Arrested Development Season 5 Review: 6 Ups And 3 Downs
There's (still) always money in the banana stand.
Arrested Development is one of the greatest sitcoms of the century - perhaps, even, of all time - and yet it's also one of the unluckiest.
Never popular when it was actually on air, the show fought and eventually lost against cancellation over the course of its brilliant three-season run on Fox from 2003-06, and was maybe a show ahead of its time (see how similar meta-comedies like Community and 30 Rock arrived in its wake).
That led to the series gaining a cult following, and eventually a little streaming service called Netflix picked it up for a revival. The fourth season, which came back in 2013, was actually quite ambitious in how it tried to utilise the then unknown advantages of streaming, but also, ultimately, a huge mistake.
Five years on they're back again, with creator Mitch Hurwitz recognising the errors of the past and attempting to get things back on track. Is Season 5 as botched an attempt as one of Gob's magic tricks, or will it have you shrieking as if you've just seen Gene Parmesan? It's a little of both, but thankfully more of the latter.
Ups...
6. The Bluths (Mostly) Back Together
The biggest problem with Season 4 was a fairly simple one: the Bluths weren't together. Due, in part, to scheduling conflicts, along with Hurtwitz's attempts to play to a streaming audience that they perhaps didn't fully understand yet, the family were off on their own stories that intersected with one another but rarely allowed them to appear together.
Season 5, then, feels like a direct attempt to address that. While there are times when characters are split up, they're usually at least in sub-groups of two or three, and there are plenty of moments in this first half where all of them are together in the same room, whether it's for Lindsay's Congress run or just some typical argument.
The show is never better than when it has the dysfunctional family together on screen, and the way they bounce off each other in this season is as good as ever.
5. Mixing Old Jokes With New
One of the reasons people love Arrested Development is just how much it rewards your investment and stands up to rewatches. Few TV shows can match its back catalogue of running gags and in-jokes, which it brings out in force here.
From the return of George Michael's muscle suit to his strange attraction to cousin Maeby, the cornballer, Tobias blueing himself or insisting he isn't gay, and huge mistakes being made, there are a number of jokes brought out to play again here in a variety of ways, feeling like either nice nods to the past or putting fresh spins on them.
Luckily, though, it's not just a collection of greatest hits for the sake of it. The majority of old gags fit perfectly well, and there are lots of new jokes to laugh at, from some politically charged humour to Michael's new job, Maeby's latest scheme, and George Michael's increased confidence, that means the show isn't simply relying on things you found funny over a decade ago. You're laughing because the jokes are so well written and brilliantly delivered, rather than because it's a case of "I understood that reference!".
4. The Core Narratives
At the heart of Season 5 are two twin narratives: Lindsay Bluth's run for Congress, and the disappearance of Lucille Austero, aka Lucille 2.
Both of these bring the family together and allow them to play off each other in unexpected ways, while being genuinely interesting to follow in their own right.
Lindsay herself doesn't appear much, but her aim for power brings out the very worst in her family, with plenty of Trump comparisons to be made (especially following on from the wall plot of Season 4). Of course, the Bluths are actually never better than when they're at their very worst, displaying their most selfish, insane, and downright horrible ways while Michael can only look on aghast.
Likewise, the disappearance of Lucille is a genuinely engaging - if very weird - mystery that gives Tony Hale some great material to work with as Buster. Without saying too much about it, it's a superb fit for his character and leads to some of the season's biggest laughs.
3. Jason Bateman As The Show's Anchor
Michael's leaving his family behind for good, a point he makes over and over again this season, which of course means he's doing the exact opposite.
Try as he might to move on, Michael Bluth just cannot escape his kin, and nor should he. While almost everyone else is being bad, Michael is once again trying his best to hold it all together, allowing Jason Bateman - who has made some real improvements as an actor, in terms of range, over the last few years - to serve as the narrative and emotional anchor.
His deadpan delivery is as brilliant as ever, his doomed fate leading to a mix of pity and hilarity, and he is, thankfully, back to being the good guy of the family after becoming a little too much like the rest of them in Season 4.
2. And Maeby And Gob As Joint MVPs
Even in Season 4, Gob was a real highlight despite the limitations of the format. In Season 5 his character arc is given a little more room to breathe, and Will Arnett just completely nails it.
It may help that he's spent the years since Arrested Development was last on playing BoJack Horseman, because there is definitely a tinge of that in Gob this year. It's not quite as emotionally devastating, but Arnett this year plummets to new levels of depraved tragic as he tries to make sense of what happened with Ben Stiller's Tony Wonder, and along with the manic energy and sublime comedy he also finds real pathos, which is one of the new season's biggest surprises.
Join MVP honours must go to Alia Shawkat, who is allowed to do much more with Maeby this year and flesh her out more than before. She's largely separated from her parents, and this means she comes into her own much more with a crazy scheme that gives Shawkat a chance to showcase her gifts for screwball comedy, while her relationship with George Michael is even stronger now too.
1. A Return To Form
No matter how Mitch Hurtwitz tries to remix it, Season 4 was largely a failure. An ambitious one, sure, with some moments of real hilarity, but ultimately it wasn't the same show people loved and simply wasn't anywhere near as funny.
Season 5 is the opposite of that. This is Arrested Development screaming that it IS still the show that became a cult classic, moving to shift the balance back to what it used to be and get back to its more classic sitcom structure.
That could've led to it feeling stale or like a nostalgia grab, but for the most part it instead represents a return to form. TV has moved on in a lot of ways from where Arrested Development was 15 years ago, but there's still room for this show. The plot threads are entertaining and interesting, the characters both feel like they're supposed to and - in some cases - are actually allowed to change (something that doesn't often happen in sitcoms), and the old spark and magic has definitely been recovered.
It doesn't quite hit the highest highs of its peak years, but that would be an unreasonable expectation given how long it's been and how much has changed. If Arrested Development is to have further seasons after this, then Season 5 could be seen as ANUSTART.
Downs...
3. The Messy Start
With just eight episodes to go on, thanks to the season being split in two and trying to play to the Emmys, this truncated season flies by for the most part, but it does get off to a very rocky start.
The first couple of episodes basically play out like their own remixes of Season 4, as they attempt to not only recap events that happened five years ago (in the real world, with hardly any time at all passing in the show) but reframe certain stories too, in ways that'll allow them to be built upon further this year.
It would perhaps have been better to have more of a time jump, or simply get straight on with the job. Once Season 5 gets going it's excellent, but the first couple of episodes (and it bleeds into the third instalment to a degree as well) are very slow and messy in having to deal with Season 4, rather than immediately taking things forward.
2. A Few Characters Don't Work
While the show largely does a good job in getting the band back together, a few characters don't land like they used to.
Although a huge plot point is Lindsay Bluth's run for Congress, but the character herself is little more than that device. Portia de Rossi has retired from acting, which is an unfortunate happenstance, but she does still appear here. The trouble is those appearances are so sporadic that it makes the plotline fumble - it'd be way stronger if she were actually there for most of it - and it's quite clear she filmed most of her scenes separately, with the sequences where she was clearly digitally inserted feeling really distracting.
Her old husband, Tobias, doesn't fare too well either. The show tries to make a joke of the fact that he doesn't fit in with the family, but without Lindsay there it's simply a sad fact. The character was always bizarre, even by Arrested Development standards, but where that previously led to humour over his being a Never Nude and their failing marriage, here it's a more annoying presence and there doesn't ever feel like a need for him to be there.
The process of introducing Ron Howard more continues too, with the actor/director - and his family - making a few more appearances outside the VO booth. His narration continues to be excellent, but the cameos in-person are a little more distracting.
1. Jeffrey Tambor Is Mishandled
Most of Season 5 had been filmed before the allegations against Jeffrey Tambor surfaced, which is part of the reason the actor is still in Season 5 (along with most of the cast and crew insisting their experiences of working with him were very different to the accounts of people on Transparent).
That's ultimately Mitch Hurwitz's decision, and for the most part Tambor's presence is a background one. He's part of the show's furniture but isn't put into the spotlight too much, yet there are still a couple of problems.
After the now-infamous New York Times interview, it's very uncomfortable to watch any scenes between George Snr and Lucille, knowing how Tambor treated Jessica Walter on set. Had that interview not been released (something Netflix couldn't account for) then it might be different, but the show doesn't exist in that bubble (and besides, it's on those involved with the show to ensure it is a safe and comfortable working environment, regardless of what does or doesn't surface).
Worst of all, though, is how they use Tambor in the opening episodes. We have detectives looking for a red-headed woman, only for it to be revealed it wasn't actually a woman at all, but "cis-male George Snr" in disguise. Then, Howard explains: "George Sr. soon realized his impression of a woman wasn’t going to win him any awards, so he took off in his trailer to Mexico to forget his shameful mistakes.”
That trip to Mexico involved George Snr realising his testosterone levels have plummeted, so he and Gob (still struggling over what happened with Tony) decide to overcompensate by going on a trip to "f*** our way through Mexico."
It may have been filmed before the allegations, but there's absolutely no reason - regardless of Hurwitz standing by him or not - that these scenes couldn't have been cut.
What did you think of Arrested Development Season 5? Let us know down in the comments.