Netflix Live-Action One Piece Review: 7 Ups And 4 Downs
Have the Straw Hat Pirates successfully set sail into live-action?
If you're a fan of the iconic One Piece franchise, then you're probably on cloud nine right now. People can barely move an inch on the internet without stumbling across something to do with the series, especially after the release of the Netflix live-action adaptation.
Now, hearing the words anime adaptation, live-action, and Netflix all in one sentence is usually enough to get fans sweating. Lest anyone forget the streaming platforms' disastrous attempts to re-create Death Note and Cowboy Bebop...
So how has the service fared with one of the most beloved Shonen stories ever made?
Well, shockingly, it's good, very good. Many viewers even think it has finally broken the live-action anime curse and proved that it is possible to bring the world of Japanese animation to the screen without butchering it.
Of course, while the show certainly has its plus points, it's not all smooth sailing. There are a few notable issues that keep it from being perfect and will hold some viewers back from fully connecting with it.
Ultimately, this is an excellent series for long-term fans and a fun adventure for newcomers. So, here's where Luffy's Gum-Gum Pistol connects and where it misses.
11. Down: The Obnoxious Close-Ups
There will be an entry later talking about the general cinematography, and (spoiler alert!) it will be much more positive. But there is one gripe that cannot be overlooked.
From the minute this show starts, you'll notice that it really, really loves a good close-up.
This seems fine initially, as close-up angles can quickly help viewers feel connected to the cast and involved in the story. They also add a cinematic edge, making the actors appear larger than life. But in this show, it quickly becomes annoying.
There are so many close-ups that it's distracting, as you'll be trying to enjoy the show and take in the stunning visuals, only to find yourself stuck an inch or two away from someone's face. Hell, you can count the cavities in their teeth at times!
This entry would have only been a nitpick in the first few episodes, but the fact these close-ups are so consistent takes it from being a minor grievance to a genuine distraction.
Playing with a distinct visual style is all well and good, but some personal space would be nice.
10. Down: The Acting Is Uneven
It is important to note that the general acting caliber for One Piece is high, as it's a very well-cast project. That said, there is a lack of balance that will be distracting to viewers who prefer a standard tone.
If anything, One Piece's acting feels like it is one of two halves. On one side, you've got people playing the roles up and going overboard to match the goofy tone. This includes folk like Iñaki Godoy as the protagonist Monkey D. Luffy, and Jeff Ward as Buggy the Clown. These actors are having a whale of a time, and it shows, as their scenery-chewing antics are a blast to watch.
However, on the other side, you've got those who opt for subtle performances. Actors like Mackenyu as Roronoa Zoro and Emily Rudd as Nami fit this bill, as they'd feel perfectly at home in a young adult series.
This is not a criticism of the actors, as both approaches are engaging. But, there are times when the clash between subtle and over-the-top performances is noticeable and leads to dissonance.
9. Down: The Inconsistent Pacing
You can't blame One Piece for struggling to achieve perfect pacing when having to fit the whole East Blue Saga into one season. But that doesn't change the fact that it struggles to keep the pace running consistently.
There are times when the show drags as it has to dart around so much to include everything. Episode 6 is a good example, as the pacing slows down to a crawl as it tries to strike a balance between fun-loving adventure, personal drama, and character development.
Forcing character backstories, battles with villains, personal drama within the crew, and exposition of the world into each episode often make stretches of the story drag, especially when you just want to continue on the adventure.
Some moments also feel rushed, quickly brushing through important character development to move on to the next big highlight from the series. A firm example of this can be found in Usopp, whose backstory is so condensed that it misses much of what made it so special in the anime/manga.
This issue will cause many viewers to switch off at times, even if One Piece is generally great.
8. Down: It Can Be Tonally Jarring
One of the biggest challenges of bringing animation to live-action is the visual style. Cartoons can get away with being over-exaggerated in a way that live-action simply can't. One Piece doesn't shy away from the goofier stuff, which is a good thing, but it's tough to take it seriously when needed.
One example is when the character's clothing interrupts dramatic scenes. The costumes look great in this show, but they're obviously cartoonish in a way that can be distracting. It's hard to take moments like the conversations between Koby and Garp seriously when you have to look at the former's funny circular glasses.
Additionally, the character designs can also suffer from this. Watching Sanji and Zeff dramatically argue in a grounded tone ends up being unintentionally hilarious as you see Zeff's ridiculous mustache bouncing about the place.
In general, this show attempts to strike a balance between the comedy and drama of the anime but has a much harder time thanks to its live-action medium. Anime fans might not be bothered by this, but folk who are new to One Piece could struggle to jump this hurdle.
7. Up: The Sets Are Epic
Now that the messier parts of the show have been discussed, why not run through the things that make Netflix's One Piece one of the best live-action anime adaptations ever made? Where better to start than with the spectacular physical sets?
It is always satisfying to see projects that build handcrafted environments, especially when CGI backdrops and settings dominate the TV/Film landscape. If Barbie didn't give you enough of it, then you'll be satisfied here as the locations of One Piece are stunningly brought to life with excellent production design and practical sets.
There are plenty of locations in the season, and they're full of incredible detail. Each set has a distinct feel, and knowing they're there physically makes it all the easier to become engrossed in them.
A fine example is the crew's main ship, the Going Merry. This iconic boat was painstakingly built and it looks spectacular. Other great sets include the Baratie restaurant, Kaya's mansion in Syrup Village, Axe-Hand Morgan's Marine Base, and more.
The production spared no expense, turning the series into a visual delight.
6. Up: It Makes The Right Changes
One of the most contentious things about bringing anime to live-action is the amount of changes viewers can expect from the source material. The projects often become unrecognisable, *cough* Dragon Ball Evolution *cough*. But, to make a show like this work, changes had to be made, and somehow, One Piece chose all the right ones.
A lot of content is cut to keep the show from being too convoluted and long. Some notable character omissions include Jango, Hachi, The Usopp Pirates, and Momoo.
Additionally, formerly major villains like Don Krieg and Gin have their roles cut down to brief cameos. Plus, Chouchou the Dog's storyline doesn't happen at all.
While this is all sad, it is a necessary sacrifice for the greater good, as these elements are not essential to the plot.
The show makes cuts, but it also adds enough to make the adaptation worthwhile. The subplot focusing on Koby and Garp brings later storyline elements in early and adds an overarching threat. Plus, scenes like Zoro escaping a well while flashing back to his childhood make for excellent sequences not found in the anime.
Overall, the changes might rub some the wrong way, but they are very well-thought-out.
5. Up: The Unique Cinematography
Yes, okay, the sheer amount of close-ups is a problem. But, in every other regard, Netflix's One Piece does a bang-up job of having a distinct visual identity, especially in the cinematography.
Whether it's the dynamic and well-choreographed fight scenes, the use of unexpected angles and camera movements, or the unique framing of characters, it's safe to say this is a show with plenty of artistic flair.
There are loads of other creative choices that stand out. One great example is the use of bounty posters, which appear every time a new major pirate is introduced. This not only provides an idea of the new person but highlights the importance of bounties in this world.
One Piece is shot in a way that other Netflix shows aren't, and hell, even those close-ups are at least something different.
4. Up: It Captures The Anime’s Tone
If you can pinpoint the one thing that Netflix always seems to botch when adapting anime, it's the tone. Their Death Note series forgot all the dark brooding that made the original property so beloved. Plus, their take on Cowboy Bebop replaced the rustic and melancholic vibes with an in-your-face sci-fi style.
Many fans were worried that One Piece would track down this same road, especially after the initial trailers featured MCU-like bickering and wisecracks. Thankfully, the creators knew that messing this up would be a disaster. Thus, they stuck by the anime, and it paid off.
This is a goofy series with an irreverent tone and a clear self-awareness. It knows it's silly, and it doesn't care so long as the audience is having fun and going along with the adventure.
That approach is something many anime adaptations try to avoid as they attempt to make the series believable or realistic. But One Piece knows what it is and earnestly captures the spirit of the anime because of it.
As stated earlier, the cartoonish tone can undoubtedly be jarring. However, it's better to suffer from that than seeing the essence of the source material get left by the wayside.
3. Up: It Crams All The Important Stuff Into A Neat Package
Pacing issues aside, it is still mind-boggling how well the series manages to hit all the highlights of the anime's initial arcs in such a short amount of time. One Piece is a notoriously long and well-packed story, so you really have to tip your (straw) hats to the creative crew for condensing it down so neatly.
This season of television packs in most of the major points in the East Blue Saga, and barely needs to compromise on anything. Each of the key Arcs are explored in roughly a few episodes each, yet all the most integral elements are included.
You get to see each character get solid intros and a chance to explore their backstories. It also includes most of the key villains, and the battles they have with the leads. Barring some previously mentioned omissions, this season taps into almost everything that the anime/manga has to offer.
If you're intimidated by the sheer immensity of the original series - over 1000 episodes is a tough sell even for massive anime fans - then this really is the perfect way to dip your toes in without the full commitment.
2. Up: The Main Cast Is Excellent
Casting can be a tough nut to crack, but that nut is harder than diamonds when you've got to contend with picking real-life actors to play animated characters. How does One Piece fair? Well, shockingly, it manages to pull it off.
The main cast does a stunning job with the characters. While they have differing approaches, each completely suits their parts and adds a new spin to them.
Mackenyu plays Zoro with unabashed coolness. Emily Rudd effortlessly captures Nami's inner conflict and acts as the driving force of the crew. Taz Skyler is charming and likable as Sanji, and Jacob Romero is amusing as Usopp. Still, the MVP of the show is Iñaki Godoy, who nails the role of Luffy.
It's like Godoy was born to play this role, as he effortlessly captures the character's goofiness, unpredictability, humour, and gravitas. But, most of all, he emits Luffy's uncompromising spirit and determination.
The supporting cast also impresses, with actors like Vincent Regan (Garp), Jeff Ward (Buggy), Peter Gadiot (Shanks), and Steven John Ward (Mihawk) shining in their respective roles.
Finally, those who want a nostalgia hit will love the Japanese dub, which features many of the same voice actors as the original anime. It's a win, win, win!
1. Up: It’s A Great Start To A Promising Series
Ultimately, despite the downs, Netflix's One Piece has done a spectacular job of bringing the iconic property to live-action, and things are only set to get better.
The show has teething issues; that much is certain. But these are all kinks that can be ironed out. Plus, even if they remain, the direction the story will go in and the new Arcs it will adapt should be enough to placate viewers.
There is still so much left to explore. The thought of what they'll do with characters like Robin, Chopper, Brook, Ace, Law, and more is tantalising. Plus, some Arcs would look incredible in this show's style.
Will there be another season? Things are certainly pointing that way at the time of writing, as the viewership numbers have been very impressive, and the whole internet has been talking about it. Plus, Netflix has made a big investment in this project, so they will want to continue to see that pay off. If they stick to it, then it's going to be one hell of a ride.
The One Piece is real, and this show knows it!