Arrow: 10 Mistakes It Must Fix In Season 5

Can they save this series?

By James Hunt /

With the sheer volume of superhero TV shows around at the moment, Arrow is in danger of getting left behind.

Advertisement

It's easy now to forget that Arrow can be credited with helping to kick-start the modern trend of comic book series, proving that superheroes could indeed work on the small screen. Not only did it launch its own universe, but since the series debuted Marvel have also got in on the act, with their lighter ABC shows, and the darker Netflix ones. Indeed, Daredevil takes what Arrow started and progresses it to an R-rated level.

As for those Arrowverse shows, which includes The Flash, Legends of Tomorrow, and now Supergirl, all have started to surpass their progenitor. Each have had their struggles, especially Legends in its first season, but they seem on more solid footing than Arrow does right now, and it's The Flash that's the cornerstone of the universe.

The quality of those shows is part of the reason, but it's also because of a worrying decline in Arrow across seasons 3 and 4. In that time it has been dividing and alienating its fanbase, making stranger and poorer storytelling choices, and moving away from the show everyone loved in the first place. With more fans turning off, or at least getting pissed off with the show, Season 5 takes on added importance.

Thankfully, the show can still be saved, it just needs to correct these mistakes.

10. Boring Flashbacks

Early on in the show's run, the flashbacks were an effective storytelling method. Charting Oliver's time on Lian Yu, they informed the present day narrative and helped to expand Oliver's (and Slade's) character, while also serving as an entertaining part of the show in their own right.

Advertisement

That started to change in Season 3, when the flashbacks took Ollie off the island and instead placed him in Hong Kong. The show tried to tell a story parallel to that of the current one, but it didn't advance our understanding, and the scenes themselves were pretty dull; there was nowhere near enough material to fill the 23 episodes.

Season 4 flashbacks promised us Coast City, an exciting prospect given which major superhero is from there. However, that was simply some bait-and-switch, and Oliver ended up back on Lian Yu. The flashbacks were just as boring as the year before, and despite some forced attempts at making them mirror the present storyline - in terms of linking Shadowspire to Darhk, magic, and Oliver's choices - it never, at any stage, felt necessary or even entertaining.

Season 5 won't be doing away with the flashbacks, but it does have another chance to get them right. Oliver is supposedly heading to Russia, which means we'll finally see him becoming a captain in the Russian mafia, which - even though it's coming a long time after the question was really being asked - should still be interesting to see play out.

9. Too Much Filler

0

23 episodes is a lot of episodes, especially for a drama. It's difficult for any show to sustain its narrative across that amount of runtime, as well as making things continuously feel fresh and exciting.

Advertisement

It's something Arrow has particularly struggled with over the last couple of years, with episodes that amount to little more than filler, simply biding time until they're at a point where they can raise the stakes again, or when the main villain can reemerge. Not every episode needs to have something big happen, or even impact on the overarching plot, but you can still do episodes that standalone somewhat while also developing the characters or simply being wholly enjoyable themselves. Arrow hasn't done that of late.

Ideally the show would reduce the number of episodes, to around 16 or even just to 20, but that isn't going to happen. So instead they need to work on ensuring that every episode feels important, whether that's by using more mini-arcs, creating better villains, having some serious character developments, or enough plot to last throughout 23 episodes.

8. Instantly Forgettable Villains-Of-The-Week

This ties into some of the problems with stretching the show out over 20+ episodes. It's not possible to have the Big Bad appear in every episode, or at least every episode be related to them, so you need some minor villains to fill in the gap. The villain-of-the-week is a well-worn trope, from Buffy The Vampire Slayer to The Flash, and when done well it can make for some great episodes and memorable villains.

Advertisement

Arrow itself did this well in the early days, whether it was villains in one episode or those who had mini-arcs, from Constantine Drakon to the Clock King, two versions of Count Vertigo, and Huntress. Even Season 3 had Brick, who just about kept things alive when Oliver was MIA.

Arrow Season 4 relied heavily on Damien Darhk and H.I.V.E., and there was no one there to fill in the gaps when they had to take a break. Brie Larvae was borrowed from The Flash late on, and was about as good as it got. Cupid was annoying (again), and Vandal Savage didn't work here, let alone as the main villain on Legends.

Going forwards, they could do with introducing a good variety of villains, and giving some of them multi-episode arcs - it'd reduce the chance of them being instantly forgettable, and put less pressure on the main villain (Neal McDonough is great, but there's only so much he can do).

7. Promising Big Developments Early (Without Knowing What They Are)

The Season 4 premiere ended with a shocking tag, a flashforward to six months from then, with a visibly upset Oliver standing by the grave of some unknown person. Right from the off Arrow was promising us that a major character was going to be killed this year. It was a bold decision, and it certainly worked in terms of ramping up excitement and hype.

Advertisement

The issue, however, was that they didn't have a plan for what came next. They hadn't wrote that scene knowing who was in the grave. Instead, they stuck it in there, and then had to figure it out as they went along, which ultimately meant they ended up writing Laurel Lance further and further into the sidelines so they could get to the stage where she could easily be killed off.

While it's rather common for network shows not to have every episode written in advance, so that they can adapt things as they go along, it's rather different when it comes to a major character death. Arrow suffered here from a lack of long-term planning, and that's not something they can afford to repeat in Season 5.

6. Death Needs To Be Meaningful

Following on from the strand of those big promises, comes that major development from Season 4: the death of Laurel Lance.

Advertisement

It's yet another example of death in the show not carrying the weight it ought to. This is something that really started last year, when they 'killed' Oliver, only to bring him back (of course they're not going to kill off the main character), then did the same with Thea, and then at the beginning of Season 4 brought back Sara Lance.

When the dead don't stay dead, it means dying doesn't carry the same impact. That's not even the big issue with Laurel though, because I do believe the showrunners when they say she won't be brought back (at least, not the modern day, Earth-1 version). The way they wrote Laurel's death meant that the character was pushed out before she was killed off (and had long been a problem character anyway), and then on her deathbed served to boost Olicity. After that, it had an impact on the remaining members, particularly Diggle, but it didn't feel massively earned, and all the talk of the Black Canary's legacy felt like something they were shoehorning in, rather than something we'd witnessed over the years and had actual proof of.

When you're killing off a main character, it needs to have a big impact, and Laurel's death sadly didn't.

5. Felicity's Role

It's fast becoming the case that there's no middle ground when it comes to Felicity Smoak. You either love her character and want her and Oliver to be together, or you think she's single-handedly destroying the show and should be killed off.

Advertisement

Felicity now is about as hated by Arrow fans as Laurel was circa Season 2, maybe even more so. It's a strange position, given how popular her character was across the first two seasons.

Season 3 brought her and Oliver together as an actual item, which was a problem for many, while since then she's frequently been on hand to deliver grandiose speeches about love and what needs to be done, and lost a lot of what made the character so great in the first place.

While I think some criticisms of the character (and actress Emily Bett Rickards) are little harsh, it is clear the writers have struggled here. They need to ensure Felicity's role is important without it completely dominating everything, and that she can retain that goofball charm and humour that helped make her so appealing. And even then, it's only part of the problem solved.

4. Too Much Soap Opera

This ties in with the Felicity 'problem', but it's become a wider issue that does stand on its own as something the show needs to fix.

Advertisement

Being on The CW, Arrow has always had its soap opera elements, with OTT relationship drama and such like. However, they've always been secondary to the action and Oliver's life as the Arrow.

Increasingly, though, these elements have started becoming a bigger and bigger part of the show, to the point where episodes are centred around them, and the superhero action becomes the subplot. 'Olicity' is the most obvious example of this, with Oliver and Felicity's relationship drama working its way into all aspects of the show. That's not solely to blame though, as we've seen it with everyone from Quentin and Donna's relationship troubles to Oliver's baby mama drama. While it's important to flesh characters out and give them a life outside of the costumes, the writers need to stop that aspect from becoming the show.

3. It Promised Lightness...And Didn't Deliver

After Season 3 spent the majority of its 23 episodes living under a cloud of misery, Season 4 was supposed to bring a marked change of tone to Arrow.

Advertisement

It was finally changing the hero from the Arrow to the Green Arrow, and was set to bring him closer to his comic book counterpart: more humour, a lighter tone, without completely moving away from the dark edge Arrow always had (and needed).

The new, lighter tone lasted for about half of the Season 4 premiere, and then the characters returned to Star City, and things continued as they were (although in fairness, that first half of Season 4 was much stronger than the back half). It wasn't necessarily miserable, but there wasn't really a lot of humour or lightness that the show could've done with to recover from Season 3.

It is, however, still achievable for the show. It doesn't need to become The Flash, but dropping in some more moments of humour - from Felicity, from Curtis, to Oliver himself, and also Thea, who was one of the best parts of the second half of Season 4, and clearly knows how to deliver a group - and some occasionally levity wouldn't go amiss. Arrow can, at times, be a ridiculous show; sometimes it should fully embrace that.

2. Magic And Mysticism

Damien Darhk was the highlight of Season 4. That, however, is mostly down to Neal McDonough's performance. Whatever flaws the character had, McDonough covered them up with a performance that was consistently captivating and menacing, with endless charisma, and he was missed anytime he didn't appear.

Advertisement

What didn't really work as well, though, and let the character down, was the 'magic and mysticism' angle they attempted this season. While The Flash (and now Legends and Supergirl) mean that supernatural elements have to be incorporated into the show, it doesn't gel particularly well with Arrow's style. That made its presence in Season 4 rather jarring, though there was also an issue with how ill-explained it all was.

There was some sort of idol, and then Oliver got a tattoo of Constantine, and then the idol appeared in present day, and Darhk was suddenly ridiculously powerful and feeding off souls, but Oliver could fight him with lightness, meanwhile thousands of people were killed by nukes but no one really cared. Arrow needs to dip a toe into those waters occasionally, because of the existence of metahumans, but it's not capable of handling it for a full season, and needs to be more grounded going forward.

1. Too Far Removed From What Made The Show Great

Arrow now is, in parts, unrecognisable from the show it started as, and the one everyone loved. The show changing and developing isn't a bad thing, because you don't want a series to just repeat the same tricks time and again and run the risk of becoming stale.

Advertisement

The trouble with Arrow is that its lost some elements that are intrinsic to the show working: the strong action scenes, urgent, focused, and coherent plotting, flashbacks that are entertaining and complement the main narrative.

Looking at Daredevil, it's easy to imagine the kind of show Arrow could be. And while being on The CW means some concessions have to be made - it's going to have some soapy parts, and can't be anywhere near as violent - it should still be aiming to compete, especially in the action stakes. The likes of Stephen Amell and Willa Holland are capable of delivering in this regard, so let them do it. Get back to the fast-paced and frenetic action and narrative pushing the show along and providing plenty of thrills.

This back-to-basics approach has been mentioned by Amell during the off-season, which shows that they are at least aware of it, and hopefully it means they can take the show back to what made it so enjoyable in the latter stages of Season 1 and, in particular, all of Season 2. Do that, and the other pieces should fall into place. Let's just hope it's not too late.

What mistakes do you think Arrow needs to fix (if any)? How would you do it? Share your thoughts in the comments.

Advertisement