjackets from falling into Lost's trap of being too worthy and po-faced.
6. The Power Dynamics
Lost was a very macho affair. The ongoing leadership battle between handsome doctor Jack, charming con-man Sawyer and mysterious sage Locke formed the crux of the character drama. It was a hierarchy that was also a shallow meritocracy, Jack was automatically assumed to be the leader because he had the most respectable job. While Lost interrogated that meritocracy throughout the series, Yellowjackets immediately subverts it.
If Yellowjackets was Lost then Jackie, the captain of the soccer team, would automatically become the leader of the survivors. Instead, she's presented as a mere figurehead - she's not even particularly good at soccer. As the survivors try to make sense of their new lives, Jackie is content to sit back and wait for help to arrive, which leads to tensions within the group.
The two people who immediately show themselves to have leadership qualities are Taissa and Misty. Taissa is the true power behind the team, conspiring to get rid of their weakest player before the tournament. It's she who takes it upon herself to lead the group from the crash site towards potential civilization rather than impotently wait for help. Meanwhile, the bullied and belittled Misty shows herself to have excellent survival skills, quickly earning the trust of those who once spread baseless gossip about her.
5. The Portrayal of Trauma
The characters in Lost were all damaged individuals. Charlie was a drug addict, Locke was betrayed by his father, and Jack turned to the bottle. The problem was that each of the Oceanic 6's traumas often felt like character traits rather than lived experience. Yellowjackets' glimpses of the traumas experienced by the survivors before and after the crash are used sparingly, to subtly add layers and explanations for some of the character's odd behaviours.
Taissa, for example, is a sleepwalker, which appears to be a trauma response. As a child, it's revealed that she sat by her grandmother's bedside as she died. Could this be the root cause for her condition? Or is there something darker and more supernatural behind it? Meanwhile, Natalie and Travis' experiences in the wilderness have led to their substance abuse issues in adulthood.
Rather than being a cheap character trait, Natalie and Travis' addiction and toxic relationship forms a key part of the ongoing mystery in the 25 years later timeline. Despite their emotional scars, they both vowed never to end their lives by suicide. When Travis is found hanged, Natalie refuses to believe he went back on their promise. As the series continues, it becomes apparent that she may be correct.
4. The Episode Count
Many of the problems with Lost can be traced back to its initial success in popular culture. It was one of the most-talked about series in the mid-2000s and, as with so much network television at the time, was re-commissioned as twenty-plus episode seasons. Eventually, the creative team were able to reduce the episode count and bring the story back into focus.
With a lean ten episodes per season, Yellowjackets could avoid the problems of Lost's bloated early seasons. It allows for the writers to focus in on the story that they want to tell without having to introduce a hitherto unseen group of survivors or a charismatic Scottish vault dweller with which to pad out each episodes.
It also reduces the risk of the wild tangents that Lost was often prone to (did anyone really need to know the origins of Jack's tattoos?) Did we need to get to know the full story of Nikki and Paulo? Without Lost's baggy pacing, Yellowjackets can keep the many mysteries ticking along in a compelling way that won't alienate the audience.
3. Flashbacks Are Used Sparingly
As with Lost, there are two timelines in Yellowjackets. There's the immediate aftermath of the crash and what happens to the survivors 25 years later. Each timeline compliments the other, teeing up what the viewer can expect to happen while also pulling the rug from under them. It's a smart narrative device that constantly plays on expectations.
It also means that half an episode isn't taken up by backstory that's irrelevant to the plot. When Lost did a flashback (or flashforward) well, they were extraordinary, shifting your understanding of the characters. When they were bad though, well, they were Jack's tattoos. Outside of the two main timelines, Yellowjackets deploys a similar trick, flashing back to the pre-crash lives of the team.
They rarely form as large a part of the episode as the Lost flashbacks did, likely because there's so much going on elsewhere. However, they provide valuable insights into character motivations. The opening of the episode Flight of the Bumblebee is pure Lost, as Laura Lee's life is saved at a Christian summer camp. Believing she was saved by God, Laura Lee feels her purpose is to rescue her fellow teammates. She's proved devastatingly wrong.
2. The Over-Arching Plot Feels More Focused
What was Lost actually about? Was it the story of a group of plane crash survivors who found renewed purpose? Or was it the story of a mythical battle between good and evil on a magical island? Were they dead all along? A bit of all three. Over six seasons, Lost's core story became increasingly muddled.
Yellowjackets' plot is more focused. What led the team to turn to cannibalism in the wilderness and how is that barbarism bleeding into their adult lives? What helps the series' focus immensely is that the "25 years later" timeline is centered on only four of the survivors - Shauna, Taissa, Natalie and Misty. It's confirmed that there are more survivors in the cliffhanger to season 1, but they will advance the story rather than divert its course.
Through necessity of being a network show, Lost was forced to throw in various red herrings and introduce new characters to keep things interesting. Streaming and the increased reverence of creators has changed the TV landscape, so Yellowjackets doesn't need to bow to network pressure for more episodes and syndication rights. This hopefully means Yellowjackets can tell the story in its own time, revealing more information about the survivors' teenage experiences in the wilderness and the mysterious cult operating 25 years later.
1. The Characters Feel Like Real People
It's clear from how trauma is portrayed in Yellowjackets that the characters feel more like real people than they often did Lost. Initially the plane is full of teen movie archetypes - the hot girl, her shy best friend, the goth, the geek. These archetypes are immediately subverted and each character feels more nuanced as a result. For example, Shauna might be Jackie's best friend, but she's also sleeping with her boyfriend.
Meanwhile, Misty's bullied geek has an unrequited crush on the team's coach. Like John Locke in Lost, however, Misty finds a renewed purpose and exalted position in the wilderness. Her quick thinking and survival skills make her a valuable member of the group, and allow her to become closer to her crush.
She's still a teenage girl who wants approval from her peers, though. Misty destroys the plane's black box, securing her new position and making it harder for any potential rescue party to locate the crash site. In the wrong writer's hands, this could be a villainous act, but it feels like the type of selfish and insecure decision a real person may make under pressure.
Misty and Shauna just scratch the surface of the depth and nuance of Yellowjackets's characters. They're a far cry from Lost's conman with a heart of gold and drug addict rockstar.