The Twilight Zone Reboot: 10 Classic Episodes It Should Remake

Between the pit of man's fears and the summit of knowledge is an area which we call the remake zone.

By Jack Kingston /

Get ready once again to unlock a door with the key of your imagination, because The Twilight Zone is back.

Advertisement

The new series, the fourth reboot of the beloved original show, has debuted on streaming service CBS All Access, with one of its opening episodes being Nightmare At 30,000 Feet, a higher altitude reimagining of the classic series episode Nightmare At 20,000 Feet (it's the one with William Shatner on a plane with a gremlin dismantling the wing).

On one level you can see why the new showrunners would want to draw viewers in with their own take on a familiar Twilight Zone staple, but this story feels a little played out. It's already been redone by Mad Max's George Miller in the 1983 Twilight Zone movie and has been endlessly referenced and parodied, most obviously in one of the earliest Simpsons Halloween specials.

If the new Twilight Zone is to continue (like its 1980s predecessors) occasionally dipping its toes into reworking some of the original stories, it would do better to avoid the much-referenced likes To Serve Man and Time Enough At Last, stories whose every twist is well known even to audiences who have never seen the original episodes.

Instead, they should look for inspiration to some less familiar classic stories or some that were great concepts which were not perfectly executed. In short, Jordan Peele and his team should think about remaking these.

10. The Time Element

The Story:

Advertisement

In the 1950s a man visits his psychiatrist to tell him about a recurring dream where he is stationed at Pearl Harbor in 1941 and tries unsuccessfully to warn people of the coming attack. He is convinced that he is really time travelling in his sleep, which the psychiatrist doesn't accept, right up until the man dreams that he is shot and killed by the Japanese.

Why Remake It?

This didn't actually air as an episode of The Twilight Zone itself, but rather was a sort of pre-pilot shown on another anthology series. Its instant popularity and strong critical notices finally provided the go-ahead from network CBS for creator Rod Serling to produce an actual Twilight Zone pilot in 1959.

Redoing it today would show that the new series respects the origins of the show, and would finally make The Time Element an official Twilight Zone story.

More than that, though, it is simply a good story with perennial themes that could easily be updated. The questions of what would you do if thrown back in time to a moment of catastrophe, and would that catastrophe even be preventable if time travel were possible, are the sort of thing that I'd expect to see addressed in some respect in the new series.

Meanwhile, we are today the same amount of time after 9/11 as the original Twilight Zone was after Pearl Harbor, so that makes it pretty easy to update some of the plot specifics for an equivalent catastrophic attack relatable to today's audience.

9. The Howling Man

The Story:

Advertisement

An American on a walking trip in 1920s Europe gets lost in a storm and stumbles upon a remote castle where an order of monks have locked up a man howling in agony. He claims to be imprisoned here at the persecution of an intolerant religious order after kissing a girl in public, while, according to the monks, the man is the Devil himself and the years of relative peace since the First World War are a result of him being imprisoned here.

Why Remake It?

Unlike the more specifically technology and media-focused likes of Black Mirror, The Twilight Zone has always had a broader supernatural canvas. In the original series, various incarnations of Death and the Devil were as much regular characters as the robots and aliens that most associate with the show, and it would be good for the new version to continue with 21st Century takes on some of that metaphysical material.

The Howling Man is one of the more conceptually interesting devil episodes, and its central moral dilemma (is it worth letting one probably innocent man suffer on the tiny chance that he really is evil incarnate and his imprisonment makes the whole rest of the world a better place?) still has mileage.

Meanwhile, the remote European castle full of fundamentalist monks and a mysterious howling prisoner is the stuff of full-on classic gothic horror. That the original does this in a somewhat hammy and stagey fashion just opens the door for a new version to really embrace that shadowy gothic mystery.

8. Button, Button

The Story:

Advertisement

In the original version of the memetic "would you push the button if...?" dilemma, an impoverished couple living in a tenement are approached by a stranger who gives them a box with a button on it and tells them that if they press the button they will receive $200,000 but somebody that they don't know will die.

Why Remake It?

The 1980s versions of The Twilight Zone (both the 1983 movie and the 1985 TV series) never really made the impact of the original series.

That doesn't mean, though, that none of it is worth revisiting, nor that the 1980s series left no pop cultural footprint. In fact, the central "would you push the button?" question of this episode has only become more discussed over time. Not only was it readapted as feature film The Box, but it has also enjoyed a healthy afterlife as the structure of a meme posing all kinds of push it or not questions.

However, despite the obvious appeal of its central hook, none of the previous versions have played out in an entirely satisfying way. The weird performances and off-book end twist in the original episode had writer Richard Matheson taking his name off it, while The Box just descends into pretentious nonsense long before its final scenes.

It still feels, therefore, like there's a definitive take on the Button, Button story yet to be made. A new writer can start with the initial button dilemma and take it any way that they want.

7. He's Alive

The Story:

Advertisement

An angry young man, abused and neglected as a child and struggling for respect as an adult, leads a fringe far-right group in 1960s America, but is mostly mocked and belittled. That is until he gains a shadowy mentor who teaches him how to fire up a crowd with nationalist, racist rhetoric, and conspire to murder a follower to create a martyr for his cause.

Why Remake It?

Featuring an impressive performance from Dennis Hopper as a distressingly convincing angry young fascist, He's Alive feels worryingly plausible even with its terribly Twilight Zone twist. (I don't think it's too much of a spoiler to reveal that the shadowy mentor is the ghost of Hitler himself).

Honestly, that twist feels a little silly for what's quite a serious subject (even if the metaphorical point - expressed in Serling's narration as "any place where there's hate, where there's prejudice, where there's bigotry, he's alive" - is a sound one), so may be better just built in from the start rather than as a big reveal. In fact, you could almost play "Hitler's back" as a bit of a silly joke at first before building to show quite how chilling that would be.

The story, which shows how quickly populist rhetoric can turn modern far-right racist politics from something that lives in the past into a very real threatening power today, is unfortunately more fitting to the political situation of today than it has been in almost any time since Serling wrote it. For that reason alone, He's Alive is worth revisiting.

6. Number 12 Looks Just Like You

The Story:

Advertisement

In a technologically advanced future everybody on entering adulthood must undergo "The Transformation", a process in which their body is transformed into one of a limited selection of fit, beautiful models, extending their lifespan and making them immune to disease. One young woman, whose father committed suicide due to the conformity and loss of personal identity engendered by the Transformation, refuses to go through the process.

Why Remake It?

The original Twilight Zone found a lot of creative ways to utilise the fact that its budgetry limitations meant that it could only use limited locations and small casts. This episode, in which everybody has to choose one of a limited number of beautiful bodies to transform into (and most of the protagonist's friends and family are the most popular model, Number 12), is perhaps the one that best turns that limitation into a creepy asset.

The story's themes of an increasingly superficial, image-obsessed society, one where people continuously modify their bodies in pursuit of perfection, have only become more relevant as time has passed.

It would be interesting, as the new episode would be twice the length, also to consider how the standards of what makes the "beautiful people" can change and how Number 12 (Suzy Parker, then the world's most popular real-life model, played all the characters using the Number 12 body in the original episode) would not always be the most desired. So a new version could see other body types come in to replace Number 12 as the popular standard. How would the permanently-12s feel about that fashion shift?

5. The Shelter

The Story:

Advertisement

A well-liked suburban physician enjoys a birthday party with his wife and son, along with their long term friends and neighbours, who are amused that he has built a fallout shelter in the basement. That is until an announcement is made of unidentified flying objects heading for America. With room for only three in the shelter, previously suppressed grudges and hostilities now come to the surface, tearing apart both the group and the shelter.

Why Remake It?

Of 156 episodes of The Twilight Zone's original 1950s and 60s run, just three were stories with no supernatural elements, simply directly engaging with plausible real world fears. The most effective of these was this Serling original script from 1961, the height of the Berlin Crisis when nuclear war appeared a very real possibility (the Berlin Wall went up just a couple of weeks after the episode aired).

The backdrop of Cold War fears, fallout shelters and the possibility of all-out nuclear war is perhaps no longer so relevant to an audience today, but the barely-suppressed deep divisions in superficially friendly suburban communities, the racism and nativism which comes to the surface in a crisis, are absolutely relatable in Trump's America.

All a new version of The Shelter needs, therefore, is a credible contemporary threat, one which plays on the fears of 21st Century suburbanites and would be exacerbated by the 24-hour news cycle. A mass shooter, perhaps, where details about the character's motivations and background remain hazy and ever-changing in the media reporting.

4. A Matter Of Minutes

The Story:

Advertisement

A couple are woken up by noises of construction work and go downstairs to discover faceless blue men, dressed all in blue and with blue tools, removing all of their furniture and rebuilding their whole surroundings. After trying and failing to escape, they discover the truth: time is a literal construction, every minute is a wholly separate universe, built and then torn down by the blue men. Having accidentally stumbled into the construction of 9:33 am, the couple are now forbidden from leaving it.

Why Remake It?

Ask people who have seen the 1980s series what they remember from it and this image of what essentially amounts to the Blue Man Group as a construction team is likely to come up. The imagery, and its accompanying time construction conceit, is interesting and memorable, but the original story doesn't really take it any further. After around ten minutes of exposition, there is a brief chase and the couple escape.

Expanded up to a full hour-long episode, however, there would be the potential actually to play with the time-building idea and tell a full story. I'm imagining something in the vein of a Charlie Kaufman-Spike Jonze slice of offbeat magical realist whimsy turned dark and sinister.

And, as for updating it, well, A Matter Of Minutes was already based on Theodore Sturgeon's short story Yesterday Was Monday, which was originally published in 1941, so it's not like it wasn't already subject to a bit of a contemporary rewrite to appear on TV in the 80s anyway.

3. Mirror Image

The Story:

Advertisement

A woman waits at a small town bus depot for a bus that is late. As she glances in a mirror, she sees an exact double of herself, down to the exact same clothing, sitting on a bench outside. Later, as she boards the bus, she sees herself already sitting in her seat with a sinister smile on her face.

Why Remake It?

With his deeply disturbing doppelganger horror Us currently riding high at the box office, it's clear that Peele has a fascination with the fear of being usurped by a sinister double. Indeed, he has described this 1960 story of a previously level-headed woman gradually unravelling on encountering her exact duplicate as a direct influence on the movie.

Serling came up with the story upon seeing a fellow traveller in an airport terminal dressed in the same clothes and carrying the same bag as him. He wondered what he would do if the man turned around and had his face as well. The episode is highly effective at capturing this sense of the uncanny and rising discomfort. Unfortunately, Serling seems to have never quite resolved the question of how he would react to the encounter and the story doesn't play out in one of the show's better endings.

Mirror Image is, therefore, an episode with a classic Twilight Zone setup but no equally classic conclusion. It would lend itself well to a new, contemporary writer tackling a story from the same starting point, beginning with Serling's mysterious airport coincidence, and developing things in their own distinct way.

2. Walking Distance

The Story:

Advertisement

In the 1950s an advertising executive, stressed from the high pressures of the modern world, stops at a gas station close to the small town where he grew up and decides to walk back there. He is surprised when everything from the cars to the price of ice cream at the drugstore haven't changed at all since he was a child in 1934. Seeing his younger self carving his name into a bandstand, he realises that he has travelled back in time.

Why Remake It?

While typically remembered today as a show that provided creepy stories or dark and disturbing twists, the original Twilight Zone was equally happy to embrace a nostalgic sentimentalism, with Walking Distance - the original series' fifth episode and arguably the first classic - perhaps the best example.

The themes of Walking Distance are evergreen, recurring both in many later episodes and in fiction ever since. It engages in a bittersweet fashion with issues of nostalgia for a simpler time, the idea of the grass always being greener and the impossibility of truly returning to how things were.

The initial story's timeframe and locations were specifically very personal to Serling himself and his frame of reference. It would be interesting to see the same concept, but updated to how a similar writer today relates to their 90s youth. That our current cultural diet is becoming ever more nostalgia-driven and the fact that we now see Serling's fast-paced 50s as an example of the very simpler time to which he hearkened back could both provide ample fuel for a new take.

1. The Invaders

The Story:

Advertisement

Alone in a remote run-down shack, an impoverished old woman lives in rustic simplicity, lacking in any modern conveniences or appliances. A tiny flying saucer crashes into her roof and little robotic-looking figures emerge and attack her with miniature radiation guns. Now she must use the simple tools around her to survive.

Why Remake It?

Unlike some iconic episodes, which are so pop culturally familiar that their every twist has been spoilt by a Treehouse Of Horror parody, The Invaders is a more under-the-radar classic. Nevertheless, it represents The Twilight Zone at its very peak. Everything that made the show great is here distilled down into a highly focused, unusual and original survival story.

With essentially just one proper character and no dialogue, the episode relies on the brilliant physical performance of its central actor (Agnes Moorhead) and sound design. A new reworking of The Invaders would be a brilliant vehicle for an ambitious and talented actor, and would be a piece of stark, experimental television that would be at least a match for some of the highly original, single-location speculative stories on Inside No. 9. Could the original half-hour story be stretched out to a full hour? That would be part of the interest in doing it again.

And, yes, The Invaders does have a predictably Twilight Zone ending (the tiny rounded figures are really human astronauts, and the woman desperate to survive is a giant that they see as a threat), but there's no reason not to subvert that with an entirely different twist in this tale.

Advertisement