Arrow: 5 Things That "The Calm" Did Right (And 3 It Didn't)

Arrow season 3 kicks off with a bang.

By Laura Hurley /

After a five-month hiatus, the CW's Arrow opened its third season with an explosive first episode, rather misleadingly entitled "The Calm." Following the series premieres of Fox's Gotham and CW's The Flash as the latest of DC Comics' ventures onto the small screen, the veteran Arrow treated returning fans to an opener in which...kind of a lot happened. With crime in Starling City at a record low thanks to the off-screen efforts of Team Arrow after the widespread destruction of the Season 2 finale, Oliver and Co. are faced with the daunting prospect of living actual lives outside of the lair. (Well, less so for Oliver himself, who is actually living in the lair.) A long-awaited romance blossoms...and falls apart. A baby is born and admired by all...just before a fan favorite dies in the ugliest of ways. A new rival shows up to challenge Oliver's place in Starling City, and the Arrow faces a fresh foe with a familiar name. There's kissing and crying, bromance and romance, catastrophes and casualties, parkour and pyrotechnics superior to what one might expect of a CW program. Overall, "The Calm" was an intense premiere that featured something for everybody. Unfortunately, by featuring something for everybody, the episode was overloaded with events that could have carried separate installments all on their own. Nevertheless, "The Calm" was more good than bad. So, here are the five best things about the Arrow Season 3 premiere...and the three worst.

The Good:

5. Action

In a series with single seasons comprised of 23 hours of television, it takes a lot to wow audiences week after week, and even the vicarious thrills of watching a man in a hood shoot arrows from a motorcycle have the potential to fade over time. Fortunately, many of the main actors-including Stephen Amell as the titular Arrow and Caity Lotz as the late lamented Canary 1.0-came into their roles possessing the training and physical abilities to perform their own stunts, a distinction that has elevated the action of Arrow to the highest of standards. Consequently, viewers have come to expect greatness out of the action sequences on the show. "The Calm" delivered. The episode opens as Team Arrow-including new addition Roy Harper as Arsenal-works together to stop an arms deal in a chase sequence reminiscent of Indiana Jones in all the best ways. As Felicity coordinates from the foundry, the boys take down the bad guys and recover the weapons without breaking a sweat. It's a heck of a way to start the season. On a smaller yet no less impressive scale is a later sequence in which Stephen Amell basically beats himself senseless. Under the influence of a powerful hallucinogen, Oliver faces off with his Arrow alter ego in a no-holds-barred fistfight. Caity Lotz also has a moment to shine as she tags into the climactic final fight and gives herself a bo staff swan song worth a rewind.

4. New Toys

It wasn't only the gravity defiance and fancy parkour that made this episode so exciting to watch. In addition to all of the drama and detonation was an array of new toys crazy enough to make even Batman jealous. Gone are the days of the wooden bows of Season 1 and the plain old compound bow of Season 2; Oliver's brand new Season 3 bow is a collapsible contraption that expands from an easy-to-carry (and conceal) handle into a formidable full-sized weapon, ready to pepper perpetrators with all of the arrows in his quiver. Of course, Oliver's nonlethal methods of dispensing justice as established after his Season 1 murder spree leave the option of peppering perps as a last resort. Thankfully, "The Calm" introduces some never-before-seen trick arrows that both keep his kill count low and look totally awesome on screen. The most whimsical of these is the arrow that bursts into a web to block doorways and prevent bad guy getaways, leaving them at the tender mercies of the friendly neighborhood vigilante. Hey, just because the Arrow doesn't kill the criminals anymore doesn't mean that he can't punch them out as they cower at his feet. And Oliver "You Have Failed This City!" Queen isn't the only one who got a gear upgrade. Roy "Who Needs More Than One Sweatshirt?" Harper trades in his trademark red hoodie for a getup properly befitting a sidekick. Decked out in head to toe leather, he looks more like a real member of Team Arrow and less like the little brother who tagged along with the big kids.

3. New Faces

In addition to those existing character upgrades, a few new faces make their first appearances in "The Calm." The most promising of these newcomers is Ray Palmer, the genius billionaire who swoops in to steal Queen Consolidated away with a dazzling sales pitch that convinces even Oliver that Ray is the right man for the job. Considering Ray's rather close attentions to Felicity, however, Oliver's goodwill toward Dr. Palmer may have a (potentially hilarious) short shelf life. As a professional and personal rival to our hero, the odds were stacked against many fans taking to the character, but former Superman actor Brandon Routh manages to strike a balance between charming and smarmy that somehow just works. His upbeat banter with everybody's favorite tech girl should prove an interesting contrast to the rest of the show. Also new was Peter Stormare as Werner Zytle, the street dealer who takes up the mantle of Count Vertigo after the original's death-via-arrows last year. Playing the Count as more opportunistic and less deranged than Seth Gabel's incarnation of the first two seasons, Stormare exudes a more sinister vibe in his total disregard for collateral damage and innocent lives. While "1812 Overture" would have been the obvious tune for him to whistle while handling explosives, "In the Hall of the Mountain King" will hereafter strike fear into the hearts of viewers in any subsequent episodes. Well, fear into the hearts of shippers, anyway. Damn that Count Vertigo! Finally, we had the first appearance of Diggle's daughter as ex-wife/girlfriend Lyla gives birth toward the end of the episode. As yet unnamed and dubbed the "Digglette" by fans, her mere existence will certainly play a prominent (if largely off-screen) part in the rest of Season 3. Plus, she's super cute. Mazel tov indeed, Digg.

2. Character Dynamics

The Diglette was not the only endearing element of "The Calm." The dynamics between nearly all of the characters received at least some attention without feeling superfluous or overwhelming the rest of the plot. Especially refreshing after the Lance family drama that occupied so much of the second half of Season 2 (and to the pleasure of about 12 people) was the way in which no relationship in the premiere was marginalized by the others. One pairing may have received more screen time, but there was so much substance to even the briefest of interactions that it really didn't matter. Oliver and Laurel have a mature conversation that did not once devolve into a blame game. Quentin and the Arrow have a stable working relationship. Diggle and Lyla have a life together outside of the Arrow lair and ARGUS. Diggle and Oliver bond, fight, and hug it out. Felicity and Ray banter. Roy has moments with each of the three original members of Team Arrow. Lyla and Felicity are friends! Sara and Laurel have a conversation that almost would have passed the Bechdel test! The episode may not have been perfect, but the character relationships came pretty darn close to it. Oh, and it may seem like a certain unit of characters was left off of this list, but that's just because there was nothing particularly worthwhile about their interactions that anybody would actually care about...

1. Oliver And Felicity

...Or maybe it's because they get their very own entry! Oliver and Felicity. They weren't supposed to happen. Felicity was meant to be an Easter egg for comic fans, and Emily Bett Rickards a one-off guest star. Oliver was meant to sizzle with star-crossed soulmate Laurel, and Stephen Amell to sell an epic love affair opposite Katie Cassidy. Despite the best efforts of everyone involved, Plan A backfired as audiences failed to connect with Oliver and Laurel as a couple. Fortunately for the showrunners, Plan B fell into their laps as Rickards created a character out of a cameo and Amell lit up in their scenes together. Purely by accident, Olicity was born. After two seasons of lackluster Lauriver, "The Calm" seemed likely to be the turning point for the series' main romance. It was and it wasn't. There's shameless flirting. There's more smiling from Oliver than has ever been seen before, and more touching from Felicity than she's ever dared before. Oliver asks her out on a date, zip-lines into the restaurant, and pulls a reverse Superman as he reveals a suit underneath his Arrow gear. Felicity is gorgeous and nervous and shy. It's basically 20 minutes of them being adorable. Then, of course, the villain follows the signal of a GPS tracker planted on the Arrow and blows up the restaurant. Our intrepid hero blames himself, decides that he can't live as both the Arrow and Oliver Queen, and breaks things off with Felicity. It was kind of a downer, not least because Oliver needs to take lessons in how to break up with people:Way to break both of your hearts, Oliver. At least she didn't have to see him gazing longingly at her and a baby. Despite the heartbreak, the romance between Oliver and Felicity in "The Calm" was handled very well. They were open and adult with one another. Even Oliver's refusal to tell her "never" came from a place of honesty rather than cruelty, and it matters that she was the one to walk away. Objectively, this felt more like a pause than a conclusion, and getting so many of the huge romantic beats out of the way in the premiere opens the rest of the season up to a greater balance. Subjectively? Go ahead and watch that video again. There's no judgment here.

The Not-So-Good:

3. Too Much Going On

And now, moving on to what didn't work so well, we have the fact that huge romantic beats were not the only plot elements of which there were ridiculously many. There's nothing wrong with a fast-paced hour of television; on the contrary, any episode of a show that features a big enough moment to not leave viewers checking their watches every few minutes is generally a good one. The problem with "The Calm" is that there were so very many big moments crammed into a single installment, and none were given the time to sink in. The final five minutes saw the birth of Diggle's daughter, a Hong Kong flashback, Oliver and Felicity's kiss, the Barry Allen phone call, and Sara's death. Any one of these would be enough to end a premiere satisfactorily, but the combination was too much. Roy's disarming of a bomb that would have killed upwards of 20,000 innocent civilians is an afterthought in the overall scheme, and the first several flashbacks are a blur. Additionally, certain scenes needed time to breathe, and the actors more time to deliver their lines. Oliver's heartbreak after Felicity walks away is abbreviated by the immediacy with which he answer his phone. Half of the dialogue in the foundry is so speedy as to be difficult to understand, and the entire scene when Oliver arrives back to the lair carrying a bloody and unconscious Felicity feels as though it was never properly fleshed out. "The Calm" would have made an excellent two-parter, and the additional time would have given the plot enough room to breathe that it would rank as one of the better season premieres of this fall.

2. Sara's Death

Sara Lance was always going to die. In a show in which superpowers do not exist and the dead stay dead, there were only so many times that she could cheat death. With Caity Lotz only ever billed as a guest star and the character only ever known as the Canary (as opposed to the Black Canary of comic lore), Sara's days were numbered from the start. After wrapping up her family drama and her ill-advised romance with Oliver by the final episodes of Season 2, going out in a blaze of glory in the season finale seemed like a fitting end for Sara Lance. But it wasn't the end. Sure, she scampered back to the League of Assassins, but she was alive. Sara could return! When she appeared in the Season 3 premiere, she didn't have a whole lot to do. She helped out Oliver and gave him some non sequitur advice about his social life. She met her sister on a rooftop-as you do-and made some vaguely sinister noises about her purpose in returning to Starling City. It was a shallow reintroduction to the narrative. Just as we got a taste of Daddy Diggle and a taste of Olicity and a taste of some new characters, this was a tiny bit of Sara to tide us over until her time came later in the season. Except that's not what happened. Instead, Sara is greeted by an off-screen antagonist who proceeds to drill three arrows into her abdomen. Fans of the show knew that she was dead. On Arrow, anybody can take one or two arrows to their torsos, but three? Three means death. Still, to make sure that viewers understood that Sara was totally 100% capital-D DEAD, she stumbled backward off of the roof, landed on her back on a dumpster, and flopped headfirst onto the concrete. Sara Lance was always going to die, but the heroine who had fought to protect women and who traded her freedom for the lives of strangers deserved better than falling broken and beaten into the trash.

1. Laurel's Role

Over the first two seasons of Arrow, no single character has been so widely disliked as Laurel Lance. Despite looking pretty good on paper and being introduced as the future Black Canary to Oliver's Green Arrow, Laurel has never been somebody with whom many viewers have connected. The unfortunate chemistry vacuum between Katie Cassidy and Stephen Amell combined with the toxic backstory with which the couple was saddled from the very first episodes of the series made her into an undesirable romantic lead. With the assimilation of Sara as Canary into Team Arrow and Felicity's emergence as Oliver's lady love by the end of Season 2, the question arose: what to do with Laurel in Season 3? There were plenty of potential starting points for her. If freed from the constraints of love interest and vigilante-roles occupied by far more popular characters and actresses-Laurel could become a character finally worth rooting for. So what if her first name is actually Dinah? The show could let Laurel settle into an original plot of her own and perhaps start to win over those viewers who tend to glaze over during her scenes. Instead, the producers chose to unceremoniously fling Sara's body onto a dumpster and literally have the Canary mask fall at Laurel's feet. Now, it's not Laurel's fault that Sara died. In-universe, Sara is dead because she fell off of a roof and smashed every important part of her body not riddled with arrows on the way down. Laurel had nothing to do with the fact that it happened or the obscene way in which it played out on screen. Objectively, we viewers know this. But it's going to be hard not to blame Laurel as she seizes on Sara's demise as her excuse to turn vigilante. There is something seriously wrong in a show when even villains not played by John Barrowman are more popular than the female lead, but swapping one character for another in the ugliest way possible should not have been the way to try to fix it, and Laurel will suffer with audiences for it.