With a new series of Sherlock underway, I think its good to look back on five questions that the first annd second episodes of Season Three have left us with. Sherlock is a show known for giving us more questions than answers by the end of the episode, and The Empty Hearse and Sign of Three was no exception. It's all coming down to His Final Vow, which promises to be a exciting episode to rival the Reichenbach Fall. With the new series underway, many of us expected an episode to be filled with answers that have plagued the fandom for two years however so far we've only gotten answerless albeit good episodes from Mark Gatiss. Some of this includes some interesting deducing about Mary Morstan, missing people from series one and two, some interesting things about Mycroft, and of course the ominous man at the end of the episode. But above all, we still dont know how Sherlock pulled off his fake death! For many Sherlockians, the fact that we still dont know how Sherlock faked his death was something that many of us harped on for much of the never-ending hiatus between series two and three. While those theories were mentioned, everything from something incredibly plausible to something out of bad fanfiction, we never got a direct answer. But there were also other questions posed that were likely hopefully to get an answer to in the next two episodes. We can only hope.
5. DonovanDonovanDonovan?
Even though Donovan is everyones favorite person on Sherlock to hate, was I the only one that wondered where she was in the episode that showed what everyone had done in two years? She had more dynamic than Anderson, who showed up less than Donovan in the past two series, and we all know that she was the one warned John in the first place. Youd think shed at least want to say I told you so to John. So where is she? Did she keep her job while Anderson lost his? If so, how did she manage that? What we can expect is that if she returns and Ive heard she will in The Sign of Three there will be awkward silences between Sherlock, John, and Donovan. She doesnt seem like someone who has an inner liking for Sherlock, she always was the meanest to him, she always seemed to have a deep disliking almost hatred for him. This would most likely mean that she would be unhappy to see him especially if his stunt cost her a job. So what can we expect? Hello Freak and a smile? Or something different? I would find it odd that a character that spent so much of her time disliking Sherlock, thinking hed kill someone some day, and helped plant the idea that he was a fake would come back and admit that she missed him. Anderson was enough of a surprise to have both people who used to hate him now appreciate him is a bit of a stretch. Some people are just bad.
4. Will Mycroft Get A Goldfish?
Dont worry, I wont get into who I think the figurative goldfish could or should be. But the episode posed a strange question one that I dont think many of us ever thought before: Do Mycroft and Sherlock ever get lonely? We know from several episodes that Sherlock doesnt want someone to share his life with, but with Mycroft being someone that weve only seen in passing, I think we all thought introversion was just in their genes. Though after seeing their parents, maybe we were wrong. The deducing and IQ definitely are heredity, but even Sherlock seems like he doesnt want his brother to be alone like hed been for two years. Is this character development at play or a tribute to the fact that Mycroft might be different than Sherlock and that he does get lonely? We saw many new factors of Mycroft in The Empty Hearse, and the fact that Sherlock picked up on the fact that his brother is lonely both speak volumes of their characters. That Sherlock cares for his brother and knows enough about him and that Mycroft does in fact enjoy interactions with humans. Is that why he prefers to call? Now many people want to ask the question, Well, who would be his goldfish? This obviously depends on Mycrofts sexuality, and while I can give names of people I would put him with, I think Ill leave my personal opinions out of this article and say that I, like Sherlock, would just want Mycroft to be with someone whose company he enjoys. Or perhaps Sherlock really meant a goldfish.
3. What Are You Hiding, Mary Morstan?
To quote Winston Churchill, this woman is a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. When looking back at the quick deducing Sherlock does outside of the restaurant, we see a few words that made us all worry for the mental health of John. Specifically the term liar. Having just talked about Johns mustache, it could easily be something as trivial as that Mary lied to John. Having just lied to him for two years, perhaps Sherlock was particularly sensitive to the idea that lying to someone especially John isnt a good idea. Do we really think that though? No, of course not. This is Sherlock and Steven Moffat were talking about. Its not going to be something simple, and as the wheels turn in the heads of the Sherlock fans, its possible that liar could be as much a warning for her than for us. Specific things that fans have noticed about Mary is that she refused the wine offered to her, there were suspicious deductions that Sherlock made, and finallysomething that Amanda Abbington let slip. According to the Mirror and the whole idea coming from this tumblr post, Mary Morstan is a journalist. You can click the link to the tumblr post, which explains it all in more detail, but basically the Tumblr post points out that its possible that in the deducing we see points that she may work for the Guardian. I find this incredibly plausible, especially since the deduction happened so fast we could barely read everything, where as normally it allows us a few seconds to read what Sherlocks thinking. Maybe Gatiss was trying to hide a plot point in the quick deductions. It would be a smart way to hide something in plain sight. No pun intended. (It should be noted however that in a recent interview with Moffat and Abbington there was nothing about her being a journalist)
2. Who's Watching Sherlock?
Obviously those eyes belonged to Charles Magnussen. I imagine it will be much like how the first season of Sherlock when we heard the name Moriarty in episode one only to see him at the end of the season. They couldnt do that again, so they gave us a picture of his eyes to show that hes watching and knows that Sherlock foiled his plot. The man comes from the short story of Sir Conan Doyles The Adventures of Charles Augustus Milverton. So we know who the eyes belonged to now the obvious question is how will this man affect Sherlock? We know that he had someone try to blow up London, so its likely that he may not even be after Sherlock specifically, hes just the only one who is crazy enough to stop Magnussen. I think its likely to say that the things we enjoyed about Moriarty wont be there with this villain and even if they are, that his murders and attempts on blowing up London will prove more important. And if a man is fine with blowing up London using the tube, what does that mean if he's after one person in particular? Let's hope that the last episode doesn't end like the Reichenbach Fall, only for real. The other interesting thing about Magnussen is that unlike Moriarty, he is not a fan of Sherlocks. It seems that Sherlock only caught his eye when he stopped the bomb from going off in the train. This will definitely give us more of a classic archenemy vibe. So far though, all Sherlock has done is diffuse a bomb, and the next episode will be most likely centered around John and Mary. So maybe Im asking the wrong question. Maybe the right question is: What in the world happens in His Final Vow?
1. No, Seriously. How Did He Do It?
If there is one thing that Series Three has lacked, it was explanation of the question that everyones been asking. While I appreciate the mystery the writers have by not telling us, its really incredibly annoying that we still dont know. Will we find out this season? Will we ever find out? Does it matter how he did it? The writers are probably trying to convey to us through the completely insane ideas shown that it doesnt really matter how he did, and that weve all spent too much time on it, we know that. It was also probably used to show us how insane some of the theories we convinced ourselves to be true were. The fact is we already know that we went a bit crazy in two years, but that doesnt make us want to know any less! Sure, maybe we should have spent the last two years in the shoes of the characters who were dealing with the loss of their friend, but feelings arent part of Sherlock! If I want to be sad Ill go watch the regeneration episode of Doctor Who, thank you. At this point I find it incredibly unlikely that well ever find out exactly how he did it, because the plot has moved on, and so must we. Who am I kidding? We need to know! Hopefully Moffat will do what he normally does and pull an explanation out in the last episode of the series. Thats what Im banking on. If not, then we put on our deerstalkers and our belstaffs and scarves and continue to deduce those moments in the Reichenbach Fall and theorize til our hands hurt. I only expect more questions to become unanswered throughout the season. What questions do you hope get answered?