Song of Ice and Fire was never going to be an easy series to adapt into a television show. In fact, thanks to the multitude of characters, complex history, and massive geography involved, many claimed that an adaptation of George R. R. Martin's epic would be impossible. Despite this, HBO's Game of Thrones Season 1 blew away even the most ardent naysayer, when it premiered back in 2011. Beautifully shot, respectful of the source material, and featuring some fantastic performances, Game of Thrones remains hugely popular among both book readers and show watchers to this day. However, with the increased complexity and amount of plot that needs to be crammed in each episode, some cracks are beginning to show. While the show still tends to do more right than wrong, season three and four have seen some highly questionable decisions from the show runners. While the last two seasons have borne witness to a few of the show's finest moments, Game of Thrones no longer feels quite as watertight and consistent as it did a couple of years ago. From bizarre characterization to underwhelming revelations, this list takes a look at some the things that the show has handled poorly in recent seasons. Please note that this list contains spoilers for both the show and the books, so read ahead with caution...
10. Robb Stark's 'Honour'
HBORobb Stark is, well and truly, his father's son. Holding family and honour above all else, he's something of a paragon for the Stark house's values. As shown in the War of the Five Kings, he's also a highly talented tactician and warrior, winning every battle he fights, despite the odds. However, during the war campaign, he falls in love and marries a medic named Talisa, breaking the pact he made with the Freys. This results in the notorious Red Wedding, causing the death of Catelyn Stark, Talisa Stark, and Robb Stark himself. While everyone enjoys a good 'forbidden love' story, it was totally out of character for Robb to have broken a pact in the manner that he did. Although they were in love, there was nothing honourable about marrying Talisa, and a man like Robb stark should have known that it was a terrible idea. To be believable, audiences needed to buy that it was true love, a grand romance that was worth throwing everything away for. Of course, this just doesn't fit remotely well with the cruel, medieval world of Game of Thrones. In the books, Robb gets injured in battle and tended to be a noblewoman called Jeyne Westerling. While recovering, he learns the news that his two younger brothers have been killed by Theon Greyjoy, and in a moment of weakness he sleeps with Jeyne. Because Robb has taken her virginity, he decides to marry Jeyne to preserve her honour, as was the done thing in Westeros. This not only further links him thematically with his father, but also turns Robb into a far more sympathetic and believable character than his show counterpart.
9. Too Much Sexposition
HBOAs is the standard with most modern HBO shows, Game of Thrones is filled to the brim with sex and nudity. As well as fitting in with the primal, medieval theme of the show, it's also no doubt lent to its massive popularity. In many scenes, the nudity and sex has worked extremely well with regards to characterization. For example, the first episode introduces Daenerys as completely naked, about to take a bath while being felt up by her brother. This showed not only her vulnerability, but also the status of many women in that world as being objects to trade and sell away. Thanks the show's average of about one sex scene per episode, it has helped to coin the term 'sexposition' - introducing narrative elements while characters are doing the dirty. However, some believe that it's starting to get a bit too much. Did we really need all those sex scenes with Oberyn to learn that he's a bit free-spirited? Were the background rape scenes at Craster's Keep totally necessary? If Game of Thrones wants to keep the sexual stuff interesting, then the creators might want to stop squeezing them into every possible moment.
8. Bloodravens Two Eyes
HBOThis one is by no means huge in itself, but it has made some readers worried that the show creators might lack a full understanding of the source material, without regard for the consequences along the line. One instance of this is in the introduction of Bloodraven. It might sound like a petty thing, but book Bloodraven famously has only one working eye. When Bran encounters him under the weirwood, he has a root growing out of an empty eye socket, demonstrating his complete symbiosis with the tree that he lives under. However, in the show, Bloodraven's eyes are both working. This wouldn't be a negative in itself, but the show still uses a line that references his singular eye, with the character saying that he has a "thousand eyes, and one". If the creators had decided to just change Bloodraven's appearance, there'd be no problem. It's puzzling though, when the character refers to traits that he doesn't actually have.
7. Season 4 Daenerys
HBONow this is one that can't be blamed on the show changing too much from the books. In fact, the show might even have made Daenerys' long stay in Meereen marginally more interesting than the source material. In season one and two, the scenes involving Daenerys were a big highlight. The huge Khalasar, Daenarys' transition into a strong, fierce woman, and the birth of her dragons served as a brilliantly exotic retreat from the grey, medieval Westeros. Then, along came the Slaver's Bay, Meereen and Daario. What should have been an epic tale of Daenerys freeing slaves from a lifetime of oppression is instead a tedious wait for her to finally take a fleet over to Westeros and claim the Iron Throne. At this rate, it's beginning to look like she'll never get there.
6. Daarios Recasting
HBOWhile we aren't huge fans of his effect on Daenerys' storyline, Daario is one of the more intriguing characters in the Game of Thrones series. From his mysterious origins to the possibility that he's a certain other major character in disguise, Daario is a bit of an enigma. In season three, Daario was played by Ed Skrien, who did a good job of portraying the Tyroshi sellsword. Unfortunately for Game of Thrones fans, Skrien was unable to return to the series, after accepting the lead role in a Transporter reboot for some reason. Michiel Huisman has now taken over the role and, while he's doing an admirable job, the guy just isn't as memorable as Skrien was. As well as causing a bit of confusion for viewers that aren't keeping up with what's happening behind the scenes, we're presented with a much plainer looking Daario. It's totally out of the creator's hands, but Daario now serves as a constant visual reminder that we're just watching actors playing a part.
5. Stannis The Mannis
HBOStannis is a big reader favourite. Known intermittently by fans as 'Stannis the Mannis' and 'The King That Cared', Stannis Baratheon has been responsible for some pretty badass moments in the series history. Unfortunately, the Stannis seen in Game of Thrones is a bit underwhelming compared to his book counterpart. Where book Stannis is strong, forceful and fair, show Stannis has led many people to believe that he's just a puppet under control of the red priest Melisandre. Several of Stannis' victories have been undersold. For example, the Blackwater Bay would have been an astonishing success if it weren't for deus ex machina arrival of Tywin Lannister's forces in the nick of time. The last episode brought a bit of life back to the teeth-grinding king, but he's got a long way to go before he can win over watchers as more than just a poorly characterised distraction.
4. Littlefingers Moustache Twirling
HBOOkay, so Littlefinger doesn't literally twirl his moustache. At the rate he's going though, he'll be waxing his facial hair and donning a black cape before season five is through. Possibly the least surprising 'surprise villain' of all time, nobody was shocked when he betrayed Ned Stark, or when it was revealed that he had orchestrated the killing of King Joffrey. He's also hasn't been particularly clever about his nefarious deeds at several stages in the series. For example, his killing of Lysa Arryn is poorly thought out, and it's only through Sansa bailing him out that he ever got away with it. Some might argue that that's exactly what he planned, but there's just too many variables that could have gone a different way. In the books, it's a big surprise that the meek, diminutive Littlefinger is behind many of the huge events that kicked off A Game of Thrones. However, in the case of the show, Littlefinger's involvement was the least unexpected revelation of season four.
3. Stoneheart Removal
Twitter.comIf you don't want to know spoilers regarding a major Storm of Swords spoiler, then skip right past this entry. It won't ruin anything from the show, but if you've been meaning to read the books in anticipation of season five, then this will ruin a big surprise. At the end of A Storm of Swords it's revealed that Catelyn Stark is still roaming Westeros, under the name of Lady Stoneheart. After being resurrected by Beric Dondarrion, Catelyn assumes command of the Brotherhood Without Banners, executing everyone she believes to be a traitor. As you can imagine, it's a pretty huge twist in the books, and important to the arcs of several other major characters. However, actress Michelle Fairley has confirmed that her character is done with, and that there are too many narrative points to include everything. You'd think one of the biggest female characters in the series returning from the dead would be a high priority for inclusion, but there you go.
2. The Sept Scene
HBOIn season four, Jaime appears to rape his twin sister Cersei while in the Sept that contains their dead son. It was a controversial scene that managed to anger a lot of people, for a lot of reasons. Many fans were upset that the event was in contradiction to Jaime Lannister's positive character progression from oath breaking villain to redeemable anti-hero. The rape seemed like a huge step backwards for the character, and a horrific deed that is completely at odds with someone that the show seems desperate for us to sympathise with. Things got even stranger when the episode's director and Nikolaj Coster-Waldau both stated that the scene was never intended to be a rape in the first place. Therefore, we've got either a badly directed scene that totally failed to put across what the director intended, or a narrative event that manages to completely undermines three seasons of characterisation.
1. The Whitewashing Of Tyrion
HBOTyrion Lannister is a very different character in the show compared to the books. In Game of Thrones, he's just about the closest thing we've got to a straight-up hero. However, he's a much greyer character in the books, ruthless and occasionally cruel. Despite Peter Dinklage providing one of television's greatest performances, the whitewashing of Tyrion has meant that later events in the series just don't make a huge amount of sense. We are, of course, speaking about the murder of Shae and Tywin. In the show, it's assumed that he kills Shae for her betrayal, and Tywin for the long years of mistreatment and under-appreciation. However, when you look at it closely, it just doesn't hold up under scrutiny. In particular, murdering Shae (someone he's literally been paying to sleep with) for being in Tywin's bed just makes Tyrion seem like a murdering psychopath. It was a huge surprise in the books, but it also didn't seem like a massive step out of character. In previous chapters, Tyrion had slapped Shae for being out of line, broken a singer's fingers out of malice, and fantasized about hurting those that wronged him. Worst of all though, the show removed the big reason for Tyrion snapping. If you'll recall from a couple of seasons ago, it was mentioned that Tyrion once had a wife named Tysha, long before the events of the show. However, shortly after the marriage, Jaime revealed that Tysha was just a whore that he'd hired to make Tyrion feel better, and Tywin ordered his soldiers to essentially gang rape her. One of the big revelations in Storm of Swords happens when Jaime frees Tyrion from his prison cell. Jaime explains that he had actually lied about Tysha being a whore, on the request of Tywin, meaning that she had actually genuinely been in love with Tyrion. This leads to Tyrion lashing out viciously at Jaime, before going on to murder Shae and his father. The whole 'life has been a lie' revelation is a more understandable trigger for Tyrion to go on a murderous rampage, unlike the flimsy excuse served up by the show. Character motivations and choices have always been a huge part of the series and, in this case, the show completely dropped the ball. Is there anything that you've been disappointed with in Game of Thrones? Are we wrong about everything on this list and you're going to tell us exactly why? Let us know in the comments below!