American Vandal Season 2 Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs

#WhoIsTheTurdBurglar.

By Jack Pooley /

Netflix

American Vandal took the world by storm last year with its wildly unexpected universal acclaim, and the much-anticipated second season is now available to stream on Netflix. Critics have been going gaga over it already, and with damn good reason.

Advertisement

Netflix smartly kept their advertising campaign for season two incredibly low-key, dropping just a brief, non-specific trailer that established the primary mystery while keeping details to an absolute minimum.

The result is a frequently surprising, expectation-defying follow-up to one of the most fiercely original new shows of 2017.

Advertisement

While season one set an extremely high bar for its successor to clear, the show's creators Dan Perrault and Tony Yacenda once again demonstrate a keen eye for our tech-infused world, the awkwardness of the high school experience and also the documentary form.

If you loved season one, it's hard to imagine you not enjoying the hell out of this ludicrously entertaining and often quite bold slice of dramatic mockumentary madness...

Advertisement

Downs...

2. There's Less Comedy, More Drama

Netflix

The most obvious difference from the show's first season - apart from its new setting - is the shift in tone.

Advertisement

Though American Vandal can still be called a comedy, the broader humour of season one has mostly been ditched in favour of a more serious and dramatic story.

While there are laughs to be had, it's actually pretty surprising how long can pass between jokes in season two, and as fantastic as the drama is, you might find yourself wishing for things to be a little funnier every so often.

Advertisement

It's a creative decision that's likely to divide fans to begin with, though by the end of the season, you'll likely be so captivated regardless that you won't much care.

1. It Lacks The Freshness Of The First Season

Netflix

Season one was such a unique breath of fresh air that attempting to follow it up just a year later is a brave and potentially thankless task. Terrifically crafted though it is for the most part, there's no denying that the gonzo originality of that first season can't quite be matched here, and certainly not topped.

Advertisement

Stylistically and creatively, it feels like a more confident iteration of what came before, though at the same time it does also recycle some narrative elements and effectively operate within a wheelhouse some may find overly familiar.

It should be stressed that these are relatively minor qualms in the scope of the season, though, and if you loved season one, you should have a blast with this follow-up. Meanwhile, here's everything the new season gets right...

Advertisement

Ups...

7. A Fascinating Central Mystery

Netflix

The #WhoDrewTheDicks mystery was so absurdly, compulsively compelling last year that season two really needed a mighty yarn to succeed it, and the Turd Burglar saga is more than up to the job.

Advertisement

Like the dick-drawing debacle of season one, it takes an inherently crude, childish concept and imbues it with stakes that feel life-or-death. Each of the season's eight episodes are jam-packed with new twists and turns, shifts on perspective as new context is added, red herrings and, of course, the customary cliffhangers.

It all adds up to an enigma that's as fascinating as any legit true crime documentary you could otherwise watch on the streaming platform, and the fact it's about a serial poo pandit terrorising a well-off Catholic school makes it all the more entertaining.

Advertisement

6. It's A Timely, Thought-Provoking Social Satire

Netflix

It'd be easy for a show like this to simply wrap a scatalogical joke around a glossy documentary format and call it a day, but as we know, American Vandal is a far more nuanced and socially conscious show than that.

Advertisement

Season two ramps up the social satire and commentary considerably, riffing on the toxic power of social media, the police, the interplay between sports and academia, race, white privilege, Internet trolls and much more.

That it hits every single one of these targets without feeling on-the-nose or like it's standing on a soapbox is all the more impressive: it's woven tightly into the fabric of the story and the characters within it.

Advertisement

And while the satire does indeed provoke laughs, ultimately you'll probably find its indictment of today's tech-centric culture to be more unsettling than funny.

5. The INSANE Production Values

Netflix

A big part of the reason American Vandal can be so funny is because it actually boasts the production values to match a high-brow "prestige" documentary like Making a Murderer.

Advertisement

The season opens with an hysterical explanation for the high school doc's big-budget visuals, which are again absolutely first-rate here. The eye-popping cinematography, slick titles sequence, abundance of beautifully-shot reconstructions and pin-sharp editing all combine to make this another gorgeously crafted season.

While it's the script and acting that truly elevate the show, the self-consciously overproduced sheen adds an extra layer of glorious meta-satire. Seriously, this thing looks absolutely spectacular in 4K HDR.

Advertisement

4. It's Genuinely Poignant & Affecting

Netflix

American Vandal's inaugural season achieved a surprising mix of gut-laughs and emotionally resonant character development, but the second season's more serious tone allows it to go to some deeper, more affecting places.

Advertisement

It's nothing short of staggering that a show revolving around a fecal terrorist can be this involving on a character-driven dramatic level, but it really is.

Inevitably as the show goes on, we learn more about the complexities of characters who could so easily adhere to brash stereotypes. The majority of the focal figures have some sort of sadness or obstacle in their lives that makes them easily relatable.

Advertisement

That the end of the season might even leave the mildest lump in your throat, after spending just a few scant hours with these characters no less, is a major achievement in scripting and performance. Speaking of which...

3. The Performances Are Incredible

Netflix

Season one was an impeccably well-cast affair, boasting a cast of largely unknown actors who were absolutely note-perfect for their roles. And while there's no performance here quite as wonderful as Jimmy Tatro's Dylan Maxwell, the entire ensemble is absolutely marvellous regardless.

Advertisement

Especially terrific are Travis Tope as focal misfit Kevin McClain, Melvin Gregg as charismatic basketball star DeMarcus Tillman and Bryan Cranston's daughter Taylor Dearden as Kevin's estranged friend Chloe Lyman.

Across the board, the performances don't put a foot wrong: everyone seems to be on the same tonal keel, with nobody playing their parts too broad or cartoonish, ensuring the show as a whole doesn't tip its hat to the audience too overtly.

Advertisement

2. It's Sensibly Standalone

Netflix

There was a lot of pre-release speculation that this new season might have a surprising tie-in to season one, but thankfully, the new series is an almost completely standalone offering.

Advertisement

Apart from Peter (Tyler Alvarez) and Sam (Griffin Gluck) returning as our documentarians, there aren't any contrived, forced links back to the #WhoDrewTheDicks phenomenon, nor really many callbacks or references to speak of.

It's for the best, really, because the season's going to be unavoidably compared to what came before regardless, so there's no need to encourage that further by, say, giving Dylan a cameo or something.

Advertisement

1. It's Netflix's Most Binge-Worthy Series In AGES

Netflix

With its agonisingly engrossing central mystery, American Vandal continues to be arguably the most bingeable show in Netflix's streaming line-up. Furthermore, with just eight half-hour episodes on offer, it's hardly a colossal time investment, and most could easily binge through the entire batch in a single, four-hour sitting.

Advertisement

Dan Perrault and Tony Yacenda have a perfect understanding of how to sufficiently escalate their story while keeping viewers gripped, and though some will prefer to dole episodes out to prolong the suspense, the compulsive appeal of just sitting back and soaking it all in at once is undeniable.

If you've got four hours to spare this weekend, it absolutely has to be done.

Advertisement

What did you think of American Vandal's second season? Shout it out in the comments!