Star Trek: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Deanna Troi
I’m sensing you want to know more about Deanna Troi. Grab a chocolate sundae and let's get going!
This empath, ship’s counselor, imzadi, chocoholic, dress-down-Friday-is-every-day, one-time Romulan, and designated driver is certainly a fan favourite. The character’s return in Star Trek: Picard was the highlight of an otherwise chaotic season, and she is always the star of any Lower Decks episode we see her in.
At least at the beginning of The Next Generation, Deanna Troi wasn’t used to best effect. The writers had painted themselves into a corner somewhat by creating a character whose empathic abilities could easily spoil the nub of the plot without careful consideration. As the seasons progressed, she did get some more meaty storylines in episodes such as Face Of The Enemy or The Loss.
Although appearing more perturbed than Worf at a Betazoid wedding such that her final fate is anyone’s guess, Troi features in the thrilling season three trailers for Picard, and so looks set for some proper screen time once more. Usually, of course, there just aren’t enough hours in the day to discuss such matters, because hours in the day are always lacking. Still, we await the final season of Picard, and especially Troi’s part in it, with bated breath. See Temporal Mechanics Department for introductions that have aged badly.
It seems to appropriate, therefore, to discuss some little-known facts about this beloved character. So, get comfortable on that chaise longue as we take a deep dive into Troi’s persona.
Paging Dr Freud. Paging Dr Freud...
10. The Role First Went To Denise Crosby
Before filming began on Star Trek: The Next Generation, the producers were set on casting Denise Crosby in the role of Deanna Troi, and, at the same time, Marina Sirtis was reading for the part of Macha Hernandez, who later became Natasha Yar. Crosby admitted that she had difficulties with her fit for the role, not quite grasping, as she once stated, the "gobbledygook and weird" concept of a Betazoid. It was Gene Roddenberry who eventually swapped the roles.
It was decided that Sirtis was a better fit for the part of the empathic Troi. In Crosby’s words (citing Roddenberry, however), she, the actress, was "just this kind of American golden girl" compared to the more "exotic," "otherworldly" element that was wanted for Troi.
In any case, the switch happened not a moment too soon! When Sirtis got the call confirming she’d got the part, her US visa was due to expire that very day. The actress was packing her bags, a little dejected, for a return to her hometown of London. Thankfully, the rest is history.
Had Roddenberry not changed things, perhaps Troi, and not Yar, would have met her end at the hands (gloopy pseudo-appendages?!) of grumpy ol’ prank-bait Armus?
9. Character Constructs: Not A Total Recall
What you may not know is that the character of Troi first took reference from prior Trek, and Ilia in particular from The Motion Picture (think DELTA-ns and BETA-zoids and their mental capabilities). The latter was already a carry-over from the abandoned project Star Trek: Phase II. Ilia’s relationship with Will Decker was then the model to build that between Troi and Riker.
Both Marina Sirtis and Denise Crosby also originally considered Troi to be "Spock-like". The character description for Troi in the TNG Series Bible does make passing reference to Spock, but this is merely to flesh out the counsellor’s telepathic abilities. Troi was, ultimately, meant to be her own person, her role nonetheless "second in importance only to the captain and first officer" according to the Series Bible once more.
There seems to be some confusion surrounding the original intent for the character, however. Between conflicting descriptions of Roddenberry calling Troi both "the brain on the show" and "sexy and not very bright," it is difficult to know what to think. Apparently, Roddenberry initially wanted Troi to have three (or even four depending on the source) breasts before D.C. Fontana THANKFULLY convinced him otherwise. Sirtis would later note that, with the costume changes of season one, "[…] when [Troi] […] got cleavage, she lost her brain matter", and only really gained some back when she (re)gained the uniform.
8. She Nearly Didn't Make It Past Season One Of TNG
Given the pandemonium behind the scenes, it is a wonder anyone made it past the first season of TNG. We all know what happened to Natasha Yar/Denise Crosby and Dr Crusher/Gates McFadden. What you probably didn’t know, however, is that it was Troi who was originally on the chopping block.
Several fairly significant changes had already been made to the character between the pilot and the rest of the season: the extent of Troi's 'powers' was reduced with regards to her telepathic capabilities, and she also changed outfit and hairstyle. No longer was she dressed in that god-awful "cosmic cheerleader" uniform with "the ugliest go-go boots ever designed," as Marina Sirtis herself famously described it.
As briefly described in the introduction, the writers struggled with the character and her empathic abilities. According to Sirtis, she was often simply written out of scenes where Troi’s presence could have been problematic for the plot. (As Captain Janeway once said, "What I wouldn’t give for a Betazoid about now".) This led the writers to consider nixing the character before the end of the first season.
It was only with the departure of Crosby and McFadden from the show that Troi was given leave to remain. Sirtis found this out straight from the horse’s mouth (at Jonathan Frakes’ wedding during the break between seasons) when Gene Roddenberry approached her to announce that the first episode of season two would focus on Troi.
7. Marina Sirtis Hated All That Chocolate
In TNG at least, Troi seemed to accumulate a lot of serious and dark scenes, some of which have been discussed above. She loses her empathic powers, is rapidly aged by a malicious alien ambassador, has her body taken over by a criminal imposter, is transformed into an amphibian, must do the acting job of her life aboard a Romulan Starship, and that’s not to mention having to negotiate the 'difficult' relationship she has with her mother.
Of course, her role as counsellor requires her to be more earnest than most, but there are lighter moments for Troi. One now famous example is her adoration of (borderline addiction to) chocolate. Well, it is a GALAXY-class Starship. (Teehee!)
In the episode The Game, Riker finds Troi tucking in to a bowl of chocolate upon chocolate upon chocolate. She proceeds to explain to him, in the minutest of detail, the fine art of the confectionary’s consumption. Remember: "It’s the whole experience"!
What you may not know, however, and far from never having met a chocolate she didn’t like, was that Marina Sirtis hated having to eat it. Contrary to popular belief, the actress does like chocolate, but eating that much take after take would be too much for anybody. Apparently, she would ask the crew to use a type of chocolate she didn’t like, and then would spit out what she ate in to a bucket.
6. Her Changing Accent Has An Origin Story
The original casting call description for Troi, not without a few uncomfortable 'of-the-time' aftertastes and clichés in all its pan-European vagueness, states that "Deanna is probably foreign (anywhere from Italian, Greek, Hungarian, Russian, Icelandic, etc.) with looks and accent to match".
Marina Sirtis, who was born in London (East and then moved North) to Greek parents, and is fluent in Greek, is skilled at accents and was tasked to create a Betazoid one for Troi. She opted for a mixture of Eastern European and what she drew from the accent of an Israeli friend.
The problem with this was that when we met Troi’s Betazoid mother – Lwaxana – she sounded, and for want of a more precise description, 'American'. Sirtis was then told that Deanna got her accent from her father, but, when we meet him, he also sounds 'generic American' (the actor hails from Texas, by the by) so that didn’t fit either.
Understandably a bit frustrated, Sirtis eventually just switched to something more mid-Atlantic as the series and films progressed, at times closer to her native North London, and at others more American. The actress stated that if she could change one thing about her time on TNG, "I wouldn’t give Deanna a foreign accent – even though her mother is a Betazoid".
5. She Might Have Married Riker In Season Seven Of TNG
All good things must come to an end, naked on Betazed. Or, it could very well have turned out this way before the series' finale.
In the actual season seven, we got to see a relationship between Troi and Worf, but it was all a bit weird and never went anywhere as Worf was transferred to Deep Space Nine. The two were married with kids in a parallel universe that prime Worf stumbles into, and Troi even 'killed' Worf in an empathic hallucination that mirrored events which took place when the Enterprise-D was under construction.
In an interview, Marina Sirtis shared her views on the relationship:
I didn’t like the fact that he totally became un-Klingon-like when he was with Troi. He kind of became a p*ssy. […] I liked better the relationship he had with Dax over on DS9.
Furthermore, she felt that Troi-Riker made a much better couple, and we’d all have to agree with that. In fact, the idea of the pair tying the knot in TNG’s final season was popular amongst the writers until producers Rick Berman and Michael Piller phasered the suggestion down in flames. Perhaps Riker wasn’t emotionally ready enough to part with his beard at that stage. To paraphrase The Beatles, all you need is… metaphasic radiation.
4. Marina Sirtis Was Directed By Jonathan Frakes In An Episode Of The Orville
This one is a bit of a deep meta-dive but stick around. Seth MacFarlane’s The Orville is a great piece of science-fiction in its own right. (Season four, anyone, please?) MacFarlane makes no secret of his love of Star Trek as a source of inspiration.
He even appeared in Enterprise, and then there was that hilarious episode of Family Guy with the Next Generation cast: "These aren’t Staaar Trek questions! What the hell?!" Many veteran Star Trek writers and producers such as Brannan Braga, Joe Menosky, and David A. Goodman have worked on The Orville, and Jonathan Frakes has called the show "Star Trek with comedy". Adding to the Star Trek 'feel' of The Orville, Penny Johnson Jerald is part of the main cast, and actors Robert Picardo, John Billingsley, and Tim Russ have made guest appearances.
In April 2019, about a year before her return in Picard (and longer for Lower Decks), Marina Sirtis appeared in The Orville’s second season episode Sanctuary in the role of a shipboard schoolteacher, directed by Jonathan Frakes. It was hard not to see a bit of a TNG reunion for the pair, and even the quasi-return of Troi in a different guise. Sirtis said of the experience, "Just being on the Orville, everything looks like [The Next Generation]. […] It was almost like stepping back in time with Jonathan directing".
Frakes has also likened the directing style on The Orville to that of TNG. In this standout episode of the programme, the parallels are evident, and Sirtis, as schoolteacher, plays a counselling role to the young Moclan Topa and parents Bortus and Klyden.
3. We Don't Know Much About Picard Season Three, But Troi Will Be In It "A Lot"
Warning: (very minor) spoilers ahead!
Troi was often side-lined in The Next Generation as the 'Captain-they're-hiding-something' character. Worse, in the films Sirtis was relegated to almost a bit-part role. The actress has admitted that she was often "decorative," but was ultimately "fine" with that, wishing nonetheless that she had suggested more storylines (particularly between other women) for Troi to the writers. In an interview for the Blu-ray release of the films, Sirtis also laments that she tried and failed to "make Troi funny" during TNG’s run to the point where she even asked her agent only to find her dramatic roles after the series’ end. Fortunately, she was delighted with the now legendary 'drunk scene' in First Contact and changed her mind about doing comedy.
What we can say, with the limited amount of information we have, is that Troi will have a big part to play in the third and final season of Star Trek: Picard. In the words of Sirtis herself, during a Red Carpet News interview, "We are in it. We are in it, a lot!" The actress also stated that, having felt "discarded" by Nemesis, the cast was "cherished" on Picard. And, whilst executive producer Terry Matalas has ominously warned us that the "safety [of the characters] [is] not guaranteed" in season three, Sirtis says she would gladly return to the role in another spin-off. Death of a character is certainly no hindrance in any case, especially with the multiple time periods of the shows.
Aaaand, Temporal Investigations has just arrived…
2. Marina Sirtis Had A Few Mishaps On Set
The character of Deanna Troi was accustomed to witnessing disaster, destruction, and injury. After all, she did, under orders, fly the Enterprise-E at full impulse into the Scimitar. She also unexpectedly found herself in command in an episode quite literally called 'Disaster'. The woman behind the role, Marina Sirtis, equally had a couple of noteworthy accidents on set you might not be aware of.
One on-set mishap befell Sirtis during the filming of Generations. During the battle scene with the Klingons, consoles were blowing up left and right. When Troi goes to replace an injured officer at the Conn, Sirtis actually sat on a piece of debris from the explosions and burnt her bottom. Thankfully, she wasn’t badly hurt, but she apparently did stop to wipe down the seat on the next take, much to the amusement of the cast and crew.
Another such incident occurred during the filming of The Next Generation episode Power Play. In a scene on the surface of the planet, O’Brien, Riker, Data, and Troi are thrown violently backwards by an EM discharge just before they can be beamed back to the ship. Whilst the other three actors had stunt doubles perform this for them, Sirtis wanted to do the stunt herself, with the encouragement of the director. She committed to it so much that, when she landed on her back, she damaged her coccyx and was in pain for months. Fair play to her! A couple of rounds of Frère Jacques won’t make you forget that.
1. She Has Appeared In Five Series, Four Films, And On A Stamp
One of the most prolific characters of the franchise, Marina Sirtis starred as Troi in The Next Generation and has appeared in Voyager, Lower Decks, Picard, and Enterprise (whatever your thoughts on that last one, it still counts). She is beaten only by Jonathan Frakes as Riker in that regard, who also appeared in the episode Defiant of Deep Space Nine. Sirtis is the only woman to appear as the same character in as many series, however, and she is among great company as one of only six actors to appear in two series’ finales (we’ll let you figure that one out for yourselves). Troi was, of course, in each of the TNG movies.
A recent highlight, aside from Picard, are her appearances in Lower Decks where she is often the foil for the bombastic Riker, his personality now ramped up to the hyperbolic comedy max: "Oh, the jazz". We’re right with you, Deanna!
What you also may not know, unless you’re already a fabulously fidelious philatelist, is that Deanna Troi is one of eighteen characters (including the likes of Janeway, Kirk, Picard, Sisko, Archer, Spock, Reed, Burnham… ) to have been commemorated on a set of UK first class postage stamps in November 2020 as a celebration of Star Trek. You’d be mad to post them, of course, but it would make for some epic snail mail.