9 Characters Who Saved Failing TV Shows

Knights in shining prop armor.

By Jacob Trowbridge /

Sustained success for a TV show isn't always easy. Consistent quality is never a given -- unless the show has the words Law & Order somewhere in its title -- and even the most critically-acclaimed, ratings darlings are bound to hit a slump somewhere in their run. When that happens, it might be necessary to inject some new blood into the mix.

Advertisement

The same can be said for a show that hits the skids right out of the gate. There are plenty of examples of soon-to-be iconic TV shows that didn't quite catch on with the public until a couple of seasons in. What changed? Sometimes just a cast member or two.

Getting audiences to fall in love with a new character can be tough, as well, and it's certainly no guarantee that this fresh face will revive a show all by themselves. In fact, they may just ruin the show once and for all. (We call this the "Cousin Oliver Syndrome.")

But every once in a while there comes a knight in shining prop armor -- a savior backed by the majestic sounds of a laugh track -- riding onto set in a white trailer to save the day. These are those characters.

9. Castiel - Supernatural

Castiel is a comically serious fallen angel sent to help Sam and Dean Winchester in their battle against Satan. He's an emotionless, hopelessly deadpan, secret badass who constantly fails to grasp the intricacies of the human condition. Basically, he's Spock in an overcoat.

Advertisement

Castiel arrived at the opening of Season 4, promising a much more grandiose mythology for the show to riff on. His wasn't your typical "monster of the week" storyline, which the show had pretty much driven into the ground after three seasons. The emergence of Cas hinted at an epic tale of good versus evil that would propel the show into its finest hour: the Season 5 finale.

Castiel may have been unfeeling, but his injection into the show ironically proved its capabilities as an emotional powerhouse. And it's inconceivable to think that the pre-Cas version of Supernatural -- find monster, kill monster, discover much more evil monster on the horizon, repeat -- could have lasted nearly 300 episodes.

Also, let's not play coy here. The dynamic between Dean and Castiel is much more satisfying than the angsty, brotherly love/hate thing Dean and Sam have been trotting out for over a decade. Their fictitious friendship is as strong as any that's ever been written for a television serial, and a major reason viewers keep tuning in.

8. Robert California - The Office

Love him or loathe him, James Spader's kooky, pseudo-philosophical turn as Robert California is what kept the engine running on The Office after Steve Carrell's unfortunate exit from the show. Michael Scott was undoubtedly the lifeblood of the American adaptation, and without him, viewers were rightfully weary of tuning in to watch a show without its heart.

Advertisement

You can argue that the show should never have continued without Carrell. And, in fact, the last two seasons truly felt like a bizarro version of The Office, where the rules of the natural universe no longer applied to Scranton, Pennsylvania. There, "The Lizard King" Robert California thrived.

Spader was brought aboard via a lightning round of stunt casting that also included the likes of Jim Carrey, Ricky Gervais, and Ray Romano, all of whom played various weirdoes and doofuses interviewing for the branch manager vacancy left by Michael Scott.

Spader didn't feel like a natural fit for the show, which might have been his most appealing trait. After watching the writers struggle to shoehorn a "Michael Scott type" into the old position -- most cruelly with the shell of Andy Bernard -- it was refreshing to see someone so unlike anyone else in the show's grounded universe take the reigns for a bit.

7. Frankie Dart - Community

"Six seasons and a movie." That was the rallying cry of Community's fanbase pretty much from the beginning. Initially just a throwaway line by Abed, the catchphrase became a beacon of hope for fans to cling to as NBC executives constantly toyed with cancelling the show.

Advertisement

Once it started hemorrhaging cast members -- Chevy Chase, Donald Glover, Yvette Nicole Brown, John Oliver, and Jonathan Banks (who left after one season) -- it seemed highly unlikely NBC would help fulfill the "six seasons" portion of that prophecy. And they didn't.

But to the rescue came an unlikely trio of heroes: Paget Brewster, Keith David...and Yahoo! Screen. Yes, the show transitioned from an actual network to little-known Yahoo! Screen for its sixth season. But more importantly, Brewster was added to the tight-knit ensemble as efficiency expert Frankie Dart.

Truth is, the show had gotten too kooky for its own good. The characters and the environment had become too weird to be taken seriously, and the only way to get any sense of sanity back was to bring in an outsider who would call them on all their crap. Frankie became a much-needed barometer for what "normal" looks like inside Greendale's bizarro campus. It made Community feel more like the classic show of old more than any genre episode ever could. And Frankie helped the cult classic achieve at least one of its goals.

6. Alan Shore - The Practice

Oh, would ya look at that. More James Spader. With all due respect to Dwayne Johnson, it seems like Spader was the original "franchise Viagra", at least when it comes to failing television.

Advertisement

For the uninitiated, The Practice was an Emmy-winning legal procedural about how Dylan McDermott handles being a very handsome lawyer in Boston. And presumably some other stuff, too. The show ran for 8 seasons, but towards the end, ratings had sunk so much that the show was forced to say goodbye to its high-priced stars, McDermott and Lara Flynn Boyle.

In their stead, Spader and William Shatner came in to liven things up a bit. Shatner was great, but it was Spader -- as Alan Shore, a morally righteous lawyer who nevertheless had no qualms about getting justice through the use of distasteful methods -- that truly refocused the show's energy. He brought a sense of levity to the increasingly stuffy series.

The duo were such a success with fans that they were quickly shuffled off onto their own spin-off, Boston Legal, where they could work more freely, without having to carry their cohorts across the finish line.

So while he may not have technically "saved" the show he was added into, Spader's presence was so invigorating he actually spawned a new one. That's some Frasier-like rejuvenation, folks.

5. Seven Of Nine - Star Trek: Voyager

It can be tough getting Star Trek fans to agree on which is the best TV series in the long-running franchise, but one thing's for certain: No one's picking Voyager. It was a pleasant enough sci-fi romp for the most part, but especially in the earlier seasons, there just wasn't much to connect to.

Advertisement

There was no Kirk or Spock or Sisko or Picard to magnetize the audience. (Captain Janeway was interesting, but the writers never had a firm enough grasp on her.) It wasn't until the 4th season the show finally hit on a character that fans could really get on board with, and the ratings spiked accordingly.

Make no mistake, Seven of Nine appeared to be nothing more than fan service when she first arrived on Voyager. Putting Jeri Ryan in a form-fitting catsuit that served no story purpose certainly didn't help that perception.

Yet, the more we saw of her character, the more nuanced and compelling she became. A former enemy of the Federation who suddenly wished to join them, a brainwashed Borg drone slowly recuperating and finding her true self along the way, and a Spock-ian sense of morality? All shoved into a skin-tight uniform?

No wonder she propelled the show through another four seasons and has since become the face of the series.

4. Ben Wyatt - Parks & Recreation

Mark Brendanawicz had to go. Anyone who suffered through the first season knew that this makeshift Jim Halpert clone -- pasted together using pieces of worn-in sweatshirts and the scraps of so many drab one-liners written on soiled bar napkins -- was not long for Pawnee. He simply wasn't right for the show, especially once it began to step out from The Office's shadow.

Advertisement

So it was goodbye, Bland-anawicz, and hello Ben Wyatt. Adam Scott's Ben was also a little drab, but his judgmental gaze always felt earned. And sure, he may have played the straight man 95 percent of the time, but the other 5 percent was spent weeping inside a Batman costume, inexplicably freaking out around police officers, and obsessing over calzones. Finally, Parks & Rec had found its relatable center.

Some may argue it was really Rob Lowe -- playing Ben's happy-go-lucky auditing pal, Chris Traeger -- that saved the show from cancellation, but his always felt more like a case of stunt casting gone remarkably well. It was Wyatt's presence, and his relationship with Deputy Director-turned Councilwoman-turned Governor Leslie Knope, that anchored the show in the later seasons.

It wasn't exactly an outright swap, but it definitely felt like Adam Scott's character had fulfilled a role the writers didn't quite know how to position Brendana-quitz into. The move no doubt saved the show.

3. Amanda Woodward - Melrose Place

Melrose Place is best remembered for its soap opera trashiness, extravagantly dark storylines, and overall "bitchiness" amongst the characters...none of which was a part of the show's DNA until Heather Locklear showed up.

Advertisement

Prior to the arrival of ad exec Amanda Woodward, Melrose was a cheesy Beverly Hills, 90210 spin-off that neatly wrapped up every episode's morality tale in a neat little bow. It was like a series of "very special episodes" that preached to its viewers about the virtues of clean living. It didn't indulge in any of the more unsavory aspects of life. It was supremely boring.

Post-Amanda, however, "unsavory" became the show's calling card. And the over-the-top drama ramped up in accordance with the show's ratings.

Locklear came onto Melrose late in its first season when the show was sinking fast. Her character became a life preserver for everyone attached, as Amanda's nasty one-liners and sexual conniving became synonymous with the series' turn toward must-see television. Gone was the silly, twentysomething sanctimony, replaced with all the guilty pleasures viewers could handle.

Its place in primetime infamy would have been fleeting at best were it not for Locklear's inclusion.

2. Stone Cold Steve Austin - WWE Monday Night Raw

One of the longest-running active programs on television, WWE Raw might've been destined for the dust bin -- along with the entirety of Vince McMahon's falling empire -- had it not been for one man: Stone Cold Steve Austin.

Advertisement

Like Hulk Hogan a decade before him, Austin became the face of the company at a time when interest in wrestling culture was at a low. It simply wasn't "cool" to tune in and watch flamboyantly-dressed dudes bounce each other off the turnbuckle in an overly-dramatic fashion.

Stone Cold signified a serious cultural shift in the industry, forgoing the bright colors, doofy gimmicks, and squeaky clean images that mid-90s WWE was still trying to push. This guy wore black and had a smoking skull as part of his logo, he cussed out his opponents, chugged beer, and beat the living crap out of his boss on the regular.

During the now-infamous Monday Night Wars, in which WWE was going head-to-head with rival brand WCW in a battle for ratings supremacy, Stone Cold ushered in the so-called "Attitude Era," which remains one of the most aggressively-beloved periods in the company's history.

Pretty much every wrestling fan -- and even Vince McMahon himself -- can agree that without Stone Cold storming through the curtain every week, the WWE as we know it may have failed to exist, and WWE Raw would be little more than a relic.

1. Frank Reynolds - It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia

It's no secret that without Danny DeVito, the weird and wicked smorgasbord of uncomfortable laughs known simply to fans as "It's Sunny" could never have become one of the longest-running comedy shows on television.

Advertisement

In the first season of this Philly-based black comedy, there was no star power to behold. It was a cast of unknowns, who were also the creators and writers of the show, engaging in a series of twisted, repugnant acts -- pretending to have cancer, hitting on women at an abortion rally, getting teenagers drunk and trying to have sex with them. It's easy to see why the ratings were flatlining.

Rob McElhenney (Mac) and Glenn Howerton (Dennis) recalled on The Nerdist podcast how, before Season 2 was to begin, the president of FX told them to add a big name to the show or it would be yanked off the air. They needed a recognizable face to get people talking, because the network had no money to market the show. Hence, Frank Reynolds suddenly re-entering his children's lives.

It's not just that the ratings got a shot in the arm after DeVito came onboard, it's that the show somehow became even weirder once he arrived. Thinking about It's Always Sunny without the ever-bizarre presence of Frank Reynolds now is like picturing WrestleMania III without Hulk Hogan. It could work, but there's no way it becomes as iconic without that missing piece.

Which other TV characters saved struggling shows? Share your picks down in the comments.

Advertisement