Of all the races seen in the vast Star Trek galaxy, Vulcans are perhaps the most recognised. Loved even to the point where audiences cheered when First Contact's oft-mentioned "alien race" revealed their legendary pointed ears and were the first to introduce Zefram Cochrane, and all of humanity, to our galactic neighbours. Despite being recognised for several reasons however, it has to be said that almost all of these (perhaps not the pointy ears) are accompanied by misconceptions. Whilst the nerve-pinch is a firm favourite for example, the death-grip is in fact made up. Vulcans are also well known for not having emotions, whilst in actuality they possess those that are far more intense than others, but which they choose to suppress. Again, just as Spock is only half Vulcan, it would also seem that on many occasions the Vulcan race is only half logical; the number of times in which their beloved logic can be described as either flawed or even non-existent is actually higher than many would realise. Thanks to Spock, Tuvok, and T'Pol, Vulcans (or at least half Vulcans) maintained a regular appearance throughout four of the six (five live-action, and one animated) television series. Add this to the series' other recurring and one-off characters, as well as the movies, and you have a fair few examples to choose from. Here however, are just ten...
10. Reverting To Your Ancestors
Before starting, it has to be said that several illogical decisions made by Vulcans were done so due to circumstances out of their control. Spock put pleasure above all else thanks to Omicron Ceti III's native spores for example, and T'Pol became enraged by exposure to Trellium-D. Despite these however, there is one moment of Vulcan illogic that is itself, rather illogical. Having travelled back to the Ice Age of the planet Sarpeidon, Spock reverts to a highly emotional, pre-logic Vulcan of their current era, some 5,000 years in the past. While his anger towards McCoy and love for Zarabeth certainly make for some dramatic conflict, the writers conveniently side-stepped the fact that when you think about it, this doesn't actually make any sense. Certainly Vulcans 4,700 years ago were barbaric, but there is no logical reason to assume that merely by sharing the same point in time (still countless light years away from Vulcan itself) Spock's physiology or philosophy would revert back to a point from before he was born. With Star Trek now a massive phenomenon, it is easy to forget that it all began with what was just one of many larger than life action-oriented TV series. Today's series and writers pay far more attention to their verisimilitude however, and with a keener attention to detail, illogical decisions comes at no-ones fault but the Vulcans themselves.
9. Discipline Is Washed Away
Amongst Vulcans, the name of Sarek is a revered one; a legendary ambassador, he served the Federation far into his old age. Perhaps too far, as in his 202nd year it was discovered by the crew of the Enterprise that he had he unfortunately developed Bendii syndrome; a form of Vulcan dementia. In order to stop this from interfering with his final negotiations with the Legarans, a pain-staking task which had already taken 93 years, those close to Sarek hid the truth from him, even to the point of telepathic help from his aide, Sakkath. Alongside Surak's wife, Perrin, the two Vulcans seemed to be in denial about the effects of Sarek's disease, and allowed it to jeopardise not just the Legaran treaty, but also the Enterprise crew themselves. While it is true that the Legarans were sticklers for detail and the negotiations would be set back by the presence of another ambassador, it seems that the Vulcans also considered Sarek's reputation to be a greater priority. Somehow the ego of the one outweighed the needs of the many. After discussions with both Picard and Data however, Sarek and Sakkath respectively are persuaded by logical arguments, and a new solution is devised. By mind melding with Picard, Sarek is able to borrow a measure of the captain's control, who temporarily shouldered the burden of his disorderly emotions. Possibly the best acting performance by Patrick Stewart notwithstanding, this allowed Sarek to complete the negotiations before retiring gracefully.
8. V'tosh Ka'tur
Literally meaning "Vulcans without logic", you could be mistaken for thinking that this should be higher on the list, were it not for the fact that the Vulcans without logic, actually have logic. Branded with this designation by Vulcan society who considered logic and emotions to be somewhat mutually exclusive, those "V'tosh ka'tur" crewing the starship Vahklas in the Enterprise episode Fusion had actually found a balance between the two. All except for Tolaris that is, who rightfully lives up to the name. Like a rebellious teenager experimenting with things he doesn't quite understand, he initiated a mind meld with T'Pol. When she asked him to stop, he didn't, became angry, and basically mind-raped her. Not only did he ignore her protests, but by underestimating the power of the mind meld, a technique he hadn't fully grasped, he left T'Pol with a neural disease called Pa'nar Syndrome.
7. We Don't Condone Intimate Acts
This storyline was continued the following season, as the episode Stigma looked at the taboo nature of both mind meld's themselves, and the Pa'nar Syndrome which T'Pol had contracted. This came as a part of Viacom's mandate that all of its shows should produce an episode which discusses HIV/Aids, and in one of its more obvious sci-fi metaphor of the modern world episodes, Star Trek looked at, unsurprisingly, the stigma that often surrounds the disease. Even without this though, Vulcans' prejudice of non-conformists, or seemingly of any minority group, is highly obvious. In the 22nd Century the V'tosh ka'tur were rejected from society because their beliefs were different from that of the mainstream, and mind melds were considered unnatural to such an extreme that anyone who had developed Pa'nar syndrome (meld's being the only way of doing so), was exiled from society. When T'Pol is first diagnosed the Vulcan doctors who uncover her illness not only attempt to recall her from her post aboard Enterprise, but also revoke Doctor Phlox's invitation to a medical conference. Although she is eventually allowed to continue in her position, Yuris, a doctor who defends T'Pol by "outing" himself as a melder, is dismissed from the Interspecies Medical Exchange. When you also factor in marriages that are arranged from young childhood, it seems that despite a philosophy of Infinite Diversity in Infinite Combinations, freedom of choice is in limited supply on Vulcan.
6. Melding With A Serial Killer
After the mind meld overcame the taboo status it held in the 22nd Century, it became a useful tool and a cornerstone of Vulcans' abilities. Unfortunately this also included those instances when the risks of using it far outweighed the benefits; Tuvok's curiosity of Lon Suder is perhaps the best example. Stuck on board the lone starfleet vessel in the Delta Quadrant, Betazoid Lon Suder found that the only outlet for his violent impulses was to kill another member of Voyager's crew. Not the first person he had killed either, as he had originally joined The Maquis purely for that purpose. In fact his impulses were so severe that Suder's only explanation for crewman Darwin's homicide is simply "I didn't like the way he looked at me." So does Tuvok lock him up and throw away the key? Of course not, he decides to give the murderous sociopath a direct link to his own mind. He also does this alone, without Captain Janeway's knowledge (let alone consent), and although he states it was also to help Suder with his self-control, the fact that he later suggests execution as a punishment/solution does tend to make this a fairly moot point. With Tuvok's further help and teachings (no mention of any mind meld's being necessary), Suder was able to regain some level of control during his confinement to maximum security quarters, but this didn't stop Tuvok from pretty much destroying his own due to the violence he inherited from Suder. All in all, definitely not worth it, but things could have been much worse...
5. Being A Serial Killer
Vulcans, as a rule, don't like emotions. They consider them a distraction, and suppress them to gain a further understanding of logic. Not that this in itself is wrong, but sometimes this can be taken to extreme, and illogical levels. Take Lt. Chu'lak for instance. In the Deep Space Nine episode Field Of Fire, Chu'lak murdered three of his fellow officers, in a rather cowardly manner, for the simple reason that they all had photos of people who were expressing some form of emotion. This came about as he had previously been one of only six survivors of the USS Grissom, destroyed in the Dominion war, and Chu'lak's psychological trauma was just too much to bear. Although survivors guilt alone can often be a tormenting affliction, the tragedy of witnessing the loss of over 1,000 crewmates would surely be too much for anyone. So whilst this particular example may be (somewhat) understandable, his defence that "logic demanded it" unfortunately just doesn't add up.
4. Vulcan Vs Andoria
When the Star Trek universe went back to the beginning in Enterprise, the Vulcans were given something of an ego trip. Whilst there had always been individuals portrayed as smug and even arrogant, these traits had now gone viral. Chief of these (quite literally) was administrator V'Las, leader of the Vulcan High Command. The ongoing conflict between Vulcan and Andoria was a story arc that continued for the length of all of Enterprise's four seasons, and included installing surveillance equipment in monasteries, and signing a peace treaty with dishonourable intentions. These culminated in the three part story The Forge/Awakening/Kir'Shara, in which the bombing of the United Earth embassy on Vulcan was perpetrated by members of the High Command as a precursor to a full scale attack on Andoria. Something which also saw V'Las himself in league with the Romulans. Luckily the Syrrannite revolution put a stop to his plan, and they led the Vulcans on a path which included a more logical interpretation of logic. But that's not to say allying themselves with Romulans was the most illogical conspiracy a Vulcan ever entered into...
3. Khitomer Conspiracy
With so many Vulcans (at least in the prime universe), it is understandable that there will also be several interpretations of what actually is logical. There aren't many as controversial as Valeris though. The only (known) Vulcan amongst several key conspirators, but who has enough illogic for several. For starters, there is the conspiracy in the first place: stop the Klingon/Federation peace treaty from being signed by assassinating the leaders of both the Klingon Empire, and the United Federation of Planets. A treaty later known as the Khitomer Accords, which history has shown to have been beneficial to both powers. Secondly, as Spock points out once he has uncovered her involvement, logic demands that she has to shoot him - something which she chooses not to do. More than both of these however, is the fact that a joining together of alien races was conspired against by several of those same races joining together. Valeris herself believes in stopping the treaty because Klingons can't be trusted, but doesn't specify whether this includes General Chang and his crew, with whom she is working. Not that it matters too much, as she's being highly illogical either way. Just as the ends don't justify the means, "Logic is the beginning of wisdom ... not the end", and it all goes to show that you can't always trust Vulcans (or Humans and Romulans) either.
2. Kal-if-fee
Whilst renowned for (mostly) being logical and unemotional, Vulcans are also well known for their other traits which these lead to, such as being peace-loving and philosophical. Obviously, this makes you wonder where exactly the tradition of Kal-if-fee comes into anything. Not that historic ceremonies are illogical, but why would a fight to the death in order to not go through with your arranged marriage still be practised by a race who are so devoted to peace they became vegetarians? Another point to consider is that the only thing to cut deeper than a Lirpa's blade is that it's the bride who initiates the challenge, but doesn't take part; it is two others who risk their lives for her benefit. Certainly the Pon farr - from which her betrothed would be suffering, and the whole reason that the marriage issue needs to be addressed - is a powerful condition, but surely a race as developed as the Vulcans could develop some medical treatment far more in line with their philosophy. Perhaps even some "release" more than once every seven years might help such a chemical imbalance from being so, well, unbalanced. Who would have thought that the first proper insight into Vulcan culture would be one of the most illogical? No wonder the whole race is so secretive about it.
1. USS T'Kumbra
While it can be difficult to specify the role of Starfleet, it can essentially be summarised as a scientific and exploratory military (at least defensively) force. Essentially it's the go-to service whenever the United Federation of Planets wants anything done. For many new lifeforms and civilisations, it's also their first example of what the UFP is; a joining of 150+ planets who have come together in peaceful union, whilst celebrating their diversity. In the more enlightened period of the 24th Century then, the USS T'Kumbra flies warp factor 9 right into the face of everything the Federation stands for. Whilst Captain Solok's pompous one-upmanship with Captain Sisko is hardly utopian, it can at least be forgiven. Going beyond this though, you would think that the race who initiated the Interspecies Medical Exchange, and who were a founding member of the Federation itself, would firmly believe in the idea that interstellar co-operation is about being a piece of something that is more than the sum of it's parts. This is certainly logic that has been proved time and time again by the UFP's merely being in existence, and is the cornerstone of creator Gene Roddenberry's vision; something which having a Federation Starship crewed entirely by a single race, in this case obviously Vulcans, goes against in every way. And the fact that they called their Baseball team "The Logicians" only adds insult to injury.