Showtime's Homeland is one of the most thrilling and captivating of the current crop of politically and psychologically taut TV series. Like The Americans, The Following, Person of Interest, and Breaking Bad, Homeland wraps us up in the world of characters whose lives seem beyond us yet in so many ways also resonate with us. It is most effective in the ways that it startles us to think of the parallels between our lives and those of the characters on the show. While most of us do not experience the dangerous dynamics of spying, espionage, and world-changing national security decisions in our own daily lives, we can experience vicariously the unsettling dynamics of the lives of characters in Homeland and consider the bigger implications of them. Here, then, are 10 reasons that Homeland terrifies us.
10. We Recognize The Power Of Deep Psychological Angst
Carrie Mathison is a character that reflects intense layers of psychological trauma. Claire Danes' gripping portrayal of Mathison illustrates what may be the most human foundation of Homeland. Carrie struggles with the extraordinary stresses of being a CIA agent, all the while dealing with her aging father, and managing her own struggles with biopolar disorder. To make matters worse, Carrie, succumbing to her own personal failings, begins a relationship with Sergeant Nicholas Brodythe man who is the subject of her obsessive intelligence investigation and who suffers from PTSD. For most of us, any one of these psychological hurdles would be monumental, and for the fact that we can imagine associated pain, we are that much more able to relate to the multiple struggles that Carrie faces in Homeland. Such struggles extend to Homeland's other main characters. Most notable in season 3 is Peter Quinn's psychological transformation from a somewhat company man in the CIA to a doubter of his own actions. Putting ourselves in the shoes of Carrie or Peter and we can only imagine the toll that such situations would have on our lives.
9. We Can Feel The Unsettling Forces That Invade Our Relationships
In ways similar to The Americans, Homeland effectively creates drama on the most intimate of levels. The politics of surveillance, covert governmental operations, and the dangers of terrorist operations are magnified and intensified in the personal struggles of the show's many characters. In season 1, Nicholas and Jessica's marriage rests on a knife-edge; throughout the series Saul and his wife Mira experience similar bumps in the road (including Mira's affair in season 3); in season 3, much to the chagrin of many fans of the show, Dana Brody's inability to deal with the stresses of her father's actions and all of the associated bad press leads to more estrangement with her mother; and, in what is the most pivotal of the relationships on the show, Carrie and Brody's feelings for one another vacillate between love and anger, trust and suspicion. While many of these intimate struggles seem at least a bit farfetched, we can nonetheless relate to them in a Shakespearean sense of their being analogues to our own lives.
8. We Feel The Pull Of Revenge Amid Uncertainty
In compelling dramas like Homeland, we often find ourselves caught up in the spirit of split loyalties. A character who is at first a hero becomes a villainthe villain later a hero. In season 1 Nicholas Brody plots revenge against Vice President Bill Walden through a complicated reprogramming of Walden's pacemaker (Interestingly, Politico reported on this same scenario that was considered within the inner circles of Vice President Dick Cheney). Initially, we might view Brody's plans as we would those of any other terrorist, but when more and more backstory is given to Nicholas Brody, we began to understand (though not accept) Brody's desire to seek revenge for the death of Issa Nazirthe boy that he loved like a son. What makes Homeland's pull of revenge so compelling is the uncertainty that accompanies it. Each season offers us the sense that any actwhether one of revenge or a simple act of intelligence gatheringis conditioned by the unsettling fact that the justification for the act may be a fleeting one. The midpoint of season 3 offers such a focus with the Javadi plot. As Carrie questions Javadi about Brody's involvement in the CIA bombing, she begins to sense that Brody may be innocent after all. After this conversation, Carrie is left undoubtedly feeling more ambiguity than certainty about her actions (and those of others) in the show. As many of the other points in this feature suggest, we never fully know the Truth. This Nietzschean focus of Homeland is psychologically gripping. While many spa dramas stress a clearer sense of good and evil, Homeland takes the route of shows like the Wire and instead forces us to consider the ambiguity and uncertainty that is present in the world of the show and, presumably, in our own everyday lives.
7. We Experience The Turmoil Of The Post-911 World
Even in the 12 years that have passed since September 11th, we feel its powerful and shocking reverberations. Homeland uses the political stage of the real world to effectively reveal in us our continued anxieties about the world. Fictionalized events that include the assassination of the Vice President and the bombing of the CIA headquarters serve as harsh reminders of the sense of impending doom that many viewers no doubt felt after September 11th and the military actions in Iraq. In the shifting and undetermined narrative of season 3, we are introduced to Senator Andrew Lockhart, who, soon to be confirmed as CIA director, appears to be Dick Cheney-like in his view of the role that intelligence plays in domestic and foreign policy. Perhaps to balance the concerns that some raised about the anti-Islamist tone of seasons 1 and 2, the character of Lockhart illustrates the complicity of the United States in the post-911 world political climate. Like many good post-911 dramas, Homeland unsettles us in part for the fact that it provides another illustration of the turmoil of the post-911 world and our own roles in it.
6. We Come To Realize The Deadly Nature Of Politics In The World
Shows like Homeland and The Americans have taken an especially interesting approach in how they consider the implications of domestic and foreign politics. Homeland sets its political stage in the presentin a fictionalized post-911, post-Iraq world that looks strikingly similar to our real post-911, post-Iraq world. War heroes, cunning CIA agents, fundamentalist terrorists, and corrupt and power-hungry politicians are the characters from the fictional world of Homeland that resonate with our own understandings of these characters' counterparts in the real world. The terrifying realization that we have from watching Homeland is the fidelity of the characters from the fictional world as we compare them with those of the real world. We come to see that the decisions of a few peoplewho very often are misguided, uninformed, egocentric, or plain crazyhave important and often terrible ramifications on many more people who often have little knowledge of the goings-on behind the scenes. In season 3, this is brought to clear realization in the police investigations of the Javadi murders. One of the officers, while questioning Peter Quinn, glibly asks him," Have you ever done anything but made things worse?"
5. We Acknowledge The Fact That We Can't Trust Everyone... Perhaps Anyone
Anyone who has been in a relationship with a person who at some point deceives you knows the pain that deception can cause. In Homeland, the issues of deception and trust are taken to extreme levels as viewers are asked to consider who is being truthful and who is lying, perhaps for political or personal gain. The "sleeping with the enemy" theme is elaborated as Mathison and Brody engage in a sexual relationship that challenges each of the character's legitimacy within their many social networks. This particular theme of mistrust continues with other charactersincluding Saul Berenson, who, it appears to the viewer, has thrown Carrie under the bus during an intelligence hearing in season 3. While it turns out that this was part of a clever ruse, the viewer is left with the unsettling sense that more of these moments of mistrust are to come. The frightening aspect of this for us is that it forces us to reflect on our own relationships and our own experiences with trust and deception.
4. We Feel The Secret Movements Of A World Beyond Us
Spy dramas have always fascinated us. Whether the classic dramas of James Bond or the many television and film dramas that have, at their heart, the world of surveillance, espionage, and double cross, we are intrigued with the sense of a clockwork operating behind the scenesa secret world that affects us and over which we have very little control. Spy dramas like James Bond have used the formula of the secret world to great successes, but in the case of Homeland there is a more startling use of this convention to offer us the idea that the stakes of the secret world are much more than an archetypal villain like Goldfinger's plans to destroy the world and James Bonds' efforts to stop him. With Nicholas Brody's rise from war hero to congressman to (had events transpired differently) Vice President, we are shown the real possibility that forces beyond our control could dramatically and negatively affect the course of our lives.
3. We Reflect On The Profound And Unsettling Ideas Of Conspiracy
Conspiracies abound. The secret world reflects the idea that people with good and bad intentions are at work, behind the scenes, determining our fates. The rise in popularity of conspiracy theories has helped fuel the popularity of shows like Homeland. Conspiracies fascinate us for at the surface level they are terrifying as they indicate the extent to which people and certain forces will go to perpetuate a crime, an act of terror, or a cover-up. Curiously, once we begin to dig deeper, we discover the sense that "The Truth Is Out There," as the X-Files taught us. We realize that the terror perpetuated by the secret world and its conspirators can be uncovered and that we (like Carrie Mathison) can have a direct role in the uncovering. What works so well in Homeland in terms of conspiraciesespecially as compared with the over-the-top layers of conspiracy in the show The Followingis the drama of key characters Carrie Mathison, Saul Berenson, and Peter Quinn who show great levels of persistence in following the conspiracies to their bitter end. A related aspect of such conspiracies (to return to the early themes of mistrust and deception) is the fact that no matter our sense of how much we have figured out the conspiracy, it could, and likely will, turn out that we were wrong about it from the beginning. As Homeland continues to progress, we may discover that Saul is the mole at the CIA, that Carrie is not who she claims to be, or that Brody isn't as guilty as he seems. Whatever the case may be, we are kept guessing and in constant suspense.
2. We See The Doppelganger
The doppelganger is a mythical figure that reminds us of the two sides of peoplethe authentic, genuine side and the more duplicituous one. One of the most startling aspects of Homeland's plot and character development is its reliance on the figure of the doppelganger. The entirety of season 1 and 2 of the show use this figure to great success in the character of Nicholas Brody. Brody is an apt doppelganger as he has all of the credentials of a true heroa war hero and prisoner of war who refuses to break under pressure; a dedicated family man who cares deeply about his wife, two children, and friend Mike; and a valuable asset to the intelligence community who can help the U.S. take down Abu Nazir. Of course, all of these previous qualities of Brody are false, and this points to the duplicity of the doppelganger. The shifting emotional attachments that we feel to Brody reveal the difficulty of coming to terms with his character. The same can be said of Carrie. With Carrie we have a complex inward-looking doppelganger as we are shown the contradictions of her efforts to do good, catch Brody, and produce intelligence successes and her own inner failings in being unable to trust even those close to her, her shifting allegiances to Brody, and her constant psychological breakdowns. The psychological aspects of Carrie's character illustrate our own multiple selves and our own desires to do good in the world. As hard as it is to come to terms with, the image of the doppelganger forces us to see that we are the enemy.
1. We Recognize Our Own Existential Limitations
Some of the most dramatic moments in Homeland occur through the actions and perceptions of Carrie Mathison. During season 1, viewers were witness to Carrie's attempts to uncover the truth behind her suspicions of Nicholas Brody. Carrie's concerns about Brody go unheardby many of those in the CIA, including Saul, and by Jessica Brodyand this exacerbates Carrie's paranoia and her various mental struggles. Even when she does close in on Brody and gradually exposes the truth about him, it is only the dumb luck of a faulty suicide vest that prevents Brody's first assassination attempt on the Vice President. The universe of Homeland, it seems, expresses a nihilistic truththe many efforts of ours are left unrewarded. For those of the fictional and real worlds of the CIA, this is, very likely, a normal state of affairs. When intelligence successes are realized, the public can never know about them and when tragedies occur (as in the real-world 911 and the fictional attack on thr CIA headquarters) the public is all too aware of these failures. Another nihilistic component of the show that more closely resonates with our lives is illustrated in the actions of Carrie and Brody. In the case of Brody, his accomplishments as a war hero and, at times, the care and love that he expresses for his family and for Carrie are negated by strings of bad decisions. Likewise, Carrie's efforts to stop Brody are always negated by similar bad decisionsthe most notable being shacking up with Brody and allowing him to escape across the Canadian border. For us, it is perhaps terrifying to think that heroes and people with good intentions could do things that cause their worlds to spiral out of control. In this sense we might recall many other popular media that have ruminated on this topic. In the film The Watchmen we get one of the most vivid portrayals of the theme of the "heroes" doing wrong, in The Dark Knight we discover the theme of masculine escalation and its negative effect on others, and in the HBO drama The Wire, we realize that forces on all sidesfrom the drug dealers to the noble police officersmake a mess of the world that falls under their purview. Homeland works on a different register than these other media but it similarly emphasizes the existential notion that our good efforts to do the right thing will, for one reason or another, likely end in negative outcomes.