Arrow Season 4: 10 Characters That Absolutely Cannot Die

Not anytime soon, anyway.

By Laura Hurley /

Over the three seasons that have aired thus far, The CW’s flagship superhero series Arrow has proved that it’s not afraid of a bloodbath. Major characters have been dying from the very beginning, and fans are often now wary of becoming too attached to anybody on screen. Heartbreak is practically a certainty.

Advertisement

Well, it was practically a certainty.

While there’s no denying that the producers have not shied away from culling the cast in the past, they have gone on record that Arrow is the story of Oliver Queen’s journey from ruthless murdering Hood to the hero Green Arrow. After three seasons of varying levels of misery, the happy ending in the final moments of the third season finale indicates that Oliver is finally on the upswing. His crucibles have had crucibles, and he’s been broken down to the basics. 

To become the Green Arrow, he’ll need to start being built back up, and that can’t happen if his world is continually turned upside down by the deaths of those around him. Some characters just can’t be killed without completely sabotaging the storytelling of the entire series.

Not all of those necessary characters are favorites whose survival is only prolonged to prevent audiences from rioting. Some characters - major and minor - need to survive because their deaths would amp up unnecessary melodrama. Here is a look at ten characters aside from Oliver that absolutely cannot die for logical, practical, or narrative reasons on Arrow.

Not anytime soon, anyway.

10. Nyssa al Ghul

Who She Is: Nyssa al Ghul – also known as Nyssa Raatko – is the daughter of the former Ra’s al Ghul and a deadly member of the League of Assassins. She fell in love with Sara Lance after rescuing her from Lian Yu, but her father viewed her affections as a weakness and used them to pass her over as his heir. Although she's proved willing to play by Oliver’s “no killing” rule in Starling, Nyssa has never been afraid to cross the line if it suited her.

Advertisement

Why She Cannot Die: Nyssa is an antihero at best and a villain at worst. Her motives are almost always murky, but she’s only fought against Team Arrow if she had a legitimate grievance. 

With her father now out of the picture as a vengeful force, former lover Sara unlikely to turn against her friends and family in Starling, and herself short enough of allies in Nanda Parbat that her forced wedding to Oliver went off without a hitch, there would simply be no point or far-reaching narrative consequences to killing her.

Katrina Law is a recurring guest star, and it’s hardly necessary for Arrow to kill off its most prominent surviving LGBT character and yet another woman for the sake of spectacle. She certainly cannot die without first enacting some vengeance on Malcolm Merlyn.

9. Sara Lance

Who She Is: Sara Lance is a young woman whose ill-advised sex cruise with Oliver Queen ultimately resulted in her taking the name “Canary” and joining the League of Assassins. After returning to Nanda Parbat following a few months in Starling, she paid a visit to her hometown in the Season 3 premiere just in time to be shot through the abdomen with arrows, topple off of a rooftop, bang into a dumpster, and land on her head in a dirty alley.

Advertisement

Why She Cannot Die: Well, Sara technically did die. Her fall from the roof, display on a table in the foundry, cold storage, and then burial in a pine box all seemed designed to drive home the point that Sara was super dead and not coming back this time.

As spoiled by the trailer for Legends of Tomorrow, Sara is super coming back from the dead again. Thanks to a dunk in a Lazarus Pit, Sara will officially be returning to the land of the living to join the cast of the new spinoff.

As this resurrection will be Sara’s third, she really needs to stay alive this time. All the material of her death has already been mined; killing her off yet again would be overkill in the worst way, and downright disrespectful to viewers. 

8. Quentin Lance

Who He Is: Captain Quentin Lance – formerly Detective, then Officer, then Detective again – is a prominent member of the Starling City Police Department. Vacillating from antagonist to the Arrow to begrudging ally to friend and then back to antagonist once more, Quentin has had reason to quarrel with Oliver as well as the Arrow. 

Advertisement

After discovering that the Arrow had neglected to inform him of Sara’s death, Quentin spent the final run of episodes of the third season trying to capture the once-celebrated vigilante.

Why He Cannot Die: Although Quentin has become rather tiresome by this point as a result of his habit of allowing his personal feelings to color his professional dealings, he cannot die simply because he occupies a unique role within the narrative. Quentin Lance is the show’s source within the SCPD. In fact, the police force basically consists of Quentin and a horde of uniformed extras. He can’t die because there’s nobody to replace him.

Besides, Quentin dying at this point would undoubtedly have more to do with his daughters than his own arc. It would be unwise to launch Sara into the spinoff after inflicting upon her the death of her father, and there was already one Lance sacrificed for the sake of Laurel's journey. For now, at least, Quentin Lance must survive. 

7. Laurel Lance

Who She Is: Laurel Lance was Oliver’s girlfriend from before the shipwreck, who became a crusading lawyer for the little guy, who became a prosecuting assistant district attorney, who became an alcoholic, who became unemployed, who became a woman terrible at recognizing her blonde sister from two feet away because of a blonde wig and domino mask, who became a gleeful recipient of a jacket, who became a vigilante taking on the name of Black Canary after boxing lessons. 

Advertisement

She’s basically a wall at which the writers have been throwing spaghetti for three years.

Why She Cannot Die: As unpopular as Laurel has become in certain circles, killing her off just after she has become Black Canary would render meaningless all of the screentime allotted to her journey in Season 3. Her meteoric rise toward the mask frustrated, but at least there was an end result. For better or worse, Laurel Lance is the Black Canary.

Perhaps even worse than the time wasted is the melodrama that her death would cause. She’s been rendered nearly irrelevant to the hero in life, but her death would undoubtedly be used to send him into a particularly epic guilt trip. Mourning and melodrama with regard to the Lance family have been overdone by this point; if any are to exit the show, they should do so alive and well. 

6. Oliver's Baby Mama

Who She Is: For a character who has only appeared in The CW’s DC universe twice in what amounted to little more than cameos, the as-yet-unnamed woman unfortunate enough to catch something other than an STD from the bed-hopping pre-island Ollie is hugely important. Becoming pregnant after a tryst with Oliver while he was still with Laurel, the young woman accepted a hefty bribe from Moira to claim a miscarriage and flee to Central City to raise the baby with big dumb Ollie none the wiser.

Advertisement

Why She Cannot Die: She is the mother of Oliver’s child. If she dies, Oliver and his guilt-complex might feel compelled to take care of the child, which…would be awful.

Sure, it would be a sign of growth that Oliver is no longer the Ollie of awful hair and sexuality not dissimilar to the visual acuity of a T-rex, but Arrow is not a show in which the hero can have a kid. Add in the fact that a child could not be killed off without being a huge tragedy, and it’s best that Oliver’s baby mama survive the run of the show.

Preferably off-screen. Oliver does not need kids anytime soon, whether a surprise 7-year old from Central City or a bundle of joy from Felicity. 

5. Baby Sara

Who She Is: Baby Sara is the daughter of John Diggle and Lyla Michaels. Fated to certainly be gorgeous as the product of those parents, the baby was named for Sara Lance shortly after Sara’s death.

Advertisement

Why She Cannot Die: Well, baby Sara mostly can’t die because she’s a baby. Arrow may be willing to go dark, but killing a baby is about a dozen steps too far. Just as Oliver could not be redeemable if he’d kidnapped Sara in place of her mother at the end of Season 3, Arrow might not be redeemable if Sara meets an untimely end.

On a less moralistic and more meta level, baby Sara needs to stick around because she is a symbol of hope for the future for Oliver. He gazed longingly at Felicity standing over the baby in the hospital at the end of the Season 3 premiere, shortly before breaking both of their hearts and giving up the possibility of having such a tableau of his own someday.

 With Oliver already opening himself up to the happily-ever-after with Felicity, the symbol of the next step needs to remain alive and adorable.

4. Lyla Michaels

Who She Is: Lyla Michaels is a former A.R.G.U.S. agent, the wife of John Diggle, and the mother of the cutest baby in the history of babies. Although she gave up her position working under Amanda Waller when she realized that she wanted to set a better example for little Sara, Lyla is still a fierce warrior who will stop at nothing to protect those she cares about.

Advertisement

Why She Cannot Die: Like Quentin, Lyla fills a unique role for Arrow by being a friendly face with connections to A.R.G.U.S. Her links to the organization have been invaluable both to Team Arrow on Arrow and to Team Flash over on The Flash. Lyla needs to live because she’s an irreplaceable source of information.

Practically speaking, Lyla also needs to live so that baby Sara can be off-screen while Diggle runs around Starling to fight crime in his new helmet. He couldn’t exactly help save the city with a bjorn on his torso or a baby carrier on his back, and setting up some sort of daycare for the child would be a needless complication. 

Audrey Marie Anderson is a recurring guest star, and there’s no reason why she can’t happily survive off-screen most of the time. She can hang out with Nyssa. 

3. John Diggle

Who He Is: John Diggle is a former soldier whose life changed forever when he was hired as bodyguard to Oliver Queen. He’s since found a purpose in life beyond following the wealthy around on their errands, a dear friend in Felicity, a surrogate brother in Oliver, and a family with his wife and daughter. 

Advertisement

The loss of frenemy Deadshot in Season 3 was a bit of a blow, but his demise reintroduced the plot of the H.I.V.E. assassination of Andy Diggle for exploration in Season 4 that will keep John plenty relevant even after his falling out with Oliver.

Why He Cannot Die: John Diggle has been an invaluable friend to Oliver since almost the very beginning of the series. He and Oliver have a deep understanding that has kept a bond between them even as they’ve fought. Oliver has already gone through losing his best friend; killing off a second best friend and comrade-in-arms who also happens to be one of the most important characters of the show would be a mistake.

Additionally, David Ramsey has said that John Diggle is portrayed on Arrow as Oliver, five years in the future. Diggle is the man that Oliver can be if he continues on his upward swing. Prematurely ending his life could stunt a story that has been sold as being about growth. 

2. Thea Queen

Who She Is: Thea Queen is the beloved baby sister of Oliver Queen. Bratty and entitled for the first half of the first season, Thea has since evolved into a strong young woman. Despite being drugged by her biological father and used as a puppet to commit terrible deeds, she has chosen to use the skills that he instilled in her to fight for good as Speedy in Starling City.

Advertisement

Why She Cannot Die: For one thing, she pretty much already died. Although she was never flung onto a dumpster and shoved into cold storage a la Sara, her confrontation with Ra’s al Ghul would have killed her without the assistance of a dip in the Lazarus Pit. Arrow should at least wait a bit before throwing her into mortal peril once more.

The main reason why Thea cannot die, however, is that she is Oliver’s last untainted connection to the good that was in him before the island. He’s lost Tommy and his parents, and none of the Lance family should have much good to say about him from before Lian Yu, but Thea is the connective thread proving that Oliver has always had the good heart beneath all of the moral failures and terrible hair. 

Oliver losing Thea would be Oliver losing the good of who he was before his crucible. 

1. Felicity Smoak

Who She Is: Felicity Smoak, M.I.T. class of ’09, is the computer genius extraordinaire that upgraded Team Arrow from well-muscled twosome to technological super-trio. She managed to foil and complement Oliver and Diggle, and her lightness in all of the doom and gloom rendered her presence invaluable. Last seen driving off into the sunset with Oliver, Felicity will have the freedom to enjoy a happily-ever-after.

Advertisement

For five months or so.

Why She Cannot Die: Felicity is an interesting character, largely in that she is replaceable in her position on the team. Team Arrow 2.0 apparently managed without her constant aid over hiatus, and both Arrow and The Flash have proved that there is no dearth of lighthearted geniuses willing to work outside of the law. The show could feasibly survive her loss.

Oliver could not.

For all of its failures in writing for Felicity, Season 3 did effectively paint her as The One for Oliver. The former playboy only had eyes for her, and there was a big Olicity beat in all pivotal episodes. He gazed longingly at her with a baby. He saw their only kiss last before he died. He chose to leave everybody behind to discover himself with Felicity at his side. Thea connects him to Ollie, and Diggle connects him to the Arrow… but Felicity connects him to the Green Arrow. She can't die.

Which Arrow characters do you think MUST survive? Share your picks below in the comments thread below and follow all of our WhatCulture coverage here.

Advertisement