Altered Carbon Season 2 Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs

An inconsistent second season for Netflix's sci-fi romp.

By Jack Pooley /

Netflix

After an agonising two-year wait, the second season of mega-budget sci-fi series Altered Carbon has finally dropped on Netflix - though given their baffling lack of marketing, you'd hardly know it.

Advertisement

The first season received much attention for its unique genre premise and undeniably blockbuster-caliber production values, even if many ultimately felt that the series didn't quite realise the full potential of Richard K. Morgan's 2002 source novel.

Season two effectively acts as a soft-reboot for the show, with protagonist Takeshi Kovacs once again being re-sleeved, this time with Anthony Mackie taking over the lead role from solid forebear Joel Kinnaman.

Advertisement

It's a transition that's mostly effortless, yet while the show retains most of the first season's lavish wow-factor, it's still the storytelling that's in desperate need of greater nuance and clarity.

Though this new season gets plenty right, it doesn't quite feel like the decisive improvement that many pre-release reviews have hailed it as, but rather a consistent follow-up that largely retains the same positives and negatives...

Advertisement

Downs...

5. The Insanely Convoluted Storytelling

Netflix

Season one received plenty of criticism for its hyper-convoluted plot, which tied itself in an almost hilarious amount of knots throughout its 10-episode run.

Advertisement

And though the second season is two episodes shorter, it still feels almost as overbearingly "complex" as its predecessor.

That is to say, showrunner Laeta Kalogridis has made the classic mistake of assuming that more plot guarantees a better plot.

Advertisement

While the conflict at the core of this season is actually fairly simple when you boil it down, it's padded out with so much flabby backstory, so much expository dialogue, and so many absurd plot twists that, by season's end, it's tough to care much about the outcome.

Though the season fleshes out the extent to which both sleeves and stacks can be used and abused, ultimately the lack of clarity regarding the show's rules makes the show almost paradoxically predictable in its unpredictability: nothing is surprising, because everything is.

Advertisement

There's no clear logical framework for the audience to latch onto, and so it's tough to become fully invested in what's going on.

4. The Disappointingly Sanitised Tone

Netflix

One of the big plusses of the first season was its aggressively adult tone: there are desperately few "mature" sci-fi shows operating at this budget, and so season one's high abundance of both gore and nudity was hugely refreshing.

Advertisement

The nudity in particular was unsurprisingly controversial with critics, but rather than simply scale back the male gaze for this season - or better yet, turn the gaze around on the show's many male subjects - it instead strips back a lot of the explicit content, as is sure to disappoint many.

There are still violent action scenes and frequent spurts of blood, for sure, but nudity in particular has been noticeably curtailed, and the generally nastier, rougher tone of season one feels massively softened on the whole.

Advertisement

It's as though Netflix wants to try and make the show more appealing to a broader audience, even if anyone who tries to watch season two standalone will surely find themselves thoroughly confused.

3. Danica Harlan Is A Totally Mediocre Villain

Netflix

Another area where season one unarguably wins out is with its villain: the reveal that Takeshi's sister Rei (Dichen Lachman) was the ultimate antagonist was both surprising and morally ambiguous enough to remain interesting.

Advertisement

But season two defers to a far more ordinary - and, honestly, quite boring - villain, with the stern new governor of Harlan's World, Danica Harlan (Lela Loren), attempting to fill Rei's void.

Though Loren certainly gives it her all in role, Harlan as written isn't much more than a generic, pant suit-wearing megalomaniacal schemer.

Advertisement

Ultimately far more interesting is Colonel Ivan Carrera (Torben Liebrecht), the leader of an elite paramilitary unit called The Wedge that is sent after Kovacs, though sadly he doesn't get nearly as much to do as Harlan.

2. The (Mostly) Mediocre Action Sequences

Netflix

The first season boasted a number of memorable and stylishly shot action sequences, which ensured every single penny of the show's budget was splashed on the screen for viewers to savour.

Advertisement

If season one was lucky enough to have landed directors with acclaimed Game of Thrones episodes on their CVs, most of this season's directorial talent has rather disappointingly been plucked from the Marvel Netflix pool - and it really, really shows.

All the Marvel Netflix shows not called Daredevil were routinely criticised for their generic, choppy action sequences, and those criticisms depressingly carry over to the directors' work on this season of Altered Carbon.

Advertisement

Aside from an amusingly extended Gladiator-inspired coliseum showdown early in the season, the majority of the set-pieces lack kinetic flair and just feel utterly pedestrian in the way they're shot, edited, and presented to the viewer.

Where is the energy and the creativity that made season one's action so memorable and distinctive?

Advertisement

1. The Frequently Cringe-Worthy Dialogue

Netflix

Though a considerable bulk of the season's dialogue is comprised of comically unsubtle exposition, there are also numerous times where the chit-chat lurches into straight-up cornball, even embarrassing territory.

Advertisement

There are so many instances of hackneyed, seemingly placeholder dialogue that somehow made it past the drafting process and into the final shooting script.

If you've seen more than a fantasy show or two in your time, you'll be able to predict countless cliched lines of dialogue before they're spoken, even though the ensemble cast admirably attempts to sell them as sincerely as humanly possible.

Advertisement

Aside from the occasionally thought-provoking morsel, the majority of the dialogue is either forgettable in its robotic efficiency, or lazy enough to induce actual laughter.

So, Altered Carbon's second season isn't the persuasive improvement most were hoping for, then. But it still gets a lot right that makes it at least worth trying out...

Advertisement

Ups...

5. The Shorter Season Totally Works

Netflix

Netflix has been taking noticeable steps to combat the infamous "Netflix bloat" problem that has characterised so many of their Original properties, and Altered Carbon is the latest to return to screens with a sensibly curtailed new season.

Advertisement

Though season one was hardly an excruciating sit at "only" 10 episodes, the dubious quality of the storytelling ensured many viewers nevertheless felt exhausted by the end.

By ditching two episodes and opting for a shortened eight-episode order, season two immediately feels more svelte and light on its feet, and even with its aforementioned scripting issues, it doesn't test the patience nearly as much as what came before.

Advertisement

For those keen to binge, you can reach the end of this season in a single day without feeling completely and utterly drained, as is thankfully becoming far more common with Netflix Originals.

4. Anthony Mackie Makes For A Compelling Takeshi

Netflix

Joel Kinnaman certainly did a rock solid job playing the re-sleeved Takeshi in the first season, and few were complaining when the ever-reliable Anthony Mackie was cast to replace him as season two's new Takeshi sleeve.

Advertisement

True to form, Mackie brings his typical brooding intensity to the role, even if it's undeniably underwritten and, as such, Mackie's often given little of interest to populate his performance with.

While there perhaps isn't a hugely noticeable continuity between Kinnaman and Mackie's performances, Mackie still commands the screen at almost all times, and helps keep the series afloat through some of its snoozier moments.

Advertisement

3. The STUNNING Visuals

Netflix

More than anything else, you cannot deny how utterly eye-wateringly beautiful the first season of Altered Carbon was.

Advertisement

Netflix reportedly spent a stonking $7 million per episode, and between the incredibly lived-in sets, first-rate visual effects, and exceptional cinematography, it was clear where the money was going.

Similarly, season two is an absolute technical marvel, and offers one of the most visually impressive 4K HDR presentations currently available on the streaming platform.

Advertisement

Even with the disappointing flatness of the action sequences, the vast majority of the season is a gorgeous joy to behold, making it a rarest of sci-fi TV shows that's likely to age shockingly well in the years to come.

2. The Terrific Supporting Cast

Netflix

The show's ensemble cast continues to be a major strong suit, with season two once again lending the meatiest supporting role to Chris Conner, whose charming A.I. Poe continues to be the heart and soul of the series.

Advertisement

Elsewhere Renée Elise Goldsberry is afforded a greatly expanded role as Takeshi's lover Quellcrist Falconer, and Torben Liebrecht is a hoot as the villainous grunt Colonel Carrera.

But easily the sharpest addition to the cast this season is Luke Cage's Simone Missick, who joins the series as bounty hunter Trepp and whose overpowering screen presence damn-near wrestles scenes away from even Anthony Mackie.

Advertisement

No matter how badly the script falters, as it often does, the cast does their level best to make it work, and without such strong casting, it'd be decidedly tougher to make it through some of the shoddier writing.

1. There's A Neat Hook For Season 3

Netflix

No spoilers here of course, but the season certainly ends with a compelling enticement for the inevitable follow-up, even if it's perhaps not quite the hook you were expecting.

Advertisement

It's left unclear who may or may not be playing the Takeshi role in season three - at this point, the opportunities are clearly myriad - but an arguably more intriguing final tease leaves audiences to ponder what its ambiguous imagery actually means.

While the show could certainly wrap up at this point and feel tidy enough - fans will surely be clenching until Netflix formally confirms a third go-around - the implied setup for the future is both wide-open and compelling.

Advertisement